Chapter 13 of 14
The Science of Biblical Interpretation
Biblical hermeneutics and the difference between exegesis and eisegesis
“Biblical hermeneutics is perhaps summarized best by 2 Timothy 2:15, "Strive diligently to present thyself approved to God, a workman that has not to be ashamed, cutting in a straight line the word of truth" (JND version). Biblical hermeneutics is the science of knowing how to properly interpret the various types of literature found in the Bible. For example, a psalm should often be interpreted differently than a prophecy. A proverb should be understood and applied differently from a law. This is the purpose of biblical hermeneutics - to help us to know how to interpret, understand, and apply the Bible.
The most important law of biblical hermeneutics is that the Bible should be interpreted literally. Literal Bible interpretation means you understand the Bible in its normal/plain meaning. The Bible says what it means and means what it says. Many make the mistake of trying to read between the lines and come up with meanings for Scriptures that are not truly in the text. Yes, of course, there are some spiritual truths behind the plain meanings of Scripture. That does not mean that every Scripture has a hidden spiritual truth, or that it should be our goal to find all such spiritual truths. Biblical hermeneutics keeps us faithful to the intended meaning of Scripture and away from allegorizing and symbolizing Bible verses and passages that should be understood literally.
A second crucial law of biblical hermeneutics is that a verse or passage must be interpreted historically, grammatically, and contextually. Historical interpretation refers to understanding the culture, background, and situation which prompted the text. Grammatical interpretation is recognizing the rules of grammar and nuances of the Hebrew and Greek languages and applying those principles to the understanding of a passage. Contextual interpretation involves always taking the surrounding context of a verse/passage into consideration when trying to determine the meaning.
Some mistakenly view biblical hermeneutics as limiting our ability to learn new truths from God's Word or stifling the Holy Spirit's ability to reveal to us the meaning of God's Word. This is not the case. The goal of biblical hermeneutics is to point us to the correct interpretation which the Holy Spirit has already inspired into the text. The purpose of biblical hermeneutics is to protect us from improperly applying a Scripture to a particular situation. Biblical hermeneutics points us to the true meaning and application of Scripture. Hebrews 4:12 declares, "For the word of God is living and active. Sharper than any double-edged sword, it penetrates even to dividing soul and spirit, joints and marrow; it judges the thoughts and attitudes of the heart." Biblical hermeneutics is keeping the sword sharp!
As an illustration of the use of hermeneutics, consider the famous commandment, "Thou shalt not kill." That seems very straightforward and easy to understand. But we soon run into textual difficulties when we discover that the same God who delivered this commandment instructs his people, just a few pages later, to enter the Promised Land and kill all the Canaanites. If we consider the word "kill" used in the commandments to be the same word used in the instructions to kill Canaanites, we deduce a God who is either fickle or schizophrenic. To retain a consistent view of God we have to look at the context of the two commands. And when we do so, we discover that one is given within the framework of a social contract dealing with neighbors, family, and community (the Ten Commandments). The other order is issued within the context of national war and political conquest (the command to take the land promised to Abraham).
So perhaps it would be best to translate the commandment, "Thou shalt not murder," which has a slightly different meaning. If a contemporary soldier, one who wishes to live his or her life according to the Ten Commandments, goes into battle with the idea that killing the enemy involves breaking one of those commandments, he or she might never pull a trigger. Soldiers are, after all, trained to kill. But they are not trained to murder. And that is the difference.
Question: "What is the difference between exegesis and eisegesis?"
Answer: Exegesis and eisegesis are two conflicting approaches in Bible study. Exegesis is the exposition or explanation of a text based on a careful, objective analysis. The word exegesis literally means “to lead out of.” That means that the interpreter is led to his conclusions by following the text.
The opposite approach to Scripture is eisegesis, which is the interpretation of a passage based on a subjective, non-analytical reading. The word eisegesis literally means “to lead into,” which means the interpreter injects his own ideas into the text, making it mean whatever he wants.
Obviously, only exegesis does justice to the text. Eisegesis is a mishandling of the text and often leads to a misinterpretation. Exegesis is concerned with discovering the true meaning of the text, respecting its grammar, syntax, and setting. Eisegesis is concerned only with making a point, even at the expense of the meaning of words.
Second Timothy 2:15 commands us to use exegetical methods: “Present yourself to God as one approved, a workman who does not need to be ashamed and who correctly handles the word of truth.” An honest student of the Bible will be an exegete, allowing the text to speak for itself. Eisegesis easily lends itself to error, as the would-be interpreter attempts to align the text with his own preconceived notions. Exegesis allows us to agree with the Bible; eisegesis seeks to force the Bible to agree with us.
The process of exegesis involves 1) observation: what does the passage say? 2) interpretation: what does the passage mean? 3) correlation: how does the passage relate to the rest of the Bible? and 4) application: how should this passage affect my life?
Eisegesis, on the other hand, involves 1) imagination: what idea do I want to present? 2) exploration: what Scripture passage seems to fit with my idea? and 3)
application: what does my idea mean? Notice that, in eisegesis, there is no examination of the words of the text or their relationship to each other, no cross-referencing with related passages, and no real desire to understand the actual meaning. Scripture serves only as a prop to the interpreter’s idea.
To illustrate, let’s use both approaches in the treatment of one passage:
2 Chronicles 27:1-2
“Jotham was twenty-five years old when he became king, and he reigned in Jerusalem sixteen years. . . . He did what was right in the eyes of the LORD, just as his father Uzziah had done, but unlike him he did not enter the temple of the LORD.”
EISEGESIS
First, the interpreter decides on a topic. Today, it’s “The Importance of Church Attendance.” The interpreter reads 2 Chronicles 27:1-2 and sees that King Jotham was a good king, just like his father Uzziah had been, except for one thing: he didn’t go to the temple! This passage seems to fit his idea, so he uses it. The resulting sermon deals with the need for passing on godly values from one generation to the next. Just because King Uzziah went to the temple every week didn’t mean that his son would continue the practice. In the same way, many young people today tragically turn from their parents’ training, and church attendance drops off. The sermon ends with a question: “How many blessings did Jotham fail to receive, simply because he neglected church?”
Certainly, there is nothing wrong with preaching about church attendance or the transmission of values. And a cursory reading of 2 Chronicles 27:1-2 seems to support that passage as an apt illustration. However, the above interpretation is totally wrong. For Jotham not to go to the temple was not wrong; in fact, it was very good, as the proper approach to the passage will show.
EXEGESIS
First, the interpreter reads the passage and, to fully understand the context, he reads the histories of both Uzziah and Jotham (2 Chronicles 26-27; 2 Kings 15:1-6, 32-38). In his observation, he discovers that King Uzziah was a good king who nevertheless disobeyed the Lord when he went to the temple and offered incense on the altar—something only a priest had the right to do (2 Chronicles 26:16-20). Uzziah’s pride and his contamination of the temple resulted in his having “leprosy until the day he died” (2 Chronicles 26:21).
