Chapter 9 of 14
A Study of the Holy Laughter Movement
Charismatic resurgence began in the sixties of the last century in America. The movement has exploded throughout the world within the last two decades. Modern society is materialistic, selfish and secular. Family disintegration and poverty multiplied the misery of millions of people. The Majority of people do not take time to study the doctrines and back ground history of the television preachers and they become victims of the fraudulent preachers. These people lose their rational and objective views; and even after the faults, failures, and immoral lifestyles of these leaders, the followers have no problem believing the lies perpetrated by them.
For example, there have been different divine healers and miracle workers that were caught for fraudulent miracle crusades. Their ministries have failed and filed for bankruptcy. But after some years have passed, the same false revivals and crusades attract thousands of people again. Many people have short memories, and many people don't care about knowing the past of these demonic preachers.
Out of all the Pentecostal groups in the world, Malayalee Pentecostals are more sober and have not gone to the extremes like Benny Hinn and Oral Roberts. This is because of their Plymouth Brethren background. However, I do not know how long Malayalee Pentecostals can hold on to their traditional beliefs. In the future, they may be taken over by extremist groups who preach prosperity theology.
This writer encourages everyone to read the book written by Hank Hanegraaff entitled "Counterfeit Revival." He has written a book about the history of all the counterfeit prophets of this age. This author has studied books by most of the counterfeit prophets such as Benny Hinn, John Arnott and Oral Roberts. I will be quoting from the Counterfeit Revival extensively because it is a summary of all other false prophets. James A. Beverley also has a study and research about Holy Laughter and the Toronto Blessing. He has written an impartial and balanced account of these new phenomena.
Occults, cults, and socio-psychological manipulations have been in existence in all religions for centuries. So, at various times, extreme charismatic cults also existed in the history of the Christian church. The modern day super-prophets and healers make big claims, but many of their lives are replete with adultery, fornication, cheating, and lying. How do you know that a person is speaking through the power of the Holy Ghost?
When looking back at Christian history, one should examine the lives of these present day “super-saints” with the lives of John Darby, William Kelly, George Muller, Hudson Taylor, David Livingston, etc. The present day super-saints cannot stand in comparison to the impeccable reputations of these well established Christian leaders, thus posing the important question of how reliable these modern-day prophets are and if indeed the Holy Ghost could possibly be speaking through them.
Modern charismatics do not need a Bible. In their sermons, you can hear Bible quotes here and there. Meetings are filled with anecdotes about the miracles and healings that happened in their revivals in Singapore or Hong Kong. Many of the healings involve backaches, joint pains, mental anguish, etc. As believers, we have to read scripture and understand the dangers of charismatic movements. I John 4:1 says, "Beloved, do not believe every spirit, but test the spirits, whether they are of God; because many false prophets have gone out into the world." This warning is particularly relevant today, as Christianity is undergoing a shift from faith to feelings and experiences and from facts to fantasy.
Some of the most recognizable names in the Christian community are endorsing this paradigm shift. The appeal is staggering that churches on every continent are now inviting people to experience God in a new way. This movement is spreading like wildfire. Even secular medias have become involved in reporting regularly.
Time magazine wrote an article titled, "Laughing for the Lord," which pointed out that Anglican parishes across England today bear a greater resemblance to "rock concerts and rugby matches" than to Christian worship. Newsweek, in an article titled, "The Giggles are for God," reported that people in churches worldwide were jerking spasmodically, dancing ecstatically, and acting like animals. The article reported that this behavior has already spread from Canada to roughly 8000 congregations in Norway, South Africa, Australia, and the United States.
Journalist Robert Hough did a story on the Airport Vineyard for Toronto Life magazine. His account gives a picture of part of an evening meeting. "The men sitting beside me, Dwayne from California roared like a wounded lion. The woman beside Dwayne started jerking so badly, her hands struck her face. People fell like dominoes, collapsing chairs as they plunged to the carpeting. They howled like wolves, brayed like donkeys and - in the case of a young man standing near the sound board - started clucking like a feral chicken. And the tears! Never have I seen people weep so hysterically, as though every hurt they'd ever encountered had risen to the surface and popped like an overheated tar bubble."
Despite these strange manifestations, there has been no hesitation on the part of many Christians around the world to engage in similar behavior. Paul Carden noted the influence of the Toronto Blessing in England: "An epidemic of laughter is spreading across the land, flashing like lightning from church to church."
There was also a national news story about a laughter movement in Puna and Bombay in India among Hindus. The roots of this movement began in the ministry of John Wimber, the international leader of the Vineyard. Todd Hunter, national coordinator of Vineyard churches, believes that it is Wimber's international reputation that set the stage for people being willing to come to Vineyard meetings in Toronto.
