Chapter 15 of 17
Appendix I
This section is intended to provide the reader with a different interpretation of an Islamic Antichrist. This author asks the reader to make your own conclusion. This work is taken from a book titled “God’s War on Terror” Islam, Prophecy and The Bible by WalidShoebat and Joel Richardson.
Daniel 2:31-35
Daniel goes on to explain to Nebuchadnezzar that each component of the statue represents a kingdom or empire that will succeed his. The common interpretation is this. Four kingdoms are Babylon, Medo-Persia, Greece, and Rome. While the first three in the sequence are accurate, there are some very serious problems with seeing Rome as the fourth. It is crucial to understand that the statue represents past kingdoms that are all destroyed together when Christ returns. “You continued looking until a stone was cut out without hands, and it struck the statue on its feet of iron and clay and crushed them”. The stone is Messiah. Messiah destroys all parts of the structure (gold, silver, bronze, iron and clay) together when he comes.
Then the iron, the clay, the bronze, the silver, and the gold were crushed all at the same time and became like chaff from the summer threshing floors; and the wind carried them away so that not a trace of them was found, but the stone that struck the statue became a great mountain and filled the whole earth. (2:33-35)
This is the Future, not History
The stone at this point, establish the kingdom of Messiah; it becomes a great mountain (kingdom). When Jesus returns, he will destroy all these empires at the same time, as the text literally states (v34). This would-be Iraq and Arabia (Babylon), Iran (Persia), Turkey and the Middle East (Greece), and of course, the Islamic empire, which includes all of these. If the statue represents ancient Babylon, Persia, Greece, and Rome as commonly thought, then why do we see all these empires destroyed in the end when Christ returns? If Daniel 2 speaks of history, how is God, strictly representing ancient Babylon, now destroyed by the messiah when he comes? The Bible is clear “(he) crushed all at the same time”. (v35).
Then you have the Iron
The texts insist that the iron crushed all the previous metals. It is understood by many westerners that the Iron is Rome. Did the Roman Empire crush ancient Babylon / modern Iraq? No. Only for a few months in A.D 116 under emperor Trajan did the Roman Empire ever extends its territories toward Babylon. But they were almost immediately beaten back. The Roman Empire and the Babylonian empire really do not overlap. The Roman Empire is significantly west. Did the Roman Empire ever extend its control over the regions of Persia/ modern day Iran? The answer is never. Thus, if the Roman Empire were utterly destroyed much of the other empires would be left unscathed, yet the text is clear that when the forth empire is destroyed, this will include all of the others as well.
The Fourth is Muslim
We cannot study prophecy without understanding the dual nature of its fulfillment. Daniel 2 can, and will, parallel ancient events, but the book is ultimately concerned with the end times. Daniel 2 Verse 33 refers to a rise of 10 toes in the end of days that will come up from the four ancient empires that make up the empire of Anti-Christ. The four empires described in this passage are not what western students think, they are:
- Babylonian empire
- Medo, Persian empire
- Greek empire or Greco-Roman empire 4.Islamic empire (Roman). The fourth beast consist of both Arab and Roman empires. According to Iban Ezra “Rome is included in the third kingdom as relatives of the Greeks.
The Romans are considered to be Kittim as mentioned in Numbers 24:24. In Genesis 10:4, Kittim are the sons of Yavan (Greece). Ibn Ezra argues that while there are reasons to understand why Rome is not mentioned in the dream, the complete omission of the mighty and extensive Arab kingdom is simply too big of an oversight that needs to be explained by those who held to the Roman interpretation. The fourth kingdom, according to Ibn Ezra, is the Arab Muslim kingdom. Many historians view the Roman Empire as an extension of the Greek empire, rather than as a different entity altogether. The thighs (the third entity), are bronze. This was the Grecian empire, and connects to the iron legs. The iron legs are an extension of the Grecian (bronze). In other words, the iron is of the bronze. This would eliminate Western Europe. Now many define a particular nation by languages, border, and culture. The Roman and Greek empires in many ways shared all of these things as well as a common religion. However, it is also quite possible that the Roman Empire itself is not even considered in this passage.
Babylon’s Future History
This passage deals with a dream that was given to Nebuchadnezzar, the Babylonian king, the ruler of all of ancient Mesopotamia. The first part is a dual prophecy. God was not so much explaining to Nebuchadnezzar the “future history “of the western world, but rather the “future history” of the regions that he ruled over, namely Babylon and greater Mesopotamia. This dream was a description of the future of the Babylonian empire, and the primary empires that would rule over it after Nebuchadnezzar.
While Rome was an important empire in world history, its real significance to the Mesopotamian region is, in feud, fairly minimal. In the year 116 A.D, under Emperor Trajan, the Romans made some incursions into portions of Mesopotamia, but it was within months, in A .D 117, at the death of Trajan, that the Romans lost southern Mesopotamia, and completely retreated from the region. They were never able to secure control over the regions east of the Euphrates in any substantial way.
The primary empire that would actually conquer and rule over Babylon was all laid out consecutively in the dream.Rome never conquered the previous empires. Perhaps the most obvious flaw in this interpretation is the single description used to define this fourth kingdom. “There will be a fourth kingdom, strong as iron for iron breaks and smashes everything and as iron breaks things to pieces, so it will crush and break all others” (Daniel-2:40).
Did Rome crush or even conquer all of the other Empires? Did Rome crush the Babylonian empire (Iraq), the Medo-Persian Empire (Iraq), and the Greek empires? The clear answer is no, it did not. It is almost surprising that such a wide range of interpreters have overlooked this fact for so long. The fourth empire would crush and break all three of the other empires.
A Brief History of Mesopotamia
After his rule, Nebuchadnezzar’s empire was first conquered by the Persians under Cyrus and then by Greece under Alexander the Great. After Alexander’s death in 323 B.C, his empire was divided and the region of Babylon and Persia was given to one of his generals named Seleucus. Seleucus and his successors ruled the region for roughly 130 years until 190 B.C. When the Persian people (called the Parthians) arose again, they took control of their former empire. Thus, after having been controlled by the Greeks for well over a hundred years, the Persians again controlled the region.
Later, after the Parthian empire, another Persian people, the Sassanid Dynasty rose up and gained control over the region. Throughout the Partho- Sassanian period, the people maintained a strong mixture of both Hellenistic (Greek) and Persian identity and culture. For this reason, within Nebuchadnezzar’s dream, there was no distinction made between the Persian or the Greek empires and the later Parthian or Sassanid period. It was not until the mighty Islamic caliphate came and conquered the entire region that the dream describes the next phase of the statue.
During the period of Roman rule, the region to the east of the Euphrates River (Mesopotamia) was controlled by the Parthian empire, not the Romans. “The wars between Rome and the Parthian empire, which took place roughly from 53 BC to 217 A.D, were unique episode in classical history. Although
Rome conquered nearly the entire civilized world around the Mediterranean, Rome could never conquer Parthia”.
While the Emperor Trajan did cross the Euphrates River and gain control over a small portion of Mesopotamia within one year, Trajan had died and his victory and control dissolved. Did Rome conquer the Babylonian or the Persian Empire? Did Rome crush the Greek empire?
While the Roman Empire did assume central of the some of the regions that were once controlled by the Alexandrian Hellenistic Greek Empire, it was in fact, the Hellenistic / Greek culture that came to dominate the Roman Empire. The New Testament, which was written during the Roman period, was written in Greek, not Latin. In other words, the Roman Empire may have assumed control of some of the western regions once controlled by the Greek Empire but it most certainly did not “crush it”.
Islam Crushed All
While the Roman Empire did not fulfill the necessary requirements to be considered as the fourth empire of Daniel. There was an empire that did. The Islamic empire fulfilled these requirements completely. Islam conquered all of the three previous empires-Babylonian, Medo-Persian, and the Grecian. Islam also conquered the Roman Empire, which had ceased to exist in Europe. Revelation 13 insists that the fourth beast constitutes the three previous empires. This must exclude Europe. Islam conquered the entire eastern byzantine Roman Empire and large portions of what was the Western Roman Empire. That included Iraq (Babylon), and Iran (Persia). The Roman Empire cannot make this claim and thus only Islam meets the Biblical criterion of (Daniel-2:40).
Arabization
The fundamental duty of Islam is to Arabize the world to unite humanity under one language, one government, and one religion; Islam; it is an attempt to reverse what God did at the tower of Babel. In case of the Islamic caliphate, “crush” is most certainly an appropriate description for what occurred when Islam conquered any region. Babylon changed its language to Arabic and its religion to Islam. Persia also lost its religion, adopted the Arabic alphabet, and kept its language. Other nations like Egypt also completely lost their ancient religion and language, and adopted Arabic. These Civilizations were all lost to Islam, and only some kept their language. In fact, it would require volumes to recount all of the history, culture, and religious influence that have nearly been erased by more than a millennium of Islamic dominance.
