Chapter 12 of 21
Western Misunderstanding of Islam
Western people have a difficult time comprehending Islam because they fail to understand that it is a form of cultural imperialism in which the religion and culture of seventh – century Arabia have been raised to the status of divine law. The difficulty in understanding Islam is rooted in the traditional western philosophic concept of the secular versus sacred dichotomy. In the West, organized religion is not viewed as having power to rule over all of life; instead, there is a secular realm in which organized religion has no authority. Thus, there is a wall of separation between church and state. For example, religious organizations in the West cannot set speed limits or legislate political laws. Islam cannot be viewed simply as one’s private or personal religious preference. There is no secular realm in Islamic countries. In Pakistan and other Islamic countries, if someone doesn’t like a person, he can concoct a story against him and accuse him of insulting the Prophet or the Quran. Then a mob would come and burn him alive. In Pakistan the mob kills a lot of Christians on fraudulent charges.
Religion in the West is personal and private. For example, Christianity does not demand that people today should dress in accordance with first- century dress codes, or they can eat only what Jesus ate. Christianity is thus supracultural in that it allows people to live, dress, and eat in accordance with the culture in which they are living. But this is not so with Islam. Whenever Islam becomes the dominant
religion in a country, it alters the culture of that nation and transforms it into the culture of the seventh century Arabia. This is why it is so hard for Muslims to convert to another religion. Every aspect of life has been dictated by Islam. The Muslim must follow the dictates of Islam regardless of where he lives or what he thinks about it. Egyptian born Victor Khalil says “Islam regulates every aspect of life, to the point that culture, religion and politics in a Muslim country are practically inseparable.” Muhammad took the Arab culture around him, with all its secular and sacred customs, and made it into the religion of Islam.
Muhammad took the political laws which governed seventh –century Arabian tribes and made them into the laws of Allah. In such tribes the Sheik, or chief, had absolute authority over those under him. There was no concept of civil or personal rights in seventh century Arabia. The head of the tribe decided whether you lived or died. This is why Islamic countries are always inevitably ruled by kings, dictators, or strong men, who rule as despots.
The historical evidence is clear that Muhammad adopted the pagan religious rite of a pilgrimage to Mecca to worship at the Kabah to appease the Meccan merchants who made a tremendous amount of money out of these pilgrimages. The pilgrimage has been both cruel and unnecessary and has fostered great hardships upon poor third world Muslims who have had to skimp and save their entire lives in order to fulfill this “pillar’ of Islam.
Veil Arabian tribal women used to wear the veil and Islam adopted this in every nation. Being covered from head to toe to be protected from the desert sun and dust is both practical and understandable if you are living in a desert. Arabian women dressed that way long before Muhammad was born. However, to impose such a desert garb on women everywhere is a form of cultural imperialism. The Quran is the most antinomian religion in the world. Sura 4:34 says men are the managers of the affairs of women. Those whom you fear may be rebellious, admonish; or banish to their couches and beat them. “ Medina Legacy: Jihad against Jews. The Jews of Arabia
In approximately 1400 BC over 2000 years before the first Muslim invasion of Palestine (as the Romans renamed it), Israel was already established as a nation.
A civil war split Israel into two nations during the time of Rehoboam, Solomon’s son. The ten tribes of the northern land known as Samaria called themselves Israel. The southern tribes of Judah, Benjamin and Levi became known as the Kingdom of Judah, from which the name “Jew” came.
The Assyrian Dispersion
Israel entered a continuous spiral of apostasy until Jehovah finally sent the Assyrians to destroy them in 721 BC. The survivors of the ten tribes were taken captive into Assyria. Why is this necessary to know? Because some of the survivors of this dispersion fled to Arabia and settled there.
The Babylonian Dispersion
The southern Kingdom of Judah experienced intermittent revivals but finally fell into the same apostasy as the Samarian kingdom. Though Judah was repeatedly warned, they did not listen. 2 Chron.: 36: 15-21, Isaiah 39:5- 7) The Babylonian destruction was predicted by Isaiah 150 years before it happened.
The Bible records that not all the Jews were taken to Babylon. A few were left in Judea by the Babylonians to maintain the land. Some were able to flee to Egypt and others to Arabia.
In 1949, after the birth of the state of Israel, Israelis rescued the Yemenite Jews from the wrath of the Muslims in an operation known as “the wings of Eagles”. They were all airlifted to Israel. The Yemenite Jews trace their origins in Arabia back 2500 years, during the time of the Babylonian invasion.
