Chapter 13 of 21

The Untold Refugee Story

16 min read · Pages 173–187 of the printed edition

If you read about the Middle East problem in the newspaper or listen to the discussions in the news, you can’t help but be bombarded by analysts suggesting the key to peace is resolving “the Palestinian refugee issue”. There is another untold side of the Middle East refugee story.

The world seldom hears about a million refugees who fled Arab terror and hatred and settled in Israel. Why the cover up?

Why isn’t this story reported? Why isn’t it chronicled? Why isn’t it remembered? If Arab nations are responsible for expelling Jews in the same numbers as was the much publicized Arab refugees displaced after the creation of Israel, why isn’t the obvious solution a simple population exchange? The enormity of the Muslim myth being swallowed by the West is nowhere more graphically illustrated than in this issue. There is no moral equivalence in this situation. The Jews did not drive out Palestinian refugees. They were not threatened or killed so as to terrorize survivors into leaving.

In many cases Palestinians were begged to stay. However, they were ordered to leave “temporarily” by the combined Muslim armies who promised to annihilate Jews and the new state.

On the other hand, Jews living in Arab countries were terrorized, murdered, and driven out. Their properties and assets were confiscated. Those who escaped were thankful just to be left alone. The Jews were received and immediately repatriated into the new fragile state of Israel.

They were given aid and jobs to the best ability of the struggling new country.

The Palestinians were deliberately forced into refugee camps and not permitted to integrate into the society of their unwilling hosts, even though they were fellow Muslims. They did not even try to help them; instead, they prevailed upon the UNO to supply the refugees’ needs. Kept in these camps by their own people for more than 67 years, they are used as political pawns so that Muslim negotiations can continue to trump up charges of “Israeli aggression.”

Some popular Muslims mythology

Many myths have been spun to suppress the facts about Jewish immigration from Arab lands. Let us review some of the tales that teach the exact opposite of the truth.

Myth #1: The Arabs have nothing against Jews in general and lived in peace and harmony with them, until the creation of the Zionist movement and consequent creation of the state of Israel in 1948.

Myth #2: Alienation of Jews began in large part because Israel is almost entirely made up of European Jews who displaced indigenous Arab peoples in Palestine.

Myth # 3: The Key to resolving the Middle East crisis is to stop Israeli aggression and occupation of Arab lands and to create an independent Palestinian State.

Myth # 4: Israel’s US supplied military weapons have been practiced against the peaceful neighbors.

These myths have worked like magic for Muslim propagandists for decades, but especially for all negotiations. You hear the propaganda “Israeli aggression and occupation of Arab Land. The real truth is that half of the Jewish population of Israel are refugees or offspring of refugees from Arab countries.

Collective Amnesia

For some reason, the whole world has swallowed unbelievable products of the Arab propaganda machine. The fact that the Zionist struggle was active mainly in Europe and America and the fact that ignorance has prevailed concerning the Dhimmi condition and its aftereffects (insecurity, fear and silence) have led to Zionism’s being viewed as an exclusively Western movement.

An incredible Irony:

Modern media invented a perfect term for what Muslim nations have done with the history of “Dhimmis”- Turn-speak which means “a cynical inverting or distorting of facts, which for example, makes the victim appear to be the oppressor. Arab propagandists have used turns to speak perfectly in perpetuating the myth of “displaced” and “terrorized” Arabs in the Jewish settled area of Palestine-cum- Israel.

The record shows that migrant Muslims came from other Arab countries to areas of Palestine that were reclaimed and developed by Jews in order to get jobs. It was afterward that they began to claim Jews displaced them from land that had been in their families for hundreds of years.

There have been colossal injustices inflicted on the people of Palestine- only it wasn’t Jews who committed the injustices but Muslims-who sought to drive Jews out of a plot of land that was only a fraction of what was originally mandated to them by the League of Nations. When the map of the Middle East was completely redrawn after the fall of the Turkish Ottoman Empire in 1917, Arab States were created from the stateless remains of the Ottoman occupation and a certain section was mandated to the Jews as a homeland. No matter how small the Jewish state was made, it was still too big for Muslims-because it isn’t the size of Israel that matters to Muslims, it is the existence of Israel.

The Rule of Hatred

The most cynical myth of all, however, is the lie that Jews enjoyed freedom, liberty and kind treatment while dwelling in Muslim ruled lands before the rise of Zionism. Here are some impartial observations of the Jews or Dhimmi’s treatment.

In their Holy Land, the Jews as well as Christians suffered long from harsh discrimination. According to the British consulate report in 1839, the Jewish life was not much above that of a dog.

