Chapter 15 of 21
Islam and Christianity on scripture
The Muslim viewpoint on scripture is this: Because man is prone to being led astray, God has sent prophets throughout history and these prophets have brought revelations from God. According to Islamic belief, all revelations from God prior to the Quran have been either lost or tampered with and corrupted. Thus they are no longer authentic or reliable and therefore no longer authoritative.
The Quran, according to Muslims, is God’s final word to humanity and is the only authentic authoritative and reliable information from God, because it is the only information that has not been tampered with and corrupted.
The Quran has many complimentary things to say about the Bible. Sura 5:44 Sura 5:68 Sura 10:94 Sura 29:46
Muhammed very much wanted to say to the Jews and Christians “Listen, I am a monotheist. I am a prophet like Moses and Jesus. We are all alike. We worship the same God. My Quran is basically in confirmation of the previous scriptures. We all agree on the essentials. The Quran is the final word from God but the Law and the Gospel were also guidance, light, revelation, and mercy from God to humanity.
However, since Mohammed himself was not very well educated, he did not have firsthand knowledge about the Christian and the Jewish scriptures. Later, in Islamic history, as Muslims came into contact with Jewish and Christian communities and began to read the Bible, they realized that the Old and New Testaments contradict the Quran on very serious issues.
So Muslims had to come up with a theory to explain this situation. On the one hand, the Quran says that the previous scriptures were the word of God and according to the Quran, “No one can change the word of God.” On the other hand, the scriptures from the Christians and Jews do not agree with the teachings of the Quran. What is the solution? The doctrine of “tariff” the Arabic word for corruption claims that the Jews and Christians have corrupted their scriptures and that is why the Bible no longer agrees with the teachings of the Quran.
Some Muslims also say, “Your own scholars say the same thing: that Moses did not write the Torah, that Jesus did not say these things. These were all fabricated and put in the mouths of people like Christ and other folks”.
The Fatherhood of God
Another of the most important concepts in the Christian faith is the fatherhood of God. Jesus taught us in the Lord’s Prayer to address God as “Our Father in Heaven” [Matt 6:9] We Christians feel privileged to be able to talk to God in such intimate terms. We believe that through faith in Christ we can become adopted children of God. When Christians talk about this to Muslims, they think that they are sharing good news. Christians do not understand that to Muslim ears, that sounds like horrible blasphemy to think of God as our Father and us as His children. To Muslim ears, that sounds like horrible news. To them it sounds blasphemous to think of God as our Father and us as his
children. For Quran, to talk about God as our Father implies sexual relations and attributes something that is not right to God: “To him (Allah) is due the primal origin of the heavens and the earth: How can he have a son when he hath no consort? He created all things and he hath full knowledge of all things. (Sura 6:101) It is a blasphemy to say that Allah begets sons like a man or an animal.”
However, Christians are not attributing a sexual act to God when we talk about the fatherhood of God or that we are sons of God, but that’s not how a Muslim understands it.
The idea of God sexually interacting with human beings is utterly foreign to Judeo-Christian teaching. Obviously when Christianity speaks of the fatherhood of God, the Son of God and the children of God, it does not mean to communicate this idea of physical, biological propagation.
We need to look carefully at how the Old Testament and the New Testament articulate their understanding of the fatherhood of God and the so- called brotherhood of man. Nowhere have we seen a Jewish person addressing God as his father. In Jesus’ day, his calling God “Father” was a radical departure from Jewish tradition. Further, in the New Testament that relationship is seen from the other perspective. God is heard speaking from heaven declaring “This is my beloved Son in whom I am well pleased “(Mathew: 17:5)
Jesus also bears the title “Son of God”, although in a very carefully guarded way. When Christ is called the Son of God, He is called the monogenesis-the only begotten of the Father. The Church understood very early that this did not mean He had a beginning in time. There wasn’t any idea of the Father’s procreating in time.