One of the other major leaders behind the Toronto Blessing is Rodney Howard - Brown. Known as the "Laughing Evangelist," Howard-Brown is from South Africa, and felt the call of God to come to America in 1987. He has played a central role in the origin of the Toronto Blessing. He believes that God has given him a special anointing to renew the church with the power of the Holy Spirit. He actually refers to himself as "The Holy Ghost Bartender," in light of his claim that he is giving to the church the new wine of the Holy Spirit.
Rodney Howard-Brown says that his revival had its origin in July of 1979. At the age of 17, he says he gave God Almighty an ultimatum. "Either you come down here and touch me or I am going to come up there and touch you." Reference: (Rodney Howard-Brown, Fresh Oil from Heaven. Louisville, KY: RHBEA Publications, 1992, page 28, The Touch of God.)
According to Brown, the anointing he received was so powerful that he had to beg God to lift it off of him so he would live. Howard-Brown says that even he was amazed at what happened when he prayed for people. At times they would be picked up and thrown over three rows of chairs like a piece of rag. On one occasion, while Howard-Brown was praying for a man, the power of God came over his shoulder like a whirlwind. The man saw it coming and tried to duck, but it was too late. The whirlwind picked him up off the ground level and then struck him to the ground. "I was shocked," Brown says, "as the power hit him, the first couple of rows all went out. It was like a Holy Ghost tornado came in there." In addition to becoming drunk in the spirit, being knocked down by the Spirit, and getting enveloped in the mist of the Spirit, suddenly, people were subjected to the glue of the Spirit.
Drinking and Driving
While the drinks dispersed by the Holy Ghost, Bartender produces hangovers, much like bars, they have to find themselves designated drivers to protect the lives of others. A large Assemblies of God church in Argentina now provides a special taxi service to help people who are not fit to drive home from their meetings.
One woman, singled out by Howard-Brown, allegedly became intoxicated just by listening to him on the radio. A police officer pulled her over. The woman was so drunk in the spirit; she had difficulty just rolling down her car window. When the officer tried to remove her from the car, the officer became so drunk himself that she had to lead him back to his patrol car.
John Wimber and the Vineyard
John Wimber has become the most recognized person in the Vineyard movement. Wimber was born in 1934 in the American Midwest. His alcoholic father left the family when John, an only child, was very young. He had no introduction to Christian faith in his youth. In 1955 he married his wife, Carol, a nominal Roman Catholic.
Gifted in music, he began his career as a writer for a rock group. John and Carol separated in 1962, but their marriage was saved.
In the early 1970's, John Wimber served as copastor of an evangelical Quaker church in Southern California. In 1979 his healing ministry began. After his Quaker days, Wimber became identified with Chuck Smith's group of Calvary Chapels. In 1982, Wimber left Calvary Chapel and became leader of a small group of churches known as The Vineyard, founded in 1974 by Ken Gulliksen. Though Gulliksen has started the Vineyard movement, he relinquished the leadership reins to Wimber out of conviction that his gifts lay elsewhere and that Wimber would bring a visionary dynamic to the movement.
In June 1986, Wimber suffered a heart attack, but he recovered and continued his leadership of the Vineyard church in Anaheim and of Vineyard Ministries International, the organization founded in 1982 to promote his teaching, healing and music ministry. In 1995, he retired from both official appointments, though he clearly remains the Vineyard's international leader and ultimate voice of authority. John Wimber died in 1997.
Mike Bickle, an energetic and powerful preacher from Kansas City offered Wimber encouragement and advice in late 1987 and early 1988. He went on to tell Wimber about the supernatural ministry of Bob Jones, Paul Cain, and other prophets connected with Bickle's Kansas City Fellowship. In 1990, Mike Bickle's Kansas City Fellowship became known as Metro Vineyard, under the umbrella of the Association of Vineyard Churches.
The Holy Ghost Bartender
In America, many are familiar with the "Happy Hour." After work, friends, especially men and women jointly, go to restaurants and spend time together drinking and partying. The bartender will serve liquor. One person won't drink so that he can drive the others home safely. That person is known as the designated driver. Similarly, charismatics also get drunk in the Holy Spirit and do all similar manifestations of a drunkard.
Rodney Howard Brown's name is synonymous with Holy Laughter. His meetings at the Carpenter's Home Church in Lakeland, Florida and at Oral Roberts University have reached legendary status in the charismatic and Pentecostal world.