In truth, “Arab” terrorism in the Holy Land originated centuries before the recent toll of the Palestinian cause was invented. In towns where Jews lived for hundreds of years, those Jews were periodically robbed, raped in some places, massacred, and in many instances, the survivors were obliged to abandon their possessions and run.

In the early seventeenth century, a pair of Christian visitors to Galilee told of life for the Jews “Life here is the poorest and most miserable that one can imagine. Because of the harshness of Turkish rule and its crippling Dhimmi oppression, the Jews pay for the very air they breathe”. The monstrous myth, that there was no problem for the Jews living peacefully with the Muslims until the rise of Zionism and the founding of the state of Israel, is a classic example of Muslim Turn-speak and the cynical hatred motivating it.

A technique of propaganda called “Turn-speak”: The Arab league makes use of a cognitive technique of propaganda called “Turn-speak”, where you attack someone and then turn it around 180 degrees and claim they attacked you. Because the truth is the exact opposite of the information being disseminated, it is psychologically difficult to counter and leads to confusion.

The term was first used by journalists to describe German propaganda after it invaded Czechoslovakia in March of 1939. To win sympathy for their invasion, the Germans practiced what has become known as “Turn-speak”. They turned the blame back on the Czechs for trying to precipitate in an all-out war in the region. In other words, the (Czechs in their attempt to hang on to their land were ready to plunge all of Europe into war.) How did the rest of Europe respond to this lie? They believed it. World leaders decided that something had to be done to preserve peace at any cost.

From the crusades to the Ottoman Turk Empire: The last European Crusade

The eighth and final European crusade was led by the King of France. It ended in A.D 1291 with the fall of the last Christian stronghold in the Holy Land- the port city of Acre (Akko in Hebrew). There would not be another European attempt to liberate the Holy Land for 500 years. Oddly enough another French King, Napoleon Bonaparte, would launch it. He arrived in 1798. Interestingly, Napoleon’s quest failed because he suffered his first military defeat at Acre.

By God’s providence, Napoleon’s cannons were captured while being transported from Alexandria to Joppa when British Admiral Nelson intercepted and defeated the French Navy. Napoleon arrived and was bombarded by his own artillery. Some of his best and bravest soldiers were lost before he gave up and left.

God’s hand was in this; for Napoleon had promised his Jewish financiers he would capture the Holy Land and establish the State of Israel. This would have been out of God’s predicted timetable; Hebrew prophets prophesied God would bring back the scattered sons of Israel and cause the nation to be born shortly before the coming of the Messiah.

The Mongol Invasion of Muslims

The Mongol tribes were united under Chief Temujin in A.D 1206. He was renamed Genghis Khan, which meant “super ruler”. He charged across the steppes and over the Caucuses Mountains to take on the Muslim empire. The formidable Mongol cavalry and fierce warriors were virtually unstoppable. By A.D 1258, the goddess horde, led by Genghis Khan’s grandson Hulague Khan, destroyed the Abbasid

Caliphate of Baghdad as well as the Seljuk sultanate in Asia Minor.

The Mongols posed a tremendous threat to Asia, the Middle East and Europe. They were finally defeated by Muslim Mamelukes at the battle of Ain Jalut in A.D 1260. Origin of the Ottoman Empire

After the Mongols had passed, a young Turkish mercenary named Othman, he gathered some of the shattered Seljuk’s forces together and began to impose order amid ruin. Othman slowly extended his martial Law through Asia Minor. After many years of struggle, he created the only kind of state feasible amid wreckage left by the Mongols. It was a military dictatorship of which he became the first sultan. (Asia Minor –Turkey). In A.D 1288, Uthman, the first Sultan of all Turks, formed the Uthman Muslim Dynasty. It soon became known by its variant name – the Ottoman Empire. Their leaders were called Sultans instead of Caliphs.

For the next six centuries, 37 descendants of the house of Uthman or Othman ruled the empire. It became one of the largest and richest in history.

The Ottoman Empire affected on the Middle East

The Ottoman Turks were not, and never considered themselves to be a part of the Arab world.

To Arabs as to Europeans, the Ottoman Turks were essentially foreign masters. They literally obliterated the State identities and boundaries of the Middle East. For the next four centuries, there were no nation- states such as Syria, Lebanon, Iraq/Babylon, Arabia, Persia etc. They were simply territories ruled by Ottoman Viziers from major cities.

Palestine, for instance, included what are now known as Syria, Lebanon, Jordan and Israel and was ruled from Damascus. There were no independent Arab nations and no defined boundaries.

When the British liberated the area from the Ottoman Turks, no Arab had any more valid claim to a specific land or state than the Jew did. As a matter of fact, the Jews had a mandate of specific land ratified by the League of Nations. Not one Arab State could claim this kind of ratification from such a world authority.