When the Bible speaks in terms of sonship, it refers not only to biological generation: it also speaks regularly of sonship as a description of a relationship of obedience. When Jesus talked about setting people free, the Pharisees became upset, saying “We are Abraham’s descendants and have never been in bondage to anyone (John 8:33). Jesus replies “If you were Abraham’s children, you would do the works of Abraham”. V: 39] To be called a child of God meant one who obeyed God. Son- ship here was defined not in biological terms, but in ethical terms. And in that sense the New Testament speaks of Christ’s unique relationship as the One who is perfectly obedient to the Father. Jesus then tells his disciples to pray: “Our Father in heaven” (Matt 6:9). That was radical; that was astonishing initially to those who heard it. Orthodox Jews and Muslims would also be offended because it was a serious departure from their tradition. In fact, from the Fall throughout the Old Testament, there is a history of the wall separating humankind from God because of sin. An angel with a flaming sword guarded the entrance to paradise (Gen 3:24) to prevent us from having an intimate relationship with God.
In Romans 8, Paul writes about the concept of our adoption by God the Father by virtue of the work of the Holy Spirit, who gives us now, as we are adopted into the family of God, the right and the authority to say “Abba Father”. (V15). We now have the right to address God as Father; even though we are not His children by nature, we are His children by adoption; by virtue of our relationship with Christ, we are now included in the family of God.
One of the most moving stories in the Old Testament is the story of Jonathan’s son Mephibosheth, who was lame in both legs. (2 Samuel 9) When the news came that Saul and Jonathan had been killed, some men in David’s camp wanted to kill all of the survivors from Saul’s family, lest any would try to seize power from David and keep him from rising to kingship. David was upset about the proposed purge. He asked if there was anybody left from the house of Saul so that he could honor him in memory of his love for Jonathan. David’s men found Jonathan’s lame son, who had been secreted away and brought him to David. Mephibosheth was terrified. He assumed that he was being delivered for execution; Instead, David said that if Mephibosheth was alive, he would eat at the king’s table and would be regarded as a member of the king’s family. This is what happens when we come to the Lord’s Table; we come as God’s children. Because of the love of the Father for the Son, and our adoption, we can have this filial relationship.
This relationship differs markedly from any found in Islam. {I John 3:1}. Even the apostles in the first century were overwhelmed with amazement that the status of a filial relationship with God would be accorded to us because of the work of Christ.
As we talk with Muslims about the Fatherhood of God, it is important to know and emphasize the fact that we are not talking about physical procreation on the part of God. An emphasis on the aspect of obedience as a definition of sonship is very important.
Trinity Another major stumbling block Muslims have regarding Christians’ view of God has to do with the Trinity.
Muslims believe that the essence of knowledge is the fact that there is one God and one God alone. Islam believes that, theirs is the final religion of God to humanity, and the gift of Islam is to restore pure monotheism to the world. Muslims believe Christianity has been profoundly corrupted by the notion of the Trinity.
Mohammad profoundly misunderstood the Christian doctrine of the Trinity. The early Muslims thought of the Trinity as the Father, Mary, and Jesus. According to Muslims, the doctrine of the Trinity is an incoherent, illogical notion that many Christians themselves don’t understand and often cannot explain or defend to an outsider; only Christianity understands the doctrine of the Trinity as affirming monotheism. Christians believe in the Trinity, not as a rational invention of the human mind, but as a revelation of Jesus Christ and Christ was trustworthy as He was the Truth.
The very word Trinity is a combination of “tri” and “unity” and the accent is on the unity; trinity is not tri-theism. Christianity has resisted any heretical idea that there are three parts to God, that there are three beings or three gods in any polytheistic way. The doctrine of the Trinity is often called a contradiction. What is a contradiction? If I say that something is what it is and is not what it is at the same time and in the same relationship, I would be guilty of violating the law of non-contradiction.
The classical definition of contradiction, by the philosopher Aristotle in his system of logic, which he called the “organon” of all science, the necessary instrument for all meaningful discourse, was this: Something cannot be what it
is and not be what is at the same time and in the same relationship. The shorthand for that is “A cannot be A and non-A at the same and in the same relationship.” For example, I can be a Father (A) and a Son (B) at the same time, but not in the same relationship.
