Chapter 9 of 19
Professor Francis William Newman & Benjamin Wills Newton
Professor Francis William Newman, Benjamin Wills Newton, Dr. Edward Cronin, George V. Wigram, George Muller, and William Kelly were all at one time friends or intimately associated with Mr. Darby. Considerate and kind as Darby was to F.W. Newman, before Newman‘s active mind rebelled against ‗the doctrine of Christ‘, he had no real sympathy with the character either of him or of his brother Cardinal Newman. Men, and not God, governed them both, though in a different way. The younger of the two had been much the most distinguished through out his academic career. The elder became a master of style in English writing, but a mere slave of tradition. Mr. Darby cared supremely for Christ and the truth to the glory of God the Father. Both brothers began as evangelicals, but they diverged, as time went on, and were quite estranged, till the one became a papist, and the other an infidel.
Almost every writer on Darby has felt it incumbent upon him to incorporate in his narrative Professor Newman‘s striking pen-portrait and appraisal of John Nelson Darby. Professor Francis William Newman (brother of Cardinal Newman) was associated with Mr. Darby in rather early days, but alas, widely drifted from his teaching. He had won an unusually high double First-class at Oxford, and became resident tutor at Sergeant Pennefathers. But ere long, after a brief missionary journey to the East along with Mr. A. N. Groves and others, Newman returned to England and lapsed into a form of skepticism or Deism, at least as soon as Mr. Darby‘s personal
influence was withdrawn. Professor Newman‘s reminiscences of those early days are interesting, as he states:
―After taking my degree, I became a Fellow of Ballial College, and the next year I accepted an invitation to Ireland, and there became a private tutor for fifteen months in the house of one, now deceased, whose name I would gladly mention for honor and affection, but I withhold my pen. While he paid me magnificently for my services, he behaved towards me as a father, or indeed as an elder brother, and instantly made me feel as a member of his family. His great talents, high professional standing, nobleness of heart, and unfeigned piety, would have made him a most valuable counselor to me; but he was too gentle, too unassuming, and too modest; he looked to be taught by his juniors, and sat at the feet of one whom I proceed to describe. This was a young relative of his, a most remarkable man, who rapidly gained an immense sway over me. I shall henceforth call him ‗The Irish clergyman‘. His bodily presence was indeed ‗weak‘. A fallen cheek, a bloodshot eye, crippled limbs resting on crutches, a seldom-shaved beard, a shabby suit of clothes, and a generally neglected person, drew at first pity, with wonder to see such a figure in a drawing room. It was currently reported that a person in Limerick offered him a halfpenny, mistaking him for a beggar; and if not true, the story was yet well invented.
This young man had taken high honors at Dublin University, and had studied for the Bar, where, under the auspices of his eminent kinsmen, he had excellent prospects; but his conscious would not allow him to take a brief, lest he should be selling his talents to defeat justice. With keen logical powers, he had warm sympathy, solid judgment of character, thoughtful tenderness, and total self-abandonment. He before long took holy orders, and became an indefatigable curate in the mountains of Wicklow.
That a dozen such men would have done more to convert all Ireland to Protestantism, than the whole apparatus of the Church establishment, was ere long my conviction; though I was at first offended by his personal affectation of a careless exterior [never was a greater mistake: it was his unworldly principle and practice.] I soon understood that in no other way could he gain equal access to the lowest orders, and that he was moved, not by asceticism nor by ostentation, but by a self-abandonment fruitful of consequences. He had practically given up all reading but the Bible, and no small part of his movement soon took the form of dissuasion from all other voluntary study. In fact, I had myself more and more concentrated my religious reading on this one book; still I could not help feeling the value of a cultivated mind. Against this my new eccentric friend (having himself enjoyed no mean advantages of cultivation) directed his keenest attacks.
I remember once saying to him, ‗The desire to be rich is absurd; but if I were a father of children, I should wish to be rich enough to secure them a good education.‘ He replied, ‗If I had children, I would as soon see them break stones on the road as do anything else, if I could only secure to them the Gospel and the grace of God.‘ I was unable to say amen; but I admired his unflinching consistency.
For now, as always, all he said was based on texts aptly quoted and logically enforced. He made me more and more ashamed of political economy and moral philosophy and all science, all of which ought to be counted dross for the Excellency of the knowledge of Christ Jesus our Lord.