Needing to know why Uzziah spent the rest of his life in isolation, the interpreter studies Leviticus 13:46 and does some research on leprosy. Then he compares the use of illness as a punishment in other passages, such as 2 Kings 5:27; 2 Chronicles 16:12; and 21:12-15.
By this time, the exegete understands something important: when the passage says Jotham “did not enter the temple of the LORD,” it means he did not did not repeat his father’s mistake. Uzziah had proudly usurped the priest’s office; Jotham was more obedient.
The resulting sermon might deal with the Lord’s discipline of His children, with the blessing of total obedience, or with our need to learn from the mistakes of the past rather than repeat them.
Of course, exegesis takes more time than eisegesis. But if we are to be those unashamed workmen “who correctly handle the word of truth,” then we must take the time to truly understand the text. Exegesis is the only way.”
It is very interesting to note the account of John MacArthur Jr. about Pentecostal hermeneutics. "I watched, in horror, a couple of years ago, as a guest on a Charismatic television network explained the biblical basis of his ministry of “possibility thinking.” “My ministry is based entirely on my life verse, Matthew 19:26, ‘With God all things are possible.’ God gave me that verse because I was born in 1926.”
Obviously intrigued by that method of obtaining a life verse, the talk show host grabbed a Bible and began thumbing through excitedly. “I was born in 1934,” he said. “My life verse would be Matthew 19:34. What does it say?” Then he discovered that Matthew 19 has only thirty verses. Undeterred, he flipped to Luke 19 and read verse 34, which read, "And they said, the Lord has need of him." Thrilled, he exclaimed, “Oh, the Lord has need of me! The Lord has need of me! What a wonderful life verse! I have never had a life verse before, but now the Lord has given me one; thank you Jesus! Hallelujah!” The studio audience began to applaud. At that moment, however, the talk show host’s wife, who had also turned to Luke 19, said, “Wait a minute! You can’t use this. This verse is talking about a donkey!” This incident shows the silly way some charismatics approach the scriptures. In addition, MacArthur states another story, which is very familiar in Kerala, and this writer has quoted many times before. A man was seeking divine guidance for a major decision, decided to close his eyes, open his Bible, put his finger down, and get guidance from whatever verse his finger happened to light on. His first try brought him to Matthew 27:5. "Judas went and hanged himself." Since this was not a good verse, he tried once again. This time, his finger landed on Luke 10:37. And Jesus’ words there were "Go and do likewise." He was persistent and tried one more time. This time, his finger came to rest on Jesus’ words in John 13:27. "What you do, do quickly." 6 The task of interpretation is to discover the meaning of the text in its proper setting; to draw the intended meaning rather than reading one’s presuppositions into it.
Inductive Bible Study
What is Inductive Bible Study
-by Tony Warren
Definition: in·duc·tive, in·duk'tiv, v.t. [L. induco, inductum.] out of; inducing principles; to introduce from; to initiate; logic: in inferring conclusions or principles from facts; the act of reasoning based on evidence in facts, to come to logical conclusions; the act of persuasion by inference from particulars; Diverse from deductive reasoning in that it doesn't begin with an hypothesis, but starts with specifics rather than premise.
To some degree, what you are told inductive Bible study means will depend upon which Theologian you are asking. But fundamentally, it is a term of logic that means interpreting scripture with no pre-judgment, from the text itself, through analyzing the evidence and drawing out of it logical conclusions. Biblical Induction literally means 'out of,' or introduced "from" the Bible. The Bible being the source of specifics from which general evidence (and thus doctrine) is derived.
Though not known by this title, this is how 'faithful' Christians have gleaned truth from scripture since Bible study began. For it is by God's use of repeated examples in scripture that He illustrates to His servants the true interpretation, that they may (by comparing scripture with scripture) come to sound conclusions based upon those received Biblical examples. By the Spirit, using inductive reasoning from the word, we both can and should come to consistently defensible and trustworthy interpretations. Though many Christians claim the Bible is totally perplexing, it is not the word that is so confusing, it is man who doesn't rightly divide, or righteously judge the word that he is reading. This is because of his own sinful nature that inevitably hardens his heart to distasteful or difficult doctrines, so that he won't understand them.
True inductive Bible study never starts with an hypothesis. And it has only one presupposition, which is:
'..the word of God alone is innerrant, authoritative over all ideas, and informative in faith, practice and doctrine. Thus it is the only qualified source of interpretation of scripture.'
It is no different from the historical Church rule that the ultimate authority and source of Biblical interpretation is Sola Scriptura. In simple terms, it is the study of scripture in true humility, from the unadulterated texts or testimony gleaned from Holy Canon alone. In this manner we uncover the proofs, examine the evidences, and use God given logic and reason wherein the scriptures will both reveal and interpret themselves.
Effective Bible study cannot begin with a supposition or conclusion from which we search the scriptures (backward) for evidence to support these preconceived views. It must begin with the evidence, which must then be followed meticulously to 'wherever' it leads. Far too many Theologians today are looking through scripture in order to justify what they already believe, rather than honestly looking to receive what scripture itself declares. This is the difference between "inductive" and "deductive" studies. Inductive Bible study is superior to deductive study in that (unlike deductive) there is no hypothesizing, supposition, or assuming, and no inference by reasoning from the general to the specific. Induction makes sound inferences from the specifics of scripture through the evidence of scripture. In other words, from the specific to the general. Or more Biblically succinct, 'from the facts of scripture, to the conclusion about scripture, via the collective evidence of scripture.'
Part of the logic and rationale in Biblical induction is to find specific consistent examples, and to use them as standards, the criteria, or evidences of law. For example, by Christ being revealed in scripture as the good Shepherd, we better understand sheep representing those He cares for. Or by poisonous serpents representing those of Satan, we better understand why God's servants are given power that serpents cannot harm them (Matthew 23:13; Luke 10:19; Mark 16). The understanding of these truths are all based upon Biblical induction, or the gleaning of general truths 'out of' the source for truth, which is the Bible. We are thus learning what is the true God breathed interpretation, by these repeated models or examples found in scripture.
The simple truth is, every man who professes to being a Christian, is not a true Christian. A true Christian will have the serious intention of doing the will of God, with a heart that 'receives' scripture honestly or nobly, rather than rationalizing it away that he may believe what "he wants."
The goal in inductive Bible study is to approach the scriptures with an earnestness that we not only read it, but are spiritually taught by it. Because if we are simply reading our preconceived ideas into scripture, or looking for justification of doctrines that we already hold, we are not seeking truth. We are merely seeking justification. True inductive reasoning in Bible study will eliminate this by having the starting point be one where the student confesses that, 'he knows nothing but the Biblical facts, and is willing to be taught out of those facts.' Then we can get a legitimate God breathed interpretation of scripture, rather than vainly reading our own personal beliefs into it.
