Chapter 2 of 19
Introduction
The Brethren Movement, which is a divine movement, is at a cross road of its nearly 200-year history. Author Wilbur M. Smith once said ―Of all the groups of Christian believers that developed in the English speaking world in the nineteenth century, the one which produced the greatest number of gifted writers was the Brethren. ―However, despite his opinion, very few Christians who maintain fundamental New Testament beliefs realize how much the Church at large owes the movement of a small, somewhat obscure group of believers. Contrary to Christianity today, a believer of even medial maturity at that time had a significant understanding of the word of God, making them much less likely to be duped by popular emotion fueled movements.
Spiritual globalization has convoluted the entire Christian world by erasing many doctrinal boundaries -specifically those associated with worship. Some outsiders and insiders scorn the Assembly model of worship as emotionless, dead, and dry. Some charismatic sympathizers who have infiltrated the movement even go as far as saying that the Brethren, as a whole, are dead and postulate that the present system of worship and Church administration is detrimental for its future progress in an attempt to bring change from within.
This writer believes that this is only because of their inaccurate understanding of history. In fact, whether considering scriptural or secular things, a comprehensive understanding of history of said thing is the foundation of a proper evaluation of it. Some brethren clamor for change, but this is only because of their inaccurate understanding of New Testament principles. Now, a book about J.N. Darby would obviously include the history of the movement that he started as a prominent subtext, which has subsequently prompted my exhaustive analysis of the subject. From this analysis, I have delineated three groups of believers in the Brethren movement.
The first group consists of believers who have been converted from other nominal Christian denominations. Among them, the majority of believers have studied scripture and the history of the ―Movement ―which ultimately led to their assimilation. However, a minority of the converts did not learn the uniqueness of the Assemblies, and came up with some ideas to try and assimilate the movement with the emerging church model. They are attracted to loud music and scintillating speeches, they lift hands and utter ―Amen…. Halleluiah‖ and consider emotional expressions as the mark of a living and spirit filled worship. But a keen observer will find that the emotional worship has no correlation to superior character in terms of a practical Christian walk. After all, the fruit of the Spirit is the only mark of a truly spiritual person. In 1827, the early brethren understood the folly of emotional worship as superfluous and thus selected meditational worship.
The second group is comprised of believers, who are born to Brethren parents, but were never taught the reasoning behind the New Testament Assembly formula of worship. Similar to the minority in the first group, they castigate assembly practices and instead opt to cite the incident of King David dancing in front of the ark as a true pattern of worship.
These first two groups mostly idolize non-brethren heroes of the faith.
Since the inception of Christianity more than two thousand years ago, there were thousands of martyrs and great men of faith, and it is obviously impossible to focus on all of these heroes in one preacher‘s speeches and writings. That being said, one should notice that the men usually left out of preachers‘ writings and teachings are somehow the Brethren. Most of the North American Brethren speakers originally came from Roman Catholicism and other Christian denominations. When they became Brethren Assembly believers, some of them received false and baseless anti- Darby indoctrination. Some of the preachers are Darby haters and they never studied early Brethren History and biographies of the founders of the movement. So the people who listen to the messages of these preachers do not feel any attraction toward the Brethren Movement. They have no problem to go to other denominations as soon as they graduate from high school and go to college in another town. Although the Brethren movement is young, they are the ones who recovered the precious truths, which were lost for two thousand years. This small movement (0.1 percent) produced more than one hundred of the greatest expositors that ever lived. This movement sent missionaries throughout five continents, which transformed Christianity all over the world in the nineteenth century. The Brethren movement has great heroes of faith with great history, so does it make any sense for some of our Brethren to ignore all the Brethren scholars and heroes of faith while only uplifting D.L. Moody, C. H. Spurgeon (a Brethren despiser), John Wesley, George Whitefield, etc.? Of course they were great men and we should definitely read about them although they were not sound in Biblical doctrines. But my question is…. why have most brethren never heard of F.W. Grant, William Kelly, Jim Elliot, C.H. Mackintosh, Robert C. Chapman and numerous others? We should not feel ashamed to identify with Brethren and their great men.
