Chapter 1 of 21
Foreword
This is not a book, this is an encyclopedia, a miniencyclopedia, if you will. If it were an institution, it would be a small university with an assortment of departments. What is unique about this magnum opus, though, is that it is one man’s work. And it shows the sweep of his knowledge, the depth of his erudition and the mettle of his commitment to Truth. Truth is as simple as black and white, but to tell the Truth, depending on its nature and content and the circumstances in which it is told, can be a dangerous undertaking. The famous dictum: “In time of universal deceit, telling the truth is a revolutionary act.” But to those who are committed to telling it as it is, no other option is available. So I congratulate Dr. Kamble for venturing into a minefield of misunderstanding, criticism and possible hostile reactions. He assures us that as a Christian living under the precept of loving friends and foes alike, he harbors malice for none and good will for all.
Dr. Kamble is a historian, a sociologist, an economist, a meticulous researcher credited with talent, enthusiasm and painstaking effort. Above all, he is a versatile scholar with the divine gift of curiosity. Among the topics he has discussed in this collection of essays, a prominent section is devoted to various aspects of Islamic studies.
It is safe to say that in America, even among well-educated citizens, there is a conspicuous absence of curiosity when it comes to what anthropologist, Ruth Benedict calls “Other Cultures.” Some years ago, while I was doing post graduate studies at Delhi School of Economics, an American missionary asked me if I could give a talk to the American
Embassy families on Buddhism. I never suspected that my audience would turn out to be 8th graders!
Even after the nine/eleven tragedy in which nineteen Muslim radicals commandeered four airplanes full of Americans and used them as guided missiles to destroy America’s pride, Americans have not tried enough to understand what Islam is capable of and what irrational behaviors Islamic sources can inspire in some of its followers. Dr. Kamble’s research published in this work should go a long way in educating the public of the rudiments of Islam.
As a teenager I grew up among Muslims. I have had enough contact with the “believers” to make proper distinction between Islam and Muslims. And my focus here, as it is that of Dr. Kamble, is Islam and not individual Muslims. I know from my limited experience and wide reading, that there are millions and millions of Muslims who are decent and peace-loving human beings, caring, compassionate and kind. V.S. Naipaul during his travels “Among the Believers” came across also Muslims who called themselves “Statistical Muslims,” slack in their practice of the faith, but rattled by the violence perpetrated by some of their fellow Muslims who bring discredit to the community which is called in Arabic “Umma.” Naipaul speaks about Arab Imperialism in which the Arabs, particularly, Saudi Arabia tries to impose its own brand of Islam by pouring billions of dollars into the Wahhabi brainwashing machine called madrassas. Naipaul writes: “Islam almost from the start, had been an imperialism as well as a religion, with an early history remarkably like a speeded-up version of the history of Rome, developing from city-state to peninsular overlord, to empire, with corresponding stresses at every stage.” (Among the Believers P.7)
Among today’s believers, two broad divisions can be identified: An overwhelming majority of peace loving, law abiding and observant Muslims (who make Islam a religion of peace) and a violent, radicalized fringe that makes Islam look like the Empire of Tamerlane.
Indeed, divisions have existed and still exist in other religions as well. Christianity is one clear example of divisions – the fault line running all the way through the Middle Ages - but they could be mended by going back to the sources where the means for mending the cracks have been provided: “Love thine enemies.” Christian teaching provides us the intelligence and humility to realize, as in Shakespeare’s Julius Caesar, that “the faults are not in our stars, dear Brutus, but in ourselves.” In Islam, however, there are no such provisions in its sources, instead, we see a widening rift between groups such as Shias and Sunnis. Muslim journalist Hasan Suroor writes in Hindu (September 29, 2014) that “the Koranic text is a minefield of ambiguity allowing people to cherry-pick equivocal and often contradictory verses to back their arguments.” Further on, in the same article, Suroor quotes a distinguished British Pakistani Islamic scholar (Ziauddin Sardar) “There is no denying the streak of violence which is “inherent” in Islam.” So peace and hostility coexist in the same Islamic sources which they all recite yet understand differently. Young Muslims are taught tolerance and peaceful coexistence in India, while In Pakistan and Saudi Arabia, they are taught Jews are pigs and Christians are monkeys and Islam is God 3.0, Christians are God 2.0, Jews are God 1.0 and Hindus and all others are God 0.0. The lessons are, alas, drawn from the
same sources.
