Chapter 4 of 13
The Trinity and Heresy
There are two primary heresies from which the Trinity is to be distinguished: modalism and tritheism. The heresy of modalism, also called sabellianism, it denies there are three distinct eternal persons in the Godhead. It believes that the so-called “persons” of the Trinity are modes of God’s substance, not distinct persons. Like water with its three states (liquid, solid, and gaseous), the Trinity is said to be only three different modes of the same essence. Unlike modalists, trinitarians believe there are three distinct persons (not just modes) in the one substance of God.
Both Islam and Christianity proclaim that God is one in essence. What is in dispute is whether there can be any plurality of persons in the unity of nature. The inadequacies in the Muslim's view of God arise in part out of their misunderstanding of Christian monotheism. Many Muslims misconstrue the Christian view of God as tritheism rather than as monotheism.
Polytheism
Polytheism is the world view that many finite gods exist in the world. In history many forms of polytheism have existed. In some forms, all gods are more or less equal. Each has a personal sphere of domain. In others, the gods form a hierarchy. In Hinduism, polytheism and pantheism go hand-in-hand with one impersonal Brahman and 330 million-plus personal manifestations of the one impersonal ultimate reality.
According to scripture monotheism existed at the beginning of the human race as revealed in the creation of Adam and Eve. Polytheism is a diversion form original revelation concerning the existence and nature of God.
Deism
Deism is the belief in a God who made the world but who never interrupts its operations with supernatural acts. It is theism minus miracles. God does not interfere with His creation. Rather, He designed it to run independent of Him by immutable natural laws. In nature, He has also provided all that His creatures need to live.
Deism flourished in Europe, especially France and England, and in late eighteenth century America. Some of the notable American deists were Benjamin Franklin (1706 – 1790), Thomas Jefferson (1743 – 1826), and Thomas Paine (1737 – 1809). There are various kinds of deists. All deists agree that there is one God, who created the world. All deists agree that God does not intervene in the world through supernatural acts. God is an absolute unity, not a trinity. God is only one person, not three persons. Deists contend that God is one in nature and one in person.
Panentheism
Panentheism is not to be confused with pantheism. Pantheism literally means all (pan) is God (theism), but panentheism means all in God. It is also called process theology (since it views God as a changing Being), bipolar theism (since it views all that actually is a gigantic organism), and neo classical theism (because it believes God is finite and temporal, in contrast to classical theism).
Rather than viewing God as the infinite, unchanging sovereign Creator of the world who brought it into existence, Panentheists think of God as a finite, changing, director of the world affairs who works in cooperation with the world in order to achieve greater perfection in His nature.
Theism views God's relation to the world as a painter to a painting. The painter exists independently of the painting; he brought the painting into existence, and yet his mind is expressed in the painting. By contrast, the Panentheist views God's relation to the world the way a mind is related to a body. Indeed, they believe the world is God's body (one pole) and the mind is the other pole. This is why the term bipolar is used. Panentheists believe God is dependent on the world. Yet there is a reciprocal dependency, a sense in which the world is dependent on God.
Variations on Panentheism
All Panentheists agree that God has two poles, an actual pole (the world) and a potential pole (beyond the world). All agree that God is changing, finite, and temporal in His actual pole. And all agree that His potential pole is unchanging and eternal.
Miracles
An implication of Panentheism is that supernatural acts are impossible. Since the world is the body of God there is nothing apart from God that can be broken into or interrupted. Indeed, God is a passive recipient of His creature's activity rather than an active force in the world.
Human Beings
Panentheists agree that humanity is personal and free. In fact, humanity as a whole is a co-creator with God and of God. He not only helps decide the course of human and world events but also those of God. The human being is partially creating himself or herself in every decision and act each moment. The goal is to serve God by contributing value to His ever growing experience.