The third group is comprised of believers who are converted and believers who are born in the assembly families. This group has a clear grasp of scripture and the history of this great movement.
Why The Brethren Movement is dying in Great Britain and North America?
Brethren Assemblies are disappearing in an alarming rate in America and Great Britain. At the same time minority groups- such as Spanish Assemblies are growing in North America because Immigrants from Latin America are doing a great job in propagating the Gospel to their own communities. After careful analysis, this writer has diagnosed the problems plaguing the Brethren Assemblies, and will attempt to present some meaningful remedies to the maladies that are apparent.
In the nineteenth century this small band of believers- The New Testament Assemblies sent missionaries all over the world. Many were willing to depart their wealth on earth in exchange for treasure in the Kingdom of God, and subsequently,
God honored for their faithfulness and blessed them materially.
Fast- forward to the twenty-first century, and most believers are relatively wealthy. However, their outlook toward spiritual matters have been gradually transformed. Although most of them strive for Godliness and are devoted to their own personal Christian development, their passion for the spread of the gospel is gone. I have greater appreciation for the Baptist churches which took the mantle from the Brethren, the role to propagate the gospel.
Just like non-believers, the brethren believers also don‘t want to bring inconvenience to their lifestyle. When you read this biography, you will find a clear distinction between the pioneers and the present generation of Brethren. Although the pioneers had meager resources they were willing to invite the evangelists to their homes and share what little they had. They derived immense joy to entertain an evangelist- so much so, that brothers were even competing for the privilege of showing hospitality. They accepted the principle from Hebrews 13:2 ―Don‘t forget to show hospitality to strangers, for some who have done this have entertained angels without realizing it ―They believed that when a child of God stepped in their house they brought blessings. What is the condition today? The conference speakers will stay in a nearby hotel and take a rental car and travel to the Assembly Hall to speak; in exchange, they will get a substantial ―fellowship‖ to cover the extra expenses. It is almost like a business trip. When did we exchange the true fellowship of believers for checks made out to them? Many believers do not seem to want to encourage evangelists materially.
The first generation of India believers are an exception- in my local assembly, at least, this group is always willing to invite the speaker into their homes. There are only a few non- Indian families willing to host the visiting evangelists. Churches in India are growing rapidly. They teach young children to give money to evangelists, who have no trouble finding a home to stay in, by the way. Over the last forty years more than 200 visiting evangelists have stayed in my home and my sons had to vacate their bed and sleep in some other places in my home. So the India immigrant community in North America is showing an exemplary model and willingness to receive evangelists and contribute financially to their work. However, most of the second generation of Indian immigrants are not adopting the model so cherished by their parents.
Assemblies in the West are not teaching the uniqueness of the New Testament principles that the Brethren Assemblies follow. The parents and local assemblies should teach the biographies of the brethren pioneers and our unique New Testament doctrines.
Deuteronomy Chapter 6, is a perfect guideline for us today. Chapter 6: 4‖ Hear, O Israel: The LORD our God, the LORD is one.] 5 Love the LORD your God with all your heart and with all your soul and with all your strength. 6 These commandments that I give you today are to be on your hearts. 7 Impress them on your children. Talk about them when you sit at home and when you walk along the road, when you lie down and when you get up. 8 Tie them as symbols on your hands and bind them on your foreheads. 9 Write them on the doorframes of your houses and on your gates‖.
Sadly, cults like Jehovah Witness and Mormons do a better job than us. Even ISIS has done more in converting more than 1000 people to Islam in North America through the internet, Facebook and other technologies. All of these technologies were invented in America, but Christians foolishly hesitate to embrace them as a tool for evangelism. Years ago, when Radio and TV were emerging technologies, Christians understood that it was a good medium to propagate the gospel to a global audience. Millions heard the gospel in Islamic countries and the oppressed former Soviet Union through radio and accepted Jesus Christ as their Lord and Savior.