Arabism
Western students focus on Daniel 2:41 which points to the nature of the two materials (iron and clay) as being partly weak and partly strong, but verse 43 is rarely addressed in full. “And in that you saw the iron mixed with common clay, they will combine with one another in the seed of men; but they will not adhere to one another, even as iron does not combine with pottery”. In the Aramaic, we can read like this “and just as you saw the iron mixed with baked clay, so the people will be mixed (Arabized) with the seed of men (through inter-marriage) and will not remain united, any more than iron does not mix with clay”.
Arabia or Mereb (1 King 10:15), is a mixture or mongrel race, Arabia, mingled people or mixed multitude. Within Daniel 2:43, “the people will be a mixture and will not remain united, any more than iron mixes with clay. The Aramaic phrase “la mutaarreb” also means “does not Arabize”. This Arab mixed kingdom would not become totally Arabized. This duality in meaning and interpretation (mixing and Arabizing) is supported by Ibin Ezra, one of the foremost respected Jewish writers. According to him, the Greek kingdom represented by the leopard includes the Roman Empire, for ethnically the Romans were related to the Greeks.
The Kittim, identified as descendants of the Romans were related to the Yavan (Greece). The fourth animal then represents the rule of the Arabs. Rabbi SaadiahGaon believes that the fourth animal in the vision includes both the Roman and the Arab empire. Islam’s goal from its earliest days has been to Arabize the whole world through Islam. However, the Persians, and Turks
who came from the brass (Greece-Roman) kingdoms never fully Arabized. Because the various descendants of Ishmael and Esau had intermarried among the various desert tribes, they had actually become known as the “mixed ones”. Daniel 2:43, speaks of the type of mixed peoples that would make up the final Anti-Christ Empire.
A Kingdom Divided
Beyond being an Arab empire or an attempt to make it so, the last day’s empire is also said to be a divided (Peleg) empire. The divisions, of course, that this passage speaks of is truly an appropriate description of the Islamic world, as it has existed from its earliest days until modern times with its various sectarian divisions. “In that you saw the feet and toes, partly of potter’s clay and partly of iron it will be a divided kingdom”. (Daniel-2:41).
One need only look to modern Iraq’s Sunni and Shia’s sectarian battles to observe how divided the Islamic world truly is. This division of the final Anti- Christ Empire is also seen in the fact that even at the time they attack Israel, they will not be able to resist their own disputes. Thus, Ezekiel tells us that, “every man sword will be against his brother”. (Ezekiel-38:21). Once again, this resembles precisely what one finds today in the Palestinian territories and Iraq, and much of the Muslim world.
Daniel 2 Four or five Empires: or Both
In Revelation 17, the Anti-Christ Empire was specified as being the eighth empire- or a revival of the seventh empire that would arise after being healed of a “fatal head wound”. So how many empires are there, seven or eight? Well, both are correct, the eighth is a recreation of the seventh. This is what the text is trying to tell us. The concept of an empire revival is also found in Daniel 2. We have 4 sections to the statue, yet we also have 5, both are correct, since the fifth is a recreation of the fourth. Here, we will see that Nebuchadnezzar’s dream also lines up perfectly with Revelation 17. The last empire of Nebuchadnezzar’s dream is comprised of two distinct phases of the same empire. They are related, but they are distinct. These two empires correspond to the seventh and the eight empires of Revelation 17. The first key to seeing this two-fold phase of the last empires is seen in the following portion of the above passage.
The head of the statue was made of fine gold, its breasts and its arms of silver, its belly and its thighs of bronze, its legs of iron its feet partly of iron and partly of clay”. (Daniel 2:32-33). What we will see is that there are five distinct elements, and thus five distinct components to the statue.
IMAGE
- HEAD- Fine gold
- BREAST AND ARMS -silver
- BELLY, THIGHS Brass
- LEGS Iron
- RECREATION OF 4TH FEET-Part Iron, part Clay.
By following the text, it is easy to see that there are not four, but rather five phases. Keeping in mind that the fifth is a recreation of the fourth, we have fine gold, silver, brass, iron, and a mixture of iron and clay. The passage continues “this was the dream; now we will tell its interpretation before the king”.
You,O king are the king of kings, to whom the God of heaven has given the kingdom, the power, the strength and the glory; and wherever the sons of men dwell, or the beasts of the field, or the birds of the sky, he was given them into your hand and caused you to rule over them all. You are the head of gold. After you there will arise another kingdom inferior to you, then another third kingdom of bronze, which will rule over all the earth. Then there will be a fourth kingdom as strong as iron; in as much as iron crushes and shatters all things, so like iron that breaks in pieces, it will crush and break all these in pieces (Daniel-2:36-40).
There are a few important observations that need to be High-lighted here. First, we need to take note of the unqualified description of the fourth kingdom. “There will be a fourth kingdom, strong as iron”. The fourth kingdom will not be partially strong and partially weak. It is simply described as “strong as iron”. However, when we look at the descriptions of the feet and the toes, they are completely different. In these descriptions, the kingdom is only partially strong but also partially brittle. Compare the descriptions below:
Legs: there will be a fourth kingdom, strong as iron (Daniel 2:40) Feet: this kingdom will be partially strong and partly brittle (Daniel-2:43).
For those who would argue that the statue contains only four phases, the question needs to be asked: how can the very same kingdom be described in one sentence as strong as iron while in the very next sentence be described as only having “some of the strength of iron in it and partly strong and partly brittle.
Upon examining the passage, one must conclude that there is both a fourth and fifth division of the statue. However, because there is also a continuity between the legs and the feet that are seen in the element of iron, there is also reason to believe that these last two empires are, in fact related.
Many modern interpreters have rightly recognized the fact that the last empire in Nebuchadnezzar’s dream consists of a two-fold division. Most of the teachers claim that the fourth empire is the Roman Empire. Again, in light of all that we have already learned, we know that this last dual-phased empire cannot be the Roman Empire, but rather represents two distinct phases of one Arab-Islamic empire. In Revelation 17, the last empire (the seventh-eight empire) follows and is distinct from Rome.
The fourth kingdom in Nebuchadnezzar’s dream represents the various manifestations of the Islamic empire that existed for over thirteen hundred years, culminating in the Ottoman Empire. This empire was fatally wounded in 1924 with the abolition of the caliphate and the divisions and colonization of the Middle East by the western powers. The fifth empire of Nebuchadnezzar’s dream represents the revival of the Islamic empire which we are presently seeing arise in functions before our own eyes.
Nebuchadnezzar’s Dream
HEAD- gold Babylonian-Iraq and Arabia, chest, arms -silver Medo-Persian. Iran belly-thighs, Bronze- Greco-Roman-Turkey mid-east, legs-iron. Islamic- Ottoman empire, feet-toes mixture. Islamic revival-Ottoman revived.
Daniel 2, confirms what we have already learned concerning the final Antichrist empire in Revelation 17. In Revelation 17, the final Antichrist empire is a revived version of the seventh empire, which we identified as the Islamic empire so also here in Daniel 2, the last empire is the two-fold fourth/ fifth empire, which also is the Islamic empire. Piece by piece, passage by passage, when the religion of Islam is plugged into the puzzle, every piece fits perfectly. There is no forcing or bending of the pieces required.
Daniel 7
Daniel 7 describes a “night vision” with four bizarre beasts; each one emerges out of the sea (people and nations). The four kingdoms correlate precisely with the four kingdoms in Nebuchadnezzar’s dream. Yet the theme (like Daniel 2) is primarily an end time passage.
The First was like a Lion:
- And it had the wings of an eagle. I watched until its wings were torn off and it was lifted from the ground so that it stood on two feet like a man, and the heart of a man was given to it. And there before me was a second beast, which looked like a bear.
- It was raised up on one of its sides, and it had three ribs in its mouth between its teeth. It was told, ‘get up, and eat your fill of flesh’. After that, I looked and there before me was another beast, one that looked like a leopard.
- And on its back it had four wings like those of a bird. This beast had four heads, and it was given authority to rule. After that in my vision at night I looked, and there before me was a fourth beast terrifying and frightening and very powerful.
- It had large iron teeth; it crushed and devoured its victims and trampled underfoot whatever was left. It was different from all the former beasts, and it had ten horns (Daniel 7:4-7).
