Chapter 2 of 21

Introduction

11 min read · Pages 12–20 of the printed edition

Rafiq Zakaria, Indian politician, and Islamic scholar dedicated his book, “Muhammad and the Quran” to his two sons, Arshad and Fareed, students at Harvard and Yale. The dedication reads: “To my sons, Arshad and Fareed who wanted to have a Correct perception of the religion into which they have been born, so that they could Share the knowledge with their friends of Harvard and Yale, where misconceptions about Islam persist. In the words of Benjamin Disraeli, they may have to ‘learn to unlearn. ’The elder Zakaria, now no more, was right on the money when he said, “Misconceptions still persist.” Misconceptions or ignorance about Islam has a much wider sweep than Harvard and Yale; they are almost everywhere in the country. I am not aware of what the Zakaria brothers have done to dislodge the ubiquitous mental disorder of ignorance. They are rich, influential, married to white American girls – an exciting part of the American Dream for many immerges – and live in the north-east. Fareed, the center of controversy last year, is a respected broadcaster for CNN. Fareed Zakaria GPS (Global Public Square) can be heard every Sunday morning. Fareed is reported to have acknowledged recently that he was not a religious person. So Zakaria brothers have not helped, and misconceptions persist.

There is no effective way we can deal with the Islamic world except through a thorough understanding of Islam and how it provokes the turbulence that rages through the world it inhabits. The emphasis on political correctness, so pervasive in our thinking, makes it more difficult for us to ask the right questions and get the right answers. Jonathan Chait writing in ‘New York’ magazine seems to think that political

correctness is wildly out of control. What are the root causes of the malaise that poisons relation between the Islamic and non-Islamic worlds? That question has riled me for a long time, and I wanted to find the answer.

My search for the root causes of the conflict within Islam, and between Islam and others, has taken me all the way to the origin of Islam as set down in the original writings of Islamic scholars. Facts do not lie, so the objective of my research has been to uncover the facts as far as historically and humanly possible. I start my enquiry, therefore, with a disclaimer: As a true Christian open to the positive elements in other faiths, I have launched this enquiry with the sole purpose of unraveling the truth and exposing it without fear or malice. I have set before me the task of studying Islam, its history, its teaching, the Circumstances that expedited its rapid expansion and the causes of its negative perception throughout the world today. The angry young men and women like the quartet that committed murder and mayhem in the French capital on January 7, 2015 are not just a band of castaways of society seeking revenge for their perceived grievances. They are people with hope. They have been assured that their ‘martyrdom’ on this side of paradise would be richly rewarded with endless pleasure in the real paradise. This hope is what motivates them to kill and to die in the act of killing. The word ‘martyrdom’ in its original meaning is witnessing to one’s own faith to the point of laying down his/her life. In other words, martyrdom is dying, not killing. Martyrdom is for heroes, not for cowards who flee after snuffing out innocent lives! Islam’s use of the word ‘martyrdom”. Therefore, is a misuse of the term, just like its use of the word ‘blasphemy!’ Blasphemy in its real meaning is speaking profanely or irreverently against God or sacred things. It is an act of mocking divinity. Muhammad, Islam’s founder never claimed to be divine. In fact, he insisted that he was only human like everyone else. So where do these ideas of martyrdom and blasphemy come from? My hunch is that it is a later misuse of terms borrowed from Judaism or Christianity. A critical analysis of Islam’s history should, I believe, provide the real clue to the understanding of the terrorist mindset. And that is one of my reasons for undertaking this study. Creating a culture of hatred and death should be alien to the essential purpose of religion.

The true purpose of religion is to create a culture of life and unity.

Freedom to Criticize

What Muslims must understand is that if they have the freedom to criticize the Bible, then other people have the same freedom to criticize the Quran. Many Muslims feel that any criticism of the Quran is blasphemous and should not be allowed. This unrelenting attitude explains why Muslim apologists will not agree to debate the apparent errors and contradictions in the Quran. They want to debate the scriptures of other religions though, but never agree to debate their own scripture, the Quran.