At work, I have witnessed interaction of American born Muslim men: they do not usually want to shake hands with female employees, and do not participate in work potlucks because it was not Halal. Seeing as these were American born, it appears that Muslims can raise their children according to their own beliefs in America. Yet, I hear from countless Christians that it is impossible to raise our Children with Biblical values in America. My above example will prove that their arguments were wrong. Yes, we can raise our Children in America with Christian values- it just won‘t be easy. According to Deuteronomy: 6, we need to brainwash and radicalize our kids in a good way, not like the Muslims. We need to teach loyalty to our faith.
Most Brethren assembly believers are unqualified to do outreach work for the following reason: Many assemblies are at the brink of collapse. These assemblies have only few members who are advanced in age. But, in my investigation of this situation, I found out that all of these believers have children and grandchildren nearby. If these believers taught their children the uniqueness of our faith and built loyalty, these assemblies would be overflowing with their own family members. In Kerala we used to criticize the Brethren saying that assemblies‘ hade only children and grandchildren, not anyone from the outside. Now looking back, and compared with the West, I am glad that the assemblies in Kerala are filled with children and grandchildren and not empty and shutting down.
My goal is to provide true historical facts about great men who gave great contributions to the Christian Church and served our Lord with great sacrifices.
This work is a result of a fervent desire from my heart to write a factual and true picture of J.N Darby to 21st century readers. Most historians present him in an unfavorable light. Modern fundamental Christians derive their energy from the teaching of J.N Darby. Even many brethren who dislike Darby are following the doctrines and practices recovered by him. Let me quote Roy A. Huebner, a Darby specialist. ―J.N. Darby has been the object of the most bitter calumny and animus. It is a disgusting, fleshly, and unholy polemic to blacken a man personally so that people will not listen to him. Thus, the integrity of J.N. Darby has long been under attack regarding his statements- in this case, regarding his having been taught of God, directly from His Word. It was his principle not to defend himself against personal attack, as often happened in his life. Such personal attack continues to this very day by some who dislike the teachings recovered to the saints through his instrumentality.‖
Fundamentalists practice the following doctrines recovered
by JND.
- Dispensational theology.
- Prophecy
- The priesthood of every believer
- The pre -tribulation rapture.
- The distinction between Israel and the church.
D.L Moody and C.I Scofield were influenced by Darby. Darby is the father of dispensational theology: a theology made popular by the Scofield and Ryrie study Bibles and the works of Clarence Larkin. The Dallas Theological Seminary and The Moody Bible Institute were founded by the principles of dispensational theology.
A.C. Gaebelein considered Darby, Kelly, F.W. Grant, and a few other men next to the apostles in their sound and spiritual teachings. Gaebelein also speaks of four saints named ―John‖ who will be present at that great celestial meeting with Christ when He returns - John Calvin, John Knox, John Wesley and John Darby.
All modern prophetical writers base their works on J.N. Darby. Dr. Billy Graham (known as America‘s pastor), Hal Lindsey, Tim LaHaye, and almost all modern fundamental evangelical preachers base their prophetic theology on Darby‘s teachings. In the last decade, Tim LaHay‘s ―Left Behind‖ series sold more than any other book in the world. ―Left Behind‖ emerges from a dispensationalist and fundamentalist framework. Tim LaHaye has written a book called ―The Rapture‖ defending vehemently Darby and his teachings. The world trade center attack on September 11 2001 and the Iraq war have re-kindled the interest in Biblical prophecy and the end time events. According to a Time magazine survey, 36% of Americans believe that the Bible is the word of God, and is to be taken literally. Also 59% believe the prophecies in the book of Revelation will come true. The word ―apocalypse‖ comes from a Greek word that literally means, ―Lifting of the Veil‖. More people in the U.S and around the world believe history is accelerating and that ancient prophecies are being fulfilled in real time. It changes the way people feel about their circumstances, and the way they act. The grays are beginning to fade out of the way people view the world, and they are now seeing things in more black and white terms.
