Chapter 1 of 13

Introduction

6 min read · Pages 5–9 of the printed edition

“Holy Trinity is Mystery;” “Holy Trinity is revealed” – these two statements, simple in their form, but awesome in their content are discussion-stoppers. As Mystery, Holy Trinity is a-logical, that is, beyond logic. It cannot be subjected to critical reasoning; it cannot be comprehended, it can only be contemplated. Holy Trinity is Christ’s radical revelation, His supreme gift to His Church. In Church teaching, it is Dogma, not to be questioned, but accepted on Faith and avowed in worship and praise.

The two thousand years of Church history, however, tells a different story. Human nature being what it is, its insatiable curiosity; its tendency to question the unquestionable; its quest for understanding; its pursuit of the unknown cannot be stifled. Even the revealed Truth of Holy Trinity is susceptible to critical examination. A great theologian like St. Augustine himself continued for a long time, his effort to unravel the Mystery. There is a charming little tale about this fourth century Bishop of Hippo: One day, while walking on the beach, lost in thought, he had a kind of epiphany. He came across a little boy carrying water in a shell from the ocean. “What are you doing?” enquired the great man. “ I am trying to empty the ocean into that hole in the sand,” quipped the cherubic child. “What foolishness! You can’t do that. You cannot empty an ocean into a little hole in the sand,” blurted the Bishop.“ Well… it is easier than what you are trying to do,” said the child calmly and disappeared.

Scores of books that line library shelves are proof positive that the words “Mystery” and “Revealed” have not quite managed to stop all discussions on Mystery and Revelation. “Of making of books there is no end, and much study is a weariness of the flesh.” Says Ecc.12:12. In the last two thousand years, serious theologians and curious critics have produced weighty volumes on the subject of Holy Trinity and caused much ‘weariness of the flesh’ to themselves and considerable anguish to their readers. Most of those books were records of the historic struggles of the early Church in defining Revelation into Dogma. My own little home library has taken on an appearance of erudition with a few of those heavy tomes. They will, however, be mostly relegated henceforth, to gathering dust in the shelf while a nifty little volume supercedes them in practical use. This booklet is unique in its category. This is probably the smallest volume ever written on a profound subject as the Holy Trinity.

Dr. Sunny Ezhumattoor did a great service to those who are prone to bouts of ‘weariness of the flesh’. There are Christians who long for clear understanding of what they believe without getting lost in the “foggy bottom” of theological incomprehension. This book provides sufficient help to such people. The author has fully realized, it seems, that in dealing with the question of the Mystery of the Triune God, no light is available and no light is adequate except the light of the Gospel.

This book is unique in its class because it is a manual for Christian seekers of enlightenment on the essentials of their Faith. Its brevity does not sacrifice completeness. Points of Faith are stated briefly and succinctly with support from the Scripture and Scriptural scholars. It describes major heresies and errors - pitfalls that early Christians suffered for lack of proper understanding. The author has traced a secure path with enough caveats posted on the way lest the reader is

drawn into such Trinitarian errors like Modalism, Tritheism, Arianism etc.

Some scholar has wisely remarked that the essential difference between religions is the way they look at God. There is the intriguing question of how the two major religious groups in India, namely, Hindus and Muslims view God. How are they different from our concept of the Triune God! The quest to know the answer is not reprehensible. Dr. Ezhumattor has paid considerable attention to this pivotal question.

The concept of a Triune God is abhorrent to Islam. To most Muslims Jesus as the Son of God is a monstrosity. The idea of God begetting a son is unacceptable to them. They cannot think, it seems, beyond the biological image of a father-son relationship. They can be answered only by showing the authenticity of Christ’s revelation and the trustworthiness of the revealer. Raymundo Panikkar states in his “The Unknown Christ of Hinduism”, “within the Christian tradition, Christ is incomprehensible without the Trinity. A Non-Trinitarian God cannot become incarnate. A Non-Trinitarian Christ cannot be totally human and totally divine.”

The author of this book provides a very useful comparison between Christianity and Hinduism. The Hindu concept of the triads in its mythology and philosophy has prepared the Hindu Mind to be more susceptible to the Christian Trinity than the rigidly monotheistic teachings of Judaism and Islam. But we should be on our guard not to make facile comparison between the Trinity and the Hindu Trimurti. The similarity does not go beyond the mystical number Three. The Hindu Trimurti is radically different from the Christian Trinity. Trimurti, when represented as for instance, at Elephanta Caves near Bombay (Mumbai), is one body with three heads. The symbol of Trimurti is the mystical letter OM, wherein O is equivalent to A and U. A means Brahma, U means Vishnu and M stands for Shiva.

“Eka murti trayo devah” as stated in Harivamsa(V,10,662) is often erroneously translated as “One God and three Persons”. The proper translation should be “one image and three gods”. The Hindu concept of God that comes close to the Holy Trinity is the Upanishadic Saccidananda. But Saccidanada is “Nirguna Brahman”, an impersonal God, the God of the Philosophers whom Pascal passed over in favor of the God of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob, a God who relates Himself to His people, a God who loved the world so much that He sent His only Begotten Son to redeem it.

The late German theologian, Karl Rahner(1904-1984) pointed out that most Christians in the West, thanks to their ignorance of the Mystery of the Holy Trinity and also may be due to their conditioning to seek rational proof in everything, have become practical Modalists who believe that the three Persons are three forms of one God. Paul Tillich calls this phenomenon ‘the loss of the dimension of depth’. The ‘dimension depth’ has been replaced by life in the horizontal dimension, a process accelerated by the driving forces of an industrial society.

The loss of the dimension of depth or the loss of the meaning of life caused quite an exodus from the West to the East in the last part of the last century. Disgruntled youth went from Mystery to mythology, from Revealed Truths to a gallimaufry (hodge-podge) of primitive imagination. The problem with the Western Man is that he has to have everything reduced to the conclusion of a syllogism. He seeks rational proof for everything. Mystery is unfamiliar terrain and those who cultivate this terrain are rejected as superstitious. Martin Luther called reason “devil’s bride.” In C.S. Lewis’ “Screwtape Letters”, Screwtape, the senior devil tells his nephew Wormwood (the junior devil in training) to make everything look reasonable.

The only way reason can be employed in explaining the Mystery of the Holy Trinity is to show that the revelation is authentic because the Revealer is trustworthy. This is what

Dr. Ezhumattoor, a versatile thinker and an accomplished scholar, does in this valuable little book on the Mystery of Holy Trinity.

George Kampalat Houston, TX November 10, 2011