Human Destiny
The destiny of humanity is not to be looked for in an actual heaven or hell or conscious afterlife. Rather, human beings, like all of god's creatures, will live forever only in God's cosmic memory. A person, who contributes richly to God's life, will have the satisfaction of knowing that God will fondly remember him or her forever. Those who live without contributing much value to God, who in other words, live unfaithfully, will not be remembered with much fondness by God.
Pantheism
Pantheism means all (pan) is God (theism). It is the world view held by most Hindus, many Buddhists, and other New Age religions. It is also the world view of Christian Science, and Scientology. According to Pantheism, God is
all in all. God pervades all things, contains all things, subsumes all things, and is found in all things. Nothing exists apart from God, and all things are in some way identified with God. The world is God, and God is the world. But more precisely, in Pantheism all is God, and God is all.
Pantheism has a long history in both the east and the west. From the eastern mysticism of Hindu sages and seers to the rationalism of such Western philosophers as Parmenides, Benedict Spinoza, and G.W.F Hegel, Pantheism has always had advocates.
Kinds of Pantheism
There are different types of belief within Pantheism. An absolute Pantheism is represented by the thought of the fifth century B.C. Greek philosopher Parmenides and the Vedanta School of Hinduism. Absolute Pantheism teaches that there is only one being in the world, God, and that all else that appears to exist actually does not. Another type is emanational Pantheism, which was set forth by the third century A.D. Philosopher, Plotinus. According to this view, everything flows from God in the same way a flower unfolds from a seed. There is also the developmental Pantheism of Hegel (1720 – 1831). Hegel viewed the events of history as the unfolding manifestations of Absolute spirit. The modal Pantheism of the seventeenth-century rationalist Spinoza argued that there is only one absolute substance in which all finite things are merely modes or moments. The multi-level Pantheism is found in some forms of Hinduism. This view sees various levels of manifesting God as the Absolute one, and lower levels showing Him in increasing multiplicity.
Basic Beliefs
All Pantheists believe that God and the real world are one, but they differ as to how God and the world are united.
Nature of God
God and reality are ultimately impersonal. Personality, consciousness, and intellect are characteristics of lower manifestations of God, but they are not to b confused with God in His being. In God there is the absolute simplicity of one. There are no parts. Multiplicity may flow from it, but in and out of itself it is simple, not multiple.
The universe was created ex deo, (“out of God”) not ex nihilo, (“out of nothing”). There is only one “Being” or existence in the universe; everything else is an emanation or manifestation of it. Absolute Pantheists hold that the universe is not even a manifestation. We are all simply part of an elaborate illusion. Creation simply does not exist. God exists. Nothing else.
In contrast to theists, who view God as beyond and separate from the universe, Pantheists believe that God and the universe are one.
Human Beings
Pantheists either believe that the human as a distinct being is absolutely unreal (absolute Pantheism) or else that humanity is real but far less real than God. The primary teaching of absolute Pantheism is that humans must overcome their ignorance and realize that they are God. Those who put a distance between God and humanity teach a dualistic view of the person – a body and a soul. The body holds the human down, keeping him or her from uniting with
God. So each must purge his or her body so the soul can be released to attain oneness with the absolute one. For all Pantheists, the chief goal or end of humanity is to unite with God.
Ethics
Pantheists usually strive to live moral lives and to encourage others to do. However, moral teachings usually apply to a lower level of spiritual attainment. Once a person has achieved union with God, he has no further concern with moral lives. Non-attachment or utter unconcern for one's actions and their results are often taught as a prerequisite to achieving oneness with God. Since God is beyond good and evil, the person must transcend them to reach God. Morality is stressed as only a temporary concern, and underlying this is no absolute basis for right or wrong. All good and all evil is relative to the individual point of growth. But, in the highest sense, there can be neither good nor evil. Thus, for the Pantheists, ethical conduct is a means, not an end in itself. It is used only to help one attain a higher level of spirituality. Ultimately, reality is neither good nor evil. As Prabhavananda puts it, “If we say, 'I am good' or 'I am bad,' we are only talking to the language of Maya (the world of illusion). “I am Brahman,” is the only true statement regarding ourselves that any of us can make.