Many Theologians claim that the Bible is not a book of logic, however I believe that the Bible is the most rational, logical book on the face of the earth. Not in man's definition of logic, science, or rational thinking, but in God's understanding of system, logic and rational thinking. What is foolishness to man is the wisdom of God and the wisdom of man is foolishness to God. To man the Bible is not truth, but foolishness. But indeed, how could a book be inspired and penned by so many different prophets, whose lives are separated by so many hundreds of years, where they have no knowledge of one another, and yet have every word and teaching be in total consistency with every other prophets' words and teachings. How could such a unique, ordered and congruous book be without logic or sound reasoning? It makes no sense. To come to such a conclusion would in itself be illogical and irrational. You could have two people of the same view speak one day apart and chances are they will end up contradicting each other in something, much less with written words over hundreds of years. Truly, the Bible testifies of itself that it is true.
Real logic and rational thinking is in understanding that if the Bible is the inspired and infallible word from the mind of God (a Christian given), then it can only be interpreted by the author, God. And this is the 'key' to understanding Canon, because the author is not man.
“For My thoughts are not your thoughts, Nor are your ways My ways,” says the Lord. “For as the heavens are higher that the earth, so are My ways higher than your ways, and My thoughts than your thoughts.” Isaiah 55:8-9 NKJV
Our thinking is not God's thinking, nor our interpretations God's interpretations. So although methods of inductive Bible study come in a variety of flavors and styles depending upon the Theologian, one thing remains constant. The most basic principle of inductive Bible Study is that the scripture alone is the source, harmonious, and inerrant. For the test of any sound exegesis is its order of invariables that bring about a consistent hermeneutic. All grounded in the only presupposition, which is that scripture alone is source and ultimate interpreter.
- Secular history (no matter how allegedly trustworthy) can neither define nor interpret scripture. Scripture in fact both defines and interprets history. Secular history and the presuppositions thereby, must be subordinate to scripture.
- The Bible (the inspired word of God) is the final arbiter for Christian doctrine, for reproof, for correction, and for instruction in righteousness. Man's ideas, whether scientific, historical, or archaeological, must in all areas be subject to the word of God.
- Rightly dividing the word means cutting or proportioning it correctly, taking things both in context, and by the examples shown in comparing scripture with scripture. It is by the use of Biblical precepts and models that we discern what God means by any given passage.
- Besides being its own interpreter, the Bible, compared with itself, can be used as its own dictionary. Words can be defined by searching through the scripture to see how God uses the same words in other passages. With prayer and supplication, and seeking wisdom and understanding, we can often set forth a word’s meaning by its use and context.
- The Holy Spirit is the true teacher of what scripture means, and by the Grace of God He works within us toward humility, and moves us to surrender to its authority. It is by this working that we 'receive' what God has inspirationally written, and are persuaded to look honestly at scripture.
- Our conclusions are induced only from the Biblical facts and evidences of what we find in scripture. Never by politics, culture, traditions, habit, nations, Church leaders, or other outside influences.
- There is often a deeper spiritual meaning to scripture underlying the literal, which is only discerned by a careful and measured exegesis. A thorough examination of like-examples, in context, is a good sound basis for coming to correct conclusions concerning spiritual with spiritual.
This is all done by the process of a sound inductive Bible Study. It is in this way that we (from the specific facts) interpret the scriptures righteously, and with sound judgment. In other words, rightly dividing, or cutting it justly/righteously.
Inductive and Deductive Bible Studies by Harvey Bluedorn
The labels inductive and deductive may be applied to several things, including methods of reasoning and methods of studying. A deductive approach moves from the rule to the example, and an inductive approach moves from the example to the rule.
I will first discuss deductive and inductive methods of reasoning (I have discussed these in greater detail elsewhere), then I will discuss deductive and inductive methods for studying.
The Deductive Method of Reasoning
The deductive method reasons from certain premises to a necessary conclusion. It is often described as reasoning from the general to the specific.
Premise: All men are mortal.
Premise: Socrates is a man.
Conclusion: Socrates is mortal.
If the premises are true, and the form is correct or valid, then the conclusion is necessarily true. However, if the form is invalid, then the conclusion is not necessarily true.
Some men are mortal.
Socrates is a man.
Therefore Socrates is mortal.
Though we may know that Socrates is mortal, nevertheless that does not logically flow from the premises of this argument. If we only know that some men are mortal, then Socrates might be among some men who are not mortal. The form of the argument is not valid.
The Inductive Method of Reasoning
The inductive method reasons in the opposite direction of the deductive method. It begins with specific observations and reasons to a generalization about the observations. It is often described as reasoning from the particulars to the general.
I have examined ten thousand dogs.
Every dog I have examined has fleas.
Therefore, all dogs have fleas.
The conclusion (really, a generalization) may possibly be true, there is no observation which contradicts the conclusion. However it is not necessarily true because there are still more observations which could be made.
If, indeed, I had examined all dogs (which, of course, nobody could possibly do), and all dogs examined had fleas, then I could conclude that all dogs do indeed have fleas. Based on my sample of dogs, it appears that all dogs have fleas. But the first dog I found which did not have fleas would contradict and therefore disprove my conclusion. So all that I actually know is that some dogs have fleas.
A Comparison of Inductive and Deductive Methods of Reasoning
The deductive method of reasoning moves toward necessary conclusions derived from correct connections between premises, which are all either given or assumed to be true.
The inductive method of reasoning moves toward possible conclusions derived from hypothetical connections between premises (observations), which are selected from among all possible true premises (observations).
Ideally, the deductive method of reasoning is objective in its conclusions (the conclusions are necessarily true), but subjective in its premises (the premises are assumed to be true).
Ideally, the inductive method of reasoning is subjective in its conclusions (the conclusions are not necessarily true), but objective in its premises (the premises are observed to be true).
Deductive and Inductive Reasoning Applied to the Bible
First of all, if we believe that all of the propositions of the Bible are absolutely true, then we must believe that if we arrive at deductive conclusions by connecting the propositions of the Bible in a formally valid way, then these deductive conclusions are absolutely true. Therefore, deduction from the Bible results in absolute certainty. Many doctrines are arrived at deductively from the Bible, and it is these deduced doctrines which are the most widely accepted doctrines among Christians simply because they are proven (at least to the satisfaction of many if not most persons) and cannot be refuted without rejecting the full authority of the Bible.
Secondly, if we selected certain propositions from the Bible and weaved them into a pattern which is not based on necessary connections (that is, they are formally valid), but rather the pattern is based on our conjectured connections (that is, what looks best to us), then we can place no certain confidence in our conjectured patterns. In other words, induction from the Bible does not result in any absolute certainty. Many theological or dogmatic systems for interpreting the Bible are arrived at inductively, and it is these induced systems which are the most divisive among Christians, creating various schools of theology and denominations, simply because different persons prefer different conjectures and are not willing to stay within the boundaries of what is provable.