The Bronze
The bronze nails in Daniel 7:19 point to a Grecian, not Roman, Anti-Christ.” “Then I wished to know the truth about the fourth beast, which was different from all the others, exceedingly dreadful, with its teeth of iron and its nails of bronze, which devoured, broke in pieces, and trampled the residue with its feet,” (Daniel 7:19). We have textual evidence for the Grecian nature of the Anti -christ kingdom. “It’s nails of bronze” must be alluding to the correlation of the ten toes to the Grecian empire. This is deduced because bronze is accepted by biblical scholars as representing Greece. No one argues that bronze is not Greece. Yet the Grecian empire was mainly Middle Eastern and not European. While many are convinced that the legs of iron in the statue of Daniel 2 represents the Roman empire, few consider the fact that the legs extend from out of the bronze thighs, which again is the Grecian empire. Comparing the Islamic empire with the Grecian empire, we see that they are identical. Yet the Roman Empire when compared to the Grecian empire is significantly different with only minor overlapping. While the Grecian empire extended all the way to India, the Roman Empire’s furthest eastern expansion barely reached the Euphrates River.
Although many argue that iron represents the Roman empire, this is a false assumption. Scripture does not validate iron as Roman. But even if we accepted that iron did represent Rome, it would also have to be admitted that the passage at the least is alluding to a Greco- Roman Anti -Christ, specifically from the Grecian parts of the Roman Empire.
So, when we view the iron, we cannot isolate it. The bronze is in it; this would align with Ibin-Ezra’s position and others who saw a combined Greco-Roman Anti-christ. When we view Daniel 7, the fourth kingdom we cannot separate it from verse 19 (nails and bronze). Out of these will come ten kings, represented in the vision by ten horns. “After that, in my vision at night I looked, and there before me was a fourth beast, terrifying and frightening and very powerful. It had large iron teeth; it crushed and devoured its victims and trampled underfoot whatever was left.it was different from all the former beasts, and it had ten horns” (Daniel 7:7).
These are the same ten horns in Revelation 17. The ten kings will be conquered by another king, an eleventh (the little horn) who is the Anti-christ, the ruler over the entire fourth kingdom. (Also, read Daniel 7:8, 11).
Having seen that the fourth kingdom of Nebuchadnezzar’s dream (Daniel 2) and the fourth beast (Daniel 7) are the same, we may also confidently conclude that the fourth beast is the Islamic empire. While the fourth beast represents the Islamic empire initiated by Mohammad in the seventh century, the ten horns and the “little horn” or the eleventh horn, represents the future and final phase of the Islamic empire that will fulfill the biblical prophecies concerning the anti-christ and his empire.
Unlocking Revelation 12 and 13 Islamic Seven- headed Beast
The final beast empire is found in the book of Revelation, chapters 12 and 13. In Revelation 12, we are first introduced to a woman who is about to give birth. This woman is understood to represent the Jewish people, who
corporately brought the Messiah into the world. But immediately after being introduced to the woman, we see that even as she is about to give birth, a dreadful and murderous red dragon stalks her. The dragon, of course, represents Satan. “Then another sign appeared in heaven; an enormous red dragon with seven heads and ten horns and seven crowns on his heads. His tail swept a third of the stars out of the sky and flung them to the earth.
The dragon stood in front of the woman who was about to give birth, so that he might devour her child the moment it was born. She gave birth to a son, a male child, who will rule all the nations with an iron scepter. And her child was snatched up to God and to his throne”. (Revelation 12:3-5). The child being snatched up to God and to his throne is obviously a reference to the ascensions of Jesus after the crucifixion.
After this we are told that there was a war in heaven, whereby “the great dragon was hurled down, that ancient serpent called the devil or Satan, who leads the whole world astray. He was hurled to the earth, and his angels with him.” (Revelation 12:9). This fits the Grecian Anti-christ “out of one of them came another horn, which started out small but grew in power to the south and to the east, and toward the beautiful land. It grew until it reached the hosts of the heavens and it threw the starry hosts down to the earth and trampled it (Daniel 8:10)
After this, Satan the dragon pursued the Jewish people as well as “her offspring” the Gentile followers of the Messiah, who came to be known as Christians. “Then the dragon was enraged at the woman and went off to make war against the rest of her off-spring – those who obey God’s commandments and hold to the testimony of Jesus”. (Revelation 12:17)
As we turn to chapter 13, we see that the dragon is shown standing on the shore of the sea. Then, as if he were some dark sorcerer, he summons a gruesome beast from the depths of the ocean.
“And I saw a beast coming out of the sea. He had ten horns and seven heads, with ten crowns on his horns, and on each head a blasphemous name. The beast I saw resembled a leopard, but had feet like those of a bear and a mouth like that of a lion. The dragon gave the beast his power and his throne and great authority”. (Revelation 13:2-3).
The first interesting observation that may be made about this beast is that it has body parts from each of the previous four beasts in Daniel 7. The beast has the body of a leopard, the feet of a bear, and the mouth of a lion. The lion Babylonian Empire (Iraq), the bear Medo Persia Empire (Iran), and the leopard, Macedonian Greek Empire (Turkey).
This is Significant
Does this sound like a European beast? Or is it a Middle Eastern/ Islamic beast? We can see a perfect fit with the rest of our analysis of scripture. We also see that the beast shares some very similar features with the dragon. Like the dragon, the beast also has seven heads and ten horns. Here, we have a perfect example of how understanding a previous passage helps us to understand a later passage. The ten horns represent ten rulers that will arise from the final beast empire; the number of horns is from each Empire. We know this because the angel made it very clear in Daniel 7, and just as Daniel was a road map for the ancients to recognize Antiochus, Revelation is a road map for us to recognize the Anti- christ.
Everything will be fulfilled to the jot and tittle. The seven heads, on the other hand, represents authority or government (as in: head of state). The seven heads represent the seven beast empires that persecuted the nation of Israel, and in its re-created state will persecute her Christian offspring .
The seven heads are the following:
- The Egyptian empire
- The Assyrian empire
- The Babylonian empire
- The Medo-Persian Empire
- The Macedonian Greek empire
- The Roman Empire
- The Islamic empire.
The Wounded Empire
We are given some key information concerning one of these empires; “one of the heads of the beast seemed to have had a fatal wound, but the fatal wound had been healed”. (Revelation 13:3) one of the heads, that is one of the seven beast empires, has a head wound. Again, we have already learned from our study of the previous snapshots of the beast empire that the empire specifically that suffers the head wound an apparent death is the Islamic Empire. This head wound may be understood as the abolition of the caliphate that occurred in 1924. Yet, presently, the Islamic empire is arising anew. It is reconsolidating its power and developing new bonds of unity. Soon the head the caliphate will be revived, healed and restored.
Thus, based on this passage, what we may expect to see emerge in the possible near future is ten rulers or leaders from the Islamic world that will form some sort of partnership, league, union or coalition.
When this partnership emerges, these then would be the ten kings mentioned both in Daniel and here in Revelation 13. Then we are told that another king will arise and will displace three of these kings, ultimately taking a leadership position over the fragmented empire. This individual will be recognized by at least a portion of the Muslim world as either the Caliph or the Imam Mahdi, or both. This will be the Anti-christ while there are yet many specific circumstances that need to fall into place in order for this whole scenario to fully become a reality. The truth is that it is not an unimaginable scenario. Dozens of world circumstances are all seemingly now merging forward, making this scenario a reality.
When this scenario does become a reality, the Bible says that the reaction from the rest of the world will be one of astonishment and a deep sense of fear. The whole world was astonished and followed the beast. Men worshipped the dragon because he had given authority to the beast, and they also worshipped the beast and asked, “Who is like the beast”? Who can make war against him? (Revelation 13:3-4). Later, a similar description is given concerning the emerging revived Islamic empire. “The inhabitants of the earth whose names have not been written in the book of life from the creation of the world will be astonished when they see the beast, because he once was, then he was not, yet coming again”. (Revelation 17:8).
Chapter 13 concludes with some strong descriptions of what the Anti- christ and his empire will do and how they will act when they are revived and brought together. The descriptions are again very similar to what we have already found in the book of Daniel. “The beast was given a mouth to utter proud words and blasphemies and to exercise authority for 42 months (Revelation 13:1-8).
Daniel 8:1 Little horn the Vision of the Ram and the Goat
This vision, in fact, was given to Daniel quite some time after the vision of the four beasts
Daniel 8:2-4
This time, Daniel sees two animals; the first is a ram with two horns. Next, we are introduced to a goat with one large horn (8:5-8). These verses refer to the dominance of the Medo-Persian Empire, the ram with two horns, by Alexander the Great and Macedonian Greek empire,the “goat”. After this, the goat with only one horn is broken, symbolizing Alexander the Great’s death. Then his generals fought until only four remained alive. These four eventually
called a truce and divided the empire into four segments: the north, south, east, and west, each division named after its respective ruler as follows
North Seleucus - Central Turkey, Syria, Iran and central Asia. South- Ptolemy – Egypt and north Africa West- Cassander, Greece and south – eastern East- Lysimachus-western Turkey.