America, a country born with a sense that divine providence was paying close attention from the start, has always had an affinity for prophecy.
The rise of Hitler, an embodiment of evil who murdered millions of Jews, read like a Bible story. His destruction, the subsequent return of the Jews to Israel after 2000 years, and the capture of Jerusalem‘s old city by the Israelis in 1967, were taken by devout Christians and Jews alike as evidence of God‘s handiwork. Israel once again controlled the temple mount, a site holy to Islam, Christianity, and Judaism as well. The temple mount is the location of Al-Aqsa mosque, the third holiest site in Islam, and is also the very place where Christians and Jews believe a new temple must one day be rebuilt before the Messiah can come.
―The Late Great Planet Earth,‖ written by Hal Lindsey and published in 1970, became the best selling non fiction book of its decade; Time Magazine called Lindsey ―The Jeremiah of our Generation‖ One of the prophecies that Hal Lindsey saw in the Bible was the emergence of a United States of Europe. The election of Ronald Reagan brought ―Christian Zionism‖ deeper into the White House. (Regan was a dispensationalist and believed Biblical prophesies. Critics wrongly made allegations that Regan would start World war III in order to fulfill Bible prophecies. Now we all know that those accusations were baseless. The former U.S. president, George W. Bush is also a believer of end time Bible prophecy. The only exception is Barack Hussein Obama. He has no love for Israel. The left in America ridicule Bush for his stand about the status of Israel in the overall peace plan.) Lindsey says that he was called a false prophet for saying that there would be a ―United States of Europe‖ back in 1970, but there is one now. American Evangelical leaders have declared that support for Israel has moved to the very top of their agenda. Christian groups are spending millions on everything from armored school buses for Israeli children to halogen lights for the army‘s emergency rescue service. There are email chains, prayer ministries, and grass roots efforts to get the word out that the U.S. must stand united with its allies on the war on terror.
The End:
(Based on Bible Prophecy)
How it got that way.
Time Magazine: July 1, 2002
―Calamity is the mother of end- of- the world prophecy. This is true as millions of Americans, many rattled into an end times frame of mind by September 11, line up to buy the latest installment in ―The Left Behind‖ series, ―The Remnant. ―It was true when the first prophecies of the End appeared in the Hebrew Bible in response to a great national catastrophe in 586 B.C. And it was true in between, when an Irish preacher (John Nelson Darby) changed the course of American religious thought by bringing a stark apocalyptic vision to a nation that was reeling from the Civil War, its own fratricidal foretaste of Armageddon. Notions of a divinely choreographed end to history are almost as old as western faith. They appear first in the Jewish Bible books of Isaiah and Ezekiel. In 586 B.C., after a brutal siege, the kingdom of Babylon conquered Israel and forced its elite in to exile. The prophets defiantly proclaimed the opposite:
The establishment over all nations of a Jewish Kingdom under a divinely anointed Messiah set at the end of days. It was so resonant to a nearly annihilated people that it became a central part of their tradition. The high water mark of Jewish apocalypticism is in the book of Daniel, which contributed a kind of timetable for the End and a vivid symbolic language. (―And four great beasts came up from the sea‖).
Eventually Jewish fascination with a militant restoration of God‘s Kingdom faded, but Christianity embraced it. Jesus‘ thoughts about the end are expressed in Matthew 24, in which he hints that it might happen in his disciples‘ lifetime. After his death, his followers developed scenarios keyed to his anticipated second coming.
The fullest of these is the techni-color spectacle called Revelation. The book is usually attributed to John of Patmos and dated around A.D. 95. John was responding to the horrific persecution of early
Christians under the Roman emperor Nero. The book incorporates the harsh yet finally hopeful scenarios now familiar to believers: The earthquakes and plagues, the four horsemen, the seven seals, and the battle against the Anti-Christ. Christ‘s 1000-year earthly rule of peace and righteousness is called the (millennium). And then these lines of scripture: ―Now I saw a new heaven and a new earth. Then I, John, saw the holy city, the new Jerusalem, coming down out of heaven from God, prepared as a bride adorned for her husband.‖ John‘s vision became the Bible‘s final book.