A Paradox, on the other hand, is not a contradiction. The “dox” in a paradox comes from the Greek ‘dokeo’ which means “to seem, to think, or to appear”. “Docetism” comes from the same root. The heretical Docetists denied that Jesus had a true body. They said that he was a phantom; He only seemed to be human. Para means “alongside”; thus paradox means that something seems like something else when placed alongside it. A paradox is not a contradiction. It is an apparent contradiction; when you look at it more closely and give it the benefit of the second glance, you can see that, in fact, the terms are not contradictory.
A paradox may be jarring to the ear. Paul said that I must become a slave to be free (Rom: 6:15-23). That sounds contradictory, but when we examine it, we see that he means I have to be a slave in one sense to be free in another sense.
Otherwise, he would be talking nonsense. He is using a paradox; a perfectly legitimate literary form used frequently in many religions and philosophies.
The third category, mystery, is the one that most often is confused with contradiction. In many courses on Christian theology, the first lecture is on the incomprehensibility of God. This does not mean that God is completely unknowable, rather that no human has an exhaustive, categorical understanding of the mind of God:
we cannot know God in His exhaustive fullness. Mohammad would agree with that: God has revealed himself to a degree that we can understand, but there are also dimensions of God that are beyond our human understanding. God is infinite in this perspective, but we can never have an infinite perspective of anything because we are finite. An infinite perspective is beyond our ability. This is axiomatic in Islam, in Jewish theology, and in Christian theology.
The church historically has been very careful in setting forth this definition of the Trinity; God is one in essence, three in person. God is one single being but three persons.
He is one in A, but three in B. The plurality is in a different category from the category of being. The church speaks of three “substances” within God, not three distinct essences.
No one can demonstrate that the formula for the Trinity breaks the law of non-contradiction. The doctrine of the Trinity is neither irrational, nor nonsensical, nor contradictory. Christians are monotheists with respect to the essential being of God Himself, but at the same time, we are saying, within the being of God, there are three distinct personae.
However, these personae do not differ from each other in essence, so it is not a distinction in essence. We distinguish within God, even as the Muslims and the Jew do, the various attributes of God: that God is eternal and God is immutable. That does not mean that there are two different parts of God, one being immutable and the other being eternal. Rather, God is immutably eternal and eternally immutable.
The doctrine of Trinity is based on the New Testament teaching on the nature of Christ.
Islam and Christianity on Sin
According to the Quran, there is a master-servant relationship between God and man. God created Adam and Eve, and they sinned. They repented. God forgave them. Basically, the whole history of salvation according to the Quran is that God has sent prophets throughout history to all people groups to guide them to the straight path, the straight path of worshipping one God, doing good deeds, looking forward to the Day of Judgment and living in the light of the Day of Judgment.
The Quran contains several accounts of the creation story, which on the surface seem similar to the biblical account in Genesis. In Sura 2, God creates Adam and Eve which (Sura 2: 35-37) contains this account.
They disobeyed God and God expelled them from Paradise. When they were expelled, God forgave them. Adam, in fact, became the first prophet. According to Islamic theology, Prophets are kept from fundamental or major sins, because they must be purer than the rest of us to be the conduits for receiving God’s revelation. Islamic theology has no room for any doctrine of the fall of man. Adam sinned and God forgave him. That is the end of the Story. Adam’s sin had no consequence for people who came after Adam. Muslims view Adam’s expulsion from Eden as the occasion for the “Rise of man.”
Islam believes that human kind is not sinful by nature. The Quran does use such terms as ‘ignorant’ ‘weak-willed’, ‘arrogant’, easily led astray, and ungrateful, to describe human nature.
Islam teaches that people are born innocent and remain so until each makes him or herself guilty by misdeeds. Islam does not believe in original sin; and its scripture interprets Adam’s disobedience as his own personal misdeed, a misdeed for which he repented and which God forgave. In this understanding, we have no bad news to tell Muslims, that they are sinners and need salvation; therefore, there is no room for telling them good news later on.
