Chapter 21 of 21
Appendices
Appendix 1
Myths about the Israeli-Arab conflict (1) Is “Occupation" the cause of this conflict? From (“Flame” published by NewsMax on September 2006) In the decades in which the Israeli-Arab conflict has raged, certain myths have been repeated so often and so insistently by Arab propaganda that most of the world has come to believe them. Today, we briefly examine one of those myths. What are the facts? The myth of "Occupation" being the cause of conflict. The very concept of occupation, as applied to Gaza and Judea and Samaria (the "West Bank"), is a myth. When the Egyptians were in possession of Gaza for almost 20 years nobody accused them of being occupiers. The Jordanians, who were in possession of Judea/Samaria (the" West Bank") and much of Jerusalem for the same length of time, were not considered occupiers by the nations of the world and by the inhabitants of the area. The Israelis were considered “occupiers" when, after a war of extermination against them, they prevailed and came into possessions of these territories. The oldest rule of warfare is that to the victor belong the spoils. Do people expect France to return Alsace-Lorraine to Germany? Do they expect the Czech Republic or Poland to return the German territories awarded to them after Germany's defeat in World War II? Of course not! Those countries evicted most of the original inhabitants or caused them to flee. Israel, in contrast, has never evicted a single Arab from these territories. On the contrary, lured by the prosperity the Israelis have created, tens of thousands of Arabs from adjacent Syria and Jordan have come to live there.
Israel's "occupation" of those territories is a myth. But even so, the hope that Israel's abandonment of any territory - the same old "land-for-peace” formula - would bring about peace is an illusion and a fallacy. In order to establish peaceful relations with its northern neighbor Lebanon, Israel abandoned the security zone of southern Lebanon. But instead of acknowledgment and gratitude, the result has been never -ending attacks with Katyusha rockets, led by Hezbollah, the "army of God", which is supported and incited by Iran and by Syria. It makes life on Israel's northern frontier almost unbearable. Israel, unilaterally, and in order to appease the Palestinians, the United States, and world opinion, vacated Gaza and evicted thousands of Israeli families and abandoned their homes, institutions, extensive agricultural installations, and valuable infrastructure. Not a single Israeli citizen, not a single Israeli soldier, remains in Gaza. But, in the few months since it has abandoned that territory, Israel has been provoked to bloody warfare and has been subjected to daily attacks by Qassam rockets. It is only a matter of time until one of those devices will crash into a school or into a hospital causing untold casualties and destroying vital infrastructure.
Destruction and civil war.
Instead of using their newly won "liberty from occupation," the Gazans have engaged in what is practically a bloody civil war and have destroyed most of their meager infrastructure. They have demolished and vandalized the valuable and extensive greenhouse installations that the Israelis had created, which could have been the basis for a prosperous agricultural economy and of substantial export income. But
they focus their efforts and their energy on digging tunnels under the wall that separates them from Israel, in order to attack Israeli military, killing and kidnapping their soldiers and thus bringing added misery upon themselves. Having the disastrous examples of the withdrawal from the southern Lebanon security zone and now from Gaza, it is easy to imagine what would happen if Israel would not have learned from experience and - under pressure from the U.S. and world opinion - would commit the folly of abandoning Judea/Samaria (the "West Bank"). While Gaza is isolated surrounded by Israel and the sea, the "West Bank" is connected to Syria and Jordan. Within days of Israel's abandonment of that territory, Syrian tanks, Syrian aircraft, Syrian artillery, and Syrian and perhaps even Iranian troops would be stationed on the ridges of the Judean hills that dominate Israel's heartland. That heartland is only nine miles wide at its narrow waist. Israel’s population centers, Israel's military installations, Israel's industrial capacity, Israel's utilities, and Israel's international airport would be in the gunfights of the Arabs, sworn to the destruction of Israel. The attack against Israel, the hoped-for final assault against the hated Jews, would begin within days or weeks and might well be successful. The Palestinians, along with most other Arabs and Moslems, are single-mindedly focused on the destruction of Israel, to "wipe it off the map." If Israel were pressured into ending the "occupation" of the territories, it would not bring peace. On the contrary, it would bring about bloody warfare, just as in Gaza and Lebanon, and could well be the end of Israel. Those who advocate the ending of the "occupation" do so either out of ignorance or because they have a death wish for Israel. Those who advocate the ending of the "occupation" do so either out of ignorance wish for Israel.