There was one problem: The vagueness of Revelation‘s imagery almost immediately inaugurated a nearly 2000-year End Times guessing game. Some of the most heated speculation has been about precisely when the apocalypse would start (wrote an annoyed St. Augustine: ―To all those who make calculations—Relax your fingers and give them a rest‖) and when they were not guessing the date, denominations, and nations tried to figure out what long-term role they might play in the great final drama.
No nation thought itself more of a player than the U.S. From as early as the 17th century, many had seen the new world as the linchpin of a particularly optimistic End Times scenario. Unlike earlier believers who thought humans were helpless to influence God‘s cosmic plan, they though they could trigger Christ‘s millennium by purifying and perfecting America. Ministers preached America as Revelations‘ New Jerusalem. Many colonists saw the revolution in millennial terms, with George III as the Antichrist. Those most convinced, whom we would now call Evangelicals, helped shape the nations‘ culture of civic engagement, founding movements to abolish dueling, drinking, slavery, and other sins. By the mid-1800‘s, some announced confidently that the millennium might be a mere three years away. By 1865, those dreams lay in bloody ruins on the Civil War battlefields. Far from a millennial peace, Evangelicals found themselves fighting their brothers in America‘s homemade taste of hell. Afterward, they fell helpless to alleviate the misery in fast growing cities and were threatened by the arrival of Catholic immigrants. As it did in ancient Israel, Calamity demanded a rethinking of the End Times.
The man with the plan was an Anglican priest turned traveling evangelical preacher named John Nelson Darby, who arrived in the U.S. in 1862 for the first of seven visits, bearing a radical new eschatology. Darby and Minister Cyrus Scofield, who would expand the evangelist‘s ideas in the vastly influential Scofield Reference Bible, divided God‘s relationship with man into seven ages (The current sixth began with the death of Christ) (Darby is the father of dispensationalism so it is called Darbyism. Darby traced eight dispensations. Scofield modified it and traced seven dispensations.)
Their vision grimly upended the previous wisdom. Far from getting ever better, things on earth would progressively worsen, until the Antichrist, also known as the beast, arose. A seven-year, hell-like Tribulation would begin, survived by only a small human remnant. Not until then would Christ return, defeat the Antichrist and commence his millennium. (Postmillennialism is diametrically opposite to the above view. The Postmillennialism teaches that the gospel already operative in the world will win a victory throughout the earth in fulfillment of the great commission. During this time the majority of men and nations will be Christianized, righteousness will abound, wars will cease, and prosperity and safety will flourish. Christ will return at the end of the present millennium. If you read newspapers, you will understand the terrorist scare and all other calamities sweeping the globe. Post-millennium view is not only wrong, but it shows a poor understanding of Scripture and world history.)
Darby‘s most striking innovation was the timing of a concept called the Rapture, drawn from the apostle Paul‘s prediction that believers would fly up to meet Christ in heaven. Most theologians understood it as part of the Resurrection at time‘s very end. Darby repositioned it at the Apocalypse‘s very beginning, a small shift with large implications. It spared true believers the tribulation, leaving the horror to non-believers and the doctrinally misled, thus moving Christianity‘s ―us vs. them‖ concept of heaven and hell in to a new and exciting theater.
In the post-Civil War decades, American Evangelicals seized on Darby like a life preserver. At the time of the Scofield Bible‘s publication in 1909, they were establishing a set of ―fundamental‘s‖ which included painstaking interpretations of scripture. Darby‘s scheme became a pillar of the new fundamentalism. It merely
confirmed for evangelicals the Darbyite assumption that the world was getting progressively more wicked-beyond any help, but the conversion of new souls to Christ. (The Scofield Bible can still be found in churches across the country)‖ Many think that Fundamentalism received a great blow at the monkey trial in 1925. ―
“Monkey Trial “Or Scopes Trial
In 1859 Charles Darwin published ―The Origin of the Species.‖ Darwin argues in his introduction ―the view which most naturalists entertain, and which I formerly entertained – namely, that each species has been independently created – is erroneous.‖ In 1871 Darwin published his second book, ―The Descent of Man.‖ In this work, Darwin directly addresses the debate over the origin of mankind; a hairy tailed quadruped, probably arboreal in its habits, and an inhabitant of the old world.