Descriptions of the Manifestations
At a typical evening rally, during ministry time, people expect to see a large number in the crowd "slain in the Spirit" (this is also known as "resting" in the Spirit). People simply fall backward, allegedly under the power of the Holy Spirit. Such behavior has been common in Pentecostal and charismatic meetings as well as in Vineyard worship over the years. Occasionally, one or two people will run during the service; these are sometimes called "Jesus laps." One man recalls what happened to him and his girlfriend in the church: "We burst into uncontrollable laughter. It overwhelmed us and we just howled with laughter. No matter how hard we tried, we couldn't stop - it was totally out of our control. My girlfriend was lying across the seats and crawling along and trying to get away from me. That evening my friend and I decided to go back - this time, we wore ski pants."
Many people roar like lions and bark like dogs. Some make noises like cows. Another group of people were found to be oinking like pigs and crowing like roosters. These animal noises have created the most disgust among some critics. The dog barking has been linked historically with a famous Kentucky revival, while the lion roaring is said to be a prophetic action to signal a powerful word from Jesus, the lion of the tribe of Judah. One account revealed that a person not only barked like a dog, but also lifted up his leg to pretend to urinate.
Another account from John Arnott
He speaks about people "prophetically acting like lions and oxen and eagles and even warriors." He refers to a situation in another church, where someone was "acting like an eagle, flying around the room." The person would not stop, so it was suggested that they "throw a rabbit out in the middle of the floor, and maybe the eagle would come down." (John Arnott, sermon, Airport Vineyard, October 19, 1994.)
Was the above actions fitting and orderly? In the same message, Arnott refers to a woman "on all fours, snorting and pawing the ground like an angry bull." What course in hermeneutics will explain this kind of behavior? And what of the meaning of all the chopping, waving, head-shaking, twitching and other more radical body contortions that occur at their meetings?
End Time Restorationism
These false prophets believe that at the end of the age, God will restore supernatural signs and raise "super apostles and super prophets." In the early morning hours of the first day of the twentieth century, Charles Parham laid his hand on a young woman named Agnes Ozman, and she began to speak Chinese. When she tried to write, only Chinese characters would emerge from her pen. Parham was utterly convinced that Ozman's experience was a prelude to global revival and a precursor to end time restorationism. It was believed that Christians need only to receive the gift of tongues and they could go to the farthest corners of the world and preach in languages they had never learned. By the middle of the twentieth century, another hoax took center stage. Men like A. A. Allen, William Branham, and Jack Coe perpetrated the myth that a restoration of healing would lead to a final Pentecost greater than the first.
They claim that "no prophet or apostle who ever lived equaled the power of these individuals in this great army of the Lord in these last days. No one ever had it, not even Elijah or Peter or Paul, or anyone else enjoyed the power that is going to rest on this great army." (Bob Jones and Paul Cain, Selections from Kansas City Prophets audiotape; tape 155c)
The promised land, described by John Arnott, and Rodney Howard-Browne, is a utopia in which Christians will be "the head and not the tail"," the lender, not the borrower." They will dominate the socio-political system of the day, and their leaders will be the greatest in the history of humanity.
Another false prophet, James Ryle, claims that the Apostle John's visions on the Isle of Patmos seem too pale by comparison to his visions. Ryle says he once dreamed he was literally inside the Lord. John Arnott conveys a conversation he had with Jesus Christ. During the dialogue (similar to Jesse Duplantis who had appointments and meetings with God the Father), Arnott asked the Almighty what He would like to do when they met. Christ allegedly responded, "Oh John, I just want to wash your feet." (John Arnott, The Father's Blessing. Orlando, FL; Creation House 1995, p.28)
The wife of John Arnott, Carol, claims she had a conversation with the Holy Spirit. During the dialogue, the spirit that spoke with her communicated sorrow over being separated from Jesus. "You know the Father, and Jesus and I have been together for all of eternity. But when Jesus went back to heaven to be with God the Father, I came to earth."
And He said, "I am so lonely for Jesus." He said, "Some people really, really have Jesus, and really honor Him, and really worship Him." He said, "I love to be around those kinds of people." He misses Jesus, and He misses the Father. (By Carol Arnott, "Receiving the Spirit's Power.")
(John Arnott's book "The Father's Blessing." p.26; section titled "Jesus Wants a Love Affair with you") Arnott describes how Jesus appeared to a woman and fulfilled all her fantasies. Jesus laughed with the woman as together they ran around with arms stretched out like airplanes. Jesus lay on the ground with the woman and played with Legos (toy building blocks); then Jesus played with her hair and met her deepest needs and desires.
Carol had visions of marrying Christ at the wedding feast. Carol Arnott said she "was standing in an open spot when Jesus walked up and said, 'Carol, may I have the first dance.'" ("Father's Blessing." pp.163-165)