So, the four horns represent the four divisions of Greece after Alexander. This correlates with the third beast of the last vision- the four-headed leopard.
What is interesting about this passage is that it is so prophetically precise that many liberal or atheist scholars have fought tooth and nail to disprove its timing, insisting that the prophecy was written well after these events occurred. After the clash between the ram and the goat, we are introduced to another horn, similar to the little horn of Daniel 7. This horn is also described as “another horn” which started small: and out of one of them came forth a little horn, which waxed exceedingly great, toward the south, and toward the east, and toward the pleasant land. And it waxed great even to the host of heaven; and it cast down some of the host and of the stars to the ground, and stamped upon them. (Daniel 8:9-12).
Scholars universally point to Antiochus 1V Epiphanies of the Seleucid division, as the fulfillment of this passage. However, while this is true, Antiochus was also a type. His power and influence grew “to the south and to the east and toward the beautiful land”-Israel,which clearly refers to the end time Antichrist. He said “I am going to tell you what will happen later in the time of wrath, because the vision concerns the appointed time of the end. The two-horned ram that you saw represents the kings of the Media and Persia. The shaggy goat is the king of Greece, and the large horn between his eyes is the first king”.
The four horns that replaced the one that was broken off represent the four kingdoms that will emerge from his nations, but will not have the same power. In the latter part of their reign, when rebels have become completely wicked, a stern-faced king, a master of intrigue, will arise. He will become very strong, but not by his own power. He will cause astounding devastation and will succeed in whatever he does, he will destroy the mighty men and the holy people. He will cause deceit to prosper, and he will consider himself superior.
When they feel secure, he will destroy many and take his stand against the prince of princes. Yet he will be destroyed, but not by human power. (Daniel - 8:19-25).
It is clear that the “little horn” is the end time Anti-Christ, who causes one third of the angels to fall. But here is the most important aspect of this prophecy. The little horns of Daniel 7 andDaniel 8 both point to the Anti- Christ. These are simply two snapshots taken from different angles. One snapshot pictures the Anti-Christ emerging forth out of the fourth beast, while the second snap-shot portrays the antichrist as emerging forth from the Seleucid division of the Greek empire. But those who argue that the fourth beast is the Roman Empire are forced to take the obviously inconsistent position that the “little horn” in Daniel 7 is the Anti-Christ, while the little horn in Daniel 8 is not. They are forced to do this because their mistaken assumption that the Anti-Christ will come from Europe is not supported by the Anti-Christ emerging from out of the regions of the Seleucid division of the Greek empire. When one sees the beast of Daniel as an Islamic empire from which the Anti- Christ emerges, coupled with the little horn of the shaggy goat as the Seleucid division of the Greek empire, then all of the pieces fit together as smoothly and easily as greased frog skin, and that is certainly something that the European Roman empire theorists can never claim.
Daniel 2 and the Little Horn
The secret to unlocking much of the Bible is to look at the duality and type fulfillments. Daniel-11: 21-35 focuses on the Anti-Christ (king of the north). In Daniel 11, the king of the north, just like the “little horn” in Daniel 8 expresses
a brutal persecution of the Jewish people, and sets up the final abomination that causes desolation (Daniel- 11:31-45).
Daniel 12:1-12
There were no events in his life and career that can be found which historically correlate with Antiochus exalting “himself above every god.” Nor did he reject the gods of his fathers. On the contrary, Antiochus worshiped the same pantheon of Greek gods as any other Greek. In fact, Antiochus even set up an altar to Zeus in the sanctuary of the Jewish temple. Beyond this, Daniel says that the Anti-Christ would meet his death in Israel. However, history records that Antiochus in fact died in Persia. The question that needs an answer to the false accusation of the Anti-Christ being a Jew is “why would God choose Antiochus (a Gentile) for a type of Anti-Christ, then choose a Jew? The Anti-Christ’s god is different from Antiochus’s god. At a glance, his passage appears to say that this evil one will not honor any god, but will exalt himself above all gods. Yet on the other hand, he is also said to honor a “god of fortresses” and to employ the help of “a foreign god.” He is not an atheist, as some claim. He simply rejects all gods, except his foreign god of war (god of fortresses). This would match perfectly with the ideology of Muhammad and the Mahdi, who are commanded to advance the cause of Allah with the banner “there is no god but Allah.”
The part of the vision that has to do with the end times begins in Daniel 11:21. God sees the Anti-christ as a “vile person”. He rises to power peaceably by means of intrigue- clever plotting and politics. In Daniel 9:26-27 we see that the Anti-Christ makes a peace covenant, as well as some sort of religious pact-possibly one that tackles the thorny issue of coexistence between Jews, Muslims and Christians in the middle east, and by which Jerusalem could be declared international city with free and equal access guaranteed to people of all faiths. This covenant could also clear the way for the Jews to finally be able to rebuild their temple on Jerusalem Mount Moriah and resume animal sacrifices on its altar “for he shall come up and become strong with a small number of people”- or a small people. The antichrist rises to power through his popularity with the “small” or poor people of the world, the masses, who respond to his political and economic policies, or he does it with the help of a “small” elite group of insiders.
“He shall disperse among them the plunder, spoil, and riches (v-24). This would fit Islam perfectly.
He will expand the Islamic kingdom by advancing to Egypt, Libya, and Sudan. This is evident from verse 25. He (the Anti-christ) shall stir up his power and his courage against the king of the South with a great army. And the king of the South shall be stirred up to battle with a very great and mighty army, but he shall not stand, for they (the Anti-christ) shall devise plans against him.”
It sounds like the king of the South has an even greater force than the Anti- Christ at this point. The tide of battle turns when the king of the South (Egypt) is betrayed by some of his own people. We have seen that Anwar Sadat was betrayed and killed by Islamists, and this is similar since the majority of Egyptians are Muslim fundamentalists.
The Little Horn and the rest of Scriptures fits very well
Daniel – 8:9. The Anti-christ must come from the Grecian empire- the eastern part of the Roman Empire and north of Israel. Since he is giving south, he must be coming from the north, in relation to Israel, exactly as specified in Ezekiel 38 and Joel 3.
Little Horn connects to Gog
It all connects: he comes from the eastern part of the Roman Empire, the Grecian side; so does the little horn come out of the four Grecian horns. Like Antiochus the Syrian, Gog also connects to the Seleucid dynasty. Seleucus became king of the eastern provinces- more or less modern Afghanistan, Iran, Iraq, Syria and Lebanon, together with parts of Turkey, Armenia, Turkmenistan, Uzbekistan, and Tajikistan.
Little Horn connects to the Beast of Revelation 13
Revelation 13 describes the end-times beast in terms of regions. Leopard (Grecian), lion (Babylonian), and bear (Medo-Persian). All three empires ruled the region of Asia Minor, the Seleucid portion of the Grecian empire. Scriptures places the Gang of Gog north of Israel, and Asia Minor is north of Israel. All prophetic writings must pinpoint the region, the Bible does not once mention any future leader coming from the west. Daniel- 11:31 describes a finl evil ruler, the king of the north, who sets up the abomination of desolation and puts an end to temple sacrifice.
Daniel 9
The next significant prophetic passage to unlock the origin of the Anti-christ is the last portion of Daniel 9:26. This portion of the prophecy is speaking of Jesus, the Anointed One, the ruler who was cut off at the crucifixion. From here, the prophecy jumps forward to the destruction of the temple- “the sanctuary”- in Jerusalem, in A.D 170. “The people of the prince who is to come shall destroy the city and the sanctuary (Daniel-9:26).
Daniel 9:25-27 Answer the Riddle
The argument for the Roman Anti-christ stems from an incomplete analysis of verse 26, which assumes that “the people of the prince” must be Romans. After all, the Romans were the ones who destroyed the temple, were they not? While it is certainly understandable how a quick reading of this verse could lead one to conclude this, when one scratches below the surface, this verse actually drives a nail in the coffin of this theory. The first things we need to analyze is the identity of the “the people of the prince.” The people of the prince. The prince he, the one who confirms the covenant for seven years.
“Who is the prince?” when did he come? Has he come yet? If not, when? Who are “the people of Prince?” Once you answer these questions and read the text again, you will understand .
- Who is the Prince? When did he Come?
Many western students of prophecy assume that the prince has already come, because Titus the Roman general was the one who destroyed the temple. Thus, Titus is often identified as “the prince” who is to come. But, this can never be so because the “he” in verse 27 (and he shall confirm the covenant with many for one week”) cannot refer to Titus, who was never engaged in a seven-year peace treaty. Neither did Titus commit an abomination of desolation. The prince must be the one who established this seven-year peace treaty. There is no way to escape this. So, the correct and only answer to the question is that the prince is the Anti-Christ. He has not yet come. All fundamental prophecy teachers agree with the above point.