No honest and open-minded discussion should be viewed as an attempt to belie or belittle a person’s belief or the source of that belief. It should be taken as a sincere effort at understanding what is sacrosanct to the debaters. Hence discussions should be carried out in an objective and respectful manner so that they lead to the discovery of truth. Any religion which refuses to allow people to examine its sacred books and long-held traditions using the normal rules

of research and logic evidently has something to hide.

My aim in this essay is to undertake an analytical and critical study of Islam without any prejudice or subjective slant. I have conducted extensive research for more than two decades on the various aspects of Islam. I am a seeker, not a bigot. My aim is truth, not slander. This writer had the opportunity to speak about Islam in many places. So I prepared extensive notes and many like-minded individuals wanted to see my notes in a book format. I thank Almighty God for enabling me to present my research and study to the public in book form.

After 9/11, when thousands of innocent people were killed by Islamic extremists, the naive and historically ignorant American liberals began to ask "why do they hate us”. “What is wrong with American Foreign Policy?” “America might have provoked the Islamic world". But the relevant question must be "what is wrong with the Islamic world, and why doesn’t it reform itself like Christianity and Hinduism". The basic problem is very clear: people in the Islamic world do not believe in free speech, freedom of religion, democracy, a secular state, Free Press, Free enterprise, and human rights. Sunnis and Shias hate each other and try to destroy each other, but Sunnis and Shias are one in hatred of Israel and America. Just travel back in history for 1400 years. Then the truth will be clear. Wherever Islam went, that place had been drastically changed, for the worse! There is a well-known, albeit, somewhat pluckish saying: “Islam can exist only in a desert, and if there is no desert, it will make one. “Look at Lebanon. Before 1970, Lebanon was the richest and most advanced country in the Middle East. Lebanon, like USA and Western Europe, practiced tolerance and inclusiveness. It allowed Muslims to enter as refugees and helped them. Then after a few years, they started sectarian conflicts and ended up killing each other and the original denizens of the host country.

At present about 70 countries are involved in civil unrest because of Islamic terrorism. There are around 1.6 billion Muslims around the globe. Are they all terrorists or violent?

Of course not. According to some calculations only 25% are extremists. Still it is a large number constituting more than 400 million Muslims in the world. Most of the Muslims are peaceful. When you investigate history, most German people were peaceful, but Hitler changed all that and about 60 million people lost their lives. The fact that the majority are peaceful is irrelevant. It is also the case with Stalin’s Russia and Mao’s China. A brutal dictator or a psychopathic group of barbarians can change the world no matter how many are peace-loving and silent. The so-called “peaceful majority” is powerless and irrelevant.

Apologists for Islam say Islam means "peace" and the fundamentalist killers are a tiny minority. This canard has been repeated, either as a statement of appeasement or out of sheer ignorance, by some highly placed officials in American administration. One would hope that they know better. They have been contradicted, quite recently, by a well-known Islamic leader. He stated during a speech, “Islam is not a religion of peace, but a religion of submission.” Polls conducted among Muslims offer some shocking revelations: 61% of Muslims worldwide believed that the Arabs did not carry out the attack on World Trade Centers on September 11, 2001; only 18% believed that they did. 77% of Muslims opposed the liberation of Afghanistan.

Islamic terrorists are like Africanized bees. Bees have been around for a long time. Living in harmony and having their place and function in the world, welcomed by everyone for their contributions and right to exist peacefully. The Africanized bee on the other hand, is tolerant of no other species or any non-Africanized bees. They will attack and kill everything else aggressively. All other species and any non- Africanized bee is their enemy. You can't de-Africanize a bee. You can only destroy it wherever you find its hive. Let us hope that we can wipe out the Africanized bees before they are the only bees left. It would be helpful if the regular bees understood this and separated themselves from the Africanized bees so that we could wipe out the bad bees and leave the good bees alone. Think about it bees. Our biggest obstacle is that we have an Africanized bee from "Hawaii" in charge of doing this job. And he refuses to use the word bee or Africanized.