Pantheism teaches that only God is absolute and necessary. Anything and everything else must be less than absolute and be utterly dependent upon God, unless God exists, nothing else could exist.
Absolute pantheism is self-defeating. The absolute pantheism claims “I am God.” But God is the changeless Absolute. However, humanity goes through a process of change called enlightenment because He has this awareness.
No how could people be God when people change but God does not.
Pantheists attempt to escape this criticism by allowing some reality to humanity, whether it be emanational, modal, or manifestational. But if we are really only modes of God, then why are we oblivious to it. H.P. Owen describes this as a “metaphysical amnesia” that pervades all our lives. If we are being deceived about the consciousness of our own individual existence, how do we know that the pantheist is not also being deceived in claiming to be conscious of reality as ultimately one.
In fact, if the world is an illusion, how can we distinguish between reality and fantasy at all? Lao-tse puts the question well: “If, when I was asleep, I was a man dreaming I was a butterfly, how do I know when I am awake I am not a butterfly dreaming I am a man?” (Guenness 14). if what we continually perceive to be real is not, how could we ever distinguish between reality and fantasy? Maybe when we cross a busy street, with three lanes of traffic coming toward us, we should not worry, for it's all an illusion anyway. Indeed, should we even look when crossing the street if we, the traffic, and the street do not really exist? If pantheists would live out their pantheism consistently, there would be no pantheists left.
Self-refuting Nature of Pantheism
Pantheism is self-refuting, at least all forms that claim individuality is an illusion caused by my mind. For according to pantheism, individual minds are themselves aspects of the illusion and can therefore provide no basis for explaining it. If the mind is the part of illusion, it cannot be the ground for explaining the illusion. Hence, if pantheism is true in asserting that my individuality is an illusion, then
pantheism is false, since there is then no basis for explaining the illusion. Pantheism also fails to handle the problem of evil in a satisfactory manner. To pronounce evil as an illusion or as less than real is not only frustrating and hollow to those experiencing evil, but it seems philosophically inadequate. If evil is not real, then what is the origin of the illusion? Why have people experienced it for so long, and why does it seem so real? Despite the pantheist's claim to the contrary, he or she also experiences pain, suffering, and eventually will die. Even pantheists double-over in pain when they get appendicitis. They jump out of the way of an on-coming truck so as not to get hurt.
If God is all, and all is God, as pantheists maintain, and then evil is all an allusion and ultimately there are no rights and wrongs. For there are four possibilities regarding good and evil.
- If God is all-good, then evil must exist apart from God. But this is impossible since God is all. Nothing can exist apart from it.
- If God is all-evil, then good must exist apart from God. This is not possible either, since God is all.
- God is both all-good and all-evil. This cannot be, for it is self-contradictory to affirm that the same being is both all good and all evil at the same time. Further, most pantheists agree that God is beyond good and evil. Therefore, God is neither good nor evil.
- Good and evil are illusory. They are not real categories.
Option four is what most pantheists believe. But if evil is only an illusion, then ultimately there is no such thing as good and evil thoughts or actions. Hence, what difference would it make whether we praise or curse, counsel or rape, love or murder someone? If there is no final moral difference between those actions, absolute moral responsibilities do not exist. Cruelty and non-cruelty are ultimately the same.
Pantheism's God also is unknowable. The very claim “God is unknowable” in an intellectual way seems either meaningless or self-defeating. For if the claim itself cannot be understood in an intellectual way, and then it is self-defeating. For what is being affirmed is that nothing can be understood about God in an intellectual way. But the pantheists expect us to intellectually know this truth that God cannot be understood in an intellectual way. In other words, the pantheist appears to be making a statement about God to the effect that no such statements can be made about God.