Of course there are differences of opinion as to what actually is provable from the Bible, but this is not due to any defect in deductive reasoning. Rather, this may be compared to the proverb that computers actually don't make mistakes, it is the programmers or the operators who make the mistakes. Because the Bible does not (for the most part) come in the form of nicely formulated and completely unambiguous propositions, the element of interpretation is introduced, and this is where we humans often fail. In addition, we often fall into various fallacies and deceptive errors in reasoning which lead us in the wrong direction.
Some believe that we can prove the Bible is true with logic. This is an unbiblical rationalism which places the authority of reason above the Bible. In order to prove the Bible, we would need propositions of higher authority than the Bible which is impossible by definition. However, if given enough time, we could conceivably prove all non- Biblical systems of thought to be self-contradictory and therefore false. This would leave the Bible standing as the only example of something which has not yet been proven self-contradictory. Nevertheless, we cannot prove the negative. So the truth of the Bible must ultimately be revealed to the individual. The Bible is self-authenticating, but only for those who have been brought within the circle of faith.
Some believe that we cannot prove anything from the Bible. This is an unbiblical irrationalism which denies that reason can be applied to the Bible. Instead, we must add experience and guesswork and take some leaps into uncertainty by faith.
We believe that the correct role of reasoning acts or serves as our servant to help us to understand the Bible. The place of logic is in submission as a servant to the Word of God.
Methods of Reasoning Compared to Methods of Studying
A method is a regular way or manner of proceeding with or of accomplishing something. We must make a distinction between a method of reasoning to conclusions, and a method for studying a book or a subject.
For example, consider the inductive and deductive methods for studying a language:
Deductive language learning involves memorizing the various parts and categories of a foreign language and learning how to fit it all together and use it. In other words, it begins with certain accepted principles of the language, then deduces the language as a whole from the correct combination of the parts and principles.
Inductive language learning involves reading passages in a foreign language, then picking it apart and learning what the parts mean. In other words, it begins with the language as a whole properly connected in all of its parts and principles, then figures out certain parts and principles of the language.
As you can see, we aren't actually talking about a method of reasoning so much as we are talking about a method of approaching a subject.
In the deductive method of study, we take for granted the work which others before us have done in identifying and categorizing various parts and their relationships of language (or any other subject), and we use this to develop our understanding of the whole system and to generate true examples of the language (or any other subject).
In the inductive method of study, what was taken for granted in the deductive method, is here our primary work. We move from the given true examples of the language (or any other subject) and we break it down into its parts and relationships and thereby develop our understanding of the whole system.
In actual practice, though, any one method of study may be characteristically deductive or inductive. Nevertheless nothing is purely deductive, and nothing is purely inductive, but they are actually used to serve each other.
How Does This Apply to Inductive and Deductive Bible Study
Used correctly, both inductive and deductive Bible study methods can be helpful in using the Bible to arrive at or to test ones’ beliefs. Each has its special uses and abuses. I will describe each method below on the basic level, then on the advanced level, pointing out some uses and abuses.
Basic Level Deductive Bible Study
Deductive Bible study on the basic level is simply instruction in Biblical doctrine. A better name for this might be synthetic Bible study [Greek: suntithemai to put together] because it puts together the separate elements of the Bible to form a coherent whole, which is more highly developed than the parts. In a deductive study we might examine a previously selected series of Biblical texts in order to gather up Biblical propositions which, when properly arranged, prove such doctrines as the deity of Christ, or the personality of the Holy Spirit, or salvation by the blood atonement of Christ. The Apostles reasoned with them from the Scriptures, explaining and demonstrating that the Christ had to suffer and rise again from the dead.(Acts 17:2-3) So a deductive study is topical in nature, and someone must first do the work of finding the texts and arranging them to prove the doctrine, then we examine his work, benefit from it, and perhaps even improve upon it. The deductive study saves us much of the work of assembling these texts and building these doctrines on our own. In this way those young in the faith can be quickly edified [built up] line upon line in basic, essential, and important doctrines of the faith.
One common way of doing a deductive study is for the student to examine a selected series of Bible texts, then to answer specific questions about each text questions which will draw out and pull together the logical inferences so that the student can think for himself step-by-step through the logic of the doctrine.
Of course, in deductive Bible study the student must place a reasonable amount of trust in his teacher to guide him through the doctrines. [Nevertheless, there are some things hard to understand, which untaught and unstable persons twist to their own destruction, as they do also the rest of the Scriptures.(2 Peter 3:16)] The danger of the deductive study is that, regardless of the teachers intentions, we may be mislead. So the student must also examine for himself the Bible texts in their contexts to see if they say what the teacher thinks they say, and he must test the logical connections to make sure they prove what the teacher thinks they prove. “The Bereans were more fair-minded than those in Thessalonica, in that they received the word [of the Apostles doctrine] with all readiness, and searched the Scriptures daily to find out whether these things were so. Therefore many of them believed.(Acts 17:11-12)” Both the teacher and the student are accountable to the Lord, as well as to each other in the Lord.
Religious cults use a deductive method of Bible study in order to keep followers at a more childish level of understanding, and thereby dependent upon them for instruction. The ultimate goal of a faithful Bible teacher is to bring his students up to his level of skill in understanding so that they may eventually instruct and correct him. Pastors and teachers, for the equipping of the saints for the work of ministry, for the edifying of the body of Christ, till we all come to the unity of the faith and of the knowledge of the Son of God, to a perfect man, to the measure of the stature of the fullness of Christ; that we should no longer be children, tossed to and fro and carried about with every wind of doctrine, by the trickery of men, in the cunning craftiness of deceitful plotting, but, speaking the truth in love, may grow up in all things into Him who is the head Christ from whom the whole body, joined and knit together by what every joint supplies, according to the effective working by which every part does its share, causes growth of the body for the edifying of itself in love.(Ephesians 4:11-16) We have much to say, and hard to explain, since you have become dull of hearing. For though by this time you ought to be teachers, you need someone to teach you again the first principles of the oracles of God; and you have come to need milk and not solid food. For everyone who partakes only of milk is unskilled in the word of righteousness, for he is a child. But solid food belongs to those who are of full age, that is, those who by reason of use have their senses exercised to discern both good and evil.
Therefore, leaving the discussion of the elementary principles of Christ, let us go on to maturity.(Hebrews 5:116:1)”
As long as the doctrine is actually demonstrated by correctly handling genuine and valid proof texts, then this method of study can be very edifying, useful, and fruitful. [A valid proof text is a proposition found in the Bible which can be clearly shown to mean only one thing.]