The Palestinians from Bosnia- Herzegovina

To counteract the effect of some Jewish emigration that took place between 1847 and 1880, Ottoman authorities began an affirmative action program to resettle European Muslims in Palestine. While Arabs often make much of the European Heritage of many of Israel’s Jews, calling them “foreign invaders”, the truth is, many of today’s so-called Palestinians have European roots going back only a generation or two.

During the latter stages of the receding Ottoman Empire, beginning around 1878, Muslim refugees from the lost Islamic Provinces of Europe streamed into Palestine

The Ottoman government settled these immigrants in troubled regions, thereby tightening its control through a policy of Muslim colonization. In 1878, after annexation of Bosnia- Herzegovina by Austria, Bosnian Muslim colonists arrived in Macedonia and on the coastal plains of Palestine

. Ottoman Desolation of Holy Land

The Holy Land under the Ottoman Turks suffered more devastation in four hundred years than the previous fifteen hundred. By the 19th century, the ancient canal and irrigation systems were destroyed. The land was barren and filled with Malaria ridden swamps. The hills were denuded of trees and brush so all the terraces and top soil had eroded away, leaving only rocks.

The Curse of the Turk “Effendis”

With the horrible condition of the land in the late 19th century, most Muslim inhabitants of the Holy Land were eager to leave if a buyer for their property could be found.

The amazing Jewish reclamation

From the 1880’s through 1918, Jews returning to Palestine faced a harsh life in a barren malaria-infested land. Still they came and by the turn of the century, Jewish villages dotted the countryside. A few years later, Jews represented most of the population in Jerusalem. There was new life in Haifa, Safed, and Tiberius. In 1909, the first modern all- Hebrew city was founded on the sands of the Mediterranean –Tel Aviv.

Far from being run off the land, the Muslim population benefited greatly from these developments. Quickly, opportunities arose for three Arab groups.

  1. The landless population looking for work.
  2. The people indebted to the absentee landlords
  3. The Effendis themselves, who sold land to the Jews at astronomical prices.

The “Effendis” sowed the seeds of the Middle East Crisis

The Effendis collected taxes for the Turkish administration and controlled the populace from their seats on governing councils. However, before long, many of them saw their little feudal empires threatened by the growing influence of the Jews. So they resorted to the age-old tactic that always worked in Muslim history- make the Jews scapegoats.

Effect of World War I on Palestine How the British set up the Middle East Crisis?

The British were to receive a lesson from the age-old Arab Adage: “Promise an Arab a centimeter and he will demand a Kilometer”. Another gross British misunderstanding was with the Muslim religious power structure. The sheriff of Mecca did not have the same authority and control over Islam as the Pope does over the Roman Catholic Church. Yet this was the basic assumption on which their planned control of the Arabs depended. The Turks had destroyed the Arab Caliphate in Mecca centuries before. So the Arabs had no controlling authority with which to deal. There was only a horde of warring tribes wanting to get the best deal in the great land grab following the collapse of the Ottoman Empire.

Britain’s’ first step in achieving its glorious imperial ambition was to enlist Arabs in their fight against the Turks. The first contact was with Hussein Ibn -Ali, Sheriff of Mecca.

Hussein was promised much of Arabia and vast amounts of gold and arms if he led a revolt against the Turks. A key player was Lt. Col. T.E Lawrence of Arabia.

England awakens to Bible Prophesy

To fully appreciate the miracle of Israel’s rebirth in the modern world, the motivation of its on-again off-again sponsor, England, requires examination. England had a long fascination with the Holy Land dating back to its earliest days of Christianity. In 1948, the Jewish state was reborn, due in large measure to the spiritual vision of British students of prophecy. The large Prophecy conferences influenced the whole nation, even members of Parliament.

Many camp meetings were set up annually to pursue and learn about Bible Prophecy. Such articulate luminaries in this movement as John Nelson Darby, William Kelly and Sir Robert Anderson spoke to large crowds about the sudden coming of Jesus Christ for his Church. They also lined the return of Jews to the Holy Land as an indispensable part of the final scenario. They not only believed in a literal rebirth of the state of Israel, but also insisted that God’s purpose for the Jews as a people and a nation, which was promised throughout the Old Testament, would be fulfilled.

England took up the cause of restoring Israel once more in the early twentieth century. However, Lord Balfour’s declaration would not have been possible without the strong biblical case made for Israel by the British Bible Prophecy studies conducted at Powers Court Castle in the 19th century.

Benjamin Disraeli, who would rise to become Prime Minister, was one of the most provocative figures in British history. A Jewish convert to Christianity, he was more concerned with the world’s debt to the Jews than the Jews’ future in the world. In 1878, Disraeli recaptured Cyprus for Britain and purchased Suez, both geographically speaking, a mere stone’s throw from the Holy Land. Disraeli knew it was just a matter of time.