- Who are the People of the Prince?
Now we come to the second part of the riddle. Because the prince must be the Anti-christ, then who are his people? When did they destroy the temple? Once you begin to put this puzzle together, the picture is quite amazing. The temple was destroyed in 70 A.D. Who were the “People” that destroyed it? Remember, there is a reason why the text says “the people of the prince.” God wants you to find out who these people are, for they will be “the people of the Anti- christ.”
Also, there is a reason why the text says, “who is to come”- it speaks of the future. These people will destroy the temple shortly. They are of the same lineage of the Anti-Christ, the prince, they are the “people of the prince.” His lineage, and his predecessors, so who were these people that destroyed the temple in 70 A. D? Yes, they were Roman legions and Roman citizens. Therefore, many scholars erroneously concluded they are of European descent and heritage as well. But there is more to this picture than is immediately apparent. If we look deeper, we quickly find that while the people who made up the Roman legions that destroyed Jerusalem were mostly eastern Roman citizens, they were not Europeans. In fact, they were primarily from the Middle East-Arabs, Syrians, and Turks.
It is crucial to note that Titus led the Eastern legions of the Roman Empire, not
the Western. After Vespasian emerged as the head of the Eastern legions to challenge Vitellus, Julius Alexander, the Prefect of Egypt, then proclaimed Vespasian to be Emperor. He and Titus became consuls in 70 A.D. So, let us read the passage in context, “the people (ancestors) of the prince (Anti-christ) who is to come (during the tribulation), will sack Jerusalem and the temple.” In other words, the people are the ancestors of the prince who will bring a seven-year peace treaty. In 70 A.D, Titus, the Roman general who led the armies that attacked Jerusalem and destroyed the temple, surrounded the city with three legions on the western side and a fourth on the Mount of Olives to the east.
Many people forget the fact that the Roman Empire also included a vast portion of the Middle East. Mostly the soldiers were Arabs, Syrians and Turks. Indeed, the majority of the ‘Roman’ soldiers that destroyed Jerusalem were Arabs, Syrians, and Turks, when we look at the four Roman legions that were under Titus, (son of Vespasian). During the siege against Jerusalem, we see that they were from the eastern portion of the empire, and were primarily from Syria or eastern Turkey. Once again, the Bible has led us to the same region. In context, the people of the prince are simply the people of the Antichrist.
Daniel was Speaking of the End
Western interpreters agree that Islam is involved in the final battle, but here we can see that Islam will play a major role. Daniel 12:4 says “but you, Daniel, shut up the words, and seal the book until the time of the end; and many shall run to and fro, and knowledge shall increase”.
The prophecy of Daniel is sealed and is regarding the “time of the end.” He will unlock the book of Daniel to the church. Daniel and Revelation would not be fully understood until the time of the end. The closer we get, the more we will understand.
Daniel 11:37 Both Deny Women’s Rights
The Anti-Christ will have no regard for women’s rights. Women will have no voice in his empire. In many Muslim countries women are treated like animals. The Anti-christ will not only change constitutional laws, but civil laws as well. According to Islamic law, a woman only inherits half of what a male inherits. In court, it takes the testimony of two women to equal the testimony of one man, because Mohammad declared that women have half the mental capacity of men. Daniel 11:37 simply says that the Anti-christ will show no regard for women- he hates women. The text never said that he does not desire women, but that he does not honor their desires. This is a big difference.
Islam proclaims death to Muslim women who marry out of their Muslim faith, yet it allows Muslim men to marry Non-Muslim women. The Quran allows even commands, men to beat their wives into subservience. (Sura-4:34). Muslims are not embarrassed when outsiders find out that Mohammad actually married his youngest wife Aisha when he was 51 and she was only 6 years old. He consummated the marriage when she was 9 and he was 54. When Mohammad died, he was 63 and his wife Aisha was only 18. If he had lived longer, he would have married someone even younger. Once, Mohammad looked at a baby girl named Um-Habiba while she was still nursing and said, “if she grows up while I am still alive, I will marry her”.
Literal References for Ezekiel 38 The Controversy over Rosh Ezekiel 38:1-9
One of the most popular prophecies of the Bible that has captured the attention of prophecy students is the “battle of Gog and Magog” that is found in Ezekiel 38: the passage speaks of a coalition of nations that attack Israel, who are all led by the nation of “Magog.” Many prophecy teachers claim that Magog is Russia, which will be destroyed along with Islamic nations. This must occur in order to usher in the battle of Armageddon and the coming of Christ. But these two arguments are unfounded and depend totally on pure conjecture. So, is Russia the nation of the Anti-christ? Or is the battle of Gog
and Magog a separate battle distinct from the Battle of Armageddon? Are Gog and the Anti-christ the same? Does Gog come from Russia? Doesn’t Russia arm Muslim nations?
The common argument for this assumption is that Russia is supplying arms to Iran (Persia) and other Muslim nations. But selling weapons does not amount to primary evidence for anything Biblical. The United States supplied weapons to Saudi Arabia and Egypt. It was the United States that forced Israel to allow elections for the Arabs in Jerusalem- and now we have Hamaistan in Gaza. Jimmy Carter deposed the Shah of Iran and Khomeini took over. Circumstantial evidence cannot be used as a substitute for solid scriptural evidence. Circumstances change, but God’s Word does not. So, do these policies of the United States make them the Biblical Gog or the land of the Anti-Christ?
When Russia stood with Nazi Germany, many concluded that Hitler was the European Anti-christ. They were wrong. As soon as Stalin was betrayed by Hitler, Russia went against Germany. During the Cold War, numerous prophecy analysts focused on Communist Russia as a major player in the end-times. But then the superpower collapsed, and its Muslim parts created their own commonwealth of Independent States (C.I.S). Few pay attention to the fact that they all are mentioned by their ancient names in the Bible.
Is “Rosh” “Russia”?
This controversy has been brewing for years. Much of the controversy revolves around the way that the word “Rosh” in Ezekiel-38:2 is translated. Some Bibles translate the word as a proper noun, “Rosh” and others as “the chief prince.” Those who argue that Rosh is a proper noun argue that it is referring to the modern nation of Russia. Dr. Charles Ryrie, takes issue with the translation of Rosh as a proper noun. He writes, “The prince of Rosh is better translated as the chief prince of Meshech and Tubal.
The far more reasonable translation of the Hebrew word Rosh in Ezekiel 38 is head of or chief. The word Rosh appears nearly 600 times in the Bible, and all but once, it is interpreted as meaning “head, chief, top, best” or something similar. Why, then would we make an exception here and translate it as a proper noun? The word Rosh here is the Rosh that we have in Rosh Hashanah- the chief day of the year- the Jewish New Year. Is Rosh a proper noun? Or does Rosh mean chief? The modern name of Russia is based upon the name Rus, which was brought in to the region of Kiev, north of the Black Sea, by the Vikings during the Middle Ages. That means it would have been nearly two thousand years after the time of Ezekiel that the supposed “Rosh people” became Russians. Billington puts Rosh in the Ukraine, north of the Black Sea or southern Russia, which would be the Muslim regions of Georgia and Chechnya. In Ezekiel’s day, Magog was elevated in Asia Minor, and Magog comes to represent modern day Turkey. Even if Rosh is interpreted as a proper noun, it could point to the Ukraine, Chechnya or Georgia and possibly even Iran.
Magog
Magog encompasses Asia Minor, but some prophecy teachers try to claim that Magog is also pointing to Russia. If Magog is the Scythian territory, then this land mass is in the southern region of the former USSR, but not Russia proper. Ancient Scythia includes the regions of Asia Minor Turkey, and the several central Asian states (Turkmenistan, Kazakhstan, Tajikistan, Uzbekistan etc.) these are all Muslim nations. If we examine some of the greatest Bible references, like the Macmillan Bible Atlas, Oxford Bible Atlas, and the Moody Atlas of Bible Lands, they all locate Magog, Meshech, Tubal, Gomer and Beth Togarmah in Asia Minor, not in Russia.
Another important point is that Meshech and Tubal must be tied to Magog, yet these are in Asia Minor and not in Russia. Magog is specifically referred to as the region of the land of Magog, chief prince (head or leader of) of Meshech and Tubal. (Ezekiel- 38:2) Because Meshech and Tubal are regions of Turkey, Magog must thus be related to Turkey, otherwise, the passage would make little sense. How could Russia be the head over regions of Turkey? It makes better sense to conclude that Gog is a leader from the land of Magog and the leader of Meshech and Tubal, all of which are in Turkey. When it comes to the geographic location of Meshech and Tubal, you will never find a
serious historian, Bible dictionary or Bible map that would agree with any of the proponents of a Russian location. What you will find written by supporters of the Magog- Russia theory are words like “probably, possibly and ‘may be’ interspersed throughout their arguments.