However, deductive (or synthetic or doctrinal) Bible study should be clearly distinguished from dogmatic Bible study, which is instruction using selected texts as evidence to support a particular model or system of interpretation. [A supporting evidence text is a statement found in the Bible the meaning of which is open to interpretation. It might be honestly interpreted to mean something other than what fits a particular model or system. It can compare biological and archeological facts which are made to fit both evolutionary and creation models.] Dogmatic Bible study may appear on the surface to be the same as deductive Bible study, but the critical difference is that deductive study carefully demonstrates what the Bible teaches, while dogmatic study shows how a particular teaching might be fitted into the Bible whether it belongs there or not. In the deductive study we are led to trust the teachings of the Bible, while in the dogmatic study we are led to trust a system of teachings or dogma. A particularly dangerous form of dogmatic Bible study is when a special set of interpretations of certain key words, phrases, and passages are imposed upon Bible texts sometimes using a specially invented vocabulary in order to make the texts to fit into an otherwise unproven system for interpreting the Bible. Much time can be spent attempting to disentangle and unravel tightly bound systems of traditions or dogma or opinions which have been imposed upon the Bible.
Advanced Level Deductive Bible Study
At the more advanced levels of deductive study, instead of relying on a teacher to instruct the student, the student himself is involved directly in building and applying Biblical doctrine. A better name for this might be research Bible study. After obtaining a good knowledge of Scripture and a familiarity with how to prove doctrines, the student may take up the work of thoroughly searching the Scriptures and making His own necessary inferences from the propositions of Scripture. He may be motivated by special questions or controversies, or by issues and situations he has encountered which require a decision. His goal is to discover, if possible, the Biblical doctrine or principle which applies or offers guidance. The more tools the student has, the more effective he will be in accomplishing his goal. Topical lists of Scripture, concordances, cross-references, chain-references, and other reference books are valuable here. Used properly, an acquaintance with the original languages and access to language tools can insure a higher degree of accuracy in research.
The danger in research Bible study is that we may weave a web of interpretations which appears to support our own desires or expectations. In other words, we may deceive ourselves by impressing our own thinking into the Bible instead of allowing the Bible to impress its thinking upon us. For this we must always be on guard.
Theology textbooks often contain much excellent deductive instruction, but the dogma of the author is always intertwined with his deductive instruction. Therefore it is often best to read the criticisms and dissenting opinions of other authors in order to help discern what is Bible doctrine from what is the authors denominational opinions or personal conjectures. (Some insist there is a difference between systematics which is supposed to be purely Biblical doctrine and dogmatics which is supposed to be the study of a creedal system of a denomination or a theological model developed by a religious movement. From a practical point of view, it is often difficult to distinguish any real difference.)
Basic Level Inductive Bible Study
Inductive Bible study on the basic level is simply careful instruction in the meaning of the Biblical text. A better name for this might be analytic Bible study [Greek: analuein to undo, to loosen back (to the elements)] because it breaks down Bible texts into parts or principles in order to examine its meaning and relationship to other texts.
In an inductive study we might examine a particular passage or book of the Bible, attempting to understand what the text means within its context. The purpose is not to build doctrine, although a little of that will probably happen, but the purpose is to build basic knowledge and understanding of the Bible. From childhood you have known the Holy Scriptures, which are able to make you wise for salvation through faith which is in Christ Jesus. All Scripture is given by inspiration of God, and is profitable for doctrine, for reproof, for correction, for instruction in righteousness, that the man of God may be complete, thoroughly equipped for every good work.(2 Timothy 3:15 - 4:1) So an inductive study is textual in nature, requiring much time in carefully examining larger continuous passages of Biblical texts in order to know what they mean and how they may apply to our lives.
One common way of doing an inductive study is to choose a large passage to examine word by word, phrase by phrase, paragraph by paragraph with a series of such questions as Who? What? Where? When? Why? How? What kind of? How many?which help to draw out some of the meaning of the text
- We begin with the observation level, determining what the text says.
- We next move to the interpretation level, determining what the text means by what it says.
- Finally we move to the application level, determining how to apply what the text means to issues of modern life.
This follows the progression of the Biblical
trivium:
- Knowledge of the facts = observation of what the text says.
- Understanding of the relationships = interpretation of what the text means.
- Wisdom in applying the understanding = application of the interpretation to life
One weakness of this method is that someone may become so focused on the details of the text and the immediate application that he may not see the larger picture and therefore he may overlook or even disparage doctrine. In our age, the focus on personal insight and personal application may have engendered an aversion to doctrine. People do have trouble seeing, or even wanting to see the forest for the trees. This imbalance may be corrected with deductive doctrinal studies, and with thematic outlining of larger portions of Scripture.
If inductive study were our only method of study, then we would be less built up or edified in the doctrines of the faith. Inductive study is a good preparation for advanced deductive study, but it is no substitute for it. One who keeps away from deductive study and only does inductive study will withhold from himself the sure and certain knowledge of many edifying doctrines of Scripture. He who does not advance to the solid food of doctrine will remain as a child on milk. Children are more easily misled and are the least prepared to sense danger or to protect themselves or defend others in danger. And I, brethren, could not speak to you as to spiritual people but as to carnal, as to babes in Christ. I fed you with milk and not with solid food; for until now you were not able to receive it, and even now you are still not able; for you are still carnal.(1 Corinthians 3:1-3)
Advanced Level Inductive Bible Study
At the more advanced levels of inductive study, the student gathers information in order to look for patterns or trends in the Bible. A better name for this might be theoretical Bible study. A theory is a system of assumptions, speculations, or conjectures weaved together to explain certain observed phenomena, but which lacks verification either with direct connecting evidence or with proof by necessary inference. If any such inductive theories are then brought into subjection to deductive proof from the Bible, then they can be very useful. But if they are pressed on others without proof, they become false and useless knowledge which generates strife and divisions among brethren. Charge some that they teach no other doctrine, nor give heed to fables and endless genealogies, which cause disputes rather than godly edification which is in faith.(1 Timothy 1:3-4) If anyone teaches otherwise and does not consent to wholesome words, even the words of our Lord Jesus Christ, and to the doctrine which accords with godliness, he is proud, knowing nothing, but is obsessed with disputes and arguments over words, from which come envy, strife, reviling, evil suspicions, useless wranglings of men of corrupt minds and destitute of the truth, who suppose that godliness is a means of gain. From such withdraw yourself.(1 Timothy 6:3-5) Guard what was committed to your trust, avoiding the profane and idle babblings and contradictions of what is falsely called knowledge by professing it some have strayed concerning the faith.(Timothy 6:20-21) Hymenaeus and Philetus are of this sort, who have strayed concerning the truth, saying [speculating] that the resurrection is already past; and they overthrow the faith of some.(2 Timothy 2:17-18) For the time will come when they will not endure sound doctrine, but according to their own desires, because they have itching ears, they will heap up for themselves teachers; and they will turn their ears away from the truth, and be turned aside to fables.(2 Timothy 4:3-4)
Theorizing is not in itself necessarily bad in fact, it can be very useful but when it takes on a life and authority of its own apart from Bible, it becomes an enemy of the true doctrine and faith of the Bible. We might compare this somewhat to the theory of evolution. Micro-evolution is the shifting of gene pools in a population in order to adapt a species to circumstances. This was originally a scientific induction, but it may now be considered verified as observable fact. Macro-evolution, on the other hand, is the changing of genetic materials in order to create altogether new species. This is a theoretical model which has never been observed and which appears to contradict observable fact (not to mention Scripture). Micro-evolution has proven to be a useful theory because it has since been proven to everyone's satisfaction. Macro-evolution is a useless speculation which can never be proven true, and which many consider to have been falsified in several ways. Its only useful purpose has been to eliminate that line of reasoning.