For the first time in my life, I saw a man earnestly turning into reality the principles, which others professed with their lips only. Never before had I seen a man so resolved that no word of the New Testament should be a dead letter to him. I once said, ‗But do you really think that no part of the New Testament may have been temporary in its objects? For instance, what should we have lost if St. Paul had never written, the cloak that I left at Troas bring with thee and the
books, but especially the parchments? He answered with the greatest promptitude, ‗I should have lost something; for it was exactly that verse which alone saved me from selling my little library. No, every word, depends upon it, is from the Spirit and is for eternal service.‘
In spite of the strong revulsion, which I felt against some of the peculiarities of this remarkable man, I for the first time in my life found myself under the domination of a superior. When I remember how even those bowed down before him who had been in the place of parents-accomplished and experienced minds- I cease to wonder in the retrospect that he reverted me in such bondage.‖
Mr. Benjamin Wills Newton and J. N. Darby first met at Oxford in 1830, where Newton was a Fellow of Exeter College. Of his character some suggestive words of the late C. H. Spurgeon are illuminative. He says, ―That in matter and spirit, Mr. Newton is far removed from the Darby school.‖ He was a scholarly man, of grave, sober manners and of very considerable influence over a certain class, especially people of leisure. B. W. Newton was perhaps the man whose learning ability and piety outshone all others in England. It was he who was used of God to begin the work at Plymouth. Newton invited Darby to visit him at his home in Plymouth.
The work had great success in Plymouth, and it was said that there was not one household there without at least one representative attending the meetings. In fact, the theater had to be closed for three years because no one seemed to be interested in this sort of amusement or entertainment anymore. The general desire among many was to live in separation from the world. Contrary to what might have been expected, the owner of the theatre, who had suffered great external loss, did not become embittered, but joined the others who had chosen this path of separation and devotion to the Lord. There were no distinctions between rich and poor. All was happiness and peace. Their dress was plain, their habits simple, and their walk was distinguished by separation from the world.
The meetings of the assembly were calm, peaceful, and hallowed; their singing was soft, slow, and thoughtful; their worship evinced the nearness of their communion with the Lord; their prayers were earnest for an increased knowledge of God, and they had deep searching of the Scriptures under the guidance of the Holy Spirit, while the exercise of the varied ministry under the power of the Spirit.
These believers also lived a great deal in each other‘s houses and company, so that there was no such thing as domestic privacy among them. The designation, Plymouth Brethren, so well known today, came from the fact that the believers in Plymouth had no name, did not belong to any particular denomination, and so they were spoken of by others as brethren from Plymouth; this led naturally to Plymouth Brethren. Also, it was in Plymouth that the movement first came into public notice.
Darby did not remain long in Plymouth. He visited Oxford several times in the next two years, and also went to London and Scotland. The purpose of his visit to Scotland was to investigate what had been called a renewed outpouring of the Holy Spirit, accompanied by gifts of healing and speaking in tongues. Darby‘s verdict was negative. He felt that in the early Church the sign gifts- including healing, miracles, and speaking in tongues- were given so that the world could see a demonstration of God‘s power and blessing upon Christianity (I Corinthians 14:22). Miracles were linked to the original establishment of a new testimony of God, and were meant to be temporary. What would be their value today when, according to his view, the Church was in ruins?
Newton, of the original four, was left alone at Plymouth, where he soon exercised a great influence. As a teacher, he was very attractive and convincing, possessing great natural gifts. The striking appearance of his eagle- like face only added to his impressiveness.
This all proved to be a danger. In the beginning the danger was not so apparent, but in time, Newton would turn against the teaching of the Brethren. He later held and taught fundamentally false doctrine as to the person of Christ.
Newton’s Teaching
Mr. Newton had attended a number of the conferences in Ireland, until it became evident that he and Mr. Darby were hopelessly at
variance, both on prophetic teaching and in regard to the nature, calling, and order of the Church. The learned Dr. Tregelles warmly supported Mr. Newton in his views. Dr. Tregelles was Mr. Newton‘s brother in law. George Muller, Newton and Tregelles were posttribulationists.
In 1835, Samuel Prideaux Tregelles, who would become so well known as a Biblical textual critic, joined the Plymouth meeting. Tregelles assisted Wigram in the early stages of his work on the Englishman‘s Greek (1839) and Hebrew (1843) concordances. Wigram himself provided money for this work, a sum fifty thousand pounds, and spoke of it as simply passing through his hands. In this work he rendered an eminent service to the whole Church of God.
