Chapter 11 of 13

The Filioque Controversy

6 min read · Pages 73–77 of the printed edition

The filioque clause was, and still is, a controversy in the church in relation to the Holy Spirit. The question is, “from whom did the Holy Spirit proceed, the Father, or the Father and the Son?” the word filioque means “and the Son” in Latin. It is referred to as the filioque clause because the phrase “and son” was added to the Nicene Creed, indicating that the Holy Spirit proceeded from the Father “and the Son.” There was so much contention over this issue that it eventually led to the split between the Roman Catholic and Eastern Orthodox Churches in AD 1054. the two churches are still not in agreement on the Filioque clause.

John 14:26 tells us, “But the counselor, the Holy Spirit, when the Father will send in my name.” John 15:26 tells us, “When the counselor comes, whom I will send to you from the Father, the Spirit of truth who goes out from the Father, He will testify about me.” See also John 14:16 and Philippians 1:19. These scriptures seem to indicate that the Spirit is sent out by both the Father and the Son. The essential matter in the filioque clause is a desire to protect the deity of the Holy Spirit. The Bible clearly teaches that the Holy Spirit is God (Acts 5:3-4). Those who oppose the filioque clause, object because they believe the Holy Spirit proceeding form the Father and the Son makes the Holy Spirit subservient to the Father and the Son.

History

Following John 15:26 the Nicene – Constantinople creed states that the Holy Spirit “proceeds from the Father.” The creed was first promulgated at the first council of Nicea in 325 without the section of the Holy Spirit elaborated. It was then modified at the first council of Constantinople in 381 to include this phrase on the origin of the Spirit. Hence, the Nicaean creed is often called “Nicene- Constantinopolitan.” This creed was not officially received until the council of Chalcedon in 451.

In thinking about God as Father, Son, and Spirit, the Trinity, following Jesus (Matthew 28:19), Christians from early times have made some important distinctions. The Son and the Spirit are said to have their eternal origin from the Father; the Son, the eternal Logos (John 1:1) is “generated” (born or begotten) of the Father, while the Spirit “proceeds” from the Father. These statements are made in reference to the being of God, from all eternity, “before all ages” in the words of the Nicene Creed.

On the other hand, the Nicene Creed and the Bible do not say explicitly that the Holy Spirit proceeds from the Son as well as the Father; that is, there is no statement that the Spirit's eternal origin is found anywhere but in the Father. However, Christians found evidence for a connection between the Son and the Spirit. For example, the New Testament teaches that the Spirit testifies to the Son (1 John 5:6) and is called the “Spirit of Christ” (Romans 8:9; 15:5; Philippians 1:19; 1 Peter 1:1) and the “Spirit of the Son” (Galatians 4:6). The Son (i.e. Jesus) also says he will “pray to the Father, and He will give you another comforter to be

with you forever, the Spirit of truth” (John 14:16). The church fathers further explained that the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit are “of one essence” (substantia/ousia) and have one common will and activity, with regard to their external actions. This tradition continued to be reaffirmed in both East and West, unanimously in medieval times by the scholastic theologians.

To this day, the Orthodox Church uses the Nicean- Constantinopolitan Creed of 381 without the filioque. They objected to the teaching it expressed, as conflicting with biblical and accepted doctrine. They said that for the Holy Spirit to proceed from the Father and the Son there would have to be two sources in the deity, whereas in the one God, there can only be one source of divinity or deity. Western theologians anticipated this objection by saying: “the Spirit proceeds from the Father and Son as from one principle.” The east, however, again objected that this formulation would merge and confuse the persons of the Father and the Son. It was also pointed out that if Father and Son are sources of deity (and only the Holy Spirit is not), it follows that the status of the Spirit is diminished, relative to the Father and the Son, by excluding the Spirit alone as a source of divinity, making the Spirit, rather, a recipient of it – as if the Son and Spirit were both subordinate in their own doctrine. Finally, if someone says that the divine essence itself is the source of deity in God, which they took the Latin theologians to say, then (as the Eastern theologians pointed out) another problem is created, a suggestion that the Holy Spirit proceeds from Himself, since He is certainly not separate from the divine essence.

(By the same reasoning, the Father and Son would also proceed from themselves. The typical Eastern approach to

Triadology avoids this problem by starting with Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, and considering that the unique divine essence is the content of these Three, rather than that the Three “proceed” from the Essence).

Filioque was originally proposed in order to stress more clearly the connection between the Son and the Spirit, amid heresy in which the Son was taken as less than the Father because He does not serve as a source of the Holy Spirit. The origins of the filioque in the west are to be found in the writing of certain church fathers in the west and especially in the anti-Arian situation of 7th century Spain. In this context, the filioque was a means to affirm the full divinity of both the Spirit and the Son.

Apollinarianism

Apollinarianism was the heresy taught by Apollinaris the Younger, bishop of Laodicea in Syria about 361. he taught that the Logos of God, which became the divine nature of Christ, took the place of the rational human soul of Jesus and that the body of Christ was a glorified form of human nature. In other words, though Jesus was a man, He did not have a human mind but that the mind of Christ was solely divine. Apollinaris taught that the two natures of Christ could not coexist within one person. His solution was to lessen the human nature of Christ.

Apollinarianism was condemned by the Second General Council at Constantinople in 381. This heresy

denies the true and complete humanity in the person of Jesus which in turn, can jeopardize the value of the atonement since Jesus is declared to be both God and man to atone. He needed to be God to offer a pure and holy sacrifice of sufficient value and He needed to be a man in order to die for men.

Jesus is completely both God and man. This is known as the Hypostatic Union.

“In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God...and the Word became flesh and dwelt among us...” (John 1:1, 14).

“For in Him dwells all the fullness of deity in bodily form,” (Col. 2:9).