Summary & Conclusion
Deductive or synthetic Bible study gathers propositions from Scripture and arranges them as premises in formal arguments which reason toward necessary doctrinal conclusions which may not otherwise have been stated in the Bible. In this way, it builds Biblical doctrine. On the basic level, the gathering and arranging of Scripture to prove doctrines has already been done for the student. On the advanced level, the student researches these on his own.
Inductive or analytic Bible study examines in detail large passages of Scripture in order to understand those passages in context. In this way, it builds a general understanding of the Bible. On the basic level, the student researches on his own. On the advanced level, the student surveys all or large portions of Scripture looking for patterns, and theorizes about the meaning of what he observes. He then goes back and attempts to prove his theory deductively.
So, inductive and deductive study goes hand in hand. Inductive study supplies the analytical Bible knowledge and understanding necessary to deductively build Bible doctrine, and deductive study researches and builds doctrine which informs inductive study concerning the wider doctrinal context of Scripture, enables it to draw out even more meaning from the text.
The weakness of inductive study is its limitations in building doctrine, and the weakness of deductive study is its susceptibility to being infected with dogma.
The abuse of inductive study comes when theory is turned into dogma, and the abuse of deductive study comes when dogma is mixed with doctrine.
Revelation
Revelation Defined: God communicating to man what he would otherwise not know (Hebrews 1:1 – God is the Source of all Revelation)
Two Kinds of Divine Revelation
I. General Revelation – God communicating to man His existence and His character through nature and reasoning, apart from any words or language.
Arguments for the existence of God from general revelation.
A. Cosmological argument – “The world didn’t just happen. Some Uncaused Being must have caused it to be” (Romans 1:20)
B. Teleological argument – “Design in the world points to a Designer” (Psalm 19:1-6).
C. Moral argument – “Our sense of right and wrong points to a moral Law-Giver” (Romans 2:14,15; James 4:12).
D. Ontological argument – “Why would people have a concept of a Perfect Being unless there was one – God Himself” (Acts 17:27; Romans 1:19)?
II. Special Revelation – God communicating to man using words and other supernatural mediums.
A. Special revelation without words
- Casting the lot (Proverbs 16:33; Acts 1:21-26)
- The Urim and Thummim – Two stones in the high priest’s breastplate that revealed God’s will (Exodus 28:30; Numbers 27:21; Deuteronomy 33:8; 1 Samuel 28:6; Ezra 2:63).
- Dreams (Genesis 20:3,6; 31:11-13, 24; 40-41, etc.)
- Miraculous Events (The Exodus, Jesus’ miracles – John 2:11, etc.)
B. Special revelation with words
- Words were spoken by God to someone (who verbally communicated it to others).
a. Angels (Daniel 9:20,21; Luke 2:10,11; Revelation 1:1)
b. Prophets (2 Samuel 23:2; Zechariah 1:1; Ephesians 3:5; Hebrews 1:1, etc.)
c. Jesus Christ (John 1:14; Hebrews 1:2; 2:3)
d. Apostles (2 Peter 3:2)
- God revealed to men what He wanted to be recorded as Scripture (see the following on “Inspiration).
III. Is There Special Revelation Today?
A. Problems with the view that there is special revelation today
Some Christians believe that the Bible gives general guidance to all believers (which is true), but they also believe that God gives specific individual guidance today by dreams, voices and specifically inspired thoughts.
- 2 Timothy 3:16,17 says the scriptures are “adequate/sufficient” for everything we need to know or do.
- Many claim “God told me” but there is no way to verify which “voices or impressions” are truly God-given.
- The cults have all begun with claims of modern “special revelation.”
- The penalty of falsely claiming “God told me” was death for a prophet (Deut. 18:20-27). To claim “God told me” is
to claim the same kind of revelation as a prophet. We must keep clearly separate what are our own thoughts and what God actually revealed.
B. Argument for the view that God does not give new special revelation today.
Certainly God is leading individuals in various ways today, but that leading is not verbal nor on par with special revelation. So how does God lead today?
- The Bible – God will use scripture to lead us (2 Timothy 3:16,17). Every time we read a specific command that relates to some area of our life today, that is God’s leading.
The Holy Spirit within us convicts and teaches us through the Bible (John 16:13). In addition to specific commands, God will use the principles of scripture to lead us into right choices. That is God’s leading as well (see Illumination, below).
- Prayer – When we pray we talk to God. He does not “talk” to us in the same way (verbally). As we pray we may, however, become more sensitive to what God has already revealed in Scripture. That is not new revelation. As we prayed, we simply became aware and perhaps more willing to follow revelation God has already given in the Bible.
- Specific Guidance – Often we have specific need for direction (to make good choices about a job, a spouse, a move, a purchase, etc.). We don’t need special revelation (a “voice” or a “sign”).
- We need an obedient heart. We must be willing to do what God wants (Proverbs 3:5,6).
- We need to search the scripture for commands and principles relating to family, finances, priorities, etc. (Proverbs 19:21).
- We need to listen to godly advice (Proverbs 12:15: 13:10; 15:22).
- We must then make our decisions, trusting in God’s continued guidance and sovereign control (Proverbs 3:5; 19:9).
- God’s Sovereignty – God has His plan which includes certain specific circumstances. He sovereignly protects, leads and arranges certain people to be in certain places and for certain events to occur. As He carries out His sovereign plan, He may utilize our human thoughts to put us where He wants us (for example: A man on a vacation trip finds a Gideon Bible and trusts in Christ.). But these are still human thoughts which God utilizes and are not new authoritative revelation. This is simply God’s sovereignty at work.
- Answered Prayer – Some Christians may pray for specific help in a troublesome situation (guidance issues, a lost billfold, etc.). God can answer those prayers and use our thoughts. But they are still our thoughts, not authoritative revelation. For example, I lost my checkbook several years ago. I prayed. I had various thoughts, new places to look, stores to call, etc. However none of them produced the checkbook. It was never found. If God had chosen to answer my prayer, one of those thoughts could have led to finding it. But that would not have meant it was inspired or that “God told me.” It would simply mean God used my thoughts in His sovereign answer to my prayer.
True revelation from God is always objective (certain and knowable). But if we don’t know that God revealed it until it turns out right, that’s not true revelation. Every prophet knew it was God speaking. He didn’t have to wait to see if the prophecy “turned out” or if the principle “worked.”
So, it is true that God answers prayer and can use our thoughts in the process. But they are our thoughts and impressions He uses. They are not His voice, nor is it revelation.
