Chapter 10 of 13

Kenosis

10 min read · Pages 64–72 of the printed edition

The Kenotic Theology

Philippians 2:5-11 (Darby Translation)

“For let this mind be in you which was also in Christ Jesus; who, subsisting in the form of God, did not esteem it an object of rapine to be on an equality with God; but emptied himself, taking a bondman's form, taking his place in the likeness of men; and having been found in figure as a man, humbled Himself, becoming obedient even unto death, and that the death of the cross.”

The term Kenosis comes from the Greek word kenoo, translated “emptied” in Philippians 2:6-7.

Many speakers wrongly teach that Jesus emptied Himself of His divinity or His deity or that He abandoned a sovereign position. It has also been said, “when He left heaven and came to this earth, He gave up the voluntary use of His divine attributes.” Some say Jesus restricted the use of these divine attributes when He took the form of man.

Jesus clearly taught, and the rest of Holy Scriptures confirm, that He is Son of God and Son of Man. (Matthew 16:13-17). In the Creed of Chalcedon the early fathers rightly affirmed that Christ must be acknowledged in two

natures, without any commingling, or change, or division or separation.

Certain statements by or about Christ are true only if ascribed to the appropriate nature. For example, because Christ is God He could say “you are of this world, I am not of this world” (John 8:23). This statement is not true of Christ's human nature. If we err in ascribing statements to His human nature, we are doing the same thing as did the doceticists, that Christ was only a spirit. On the other hand, because Christ is man, He says concerning His second coming, “But of that day and hour no one knows, not even the angels of heaven, nor the Son, but the Father alone” (Matthew 24:36). This statement is not trued of Christ's divine nature. If we ascribe this statement to His divine nature, we would conclude that as God, He did not know when He would return. He would not be omniscient, He would be less than God, and thus, not God at all, as the Arians argued.

The Kenotic Theology

Most kenoticists believe that Christ gave up His sovereign dominion when becoming incarnate. They follow the same logic as the Arians. Other kenoticists believe that Christ continued being sovereign while on earth, but that His divine and human natures were not truly united into one person. This could be classified as neo-Nestorian. Most kenoticists thus either diminish the deity of Christ or they undermine the union of the two natures in one person.

Referring to the kenosis in Philippians 2:5-7, John Calvin writes, “In order to exhort us to submission by His example, He shows that when, as God, He might have displayed to the world the brightness of His glory, He gave up His right, and voluntarily emptied Himself; that He assumed the form of a servant, and contented with that humble condition, suffered His divinity to be concealed under a veil of flesh.”

The veil of flesh is an illusion to Hebrews 10:19-20. Neither Christ's divinity, nor His divine attributes, nor the use of those attributes, nor His glory, was in any way emptied. Rather, these were concealed under a veil of flesh. Condescension means a voluntary descent from one's rank or dignity in relations with an inferior. The verb condescend means to descend to a less formal or dignified level. It is used of the willingness of God the Son to assume the nature of man. Philippians 2:6 presents the fact of His condescension.

Nestorianism

Nestorianism is the Christian doctrine that Jesus existed as two persons, the man Jesus and the divine Son of God, or logos, rather than as a unified person. This doctrine is identified with Nestorius 386-451 AD, Patriarch of Constantinople. This view of Christ was condemned at the council of Ephesus in 431, and the conflict over this view led to the Nestorian schism, separating the Assyrian Church of the east from the Byzantine Church.

The Arian Controversy

Arius was born around 256 in Lybia. This teaching is attributed to Arius (AD 250-336), a Christian Presbyter from Alexandria Egypt, concerning the relationship of the entities of the Trinity. The Arian concept of Christ is that the Son of God did not always exist, but was created by – and is therefore distinct and inferior to God the Father.

A Summary of Arius's Claims

  1. God is solitary, the Father unique.
  2. The Son had an origin ex nihilo (out of nothing). There was a time when he did not exist. He was created, existing by the will of God. Before he was created, he did not exist. (The logic here is that since everything created came into being out of non existence, and the word of God is a creature, so the word of God also came into being out of non existence. Thus, God was not always Father, for before He created the son, He was solitary).
  3. God made a person (word, spirit, son) when He wanted to create. In short, He created by an intermediary.
  4. The word has a changeable nature, and He remains good by exercising His free will only so long as He chooses.
  5. The ousiai (substances or beings) of the Father, the Son, and the Spirit are divided and differ from one another. The father is the son's origin, and the son's God. There are two wisdoms, one that existed eternally with God, the other the son who was brought into existence in this wisdom.

Thus, there is another word of God besides the son, and it is because the son shares in this that he is called, by grace, word and son.

Early Arianism – Main Tenets

  1. God was not always Father, for there was not always a son. Prior to the son, God was simply God. (Athanasius refers to the early Arian's habit of confronting a man in the street and asking him if he was a father before the birth of his son, following

with the clinching point that neither was God always Father. Here we see their assumption that divine substance and generation were to be understood in a material sense, according to the analogy of human fatherhood and generation).

  1. The son or Logos is a creature, made out of non existence.
  2. The son is variable – changeable – by nature, and is stable by the gift of God.
  3. The son's knowledge of God and of himself is imperfect.
  4. The son was created by God as an instrument by which He created the world.
  5. The Trinity, such as it is, is of unlike hypostates. Any unity is purely moral, not ontological, dependent on will, not essence.

The Arians wanted to protect God from involvement in creation, from human experiences and suffering. Jesus' human limitations showed that he was inferior to God, so He should not be worshiped. In the incarnation, the son took a human body, but not a human soul or mind (this had not been a matter of consideration hitherto and was not to arouse opposition until later in the century, when Apollianarius propounded it as a major theme and was condemned as a heretic at the council of Constantinople in 381 A.D.).