One common denominator in the argument over the Gog and Magog story is that everyone at least agrees that Gog is prince of Meshech and Tubal. No serious historian would argue that Meshech and Tubal are not in Turkey. If we go with the translation that Gog is the “prince of Rosh, Meshech and Tubal’ are we then to say that Gog rules both Russia and Turkey.
You might want to counter that Gog could indeed be the chief over this whole confederacy.However apart from the fact that these two nations have warred against each other from time immemorial, why didn’t the Bible then give him the title of prince of Rosh, Meshech, Tubal, Persia, Phut, and Cush? Gog is of the land of Magog, a very specific place, and he is the ruler of his domain; “Meshech and Tubal” which must be associated with Magog. All these are given for locators, and are not intended to lead us on a wild goose chase or a genealogical and historical puzzle. The error of the Russian theory arose from the Scofield Study Bible, which identifies Meshech and Tubal with the modern Russian cities of Moscow and Tobalsk. The only basis for this interpretation is the somewhat similar sound of the two words. Thus, Meshech sounds like Moscow, and tubal sounds like Tobalsk. However, one cannot simply take a word from an ancient Semitic language (in this case, Hebrew) and find a correlation to a modern name from a drastically different language, simply because the two words “sound the same.” While this may be convincing to some for the sole reason of phonetics, it is very irresponsible hermeneutics.
If phonetics is the yardstick to prove where Gog comes from, then Meshech fits best with the ancient Moschi/ Mushki far better than it does with Moscow. Likewise, Tubal fits far better with the ancient Tubalu peoples than it does with modern Tobalsk, especially because the two locations were well known regions of Asia Minor in Ezekiel’s day. Knowledge and refinement are increasing the closer we get to the actual events. Meshech appears in Assyrian texts as Muski or Musku from 1200 B.C onwards. The people of Musku were known to be aligned with tubal. There is little doubt that the frequent biblical association of Meshech and Tubal (Genesis- 10:2; Ezekiel- 27:13; 32: 26; 38: 2-3; 39:1; 1 Chronicle- 1:5) reflects this ancient political alliance in central Asia Minor during Ezekiel’s days.
Like Magog, the support for Meshech and Tubal to be in Asia Minor gains the blessings of historians even in Ezekiel’s day- Herodotus tells us that the name of the Cappadocian’s (Katpatouka) was applied to them by the Persians, while they were termed by the Greek “Syrians” or white Syrians (Leucosyri). Some people even say that Gomer is referring to Germany. Imagine how foolish the use of this methodology could become. One could even go so far as to make the Biblical Javan a reference to Japan or Saksin into Anglo-Saxon. After all, they sound similar. Had God intended a European nation to be included in the Gog coalition, he would have simply mentioned them. Iberia is mentioned in the Bible. So is Chittim, which was the ancient name for Rome. Hitchcock writes “Magog today probably represents the former under belly of the Soviet Union: Kazakhstan, Kirghizia, Uzbekistan, Turkmenistan, and Tajikistan. All these are Muslim. Meshech was located near what was known as Phrygia, in central and western Asia Minor (Turkey), while Tubal was located in eastern Asia Minor Turkey).
Gomer is in Turkey, not Russia or Germany. This is the land of ancient Kimmeria. Gomer is well known to the ancient world as Gimarri of north central Asia Minor (Cappadocia). These people are also known as the Cimmerians, so Gomer is Gimarra or Cimmerian in Cappadocia. Cappadocia, being central Turkey, again, another Islamic region.
Togarmah- Beth Togarmah is also in Turkey. Togarmah or Tilgarimmu was a city state in eastern Anatolia (Asia Minor, modern Turkey), more specifically as Ryrie states, “the south-eastern part of Turkey near the Syrian border.” Once more, we have another region that is in present day Turkey.
The Literal Evidence
Beyond so much of the geographic weight of this prophecy falling on Turkey, the Bible also ties this coalition to modern Turkey in a direct way. Zechariah-
9:13 confirms that the final end time battle will be between Israel and Yavan / Ionia (often translated as Greece) which is in Turkey today. The key element of this passage is the reference to the sons of Zion (that is the Jews) fighting against the sons of Greece (Yavan, Ionia), which is in Asia Minor or modern Turkey. What is translated as Greece, is the Hebrew word Yavan. When the Bible translation says “Greece” this should not be confused by popular western thinking as Athens or Cypress. Yavan was a descendant of Noah who came to live on the west coast of Asia Minor, or modern day Turkey, in the area that came to be known as Ionia. . While Yavan is a term that can in broader sense, imply all of the ancient Greek empire, it is most specifically a reference to Ionia in Asia Minor, or Turkey. Again, the verse that we are discussing is ultimately for the last days. As such, it is most clearly speaking about the citizens of Israel fighting against the Turks who are attempting to occupy their land.
One cannot separate Zechariah 9 from Ezekiel 38. In both passages, the messiah is present. The casting of the Ezekiel 38 alliance into hell is mentioned in Ezekiel 30 ,where the literal name Lydia is associated with several of the nations in the Ezekiel 38 coalition. “Cush and Put, Lydia and all Arabia, Libya and the people of the covenant (league) land will fall by the sword with Egypt. (Ezekiel- 30:5). Lydia undisputedly refers to the western region of Turkey. The same event is seen in [Jeremiah – 46:9]. Here, the Bible clearly connects the Gog coalition with Lydia (Turkey). There is Meshech, Tubal, and all her multitude [Ezekiel 32:26]. Why do we have Meshech, Tubal, Beth-Togarmah and Gomer included, yet Russia, the supposed leader of this coalition is missing? These nations are in league or covenant and allied with Egypt. In fact, in the prior chapter, Ezekiel 29 identifies Turkey with Meshech “Javan (Ionia, Turkey), Tubal and Meshech, they were thy merchants. They traded the persons of men and vessels of brass in the market. [Ezekiel 29:13]
Why does the Bible so consistently group these nations and regions together? The answer is that they were closely related in Ezekiel’s day and were understood by any who read the book in its original context.
When the Gog and Magog invasion occurs, the primary player will be Turkey.
The emphasis on a Turkish ruler being called “The Assyrian” would validate the Turkey argument because the Assyrian empire and Turkey significantly overlap, but Russia and Assyria are two entirely different geographic locations that never overlap. Obviously, the Lord directed Ezekiel to highlight significantly Turkey with the combination, “Of the land of Magog, the chief prince of Meshech and Tubal”. The other three nations mentioned Libya, Sudan and Iran, together with Turkey form a perfect circle around Israel. Turkey covers Israel’s entire northern horizon, while Iran is east of Israel, Sudan is south, and Libya is to the west. Israel finds herself surrounded on all four corners by the Islamic coalition. Instead of Russia, we see an Islamic invasion of Israel, most likely led by Turkey, and involving Iran, Libya, Sudan, Syria and several other Islamic nations.
Gog or “Gygez” was a real historic person from Turkey. This is perhaps the name preserved in scripture as Gog [Ezekiel: 38:2]. Gog is the reference used in the past to refer to Gugu of Lydia in Turkey. Esarhaddon [681-668 B.C] records his defeat of the Gimirrai, while king Ashurbanipal tells us in his records of the Cimmerian invasion of Lydia in the days of the Lydian king Gugu (Gygez, Gogaz) around the year 660 B.C. This is the same general period that Ezekiel was writing his prophecy.
Like other places in the Bible in which God refers to the Anti-christ as the prince of Tyre, or the king of Babylon, or the Assyrian, here he is calling the Antichrist “Gog” as a throwback to Gygez, a real historical figure from Lydia (Turkey). In fact, the Gomers were Turkic peoples who were descendants of the tribe recorded in history as the Oguz. They founded the Gokturk empire in the 6th century, 522 B.C and were defeated in 745 B.C by the Uygurs, an ethnically related Turkic tribe, “Gokturk” with the “Gok” part being the distinguishing name of this particular Turkic tribe, is remarkably similar to “Gog” and again reinforces the point that the Biblical Gog is a ruler from the Turkic region of Asia minor.