Revelation
God took the initiative to disclose or reveal Himself to mankind. (Heb. 1:1) The vehicles varied; sometimes it was through the created order, at other times through visions/dreams or speaking prophets. However, the most complete and understandable self-disclosures were through the propositions of scripture. (1Cor. 2:6-16)
Inspiration
The revelation of God was captured in the writings of scripture by means of “inspiration.” Revelation concerns the material or content by which God is disclosed, and inspiration concerns the record of that content, the Bible. Inspiration means “filling or breathing info.” In 2 Timothy 3:16, the word usually translated “inspiration” is more accurately “spiration,” that is, “God-breathed.” In other words, the verse simply says that scripture is God-produced, and it does not actually indicate any of the means that God may have used in producing it. Peter explains the process in 2 Peter 1:20-21. By this means, the word of God was protected from human error in its original record by the ministry of the Holy Spirit (Deut. 18:18; Matt. 1:22).
We must understand that the Bible is actually one book with one Divine Author, though it was written over a period of 1,500 years through the pens of almost 40 human writers. The Bible began with the creation account of Genesis 1 and 2, written by Moses about 1405 B.C., and extends to the eternal future account of Revelation chapters 21 and 22, written by Apostle John about A.D. 95. During this time, God progressively revealed Himself and His purposes in the inspired scriptures. God intended His word to abide forever (preservation). Therefore, His written, propositional, self-disclosure (revelation) was protected from error in its original writing (inspiration) and collected in 66 books of the Old and New Testament (canonicity).
What about the claims of Roman Catholics and charismatics with their extra biblical revelations? “Is the canon forever closed?” Scripture texts warn that no one should delete from or add to scripture (Deut. 4:2; 12:32; Prov. 30:6; Rev. 22:18-19).
The book of Revelation is unique to the scripture in that it describes with unparalleled detail the end-time events which precede eternity future, as Genesis began scripture by bridging the gap from eternity past into our time/space back into eternity future (Rev. 20-22). Genesis and Revelation, by their contents, are perfectly matched bookends of scripture. Just as there was prophetic silence after Malachi completed the Old Testament canon, so there was a parallel silence after John delivered Revelation. This leads to the conclusion that the New Testament canon was then also closed.
Illumination
Although the word illumination has been applied to several aspects of doctrine (like the general enlightenment that the coming of Christ brought to all men, John1:9, and the illumination theory of inspiration, it is generally thought of in connection with the ministry of the Holy Spirit that makes clear the truth of the written revelation in the Bible.
In reference to the Bible, revelation relates to its content or material, inspiration to the method or recording that material, and illumination to the meaning of the record. The unsaved man cannot experience the illumination ministry of the spirit since he is blinded to the truth of God (1 Cor. 2:14). This does not mean that he cannot learn anything of the facts of the Bible, but that he considers what he knows as foolishness. On the other hand, the Christian has been promised this illumination of the text (John 16:12-15; 1 Cor. 2:9- 3:2). Taking these two passages together, several facts emerge: 1) The most obvious is that the spirit Himself is the teacher, and His presence in the life of the believer is the guarantee of the effectiveness of this ministry. 2) The content of His teaching encompasses “all the truth” (John 16:13). It specifically includes an understanding of prophecy (“things to come”). 3) The purpose of the spirit’s illumination is to glorify Christ, not Himself. 4) Carnality in the believer can hinder and even nullify this ministry of the Spirit (1 Cor. 3:1-2). Illumination, though assured, does not always guarantee automatic understanding. The believer must be in fellowship with the Lord in order to experience this ministry. But also, he must study, using the teachers God has given to the church (Romans 12:7) and the abilities and means at his own disposal.
Some denominations try to build important doctrines based on some isolated verses. Mormons conduct proxy baptism for the people who were dead in the past based on one verse from 1 Cor. 15:29: “Otherwise, what will those do who are baptized for the dead, if the dead do not rise at all? Why then are they baptized for the dead?” In their practice, individuals go to their local temple, dress appropriately for a baptism, representatively adopt the name of a person who has died, and then the Mormon is baptized in water for that deceased person. This way, the dead person has fulfilled the requirements of salvation in the afterworld and can enjoy further spiritual benefits in the spiritual realm. However the Mormons are incorrect.
They have taken this verse out of context.
I remember when I studied in law school; we came across a section called the weight of evidence. Of all the evidence on both sides of an issue, the more convincing body of evidence was determined not by mere quantity, but by its significance, coherence, and credibility. In a court of law, a judge or a jury must review the evidence presented, evaluate it, and determine if it meets the standard of proof.
The judge or jury examines the weight of evidence if they have only circumstantial evidence. We do not have another verse in scripture to support the Mormon theory of baptism for the dead.
Revelation and Inspiration
In the book of Job we see the statements of Satan, and the statements of Job’s friends. Some of their statements are true. None of these men who spoke were inspired in their utterances, though we have an inspired account of what they said, so that the picture presented is perfectly true.
We must never overlook the difference between revelation and inspiration. All scripture is inspired of God, but not every word found therein is a revelation from God. When Solomon wrote, for instance, “there is nothing better for a man, than that he should eat and drink” (Eccl. 2:24), he was not uttering a revelation from God, but rather his own foolishness – inspired to put it on record for our warning.
Revelation means God disclosing to humanity truths that they would not otherwise know. Divine inspiration means that God preserved the writer from recording error when they wrote the scripture. Divine inspiration does not always imply revelation or vice versa. For example, Moses was divinely inspired by God to record events that he himself witnessed. These events were the actual source of his knowledge on the subject. The subject matter was not beyond human knowledge but was there for any observer to record.
Does God give revelation today?
Many believe that God speaks to men directly and also in the form of dreams and visions. Groups that teach this include the Catholics, Pentecostals, Charismatics, and most Christian cults.
Most of the cults were formed when their supposed prophets received special visions, visitations or revelations from God, and they supposedly were told to form special churches or movements. Among those groups are the Mormons, Christian Science, Jehovah’s Witnesses, and Seventh Day Adventist. Each claims God spoke or appeared to them directly and now they represent God; and men should follow them.
This presents the believer with a problem. How can a person determine that what is being presented is really coming from God? Among the revelations the cults say they received, there are great contradictions and yet each claim that what they saw or heard was from God. If their “revelation” came from God, why does it contradict the teaching of the Bible and also of others who make the same claim to receiving authentic revelation from God? The point is that dreams and visions are subjective. How can one determine they came from God and how can one interpret the dream?
The modern day revelations are clearly not from God because God would never contradict Himself. Often the “dreamer” is perpetrating a hoax intended to deceive people into following them. They claim their visions from God gave them special authority to form their new movements and teachings. A prime example is Joseph Smith, the founder of Mormonism, who claimed God and Jesus appeared to him and told him that all the churches on earth were false. He was to form a new church and preach the “restored” gospel. However, the church he formed and its teachings are wholly unbiblical, which proves Smith received no visitation from God. God does not contradict Himself.