Regarding the doctrine of man, Islam finds itself much in agreement with many people in the West today. Ads for the US Army used the slogan, “Be all that you can be”. Muslims say that Christianity makes man a weak creature that is fallen and in desperate need of help, but Islam gives him dignity. It says “Rise Up! You are morally capable of fulfilling God’s will for yourself. You can do it! You can take actions for yourself and your neighborhood and clean up your society! That is another significant point of difference between the Christian and Islamic understanding of humankind.
Contemporary Muslim critics of Christianity maintain that they have great allies in their debates from not only Enlightenment thinkers and Western philosophers, but also Christian theologians who support their contentions. The majority of the evangelical Christians believe that human kind is basically good. In the history of Christianity, there are basically only three subdivisions of theology. The Pelagian School, the semi-pelagian school and the Augustinian school. Throughout history the church had to deal with heretics.
For centuries, advocates of semi-pelagianism and of Augustinianism have struggled with each other theologically. Both semi-pelagianism and Augustinianism believe in original sin; the debate is over the extent of the original sin. However, Pelagianism, which was condemned as heretical early on in church history, denies original sin.
Pelagians take the position that Adam’s sin affected Adam and only Adam, that sin did not have the power to distort, in anyway, the nature of humankind. That is basically the Muslim view as well.
Thus, before Mohammad, there were Pelagians, teaching this same idea and objecting to the doctrine of original sin. This theology was resurrected in the sixteenth century in the Socianian heresy, which also denied original sin. It was resurrected again in the 19th century by Charles Finney, who was a charismatic, yet denied any transfer of guilt from Adam to his descendants. There are also many within the neo-liberal and radical left schools who profess to be Christian yet deny the fall of man and original sin.
Even if the Bible didn’t teach a doctrine of original sin, natural reason would require it in order to explain the universality of human corruption. If all people were born innocent, and without any bent or inclination towards sin or wickedness, why then do we have the almost universal recognition that nobody is perfect, that everybody sins?
Even humanists will admit that we are not perfect. The universality of corruption is evidence that there is something wrong with the very moral fabric of human nature. Muslims respond to that by saying”, People are born innocent and it is society that corrupts them”.
How did society get corrupted in the first place? Societies are composed of individuals, and if mankind is basically good, one would assume that at least some societies would be without corruption.
However, we must examine ourselves in light of the ultimate standard of righteousness, which is God’s character as presented in the Bible. God calls us to be perfect and holy even as He is holy (I Peter: 1:16)
Paul, writing to the Corinthians, makes this observation: “But they measuring themselves by themselves and comparing themselves among themselves are not wise. (2 Corinthians 10:12). If I compare myself with other people, if I can find someone whose wickedness seems to be more heinous and egregious than my own, I can easily flatter myself into thinking that somehow, I have arrived at an acceptable state of righteousness in the sight of God.
However, the minute we lift our gaze to God Himself and examine ourselves from the vertical standard of His righteousness, we suddenly see our own sinfulness. This is what happened to Isaiah when he saw a glimpse of the holiness of God and was undone (Isaiah 6:), to Habakkuk when he trembled before the manifestation of the holiness of God (Hab. 3:16; to Job 42:1-6) and to the disciples when they realized the full purity of the Christ with whom they were dealing e.g.: Luke 5:8; John 6:”69) All of a sudden, by contrast, they saw their sinfulness. When we fail to do this, we can falsely conclude that we live in a haven of righteousness where there really is not any need for
salvation and atonement. There is no need for redemption because there is nothing to be redeemed from.
In the Quran, God is portrayed in highly majestic and sovereign terms: however, in the entire Quran, the word holy is attributed to God only twice. In one verse in Isaiah,” Holy, Holy, Holy” (Isa 6:3), there are more references to the holiness of God than in the entire Islamic scripture. This has shaped the limited Muslim understanding of the holiness of God. Further, orthodox Muslims do not believe that God has revealed his will and his commands. However, that will and those commands do not reflect God’s righteous and holy character because we cannot know God. His law is not based on His own character.
Because of that understanding of God, and the diminished view of how holy He is, it is obviously very hard for Muslims to understand how sinful we are, and the radical nature of human sinfulness. Many think that “‘we all believe in the same God”.