Archaeology can sometimes be the best forensic science when examining prophecy. In the case of Gog, the Bible uses past names, leaders, and locations to be introduced in the future. Gyges was first known to the Greeks
as “Tyrant” and the one who introduced “tyranny” to the Greeks: he was called “tyrannous” or the tyrant one. This is exactly how the Antichrist is portrayed in the Bible [Isaiah 14]. The same is said of Nimrod in Micah 5. Thus, after all we have so far discovered, we are not surprised to learn that Gyges of Lydia (Turkey), the first to be called a tyrant, bears a striking similarity with the Biblical Anti-christ. Turkey is far more qualified to lead an Islamic coalition than Russia could ever be. All of the nations allied with Magog and all the alliances throughout the Bible are Muslim. Why would Ezekiel 38 be any different? [Ezek: 38: 4]
Persia – Iran
Persia is modern day Iran. Iran was called Persia until 1935.
Cush: Sudan, Somalia
Not to be confused with modern Ethiopia, Cush of Ezekiel’s day was simply the region immediately south of Egypt often called Nubia. In scripture, Cush was often associated with Egypt and was a border nation to her. “I will make the land of Egypt a ruin and a desolate waste from Migdal (Northern Egypt) to Aswan (today in southern Egypt) as far as the border of Cush [Ezek: 29: 9-10]. The only legitimate identification of Cush then is modern Sudan, officially known as the Islamic Republic of Sudan since 1989. The region of Cush could also extend to the south of Sudan into Somalia.
Put or PHUT
Biblically, Put or Phut is the region west of Egypt. Today this is the nation of Libya. Algeria, morocco, Tunisia and Mauritania could also be included here as well.
Ezekiel 38 Is it Armageddon?
Many prophecy teachers in the West teach that the invading coalition of nations described in Ezekiel 38 – 39 is not the army of the Antichrist, but another army entirely, led by some other evil world leader, who is destroyed prior to Christ’s coming to defeat the Antichrist.
The reason for this view is simply because Ezekiel 38-39, which clearly describes a Muslim coalition of nations, does not support their European Antichrist Paradigm. For this reason, they are forced to find a way to divorce the battle of Gog and Magog from the main event when Christ returns to the earth for the showdown with the Antichrist. Most western prophecy teachers claim that Islam will be defeated and out of the scene before Antichrist emerges from Europe as a world leader. Ezekiel 38 indeed is Armageddon for several reasons.
- Israel will be pure. [Ezekiel 38:23-39: 7-8].
- The Gentiles will know God. God himself says that after the defeat of Gog and his armies, all of the Gentile nation as well as Israel will be convicted of their unbelief and will know that He (Jehovah) is God. The text of Ezekiel 38 describes the heathen as finally knowing who the true God is “the heathen may know me” [Ezekiel: 38: 16]. How could these be “heathen”? All these nations in Ezekiel 38 are Muslim nations. Worshipping Allah, according to Bible, cannot be the same as worshipping Jehovah. Islam is spread by force, yet keeps certain abrogated peace verses for the sake of deception.
- Christ is Present. In both battles – Gog and Armageddon, Christ is present along with the greatest earthquake [Ezek: 38:20]. [Ezek: 39:7]. Here it says “The Holy One is in Israel”. Other parts of scripture use the phrase “the Holy One of Israel”, but here the Messiah is actually present in Israel. We also have verse 18 of Ezek: 38 “my fury shall come up in my face”(Ezek: 38: 19-20.) Shake at my presence. In the same verse, we read about the earthquake and His presence on earth. This is not a small event. Every creature on earth will shake at the presence of Jesus. The book of Revelation also tells us that this event occurs when
the Antichrist’s armies are gathered together against Israel [Rev: 16: 18-20] Both descriptions tell us that the mountains are “thrown down”. In other words, no nations are left. Only one kingdom remains – the kingdom of the Messiah. Zechariah describes the same event from his own prophetic perspective. [Zach: 14: 1-4]. When did, Jehovah have feet? Zach: 14 gives both accounts – the final victory of Jehovah – God and the great earthquake Ezekiel 38: 19-20 speaks of it as well. The war of Ezekiel 38 is massive. If the war of Gog and Magog occurs just prior to Christ’s coming and is a separate event for Armageddon, then do we have two separate battles for Christ, one to fight Gog and one for Armageddon. After the destruction of Gog, the people of Israel will burn the weapons of war that have been scattered on the battlefield (Ezekiel- 39:8-9).
It is wrong to call the seven-year false treaty offered by the Anti-christ the “seven-year tribulation,”. The tribulation begins in the middle, when the Anti- Christ reneges on his deal. In reality, the tribulation is 3½ years. Such an event, the burning of weapons for 7 years would not take place unless Israel no longer needed weapons. Would it make sense to burn weapons at an hour of need? Why would they still burn the weapons after the middle of the 7 years? They will need all the weapons they can get. Gog and Magog is indeed the final war. There is no longer a need for weapons. They will burn into Millennium (Micah- 4:3).
WESTERN MISCONCEPTIONS
Middle Eastern Context
We now need to address important misconceptions regarding the scope and geographical focus of Biblical prophecy. For many years, it has been taught that in the last days literally every nation of the earth will be utterly dominated by the Antichrist. There will be no place to escape from the dreaded mark of the beast; every last nation of the world will come against Jerusalem. Zechariah 12 is used to validate the theory. The prophet Joel prophesies similarly. (Joel- 3:2) (Revelation- 13:7).
This would seem to be an ironclad case for the antichrist ruling the entire world, which he shows in his march against Jerusalem. The word used for “earth” in Zechariah is “eretz”, which most often is translated as “land.” But there are many verses in the Bible that also use the same type of language, yet they are clearly not speaking of the whole globe. These verses all use a Hebrew grammatical construct that is an exaggeration, or an emphatic statement, in order to convey their point. Using hyperbole is extremely common in eastern culture and elaborating on the exceptions, would entirely blunt the impact of the statement. For instance, Daniel the prophet, speaking to King Belshazzar: O King, the most-high God gave your father Nebuchadnezzar sovereignty and greatness and glory and splendor. Because of the high position He gave him, all the peoples and nations and men of every language dreaded and feared him. (Daniel- 5:18-19).
Did every Single Nation in the Earth Fear Nebuchadnezzar?
Was Daniel speaking of every nation of the earth, or only those nations that were in close proximity to Babylon to be affected by her? Daniel’s use of the phrase “all the people’s, and nations and men of every language was more of an emphatic expression used to convey his point. Or how about this one: men of all nations came to listen to Solomon’s wisdom, sent by all the kings of the world who had heard of his wisdom. (1 Kings- 4:34) Solomon was visited by kings from china, Korea etc.; another example in (2 kings- 17:29). Did the inhabitants of every last nation of the earth have Samaritan gods in their homes? This passage concerns a local area where such practices were the norm. ‘All’ is simply used to emphasize how widespread this practice was. In Isaiah 37:18, we read that “the kings of Assyria have laid waste all the nations, and their countries.” Did king Sennacherib of Assyria actually destroy all nations on the face of the earth? Was South Africa or Japan laid waste by Sennacherib? Did Alexander the Great ever occupy the whole world? Daniel-
8:5 says he did. There are numerous examples like this throughout the Bible. (Zechariah- 12: 2-3.) Who does this passage specifically say will attack Jerusalem? The answer is “the surrounding peoples.” Today, the nations that encircle Israel on every side are Muslim. The prophet Joel confirms this as well (Joel- 3:2, 4, 9-12). Once again, Joel like Zechariah, specifies just who the surrounding nations are. Does this include New Zealand, Papua New Guinea? Or is this prophecy speaking about the sea of Islamic nations that surround Jerusalem on every side which is exactly how it is today. Ezekiel also specifies who the nations are that will attack Israel and incur God’s judgment at the end of the age. (Ezekiel- 36:4-5).
Nations that will Attack the Anti-Christ
Some nations will attack the Anti-Christ (Daniel – 11: 40-45). The Bible says “many countries,” not all. Elsewhere, we read that Chittim will come against him. Daniel 11:30 says that ships of Kittim (out of the west) will come against the king of the north (Anti-Christ). In Numbers 24:24, Balaam, foretold, that ships shall come from the coast of Kittim, and afflict Eber.” Josephus identifies Kittim as Cyprus, whose ancient capital was called Kition by the Greeks. Cypress also extended to include lands west of Syria, all of Greece and as far as Illyricum and Italy. Note none of these lands are Muslim. In fact, Kittim actually appears in the Dead Sea scrolls and is even translated as “Romans” in the Septuagint. If the Antichrist were to come from the western Roman empire of Europe, the ships of Kittim would not come against him. To answer the question, are any European nations mentioned in the Bible? Yes. The ships of Chittim in the Septuagint are literally the European nations from Cyprus to Italy to Spain. According to the prophecy of Daniel 11, they attacked Antiochus who foreshadowed the Anti-Christ. As such, this passage could very well involve a dual fulfillment, and we could have a prophecy about a European attack against the forces of the Anti-Christ. Consider Turkey’s army -it supercedes the combined forces of Britain, Italy and France. Yet Turkey is no match for Rome’s fleet. No European country is featured in end time prophecy as receiving a judgment of wrath. Rome is mentioned several times, and Spain twice, without a single reference to judgments.