Let me use part of John MacArthur’s article from “Master’s Seminary Journal,” Volume 14.
Strange private prophecies have been a noted characteristic of the Charismatic movement, prophecies such as those received by Oral Roberts, Kenneth Hagin and other leaders.
“God told me” has become the anthem of the Charismatic movement. Strange private prophecies are proclaimed by all kinds of people who evidently believe God speaks to them. Surely the most infamous is Oral Robert’s preposterous death threat prophecy. In 1987, Roberts told his nationwide audience that God had threatened to “call him home” if he could not raise eight million dollars by his creditor’s deadline. Whether and how that threat might have been carried out, the world will never know; Roberts received a last-minute reprieve in the form of a large check from a Florida dog track owner. Two years later, when Roberts was forced to close his multimillion dollar, Tulsa-based City of Faith Medical Center, he asked God why.
We may gasp at Oral Robert’s hubris, but he is not the only charismatic who thinks he is receiving private revelation from God.
Scripture is a closed system of truth, complete, sufficient, and not to be added to (Rev. 22:18-19). It contains all the spiritual truth God intended to reveal. God’s revelation is complete for now. The canon of scripture is closed. Jude 3 is a crucial passage on the completeness of our Bible.
Proof Texting
A text without a context is a pretext for a proof text
A PROOF TEXT is a verse or short passage from the Bible used by someone as part of his proof for a doctrinal belief he wishes to substantiate to others. However, since verses and passages may rely extensively on the context in which they appear for correct interpretation, pulling these out of their context and having them stand alone in a "proof" can, at times, be very misleading. In addition, a set of such proof texts can completely ignore other passages which, if added to the mix, might well lead to an entirely different conclusion.
Someone who relies strongly only on a list of proof texts in order to make a doctrinal argument may have a very weak case for his argument. Noting that a religious teacher relies heavily just on proof texting is viewed in theological circles as a very negative evaluation. Doctrinal beliefs based strictly on proof texts can lead people to believing, and even whole churches to teaching, something which is not Biblically correct.
Glossary of Terms
The following glossary will enhance your ability to research difficult passages and unwrap the riddle.
Definition of DIALECTIC
1 : logic 1a(1) 2 a : discussion and reasoning by dialogue as a
method of intellectual investigation; specifically : the Socratic techniques of exposing false beliefs and eliciting truth b : the Platonic investigation of the eternal ideas 3 : the logic of fallacy 4 a : the Hegelian process of change in which a
concept or its realization passes over into and is preserved and fulfilled by its opposite; also : the critical investigation of this process b (1) usually plural but singular or plural in construction : development through the stages of thesis, antithesis, and synthesis in accordance with the laws of dialectical materialism (2) : the investigation of this process (3) : the theoretical application of this process especially in the social sciences 5 usually plural but singular or plural in construction
a : any systematic reasoning, exposition, or argument that juxtaposes opposed or contradictory ideas and usually seeks to resolve their conflict b : an intellectual exchange of ideas : the dialectical tension or opposition between two interacting forces or elements
Definition of DIALECTIC MATERIALISM
: the Marxist theory that maintains the material basis of a reality constantly changing in a dialectical process and the priority of matter over mind. The Communist manifesto in 1848 states “The history of all hitherto existing society is the history of class struggles”.
Hegel
Dialectical Materialism is essentially characterized by the thesis that history is the product of class struggles and follows the general Hegelian principle of philosophy of history, that is the development of the thesis into its antithesis which is sublated by the synthesis.
Definition of SYNTHESIS
1 a : the composition or combination of parts or
elements so as to form a whole b : the production of a substance by the union of chemical elements, groups, or simpler compounds or by the degradation of a complex compound c : the combining of often diverse conceptions into a coherent whole; also : the complex so formed 2 a : deductive reasoning
b : the dialectic combination of thesis and antithesis into a higher stage of truth : the frequent and systematic use of inflected forms as a characteristic device of a language
Definition of HYPOTHESIS
The Adjective hypothetical meaning “having the nature of a hypothesis, or being assumed to exist” is an immediate consequence of a hypothesis. Hypothesis is a proposed explanation for an observable phenomenon. For a hypothesis to be out forward as a scientific method, it requires that one can test it. Scientists generally base scientific hypothesis on previous observations that cannot be satisfactorily explained with the available scientific theories. Even though the words hypothesis and theory are often used synonymously in common and in formal usage, a scientific hypothesis is not the same as a scientific theory – although the difference is sometimes more on degree than of purpose.
Definition of THESIS
An unproved statement put forward as a premise in an argument. A proposition that is maintained in an argument, a dissertation advancing an original point of view as a result of research, especially as a requirement for an academic degree. A hypothetical proposition, especially one put forth without proof. It is the first stage of the Hegelian dialectic process. It is a dissertation resulting from original research, and a doctrine that is maintained or promoted in an argument.
Definition of ANTITHESIS
A contrast, or opposition of thoughts, usually in two phrases, clauses, or sentences i.e. “you are going, I am staying”. The second expression is in contrast, opposition, or the exact opposite.
Definition of SYLLOGISM
One of the most common and useful forms of deductive reasoning is the syllogism. A syllogism is a specific form of argument that has three easy steps: a major premise, a minor premise and a logical conclusion. For example, the premise "Every X has the characteristic Y" could be followed by the premise "This thing is X," which would yield the conclusion "This thing has the characteristic Y." The first wasp example could be broken up into the major premise "Every wasp has a stinger," the minor premise "This insect is a wasp" and the conclusion "This insect has a stinger." Creating a syllogism is considered a good way for deductive reasoning to be tested to ensure that it is valid.
Definition of OBJECTIVE
- Of or having to do with a material object.
- Having actual existence or reality.
3.
a. Uninfluenced by emotions or personal
prejudices: an objective critic. See synonyms at fair1. b. Based on observable phenomena; presented
factually: an objective appraisal.
- Medicine. Indicating a symptom or condition perceived as a sign of disease by someone other than the person affected.
- Grammar. a. Of, relating to, or being the case of a noun or pronoun that serves as the object of a verb. b. Of or relating to a noun or pronoun used in this case.
- Something that actually exists.
- Something worked toward or striven for; a goal. See synonyms at intention.
- Grammar. a. The objective case. b. A noun or pronoun in the objective case.
- The lens or lens system in a microscope or other optical instrument that first receives light rays from the object and forms the image. Also called object glass, objective lens, Also called object lens.
Definition of SUBJECTIVE
1.
a. Proceeding from or taking place in a
person's mind rather than the external world: a subjective decision. b. Particular to a given person; personal:
subjective experience.
- Moodily introspective.
- Existing only in the mind; illusory.
- Psychology. Existing only within the experiencer's mind.
- Medicine. Of, relating to, or designating a symptom or condition perceived by the patient and not by the examiner.
- Expressing or bringing into prominence the individuality of the artist or author.
- Grammar. Relating to or being the nominative case.
- Relating to the real nature of something; essential.