Appendix 11
ISIS AND THE MAPPILA REBELLION OF MALABAR
I shudder when I look at those lurid videos of the killings of innocents by ISIS a la “Islamic Justice.” I cannot feel indifferent to the killings; for me, they are not remote happenings to some strangers in some far away land. Such killings are part of my own story, part of my family history as narrated to me by my grandmother who lived through it all, some 93 years ago, in 1921. It is the story of the Mappila Rebellion of Malabar, an offshoot of the Khilaphat movement in which atrocities were committed on Hindus and other non-Muslim communities, out of revenge and hostility, fueled by a seventh century ideology. There is a close parallel between the Khilaphat Rebellion of 1921 in Malabar and today’s frightening specter of ISIS atrocities in Iraq and Syria. Reasons for the atrocities vary somewhat, but the main purpose was the same: the establishment of a Caliphate.
My grandmother’s narrative was chilling. The murderous mob from Ernad Taluk (part of today’s Malappuram District) forded the shallow end of the Chaliyar and went, swords in hand, from door to door, looking for non- Muslim families. They dragged men, women, and children out of their homes, raped women, maimed and murdered the men who refused to convert, and carried away the children after putting fire to their homes. My grandmother told me that I almost missed being born, but now I am here to relate the story, because, she told me, she was protected by a friendly Muslim family that shielded her and her two daughters when the marauders came calling. The Chaliyar, she told me, had turned crimson and the
headless bodies bobbed their way down to the Arabian Sea. When the local police force could not put down the rebellion, a special police force called MSP (Malabar Special Police) was formed. But even they could hardly contain the fury of the mob. Finally, the local British Administration had to call in the army and the formidable Goorkha Regiment. Between them, they destroyed the rebels, thousands were killed or imprisoned, and hundreds were banished to the Andaman Islands.
The Mappila Rebellion was part of the Khilaphat Movement of India, which in turn was part of the Pan-Islamic program inaugurated by the Ottoman Emperor of Turkey. Gandhi was implicated in the movement at the start, for Gandhi took it as part of the “Swaraj” movement. Later, Gandhi withdrew his support of the movement and allegedly left the beleaguered Hindu and Christian communities to the mercy of the violent mob of Mappilas. A prominent Nair leader, C. Sankaran Nair wrote a scathing criticism of Gandhi whom he called an ‘anarchist’. “The horrid tragedy,” he wrote, “continued for months; thousands of Mohammadans were killed or wounded by the troops; thousands of Hindus were butchered by the raging Mappila mobs; women were subjected to shameless indignities, hundreds of them threw themselves into wells to avoid dishonor or forced conversion.” …. “This is what Malabar owes to the Khilaphat agitation and to Mahatma Gandhi.”
In pop culture, the events of the Mappila Rebellion were featured in novels and Malayalam language films. Renowned author Urub’s “Sundarikalum Sundaranmarum” was set in a backdrop of the Malabar uprising. The novel features thirty characters of three generations of eight families in Malabar. The book won the Keraliya Sahitya Academy Award and numerous other awards. In 1988, a Malayalam Language film, Aayirathi Thollayirathi Irupathonnu (1921) directed by I.V. Sasi, written by T.
Damodaran Nair, and starred in by Mammootty and Madhu, depicts the events of the Mappila Rebellion. The film won the Kerala State Film Award.
In 1924, Mustafa Kemal Ataturk had overthrown the Ottoman rule in Turkey and established a pro-Western Republic. He had also abolished the rule of the Caliph. Ever since, there have been several attempts to restore the position of the Caliph as the religious head of the world Muslim community. The efforts had collapsed as there was no way to bring about reconciliation between the feuding groups of Muslims who pronounce fatwa against each other and consider each other apostates or ‘kafirs’. So just as in the rebellion in Malabar, ISIS, for all its formidable strength, may also be headed for abject failure. Powerful Muslim states themselves are at loggerheads with Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi and his murderous minions.
So what is ISIS, and who is its reclusive leader? ISIS, acronym for “Islamic State of Iraq and Syria” is a mediaeval outfit that has imposed the most brutal form of the Sharia Law throughout its territory. They have destroyed Shiite mosques and tombs, massacred those whom they deem infidels, imposed stringent restrictions on women, banned music, dancing, and smoking, and drinking. ISIS is the most media-savvy militant group to emerge in the Middle East.
The commander-in-chief of ISIS is Abu Bakr al- Baghdadi, the man who has declared himself Caliph of the Islamic world. Baghdadi is an Islamic scholar, poet, and Sunni extremist; an enigma to his own followers as well as to his enemies. Baghdadi started as a preacher of the Salafic wing of Islam, a hardline militant group a la Osama Bin Laden. His
goal is to restore the Caliphate and crown himself as the Caliph. His method of reaching that goal has been inspired by the four immediate successors of Muhammad in spreading Islam by the sword. He models his justice system after the system used by the Abbasid Dynasty of Caliphs– using beheadings, stoning, and crucifixion. He uses terrorism as a way to avenge humiliation, subjugation, and subordination at the hands of infidels, as he stated in July, 2014.