The Roman Dispersion
The greatest flood of Jewish refugees resulted from the initial Roman destruction of Jerusalem and Judea in AD 70, and continued for some 150 years. During this time, the Romans fought off different Jewish Guerilla-style wars that tried to reclaim Jerusalem. Finally, the Jewish resistance was totally crushed. Some survivors stayed on in Israel while others fled. Yathrib or Medina was established by Jews.
The second holiest city in the Islamic world was first established by Jews, an amazing fact confirmed by historical sources.
Mohammad’s zealous crusade against polytheism made him increasingly unpopular in his hometown of Mecca. When they tried to kill him, he and his followers fled to Yathrib. Mohammad tried to win the Jews over by representing himself as simply a teacher of the creed of Abraham. He even adopted the Jewish Sabbath, some dietary laws and initially required prayer toward Jerusalem rather than Mecca.
Believe or Be Beheaded
The Jews however were not deceived and refused to acknowledge him as anything but a false prophet. This infuriated Mohammad. To attract Jews, Muhammad had tried to encourage the Jews to accept his prophet hood by preaching monotheism, observing the Jewish Sabbath, praying toward Jerusalem, appealing to Abraham and the Patriarchs, adopting some of their dietary laws and praising their scriptures. But the Jews rejected him.
He turned to what would become his standard pattern: the use of the sword. He marched against this Jewish tribe and besieged their village. When they surrendered and came out one by one, they were beheaded. The first Muslim massacre was executed on the Jews. The pattern of “confess Islam or face sword” was established. He changed the direction of prayer from Jerusalem to Mecca, dropped the Saturday Sabbath, and adopted the pagan Friday Sabbath instead. Mohammad was anxious to spread Islam beyond Medina.
The Quraysh model of Meccan conquest
Three years after the battle of Badr, a 10,000-man Meccan army again laid siege to Medina. The Quraysh tribe of Mecca could not conquer Medina and Mohammad was not strong enough to defeat them. So Mohammad signed a ten-year treaty of non-aggression with Mecca.
By AD. 630, less than a year later, Mohammad had built up his army. He stormed Mecca by surprise and conquered it, thus making himself ruler of the city of his birth. Mohammad’s first act was to establish Mecca as the holiest city of Islam. Mohammad proclaimed the Kabah as “Haram” (forbidden to non-Muslims)
Muslims have quoted the “Quraysh model” as justification for many deceptive treaties. It means “Negotiate Peace with your enemy until you become strong enough to annihilate him”. It is called the “Hudna” agreement. This is the justification chairman Yasser Arafat gave to his critics who condemned him for signing the Oslo agreement.
Why Jews were persecuted
Mohammad and his disciples treated the Jews more severely than any other “unbeliever”. They had irritated him by their refusal to recognize him as a prophet. Mohammad decided these non-believers in his homeland had to be eliminated if he was going to fulfill his ambitions. So he ordered an Islamic Law. “Two religions may not dwell together on the Arabian Peninsula”.
The Arabian Holocaust
After issuing this decree, he started to enforce it immediately. He went after Jewish communities of Northern Arabia, systematically slaughtering them all. First, the Qurazia tribe was exterminated. Then Mohammad sent messengers to the Jewish community at the oasis of Khaibar, “inviting” Usayr, and their war chief, to visit Medina for peace negotiations. Usayr set off with 30 companions and a Muslim escort suspecting no foul play. The Jews went unarmed. On the way the Muslims turned upon the defenseless delegation, killing all but one who managed to escape. Mohammad attacked and destroyed their whole community.
Mohammad justified this treachery saying “war is deception”. War practiced according to this Muslim doctrine was not just deception, it was like hell.
The complete annihilation of the two Arabian-Jewish tribes, with every man, woman, and child slaughtered is according to the late Israeli historian and President Itzhak Ben-Zvi, “a tragedy for which no parallel can be found in Jewish history”.
In the war against Islamic Fundamentalist terrorism, it would be good for Western leaders to remember this “Islamic tactic of warfare “. According to this religious doctrine of Islam, what they say does not have to be true-after all, war is deception; the end justifies the means.
A Heritage of brutality
As an example of their brutality and barbarity, after one Jewish town surrendered to the Muslims, about 1000
men were beheaded in one day. The woman and children were sold into slavery.