Ezekiel 28 also confirms that the most powerful nations on earth will attack the Anti-Christ (Ezekiel- 28:7). God will rise up several nations to attack the Anti-Christ. Therefore, it cannot be true that every nation of the earth will fall to the Anti-Christ and attack Israel. There have always been attempts to establish a one world government, yet they have never succeeded. Westerns have missed the obvious fact that the Bible is thoroughly Middle Eastern. In the Biblical world view, Jerusalem is the center of the earth, not Europe or America. The Biblical prophecies about the end times are no different.
Western Misconceptions and the Challenge
There are no literal references to non-Muslim nations that God will destroy in the end times anywhere in the Bible. Besides the argument over whether Magog is Russia, there is no literal reference to a nation that God destroys in the end times that is not Muslim.
Ships of Tar-shish
Many teachers of Bible prophecy claim that the European Union is the Anti- Christ’s dominion. They claim the Biblical Tar-shish is Spain or Britain, but do not support this nation Biblically. They claim that the merchants of Tar-shish and all the young lions there of (Ezekiel-38: 13) are other European countries. It is important to distinguish between ships of Tar-shish and the merchants of Tar-shish as nations that simply traded with Tyre. For example, an oracle concerning Tyre: Wail, oh ships of Tar-shish! For Tyre is destroyed and left without house or harbor. From the land of Cyprus word has come to them. (Isaiah- 23:1). In this verse, “ships of Tar-shish”, points to Tyre (Lebanon). Here the Bible ends speculation that “ships of Tar-shish” is any European entity. Tar-shish is cited in several passages. Many writers point to (Ezekiel- 27:12), noting that since only Britain or Spain manufactured tin, and because Britain still manufactures tin, then it must be Tar-shish. But this theory has several flaws. For this to be true, Britain
and Spain must also manufacture silver, lead and iron. :Tar-shish was thy merchant by reason of the multitude of all kinds of riches; with silver, iron, tin, and lead, they traded in thy fairs (Ezekiel- 27:12). Only Turkey was renowned for its production of silver, iron, tin and lead altogether. For the next argument, we turn to Jonah who, attempting to flee to Tar-shish from Israel, boarded a ship at the port of Joppa (Israel) on the Mediterranean coast (Jonah- 1:3). This would indicate that Tar-shish lies to the west. This is true, but the ships could also sail westward to Turkey and Lebanon. Even so, many modern authors are divided between Tartessos in Iberia (Spain) and Tarsus in Cilicia (Turkey). Celicia was the ancient name of southern Turkey. Josephs citing from the Hebrew Bible, notes that Tar-shish is a descendants of Japheth (Greek) (IAPETOS/JAPETUS) and Javan (Hebrew) associated with the Greek IONIA, a province in modern western Turkey. Modern metallurgy maps indicate that every single metal associated with Tar-shish can be found in the Taurus Mountains. Silver beaten into plates is brought from Tar-shish (Jeremiah-10:9). The Bible itself indicates that Tar-shish was a producer of silver. This cannot be Britain or Spain. Harper’s Bible dictionary describes Tarsus: “Tarsus, the capital of Cilicia. The city was built on the banks of the swift Cydnus River, 10 miles from the Mediterranean and 30 miles south of Tarus (silver) mountains, which were veined with lead and silver. If the people of Cilicia were capable of mining tin in the early Bronze Age they certainly did not need to sail to Spain to get tin to make it. Ezekiel 38:13 describes the merchants of Tarshish. There are some who claim that Tarshish is Europe, noting a prophecy in Isaiah 60 that seems to hint to western ships that carried immigrant Jews to Israel. [Isaiah 60:9] However, this will be fulfilled in the Messianic kingdom, when all the nations that hated Israel will participate in bringing the exiled Jewish captives back to their homeland. [Isaiah 60: 6-7]. They will even flock from Saudi Arabia to worship the real God – the Holy One of Israel. It is obvious that the Arabs will participate in helping the surviving Jews after Christ returns and completely defeat the Muslim nations. If Europe to any is the candidate for the “Ships of Tarshish”, which carry Jews back to the homeland, it is hard to imagine Arabs [Midian, Kedar, Sheba) ever doing such thing. If anything, the Arabs today would rather drown the Jews in the sea than extend assistance in carrying them to the land of Israel. Biblical Tarshish is lumped together with the Turkic regions. Isaiah clarifies this issue [Isaiah 66:19].
Here, Tarshish, Pul, Lud, Tubal and Javan are thrown together in on “that draws the bow”, and all these are in Turkey. Why should only Tarshish be identified as Spain or England?
The Ethiopia Question
Ezekiel 38 mentions Ethiopia, which many westerners interpret as modern day Ethiopia, a predominantly Christian nation. So, does that mean Ethiopia will join the Islamic coalition against Israel? This interpretation poses several problems. According to the Encyclopedia of the Orient,” Cush is the ancient kingdom of Nubia in today’s northern Sudan, whose rulers conquered southern Egypt in the 8th century B.C and established a capital at Napata.” The Sudan is one of the most strident, fundamentalist Islamic states. Two million Christians have been slaughtered and starved in the last 20 years. One can see on any Biblical map that Cush boarders Egypt. Isaiah describes the destruction of Egypt from the Aswan Dam to the borders of Cush. [Ezekiel 29:10]. If Egypt borders Cush, and is also adjacent to Sudan, then Cush could definitely be the nation of Sudan.
The Kings of the East
Some scholars think China is the king of the East, with its 200 million army invading Israel. This conclusion is based on one verse in Revelation 16:10. The interpretation, isolates the text without exploring the rest of scripture regarding literal nations from the east. In all of scripture, not a single passage connects “Kings of the East” with china. The real connection is rarely
considered. Matt: 2:1. States wise men came from the East. We know that these wealthy kings of the east were from the regions of Babylonia and Persia.
Why not consider this option? Westerners argue that the reason the kings of the east in Revelation come from China is the staggering number of soldiers – a 200-million-man army. But Islam can easily master this if you consider Iraq, Iran, Afghanistan, and Indonesia, east of the Euphrates with several kings.
The Key to Unlocking Symbolism
The Bible is constant and does not change meaning with every altering wind. For the last 500 years, the prevailing wind within the Protestant Church has suggested that the Antichrist will come out of the Roman Catholic Church, or that we are somehow moving toward a one-world- government. While there are indeed satanic forces that would like to unite the world for their own purposes, a close examination of the scriptures tells us that Satan will not succeed. This theory of the Antichrist controlling the whole world is completely wrong – God intervened in the tower of Babel, during Satan’s first attempt for control of the world. This story will repeat itself when Christ intervenes and comes down to stop the Antichrist from establishing a one-world Government – an Islamic caliphate.
Mountains as Kingdoms
Many of the symbols used during Biblical times are still commonly understood in many cultures today, but they are not easy for many westerners. Thus, we need a little background information. The Bible often uses mountains as a symbol, representing a kingdom or an empire [Isaiah 2: 2-4]. In other words, God’s kingdom will be over all other kingdoms; this is quite simple. In the east, this language is common. But western misconceptions and lack of understanding have caused much confusion. In the West, many are waiting for the Catholic Church to arise to power. Rome, after all, is the city of Seven hills (mountains). But listen to the former president of Iran Ahmadinejad “I have a dream, do not doubt, Allah will prevail, and Islam will conquer mountain tops of the entire world”. The mountain tops Ahmadinejad is speaking of are the great kingdoms and governments of the west- Great Britain and America. This is the proper eastern allegoric usage for the word “mountain”. Many passages in the Bible confirm the usage of this word “mountains” as kingdoms. [Ezekiel 34:6]. God’s sheep, the Jews, were scattered in Diaspora, throughout many different nations.
The word “mountain” is symbolic for a nation, empire, or kingdom. In Jeremiah 51:25 God rails against the Babylonian empire – the “destroying mountain” which he will make into a “burnt mountain”. Daniel 2:35 is a good example to prove this point. From the stone (Messiah) will come the “great mountain” which is the kingdom of God. In other words, the kingdom of God will rule over all the earth. Also, read (Ps 46:2-3, 6). In verse 6, the Bible even gives the explanation – mountains falling (V.2) or kingdom falling V.6 Christ spoke of having the faith of a mustard seed, that we can move mountains. Are these literal mountains? No. These are governments and kingdoms. This is Exactly what the disciples and the first believers did, they eventually changed the Middle East.