Chapter 5 of 19
Darby’s Negative Aspects
W. G. Turner (A Darby Biographer) records the following events) A London surgeon told the writer a story of a Bible reading in which Darby was giving in the United States. A number of ministers were present and paying great attention to him. One of them, Rev. G. F. Pentecost broke in with a question as the meeting proceeded. Darby replied briefly, but the questioner not quite grasping the relevance of the reply, asked him to kindly repeat it. This Darby did, but Pentecost remarking that he still could not clearly see the point, asked for a third and more detailed explanation.
Arrested by this in the full flow of a most interesting argument, Darby rather spoiled things by very tartly retorted, I am here to supply exposition, not brains, or words to that effect.
It is interesting to note that while in Chicago on one occasion, Mr. Darby was invited by D. L. Moody to give a series of Bible readings in Farwell Hall. These were attended by many lovers of the Word of God, but unfortunately suddenly came to an abrupt end as the two clashed over the question of the freedom of the will. Mr. Darby held to what Moody considered extreme Calvinism on this point. Darby affirmed that so perverted was man‘s will, he could not ―will‖ even to be saved. He based his contention largely on the texts; ―which were born not of the will of the flesh, but of God; and It is not of him that willeth, but of God that showeth mercy.‖ Mr. Moody insisted that man as a responsible person was appealed to by God to turn to Him, and he would be condemned if he did not.
―Ye will not come to Me that ye might have life,‖ Jesus said to those who refused this message. ―Whoever will‖ is the great gospel invitation. The controversy became so heated one day, that Mr.
Darby suddenly closed his Bible and finished his visit with Moody. Another American leader whom Mr. Darby met was Dr. Daniel Steele, the great Methodist divine, and advocate of Wesleyan perfectionism. He was at first greatly delighted with Mr. Darby‘s downright earnestness of purpose and vast knowledge of the Word. He attended many of Darby‘s readings in Boston. However, he could not accept the doctrines of grace, and considered Mr. Darby‘s teaching on the two natures and the believer‘s eternal security to be utterly false.
One day when Mr. Darby was expounding on 1 John 1:7 showing that the subject dwelt on there was ―where you walk – not how.‖ Dr. Steele interrupted with the question, ―But Brother Darby, suppose a real Christian turned his back on the light, what then?‖ ―Then, replied Darby, the light would shine upon his back.‖
Later, Dr. Steele wrote a book against the Brethren called Antinomianism Revived or Plymouth Brethrenism Exposed. F. W. Grant ably answered this in Christian Holiness: Its Roots and Fruits. Mr. Darby, however, had the greatest patience with the poor, unlettered, simple believers. At his Bible readings, he was frequently known to help an uneducated brother out with his questions, and to go over the same ground again until the difficulty was cleared up. Occasionally, his stock of patience ran out with those of another class whom he thought were inclined to temporize with the truth under consideration.
The Reverend Sir Charles Brenton commented that he never knew a man in whom the ―two Adams‖ were so strong as they were in Darby. The negative side of Darby‘s character is undeniable, and it would not be honest to try to play it down. Darby was an Englishman by birth and upbringing, but he also had an Irish background. The people of each land have some distinct characteristics. Darby bore characteristics of his background as we all do, but as a Christian, he sought to bring the negative ones under Christ. The Lord Jesus was Darby‘s one and all. He gave up all for Christ, and he held fast to all he considered true, regardless of the cost. Like Paul, he stayed single, and consecrated his life for Christ. Someone once said that Darby was the most gullible man in all of
England. Darby often made mistakes in trusting men who were unworthy of his trust, especially if he believed that they had suffered for Christ and for the truth. Darby was too easily deceived. He had the habit of believing the first person that came to him with a story.
Darby was also well known for his consideration of the needs of others. Once he heard of a poor brother who thought of going to America because he was no longer able to support himself in England. Darby gave him a check to cover his expenses. During a conference, Darby stayed as a guest in a large house. At bedtime, he was missing. The others finally found him sleeping in a loft so that a poorer brother, whose loft bed he now occupied might have his more comfortable quarters in the house.
Darby sought to be a help wherever he could, even helping out in a barbershop that belonged to a brother who had been taken ill.