Elsewhere, as the attacks on Jews continued, some managed to survive. Under a new Islamic Policy, non- Muslims or “infidels” were permitted to maintain their land so long as they paid as 50 percent tribute for “protection”.
Thus the Jewish Dhimmi evolved- the robbery of freedom and political independence compounding the extortion and eventual expropriation of property. Operated between onslaughts, expulsions, and pillages from the Arab Muslim conquest onward, the non-Muslim Dhimmi, predominantly Jewish, but with Christians too- provided the important source of religious revenue through the “infidel’s head tax.” He became very quickly a convenient political scapegoat and whipping boy as well.
The Precedent of Prey
The betrayal and killing of Jews in Medina, the massacres of the Nadhir and Kainuka tribes and the dispossession of property by Muslims set up what Joan Peters calls:
“The Precedent of Prey”- a pattern that would be repeated again and again. The agrarian and merchant Jews lucky enough to escape death would be plundered and exploited by nomadic Arabs. Islam not only gave them an excuse for such oppression, it commanded it. All over the world today- from Georgia to Azerbaijan to Serbia to India to Sudan and Eritrea, Muslims are killing others.
Hate, a Religious Doctrine
What began as a rivalry between brothers degenerated into a family feud? It evolved into an everlasting, irreconcilable hatred.
There were some cases of reconciliation between the Arabs and the Jews of Arabia in the centuries before the birth of Mohammad. They were not loved, but they were accepted.
Hatred of Jews in Islam is justified as a religious cause. Islam literally resurrected the ancient enmities and jealousies of the sons of Ishmael, Esau and Keturah toward Jews, and enshrined them as religious doctrine.
Deification of 7th century Arab culture
The tribal aspect of pre- Islamic Arabia explains many of the things that can be found in Islam today. For example, it was perfectly in line with Arab morality to mount raids on other tribes to obtain wealth, wives, and slaves, and so the tribes were constantly at war with one another. The same behavior pattern is seen now in 2014 and 2015 in Syria and Iraq by ISIS fighters. The desert tribes lived by the code of an eye for an eye and a tooth for a tooth. Vengeance was extracted whenever anything was done to hurt any member of the tribe. It meant nothing to them to cut off the hand, foot or tongue. Even the ears were lopped off and the eyes were gouged out as punishment for various crimes. To sneak up behind someone and slit his throat from ear to ear was viewed as the right thing to do in certain situations, and the person who did it was viewed as a hero. Forcing people into
slavery or kidnapping women, holding them in your harem, and raping them at will was considered pleasing to Allah. The harsh Arabian climate produced a harsh tribal society in which violence was the norm, and violence is still an attribute of Islamic societies.
The desperate plight of Salman Rushdie is a modern example. To receive a death sentence for writing a book which gives an unfavorable view of Muhammad is something a Westerner does not understand or tolerate. However, for a Muslim, it makes perfect sense. The Danish cartoonist, Kurt Westergaard, was attacked on January 1. 2010, by a 28-year-old Somali Muslim with an axe. He survived the attack. His crime was drawing a cartoon of the Prophet Muhammad. Theo Van Gogh, a Dutch film maker who made a T.V. film critical of Islam, was shot and stabbed to death on an Amsterdam street in November 2004.
The Muslim religion actually froze in time the seventh century Arab culture of Mecca and raised it to the level of being a “Divine Revelation”- how all people should live for all time. The modern concept of “Jihad” primarily has to do with forcing this culture upon the world- either by conversion or by conquest.
In a profound, almost mystical sense, Mohammed is the product of the seventh century Arab culture and the Muslim religion is an expression of his perceptions of it; a major part of this being revulsion of the Jews. Mohammad never forgave them for rejecting him and his claim of being God’s Prophet. That hostility was woven into the Quran.
Religions- cultural imperialism
Islam is nothing less than a religious –cultural imperialism that works to take over the world. This is why Mohammad divided the earth into two spheres.
- Dar al-Islam –the land of peace
- Dar-al- Harb – the land of war.
Mohammad believed the Muslim is in a perpetual state of “Jihad”- holy war” – with all countries in the Dar-al- Harb sphere. The true follower believes that Allah has willed for Muslims to establish Islamic ways over the whole world – either by conversion or by sword.
Islam believes this doctrine is especially applicable to the Middle East, which they claim as the center of their world.
Israel’s victories over the armies of Allah in five wars have placed the Quran in jeopardy, for it promises the forces of Islam victory in holy wars.