The Bible says that we fell in Adam: (Rom 5:12, I Cor. 15:22)
The New Testament makes it clear that there is a link between the sin of Adam and the sins of all mankind and this is found in the Old Testament as well (Ps 51:5)
Salvation
The Islamic view of salvation differs radically from the Christian view. Islam views sin as simple actions. When we witness to Muslims it is crucial that we share with them passages like the Sermon on the Mount to show that the biblical view of sin takes us much deeper into heart issues than just superficial actions. Basically, Islam claims that salvation is earned by good works; one of the images in the Quran is that of a scale. On the day of judgment, all your works will be weighed. Then those whose balance of good deeds is heavy, they will attain salvation: but those, whose balance is light, will be those who have lost their souls; in hell will they abide Sura 23:102-103.
Faith is important, but works are essential for salvation. There is hope of salvation, but no assurance, for them Christianity is a welfare religion. “Jesus paid it all”. According to a Muslim, Christianity turns men into weak creatures who are helpless and hopeless and need a savior. Islam gives dignity to men. It says, you can do it. You can stand on your feet. This is basically the Islamic view of salvation. This view is reminiscent of Friedrich Nietzsche, who complained that the soft underbelly of Western Europe was the direct result of the “weakness of religion” propagated by Christianity, which elevated virtues of mercy and grace rather than strength and courage, thus undermining the strength of the existential hero. We find this perspective also in modern existential heroes like Sartre and Camus and even in the popular writings of Ernest Hemmingway and others who complain that Christianity is for the weak and for those who have lost their humanity and have been emasculated.
The Death of Christ
Muslims deny both Jesus’ death on the cross and His deity. They believe in Jesus and honor Him as a great prophet. The Quran mentions Jesus dozens of times and gives Jesus many honorary titles, for example, the messiah or Christ (Sura 4:157) and a sign (23:50) The Quran also claims that Jesus was born of the Virgin Mary. The Quran claims that
Jesus worked many miracles, including raising people from the dead. Further, the Quran claims that Jesus is alive today, and according to Sunni Muslims, he will return before the resurrection of humankind to set the whole world straight.
Muslims assume that they already believe everything that needs to be believed about Jesus and that they already honor him as one of the greatest of Prophets, maybe second only to Muhammad.
In the Quran we read “That they (the Jews) said (in boast), we killed Christ Jesus, the son of Mary, the messenger of Allah. But they killed him not, nor crucified him but so it was made to appear to them, and those who differ therein are full of doubts with no knowledge but only conjecture to follow, for a surety they killed him not, nay, Allah raised him up unto himself (Sura 4:157-158). What ever happened, the Quran makes it very clear that Jesus never died on the cross. However, it was made to appear to people as if Jesus had been crucified. Thus, God was involved in some kind of deceit to save the great honored prophet Jesus.
The Deity of Christ
Islam rejects not only the death of Christ on the cross and the doctrine of the atonement but also the deity of Christ.
The Quran says: “They do blaspheme who say: Allah is Christ, the son of Mary! But said Christ:” O Children of Israel! Worship Allah, my Lord and your Lord (Sura 5:72) Sura 5:75 9Sura 9:30)
When the rich young ruler asks Jesus “Good Teacher, what shall I do that I may inherit eternal life”? Jesus stops him in his tracks and says “Why do you call me good? No one is good but one, that is God” (Mark 10:17, 18). Some critics infer that Jesus is denying his goodness and his deity.
However, if He is denying his goodness, He is also denying His own sinlessness, which would disqualify him from offering an atonement. This inference flatly contradicts everything else Jesus said.
Let’s examine what Jesus is saying here. The man who approached him had no idea that he was talking to God incarnate, and he probably had a very superficial understanding of goodness. He may have thought that all teachers or even all people were basically good. Jesus could have replied, “Your problem, Young man is that you have no idea what goodness is”. Instead of saying that, Jesus points him directly to the law, the standard by which we are shown to be less than good.