At informal discussions, I am often asked about the difference between Christianity and Islam. I tell them, there is no simple answer to that question. Books can be written about the differences. However, for a simple answer, I would say, Christianity was born of love and forgiveness; Islam, of war and violence. Christianity had its bad days (Middle Ages) and Islam had its good days, but as Hasan Suroor wrote in Hindu (Sept 29, 2014), Christianity got over its violent history, but Islam failed to move on and update its theological precepts. Dedicated Christian scholars and theologians work hard at Biblical analysis and criticism to unearth the true message of the Sacred Books. They use modern methods of studying the original languages of the Bible and Biblical archeology. Few such efforts are reported from the Islamic side. So the ideology that drives this terrorist groups are not based on any deep understanding or research into their sacred scripts. They are, apparently, based on blind faith.
Varghese Kamplath.
Appendix 111
WRESTLING WITH CONTRADICTIONS
I was focused, for the last couple of weeks, on a special topic: Islam. Islamic faith has never been a strange phenomenon to me. I lived among ‘the believers’ for almost two decades. In my younger days the difference between ‘them’ and ‘us’ was defined by our separate identities, rituals, and symbolisms. I recognized ‘Mappilas’ by their peculiar attire: checkered ‘mundu’ with its ends knitted together; long, loose kurta and a turban carelessly knotted; men shaved their heads and grew long beards, smelled bad, for they never used deodorants; men washed themselves every time they urinated – I still remember watching curiously from my brother’s riverside restaurant, a sickly old man hurrying down to the river holding the large growth at his scrotum(hydrocele) to wash himself clean of the urine.
Women were recognized by their loose coveralls which shielded them from gawkers and gave them an air of modesty, but they evidently roused curiosity as they seemed to wear little or no underclothes. Our next door neighbor was a Muslim who was called ‘Haji’ as he had been on a ‘haj’ to Mecca with his wife. They were some of the nicest people I knew when I was young. The Haji brought fruits and other goodies to our Onam celebrations; they visited us whenever we were home for holidays and invited us to their home. On one such occasion, the lady suggested that I convert to Islam and marry one of her daughters. As I mentioned in my last piece, it was their ancestors who had protected my grandmother from being put to the sword by the murderous mob that came across the river looking for non-Muslims to
convert or to kill during the infamous ‘Mappila Rebellion’ of Malabar. Later on, when I was a young man, my grandmother used to narrate the story of her ordeal to me, and I remember her protectors gratefully. But ironically, she warned me not to trust Muslims as “they were liars and cheats and had no qualm about hurting those who were not of their faith.” Later, while reading V.S. Naipaul’s account of life in his native Trinidad, I read the same advice given to him by his father. So to my adolescent sensibility, this apparent contradiction in Islam was disturbing, and I wanted to get to the root of this and many other seeming contradictions in the Muslim way of life.
My quest for the root of the many contradictions in Islam led me all the way to the seventh century Arabia, to the time and teachings of their prophet. For my quest, I largely relied on two books, besides the Islamic scriptures themselves: The books were “Infidel” by Ayaan Hirsi Ali and “The Truth About Muhammad” by Robert Spencer. “Infidel” was the book of the month that we discussed at our book club meeting, on October 8, 2014 at St. Vincent de Paul parish hall. The club consists of 12 members, most of whom, retired, and all of whom are American. I am the only one with a different skin tone, but I moderated the exchange as I had read the book twice and I had recommended it for our book of the month. It was a heated session, an eye opener to almost all and they were grateful to me for bringing the book to their attention.