Mr. Newton was a voluminous writer. He lived to be ninety-three years of age, and after his separation from the Brethren, became the pastor of an independent congregation characterized by his particular teaching, in the city of London. This was the man who was destined to be the means of rendering the Brethren asunder. In the minds of many even today, he is the very incarnation of iniquitous teaching.
Newton viewed with extreme disfavor any departure from Puritan theology, except along eschatological lines. For him, the Church included all the faithful from Abraham down. He considered Mr. Darby‘s dispensational teaching as the height of speculative nonsense. He was vehemently opposed to the idea of the Church being a special company of whose calling and destiny the Old Testament knows nothing- a line of things emphasized by Mr. Darby.
At the Powerscourt meetings, Sir Edward Denny and Mr. Darby suggested the idea of the cancelled seventieth week of Daniel, beginning after the rapture of the Church. G. V. Wigram and J. G. Bellett readily accepted it as the key to the prophecies. It was, however, utterly rejected by Mr. Newton, who maintained that the Church must go through the final Tribulation, and that the Rapture would be coincident with the ―appearing.‖ Other differences gradually led to Mr. Newton‘s absenting himself from these gatherings in after years.
Other Teachings of Mr. Newton
Christ came by birth into man‘s relative condition as a sinner, and into Israel‘s condition as under a broken law, making part that, of an accursed people; that He was exposed to and threatened by the consequences of this position – not vicariously, but being one of them; that He had the experiences which an unconverted electman, if he felt rightly would have; that He had to work His way up to a point where God could meet Him; that He preserved Himself in a measure, from the consequences referred to above, and extricated Himself out of that condition by His life under the law; that subsequently He underwent what was due to it, vicariously on the Cross; that is that Christ was under the doom of death, and subject, not vicariously, but as associated with us, to condemnation and wrath; but He freed Himself from that position by keeping the law; that what He suffered when in this position during the first thirty years of His life was the infliction of God upon His soul; not entering into the condition of man merely in spirit, though this might be true too, and that He got out of this condition-this relation to God, at John‘s baptism (though in this Mr. Newton contradicts himself).
Irvingism taught that there was no personal sin in Christ, but that there was in the nature He took; so that He was exposed and liable to death.
Darby wrote a summary of Newton’s teachings:
- The Lord Jesus at His birth, and because He was born of a woman, partook a certain consequences of the Fall, mortality being one, and because of this association by nature, He became an heir of death, born under death as a penalty.
- The Lord Jesus at His birth stood in such a relation to Adam as his federal head, that guilt was imputed to Him; and that He was exposed to certain consequences of such imputation-as stated in Romans 5:12, ―By one man‘s offense- by one man‘s disobedience . . .‖
- The Lord Jesus was born as a Jew under the broken Law; and was regarded by God as standing in that relation to Him; that
God pressed upon His soul the terrors of Sinai as due to one in that relation.
- The Lord Jesus took the place of distance from God, which such a person so born and so related must take, that He had to find His way back to God by some path in which God might at last own and meet Him.
- So fearful was this distance, and so real was this relationship by birth, and so actual were their attendant penalties of death, wrath, and the curse, that until His deliverance, God is said to have rebuked and chastened Him in His anger and hot displeasure.
- Due to these dealings from God and Christ‘s sufferings under them, the language of Lamentations three and Psalms six, thirty-eight, and eighty-eight, etc. has been stated to be the utterances of the Lord Jesus while under this heavy pressure from God‘s hand.
- The Lord Jesus extricated Himself from these inflictions by keeping the Law; and that at John‘s baptism the consequent difference in Christ‘s feelings and experience was so great as to have been illustrated by a comparison of the difference between Mount Sinai and Mount Zion, or between law and grace.
- Therefore, it was stated that He had the experience of an unconverted, though elect, Jew. Later, Mr. Newton retracted most of the aforesaid doctrines.
What Brethren Hold Who are Sound and Separated from Evil Question: Could it be said that although the Lord Jesus never relinquished communion with His Father, yet it was in abeyance during the three hours of darkness on the Cross-, when as the sin-bearer He was forsaken by God?
Answer: We do not believe that there is any Scriptural support for the thought that during Christ‘s three hours of darkness on the Cross, communion between the Father and the Son was in abeyance. The gospel of John especially shows that there was perfect and unbroken communion between the Father and the Son- always-perfect union and perfect unanimity (John 10:30). It should be remembered in this connection that Scripture does not say that the Lord Jesus was forsaken of His Father, but of His God. The communion of the Son with the Father rests upon their eternal relationship in the Godhead, and being founded upon their essential Being, it could never be interrupted, nor be in abeyance.