He goes to the second table of the law. “You know the commandments:” Do not commit adultery,” Do not murder, do not steal. The man replies,” All these I have kept from my youth”. He may have been thinking: “Is that all I have to do to get into heaven, Keep the Ten Commandments?” Jesus could have said, “Obviously, you were not there when I gave the Sermon on the Mount, when I explained what the real demands are within these commandments, or you wouldn’t have made such a statement.”
The Dark side of Islam
Is Islam a religion of peace or a religion of violence? Let us focus on the issue of Islamic justification for violence and terrorism. The violence of Islam has taken many forms. Most cases of persecution of Christians around the world
today occur in the Islamic World. The Islamic law of apostasy states that any person who converts from Islam to any other religion, whether that person becomes a Christian, a Jew or whatever else, has committed a crime punishable by death.
Many people wrongly say that Islam is a religion of peace. Some claim that these violent Muslims are to Islam what the Ku Klux Klan is to Christianity. Mainly liberals and Muslims say that Osama bin Laden is to Islam what Timothy McVeigh was to Christianity. These are absolutely false analogies. Bin Laden could quote Quranic verses and traditions from Mohammad that justified his actions. McVeigh could not quote from the Bible or refer to Jesus to justify his actions. When the Klan commits acts of racial violence, they are betraying the teachings of Jesus Christ. These false analogies and characterizations are being perpetuated by Western media, politicians, and intellectuals.
Read (Sura 2:190-193), Sura 2: 216 (Sura 3:157-158) (Sura 3:169) Sura3:195, Sura 4:101, Sura 4: 89 (9:5), (9:29), Sura 5: 33 :8:12-13) Sura 47:4, Sura 9:14
These are not isolated passages that some people are misinterpreting or quoting out of context. Such verses are prevalent throughout the Quran, supporting the view that Allah wants his people to fight and destroy the enemies of the people of Allah by the use of the sword and other tools of violence.
Many people today say that these verses were intended just for the time of Muhammad, when the pagans of Mecca were attacking him, and that they do not apply today. However, not even once in the entire Quran is there a restriction put on these verses, which have been used throughout 1400 years of Islamic history, and these verses are universal for all times and all places.
In the Old Testament book of Joshua, God tells Joshua to destroy certain cities in the land of Canaan, but God specifically restricts His command to that time period for a special purpose and a specific group of people. Nowhere in the later Old Testament period do we read general commands to fight the pagans and spread the monotheistic faith of the Jews.
Some Muslims are fond of saying that the Jihad or holy war, in Islam is only a defensive action, only in case of self-defense are Muslims allowed to fight. Muslims are never allowed to initiate a war.
Islam divides the world into two segments: The House of Islam and the House of war. The goal of Islam is to dominate the world; the House of Islam must conquer the House of war.
In a sense it is similar to the Great commission of Jesus Christ; take the gospel to the ends of the earth. On the other hand, Muslims are ordered to use the sword to the ends of the earth.
Muslims do not believe only in the Quran as their ultimate source of authority. Some traditions and some sayings and actions of Muhammad are recorded in other books incorporated into an authoritative body of teaching for Muslims.
In the second century of the Islamic era, Ibn Ishaqe, a Muslim historian wrote a biography of Mohammad titled “Sirat Rasul Allah.” It includes descriptions of the pattern of violence in the life of Muhammad and the example that he set for his followers in terms of violence.
Muhammad started his prophetic ministry when he was 40 years old, when he believed that he began to receive revelations from God. The first 13 years he preached in Mecca about the oneness of God and the pagan society rejected his message. He was invited to go to Medina. He became violent and political in Medina.
Muhammad ordered and orchestrated a series of assassinations against people who opposed him. The first person whom he had assassinated was an elderly Jewish man. In Medina 900 Jewish men were beheaded, and he took their women and children. On one occasion, Muhammad ordered the death of his own uncle, Abu Sufyan, who was the leader of an opposition group.
Besides the actions of Muhammad, another important thing that has shaped the Islamic legal system is the collection of Muhammad’s sayings, the Hadith. In Sunni Islam this book is second in importance to the Quran.
The following saying is the basis of the law of apostasy in Islam: “whoever changed his Islamic religion, kill him”.