Ayaan Ali was born in Somalia in 1969, grew up in Somalia, Saudi Arabia, in Ethiopia and Kenya. She went to Europe as a refugee in 1992, and became a member of parliament in Holland. She made a movie with Theo Van Gogh, a descendent of the Famed Van Gogh, the artist. The movie focused on the abysmal life of women in many Islamic countries. Theo Van Gogh was murdered in broad daylight, in November, 2004, on a street in Amsterdam by a Moroccan Muslim who stuck a warning to Ayaan on Theo’s chest, with a dagger. Ayaan came to the United States in 2006 and now lives in Washington D.C with “body guards and armored cars.” She works for a Think Tank in the D.C. area, and part time, at Harvard. One of the blurbs on the book cover says:
“A brave and elegant figure, an honest woman. No one who reads her memoir will doubt the self-questioning and the rigorous honesty of her mind.” The book will tell you the atrocities she and numerous other women have suffered in some Islamic lands, how women are flogged for committing adultery; how they are forced into marriages with older men whom they loathed; how they are beaten by their husbands on a regular basis and how they are shunted by their fathers when they are raped by a relative, and sometimes put to death. The book also will tell you in graphic detail how little girls are tied down and subjected to the inhuman practice of clitorectomy and sewed up for life with the approval of imams. “In Saudi Arabia where Islam is practiced in its purest form, every step we (women) took is infused with concepts of purity or sinning, and with fear. Wishful thinking about the peaceful tolerance in Islam cannot interpret away this reality: hands are still cut off, women still stoned and enslaved just as the prophet Muhammad decided centuries ago.”
The second book that helped me to identify contradictions in Islam is “The Truth about Muhammad” by Robert Spencer. The book was a New York Times best seller when it was published in 2006. Spencer is the director of Jihad Watch, a program of the David Horowitz’ Freedom
Center. “At a time,” writes Daniel Pipes, “when even in the West, the pious narrative of Muhammad has gained a near hegemonic hold; Robert Spencer offers a rare skeptical biography and the interpretation of the prophet of Islam. Relying exclusively on Islamic sources, ‘The Truth About Muhammad’ argues that, for fourteen hundred years the ‘words and deeds of Muhammad have been moving Muslims to commit acts of violence.’’ Spencer’s book offers a wealth of information on the man and his teaching that conquered much of the Arab world and spread the Islamic faith throughout the Middle East and far beyond.
I did not pick these volumes for their authors’ fierce criticism of Islam, but for their integrity and their fearless honesty. I am a professing, practicing Catholic. Criticizing and, much less, denigrating other people’s religion are not among my Church’s agenda. I attend Mass every day; I visit four churches and listen to homilies and sermons; but never have I seen or heard attempts to put down other cultures or other religions. We are exhorted to love every human on the face of the planet and pray for them and help them in their needs. Such sermons are based on the principle that God created all men, even the terrorists who point their guns at us; God loves them too; He has a plan for them; He wishes their good. So who am I to hate, to pass judgment, to condemn!
Why should my heart ache, my eyes weep, my soul sink? Whenever I see a perfect stranger hurt, sick, lonely, or abandoned because every time I try to ignore other people’s problems or pain, something stirs deep within me and rekindles an inner light. There’s contradiction when a religion is defined as a religion of peace, but in practice, spreads violence and hatred!!!
Varghese Kampalath.
The above notes were taken from the following
books. God’s War on Terror by Walid Shoebat with Joel
Richardson
The sword of the prophet by serge Trifkovic
Islam prophesied in Genesis by Dennis Avi Lipkin
Answering Islam by Norman Geisler and Abdal Saleeb
Return to Mecca by Dennis Avi Lipkin
The Great Divide. The failure of Islam and the Triumph of the West. By Marvin Olasky.
The Road to Holocaust by Hal Lindsey
The Truth about Muhammad by Robert Spencer.
The Dark Side of Islam by R.C. Sproul and Abdul Saleeb
Why we want to kill you. By Walid Shoebat.
Behind the Veil by Abd EL Schafi
The History of Islam by Robert Payne.
Unholy War by Randall Price
Unveiling Islam by Ergun Meh Mechmet Caner and Emir Feth Caner
Islam 4th edition by Caesar Farah The Glorious Qur’an Translation by Mohammed Pickthall The Qur’an Translated by M.H. Shakir.
The Islamic Invasion by Robert Morey
Nagationism in India By Koenraad Elst
Infidel by Ayaan Hirsi Ali
A God Who Hates. By Wafa Sultan
They must be stopped. By Brigitte Gabriel
Because They Hate. By Brigitte Gabriel
Understanding the Hadith by Ram Swarup
Hadith of Bukhari Volumes 1, 11,111& 1V
Conspiracy by Daniel Pipes
Real enemies’ conspiracy Theories World War 1 to 9/11 By Kathryn s. Olmsted.
Behind the Veil by Abd EL Schafi
The Everlasting Hatred by Hal Lindsey
Unveiling Islam by Ergun Meh Mechmet Caner and Emir Feth Caner
Islam 4th edition by Caesar Farah
Race & Economics. Walter E. Williams. Hoover Institution Press. Stanford University. California.
In the Shadow of the Sword. By Tom Holland.