We face three major problems when we try to delve deep into the history and teaching of Islam: 1. Why did the immediate followers of Muhammad fail to bring about a smooth succession? What caused the Shia/Sunni divide? 2. After a thousand years of glory, what caused the humiliating fall of Islamic civilization? And 3. If the Koran is the literal word of Allah and co-eternal with him, what accounts for the baffling contradictions in the Koranic text?
- When Islam’s founder, Muhammad died suddenly in AD 632, there was no designated successor or a system of succession. During the powwow that ensued, two contestants emerged to claim leadership of the community. They based their claims on bloodlines. The first was Abu Bakr, a close friend of Muhammad and father of Aisha, Muhammad’s favorite wife and a force to be reckoned with in her own right. The second contestant was Ali, Muhammad’s cousin and husband of his daughter Fatimah. Plenty of bad blood had existed between Ali and Aisha before the question of succession came up. There was no love lost between Aisha and Khadija, Muhammad’s first wife and Fatimah’s mother. And also Aisha hated Ali for demanding punishment to be meted out to her for spending time with a young fighter who was not a relative. The story of the ‘Lost Necklace’ is well known in
the history of Islam. Abu Bakr and Ali had supporters in the community. The partisans of Abu Bakr were called ‘Sunnis, for they decided to follow the ‘Sunna’ which is described as the code of pious practices based on Muhammad’s example.
The supporters of Ali were called Shi’at Ali or the party of Ali from which the term Shia is derived. Abu Bakr was almost immediately chosen successor or Caliph because Aisha testified that Muhammad had designated him as the successor. When Ali was passed over two more times, his party rebelled. So he was made Caliph in 656. Ali’s claim was, nonetheless, hotly contested. Intense hatred, spawned by the ever-deepening family feud, played a role in the assassination of Ali at Kufa in 661 by an extremist whose poisoned sword struck a tragic note that has reverberated ever since. The Shia-Sunni schism pitted Muslim against Muslim and led to civil wars, massacres and collapse of dynasties. The split and its deadly consequence have lasted even to our own day with no effort at compromise or unity.
Pope Benedict XVI argued that for any move towards understanding and unity, the discussions should be based on reason. The Pope added that a conception of God without reason leads to violence. An effort was made in Basra and Bagdad, (Iraq) in the 8th century to build up an Islamic theology based on reason and rational thinking. The effort was masterminded by a group called the ‘Mutazilites’ who were inspired by Greek Philosophy and Christian Apologetics. Mutazilites denied the presumed status of the Koran as uncreated and co-eternal with God. Though the Abbasid Caliphate endorsed the Mutazilites position, it lasted only
two centuries and was confined only to a small area in Iraq.
A New school of theology called the Asharites replaced the Mutazilite School. They contradicted and rejected the rationalist position of the Mutazilites. The primacy of reason lost out to the primacy of will and power. God was pure will. He can change his mind and do anything he wills. Asharites reinstated the status of the Koran as coeternal with God. They taught that it is inscribed on a tablet in heaven and it appears exactly today in Arabic. Muhammad Ibn Zakariya a Razi, a Persian Polymath who lived between the years of 854 and 925 AD challenged this position. “………. You claim that the evidentiary miracle is present and available, namely the Koran. You say: “Whoever denies it, let him produce a similar one.” Indeed, we shall produce a thousand from the works of rhetoricians, eloquent speakers and valiant poets, which are more appropriately phrased and state the issues more succinctly. They convey the meaning better and their rhymed prose is in better meter…. By God, what you say astonishes us! You are talking about a work which recounts ancient myths, and which at the same time is full of contradictions and does not contain any useful information or explanation. Then you say: ‘produce something like it.” Contemporaries of Sheikh Zakariya a Razi referred to him as ‘that infidel, that crazy ex-Muslim’. And the Sheikh retorted: “If the people of this religion are asked about proof of the soundness of their religion, they flare up, get angry and spill the blood of whoever confronts them with this question. They forbid rational speculation, and strive to kill their adversaries. This is why truth became thoroughly silenced and concealed.”
The second dilemma, namely, what caused the collapse of the Islamic civilization after a thousand years of glory, has been effectively studied by the eminent Islamic scholar, Bernard Lewis, respected and endorsed by both Muslims and non-Muslims alike. In a tribute, the late Fouad Ajami said in 2006: “Bernard Lewis, the esteemed scholar of Islam and of the Middle East is one of the Cassandras of our time.” Cassandra, by the way, was one of the princesses of Troy, astonishingly beautiful and blessed with the gift of foreseeing the future. Bernard Lewis in his book, “Clash of Civilizations” written way before the nine/eleven, refers to the ‘tense dynamic between Islam and the West’ and offers a historical case for what he calls the Muslim world’s “downward spiral of hate and spite, rage and self-pity, poverty and oppression.” And though, he does not explicitly mention it, he leaves his readers to ponder the question:
whether a religion rooted in the belief that all truth was revealed to its prophet, can ever successfully embrace change.