Lord Balfour

The next British leader to pursue the vision was Arthur James Balfour, who, as England’s foreign minister, signed the famous Balfour Declaration mandating the recreation of the Jewish state. He too, believed religion, and civilization in general, owed Judaism an immeasurable debt, shamefully ill repaid.”

Britain’s Betrayal: The sellout of the Jews

Of all the injustices perpetuated against the Jewish people in the Holy Land, the worst was how their country has been continually reduced from its original mandated size. There has continually been a sizable Jewish remnant living in the Holy Land, despite the Roman destruction in AD 70 and the crushing of Jewish rebellions in the second century AD. In the 18th and 19th centuries, Jews outnumbered Muslims in Jerusalem. During the four centuries under Ottoman Turkish control, the Holy Land reached its ultimate state of desolation. The absentee landlords, known as Effendis, practiced such callous usury and taxation on the poor Arab farmers that they were eventually overwhelmed with debt and fled the land.

Whence cometh the Palestinians

There was no Palestinian state or people known as “Palestinians”. The few Arabic-speaking people living there considered themselves “Ottomans”, Turks, Southern Syrians, or simply Arab People but never Palestinians. The migratory Bedouins who seasonally moved through the area never laid claim to the land. The Jews, who began returning to the Holy land throughout the mid-nineteenth century bought land from the all-too-willing–to sell Effendis for enormously inflated prices.

With the price of Herculean labor and the loss of many lives to malaria, the Jews began to reclaim the land and make it flourish. This development encouraged a significant number of poor Arab-Muslims to flock there in order to find work and a better standard of living. Jews became victims of their own success. Little did they realize the very ones they were helping, would turn and claim the Jews had stolen their land that had belonged to Arab families for hundreds of years?

The Balfour Declaration

Because of the existing conditions in the Middle East, Lord Balfour and other members of the British Parliament thought that setting forth the propositions contained in the Balfour declaration was not an invasion of Arab-Muslim land. The motto of the forming committee was “A people for a land, for a land without a people”. Furthermore, the League of Nations concurred with the “Declaration” for the same reasons.

The League of Nations Mandate

The boundaries of the new nation were defined and approved unanimously by the League of Nations three years after the Balfour Declaration. Britain was given authority over the entire Middle East from the Mediterranean to the borders of India.

The territory to become the state of Israel, then variously referred to as “Palestine” “Western Palestine” South Syria or even as part of Turkey, extended east and west of the Jordan River from the Mediterranean to Arabia and Iraq, and North and South from Egypt to Lebanon and Syria. On present day maps, that includes most of Jordan, Southern Lebanon and the Sinai.

Simultaneously, independent Arab statehood was being granted in Syria, Iraq and Saudi Arabia. Arab leaders were initially satisfied with their acquisition and didn’t question the status of Jewish Palestine.

Britain gives away 75 percent of the Jewish Mandated

Land

It was not long, however, before Abdullah, brother of Faisal Ibn Hussein, decided he should have Trans Jordan as his kingdom. He protested to the British who unilaterally decided to carve out of Jewish Palestine 75 percent of its mandated land, then known as the Trans Jordan and hand it over to Abdullah.

It should be explained why Abdullah, who was a Hashemite, was in Trans Jordan: The tribe of Ibn Saud and his fanatical sect of Wahhabi Muslims had just driven the Hashemite Tribe out of Mecca and Medina, taking over the holy sites and all of Arabia.

The Hashemite had been custodians of Mecca and Medina for centuries. Faisal, the ruler of the Hashemites, was the one with whom the British Foreign Office made promises to, for fighting against the Turks. Abdullah argued the British gave his brother Faisal ibn Hussein both Syria and Iraq, but gave him nothing. The British foreign office quietly scrambled to offer him the major part of land they were bound by the League of Nations mandate to give Israel.

Transjordan became the Arab country comprising 38000 square miles. When Israel came into existence in 1948 it only got less than 8000 square miles. 35000 square miles of the Jewish National Homeland were given to Arabs. Thus 80% of their mandated land was lost to the Jews. Britain violated its mandate

When Britain gave Transjordan to Abdullah, it specifically violated article 5 of the mandate giving unanimous approval by the League of Nations at the San Remo conference on July 24, 1922. Today the actual Palestine is the country of Jordan

References

“God’s War on Terror” by Walid Shoebat with Joel Richardson “The sword of the prophet” by serge Trifkovic “Islam prophesied in Genesis” by Dennis Avi Lipkin “Answering Islam” by Norman Geisler and Abdal Saleeb “Return to Mecca” by Dennis Avi Lipkin