Poll conducted among Egyptians in September 2002:

The majority (52%) of Egyptians supported the September 11 killings. Only 19% think Islamists did it, despite the fact the operation was led by an Egyptian! 39% thought Israel did it. The majority of Muslims in the world also supported suicide bombings and the destruction of Israel. Another interesting poll shows that almost all Muslims hate U.S.A. But another question was like this:

“In which country would you most like to live? Top answer is- U.S.A. After 9/11, Palestinians danced in the streets to celebrate the killing of thousands of innocent civilians. The celebration took place also in many other Islamic Countries.

One of the most depressing aspects of the modern crisis has been how little soul searching there has been in Islam after 9/11.

An Indian Muslim, Muqtedar Khan, once said: “America is without a doubt one of the greatest countries in the world because it assumes we are moral beings and capable of doing good – we are free” He further stated “I know for sure that nowhere on earth including India, will I get the same sense of dignity and respect that I have received in the US.” It is time that we acknowledge that the freedoms we enjoy in the U.S are more desirable to us than superficial solidarity with the Muslim world. If you disagree then prove it by packing your bags and going to whichever Muslim country, you identify with”.

Thomas Friedman wrote in a December 3, 2008 article on the hypocrisy and silence of the Muslim world after the Mumbai terrorist attack asked, “After all, if 10 young Indians from a splinter wing of the Hindu Nationalist Bharatiya Janata Party travelled by boat to Pakistan, shot up two hotels in Karachi and the Central train station, killed at least 173 people and then, for good measure, murdered the Imam and his wife at a Saudi financed mosque while they were cradling their two year old son - purely because they were Sunni Muslims – where would we be today? The entire Muslim world would be aflame and, in the streets”,

As Ed Morrissey says: “Has Friedman seen massive protests in the streets against radical Islamist terrorists in these Muslim countries ever. Did any of them protest 9/11 attacks or the Madrid attack, Mumbai attack, London attack”?

Freedom of Religion

Many Muslims take personal offenses at any criticism of their religious beliefs. They find it very difficult to understand that “Freedom of religion” in the west means that people are free to criticize Islam as well as any other religion. This freedom is protected in the west. This is sometimes very hard for Arab Muslims to understand because they previously lived in Islamic countries, where any criticism of Mohammad or the Quran is viewed as a criminal offence punishable by death. Under Islam if you criticize Islam you die.

No religion, no matter how fervently believed or zealously practiced should be afraid of the searching light of scientific research. Since Muslims evidently have no problem whatsoever in openly criticizing other religions, why should they have a problem with those who for good and sufficient reasons criticize Islam.

After all, the same Bill of Rights that guarantees to Muslims the freedom to criticize other religions also gives other people the freedom to criticize Islam. The sword of religious freedom always cuts both ways.

Koran’s tolerance of other religions

Koran 2: 191 “Slay unbelievers wherever you find them.” Koran 3:28 “Muslims must not take the infidels as friends”. Koran 3: 85 “Any religion other than Islam is not acceptable.” Koran 5:33 “Maim and crucify the infidels if they criticize Islam”.

Koran 8:12 “Terrorize and behead those who believe in scriptures other than the Koran”. Koran 8:60 “Muslims must muster all weapons to terrorize the infidels.” Koran 8:65 “The unbelievers are stupid; urge the Muslims to fight them.” Koran 9:5 When opportunities arise kill the infidels wherever you catch them.” Koran 9:30 “The Jews and the Christians are perverts; fight them.” Koran 9:123 “Make war on the infidels living in your neighborhood.” Koran 22:19 “Punish the unbelievers with the garments of fire, hooked iron rods boiling water; melt their skin and bellies”. Koran 47:4 “Do not hanker for peace with the infidels; behead them when you catch them.”

Wife Beating Sura 4:34

Men are in charge of women, because Allah hath made the one of them to excel the other, and because they spend of their property (for the support of women). So good women are the obedient, guarding in secret what Allah had guarded. As for those from whom ye fear rebellion, admonish them and banish them to beds apart, and scourge them. Translated by: Mohammed Marmaduke Pickthall.

“Islam is as dangerous in a man as rabies in a dog” Winston Churchill.