Arians wanted a God who could suffer, but at the same time, it was inconceivable to them that the one God, the Father, could Himself suffer. Revelation and redemption had to be by one less than fully divine, since God could not come into contact with the creation without either deifying it or destroying it. They held to a nature-grace dualism, like Gnosticism, which kept God at a distance from any contact with the material creation.

Thus, they needed a god of lesser status than the Father, one less than fully divine.

Docetism

In Christianity, Docetism is the belief that Jesus' physical body was an illusion, as was his crucifixion; that is, Jesus only seemed to have a physical body and to physically die, but in reality he was incorporeal, a pure spirit, and hence could not physically die. This belief has historically been regarded as heretical by most Christian theologians.

This belief is most commonly attributed to the Gnostics, who believed that matter was evil, and hence that God would not take on a material body. Docetism could be further explained as the view that, because the human body is temporary and the spirit is eternal, the body of Jesus, therefore, must have been an illusion and his crucifixion as well. It could be compared to the philosophies of Hinduism and Buddhism, when they speak about illusion. Illusion is everything that is temporary, not everything that is real. When someone says that the human body is temporary, it has a tendency to undermine the importance of the belief in resurrection of the dead and the goodness of created matter, and is in opposition to the Christian view.

Islam also teaches that Jesus' crucifixion was an illusion.

Monarchianism

Monarchianism (mono - “one”; arche - “rule”) was an error concerning the nature of God that developed in the second century AD. It arose as an attempt to maintain monotheism and refute tritheism. Unfortunately, it also contradicts the orthodox doctrine of the Trinity. Monarchians were divided into two groups, the Adoptionists or dynamic monarchians, and the Patripassians, or modalistic monarchians.

The adoptionists taught that Christ, although of miraculous birth, was a mere man until His baptism when the Holy Spirit made Him the Son of God by adoption. This doctrine was taught by Paul of Samosata, at one time bishop of Antioch. In the Dake Bible, the first note in the New Testament the author writes similar views like the adoptionists. Patripassians believed in the divinity of Christ, but regarded the Trinity as three manifestations, or modes, of a single being. They taught that the Father had come to earth and suffered and died under the appearance of the Son; hence their name (Latin Pater; Patris - “father”; Passus - “to suffer”). This doctrine was taught by the Roman Christian Prelate Sebellius and sometimes referred to as Sebellianism. Dynamic monarchianism teaches that God is the father and that Jesus is only a man, denied the personal subsistence of the logos and taught that the Holy Spirit was a force of presence of God the Father. Present day groups in this category are the Jehovah's witnesses, Christadelphians, and Unitarians.

In its most general sense, Monarchianism (also called Patripassianism or Sebellianism), refers to the primarily western attempts in the third century to defend monotheism against suspected tritheism by denying the personal distinctiveness of a divine Son and Holy Spirit in contrast to God the Father.

Modal monarchianism teaches that the Father, the Son, the Holy Spirit, are just modes of the single person who is God. In other words, the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit are not simultaneous and distinct persons, but consecutive modes of one person. Modern groups in this general category are the oneness Pentecostal groups known as the United

Pentecostal and United Apostolic Churches. However, the present day modalists maintain that God's name is Jesus. They also require baptism “in Jesus' name” not in the name of the “Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit” for salvation.

Sebellianism

Sebellianism, also known as modalism, is the belief that the Father, Son and Holy Spirit are different modes or aspects of one God, rather than three distinct persons. Sebellius taught this form of doctrine in Rome in the third century.

Monophysitism

Monophysitism (from the Greek monos meaning “one, alone” and physis meaning “nature”) is the christological position that Christ has only one nature, as opposed to the chalcedonian position which holds that Christ has two natures, one divine and one human. There are two major doctrines that can indisputably be called monophysite.

  1. Eutychianism holds that the human nature of Christ was essentially obliterated by the Divine, “dissolved like a drop of honey in the sea.”
  2. Appolinarianism holds that He had a human body and human “living principle” but that the Divine Logos had taken the place of the nous, or “thinking principle”, analogous but not identical to what might be called a mind in the present day. Appollinarianism was condemned by the second council at Constantinople in 381. He was an Arian who denied the human nature of Christ. He taught that Jesus did not have a human soul, but that the Logos became one with the flesh in Mary's

womb and functioned as His soul. This heresy denies the true and complete humanity in the person of Jesus. Apollinarius of Laodecea died in 390 AD in Syria.

Miaphysitism

Miaphysitism is the christology of the Oriental Orthodox Churches. It has often been considered by Chalcedonian Christians to be a form of monophysitism, but the oriental orthodox churches themselves reject this characterization, a position which the Eastern Orthodox and Roman Catholic Churches have begun to take more seriously. Miaphysitism holds that in the one person of Jesus Christ, the nature of Divinity and the nature of Humanity are united in one “nature” (physis), the two being united without separation, without confusion, and without alteration. It evolved as a reponse to Nestorianism.

The churches of the Oriental Orthodox Churches, while sometimes called monophysite, vehemently reject the label. These include the Armenian Apostolic Church, the Syrian Orthodox Church, the Indian Orthodox Chruch, the Coptic Orthodox Church, the Ethiopian Orthodox Tewahdo Church and the Eritrean Orthodox Church.

The decision at Chalcedon (451) remains the official teaching of the Eastern Orthodox Church, the Roman Catholic Church and traditional Protestants. The anti-chalcedonian churches are usually grouped together as Oriental Orthodox.