Chapter 14 of 21
Arguments for Islam and the Answers
It is very important for the Christian Church to know the challenge of Islam and how to respond to it. There are 7 to 9 million Muslims living in America. Many Christians interact with Muslims every day, as co-workers and neighbors. Thus, it is very important for every Christian to have a better understanding of Islam, what Muslims believe and how to respond to the typical Muslim’s questions about the Christian faith.
It is also important not to stereotype Islam as a simple religion that promotes violence. In fact, Islam had a rich tradition in its intellectual history and in its cultural achievements. Throughout history, the Muslim world has produced many philosophers and scientists.
There is a fundamental difference between Islam and Christianity in four main areas. 1) The nature and the authority of the Bible. (2) The nature of God 3) the view of human kind 4) the view of Christ. Islam and Christianity have diametrically opposed ideas on these four important points.
The theological challenges that Islam presents to the Christian faith are not only from Muslims. Western intellectuals, liberals, Christian scholars, and the so called enlightenment thinkers have expressed basically the very same challenges to Christianity that Muslims have expressed for the past 1400 years. It is, therefore, understandable that Muslims feel intellectually justified in rejecting Christianity.
They might say “we have been saying these things against Christianity for 1400 years and now your own Western scholars and your Christian writers are saying these same things that we have been saying all along.”
Immanuel Kant and Thomas Jefferson expressed their doubts about the doctrine of the Trinity. According to many Christian scholars the doctrine of the Trinity is incomprehensible. A Muslim might say “Our holy book, the Quran, told us 1400 years ago that there is only one God and we should worship that God; and that Christians have been misled from the teachings of the Prophet Jesus when they have professed the doctrine of the Trinity.
Another fundamental conviction of the Christian faith is that we are born in a state of sin, that Adam’s sin has affected us. However, many surveys indicate that the vast majority of Americans, including evangelical Christians, believe that we are basically good people. A Muslim might respond by saying “we have been saying for all these years that human kind is basically good and now Western people, including Christians are coming to the same conclusions.”
Also, the Christian faith believes that it is only because of Jesus’ death on the cross that we can have any hope of salvation, our sins have been imputed to Him and His righteousness has been imputed to us. Islam, on the other hand, claims that all people are responsible for their own actions and for their own salvation. Nobody else can pay for someone else’s sins.
The idea that God forgives human sin by virtue of punishing an innocent figure in our place raises a host of moral difficulties. Many Christians even view individuals as morally autonomous agents: I am responsible only for my own choices. Such a moral perspective poses many questions for the theory of atonement. How can the suffering of an innocent person take away my guilt?
Islam has a great appeal to people of all backgrounds because it presents itself as a very rational, intellectual, and easy to understand faith. Muslims believe Christianity is filled with mysteries and mumbo jumbo that nobody can understand. People simply have to take all of it by faith. However, Islam presents itself as a very rational simple religion, the religion of nature that any child can understand.