The downward spiral of the Islamic civilization was set off with the military defeat at the gate of Vienna in 1683. The setback was repeated in other spheres as well when the Western (Christian) societies leaped ahead. Muslims tried to respond, but they conflated Westernization and Modernization together. They rejected Westernization, but sought modernization. Lewis says, ‘it’s a bleak roadmap of missteps to the Islamic world of today, impoverished in almost everything but terrorism and despotism.’ Hasan Suroor whom I already quoted above, says: “There has been no Islamic equivalent of Enlightenment and Renaissance, and the Islamic mindset remains awkwardly out of step with historical progress, and therefore, with modern times, reinforced by attempt to assert an Islamic identity through beards and hijabs.
The third and the last question is how to reconcile the contradictions that exist in Islam with the stultifying claim that Islam is so perfect that there is nothing in it that needs change or reform. Some of the mainstream Muslims or the silent majority accept this position without questioning. They believe that there is no need for any reform in Islam. In most Muslim communities, the operational principle is: “yours is not to question why; yours is to do and die.” Independent thinking is not encouraged, in fact, it is often stifled. Philosopher Susan Neiman defines an adult as a person who has developed a capacity for independent thinking, a talent that society conspires to stifle. Islamic societies, particularly the ones dominated by fundamentalist thinking, have conspired to stifle independent thinking. Most believers in those societies are so docile as to live with contradictions that exist in their religion, yet never question. They will tell you that Islam is a religion of peace and yet, watch without dismay the mindless violence that are often perpetrated in its name. They will tell you that women in their society enjoy equality and are treated with dignity and respect, and yet, they are aware of the fact that in Islam, a woman’s testimony is only half as good as that of a man. They see no irony in the fact that their religion exhorts its followers to gain knowledge even if it means “going to China” yet, they condone killing of little girls for attending school. Their leaders preach tolerance and peaceful coexistence with other communities but they never ask why their religion is so often described as synonymous with hate and intolerance.
Hasan Suroor whom we have already met in these pages, admits that Islam has two faces: There are some Muslims who cite the Koran and the Hadith to underline injunctions against violence, and the command to respect women, and practice tolerance, love and brotherhood, but then there are also other Muslims like Taliban who quote the same sources to show the legitimacy of their positions on treating infidels and renegades the way they do.
Suroor tries to explain these conflicts by chalking them up to texts that lend themselves to misunderstanding and misinterpretation. He and many others like him have suggested ways of remedying the confusion, but these moderate, well- educated Muslims exert hardly any influence in the larger community. Any suggestion of change or reform is rejected outright, because “the Koran is the literal word of Allah revealed progressively to Prophet Muhammad.” So moderate Muslims as well as non-Muslims are left with a bunch of questions with no convincing answers!
I feel it would be ungracious of me to end these comments on Islam’s history on a pessimistic note. Islam has its problems just as other organized religions, but it would be grossly unfair to portray the second largest religion in the world as a problem. Islam’s contribution to world civilization and to progress in the sciences is enormous. The way it transformed Arab society is nothing less than phenomenal. Islam brought an end to 'Jahilliya’ (period of ignorance); polytheism and widespread idolatry once practiced by the pre-Islamic Arabia were replaced by strict monotheism. Islam built some of the greatest cultures in the world and some of the world’s great wonders. What happened to those powers, talents and the creative energy? Why has the once glorious civilization now ended up near the bottom of the heap? How did Islam get from Avicenna and Cordoba to Osama Bin Laden and the Al Qaeda? How does the strident call for jihad benefit the religion? The world today is too big and too
powerful for one small group of Jihadists to conquer and convert it to its own ideology. The world is moving inexorably forward and it is moving through cooperation and collaboration. Globalization is the language of mutuality and reciprocity. The rest of the world is moving towards unity, towards symbiosis.
As I write this, Pope Francis is addressing the United Nations. “You are a microcosm of the world,” he reminded ambassadors of nations, “take care of each other. And if there are non-believers among you, I ask them to wish me well.”
I have long understood that arguments never change hearts. As the great Indian sage, Kabir said, it is love that changes heart. So, every morning I pray for a change of heart, first in me, and then in all the people who hate those who follow different ideologies. I wish Dr. Kamble much success in his effort to bring people together in wisdom and grace.
Varghese Kamplath