In 1921 a former U.S. congressman and ex-secretary of state, William Jennings Bryan became a leader in the anti-evolution movement, delivering speeches entitled ―The Menace of Darwinism‖ and the Bible and its enemies. Bryan declares that it is better to trust in the Rock of Ages, than to know the Age of the rocks; it is better for one to know that he is close to the Heavenly Father, than to know how far the stars in the heavens are apart‖
In January 27, 1925, the Tennessee House of Representatives approves the Butler Bill. It prohibited the teaching of ―any theory that denies the story of Divine Creation of man as taught in the Bible, and to teach instead that man has descended from a lower order of animals‖ By 1925 states across the South had passed laws prohibiting the teaching of evolution in the classroom. American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) brought lawsuits against the Bill and in 1927 the Tennessee Supreme Court ruled that the Butler law was constitutional.
In fact, pre-millennial Dispensationalism (Darbyism‘s Official name) was, and remains one of the narrowest and most inward-turned strands in American religious belief.
The Balfour Declaration
The Balfour Declaration was an official statement issued on behalf of the British government in 1917, announcing its support in principle of a proposed home for the Jewish people in Palestine. It was drafted by British Foreign Minister Arthur J. Balfour in concert with prominent Jewish leaders and the British cabinet and was issued by Balfour in the following communication to the 2nd Baron Rothschild on November 2, 1917;
"I have much pleasure in conveying to you, on behalf of his Majesty's Government, the following declaration of sympathy with Jewish Zionist aspirations, which has been submitted to, and approved by, the Cabinet.
"His Majesty's Government views with favor the establishment in Palestine of a national home for the Jewish people, and will use their best endeavors to facilitate the achievement of this object. It being clearly understood that nothing shall be done which may prejudice the civil and religious rights of existing non-Jewish communities in Palestine, or the rights and political status enjoyed by Jews in any other country. "I should be grateful if you would bring this declaration to the knowledge of the Zionist Federation."
This declaration, which Zionists interpreted as a promise for a Jewish state in Palestine, was formally approved by representatives of the Allied governments at Versailles in 1919 and was the basis of the League of Nations mandate for Palestine.
John Darby, whose Biblical teachings as to Israel being restored to their land influenced Balfour and others in the British government at the time, wrote this:
"A very clear prophecy of Israel's condition in the last days is contained in Isaiah 18. They shall be restored by means of some powerful nation, outside the limits of their then national relationships; but Jehovah stands apart from His own relationship with them, though ordering all things. Then, when Israel shall begin to bud as a vine in the land, they shall be given up as a prey to the nations. Nevertheless, in that time they shall be brought as an offering to Jehovah, and shall themselves bring an offering too."
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
I would be a great ingrate if I failed to mention the saints who over the years have helped and encouraged my ministry. Christy Nelson is an integral part of my written ministry. She has contributed her time and talents in publishing many of my books. I write everything in an almost indecipherable long hand, and Christy edits and types it in readable format. I would like to add my special thanks and gratitude to Rob and Mary Terrill for correcting and editing this work.
The late Roy a. Huebner is a well-recognized Church historian and Bible expositor. Great men like Charles Ryrie, Dr. John Walvoord, Thomas Ice and many others have used his research materials in their works. He provided enough materials to use in my work, for which I am grateful. I am grateful for his support. I also wish to thank Dr. Alexander Kurian for writing a foreword. He has become a global speaker and evangelist. My youngest son Cyril Mathew organized the final draft and collected all the necessary photographs of prominent brethren, and the Lord will reward him for that work.