Chapter 7 of 14

Tongues and Spiritual Gifts

34 min read · Pages 107–135 of the printed edition

Speaking in tongues in the book of Acts, as has been noted, was a sign to the Jews of a change in God's economy that vitally affected them. In the epistles, the apostolic gift of tongues appears and is apparently distinct from the sign of tongues appearing in Acts. There is no evidence that the people who spoke in tongues in Acts continued to do so after the specific dispensational purposes of their speaking was accomplished.

The gift of tongues, on the other hand, was a spiritual enduement that could be continuously exercised in the apostolic church by its recipients. Unlike the sign in Acts, the gift was not a sovereign manifestation exhibited for a special occasion and then terminated. It was a gift to be exercised in the primitive assemblies, along with other spiritual gifts, some of which were to fulfill a temporary need and then pass away.

The gift of tongues had been abused in the church of Corinth. To correct the abuse, Paul discusses the gift in I Corinthians 12:1-14:40). In I Corinthians 12:1-31, the subject of tongues and spiritual gifts is expounded upon.

The subject of the gift of tongues, like other gifts of the Spirit, demands accurate knowledge (I Corinthians 12:1-3). This was the very first thing the apostle stressed as he took up the subject of spirituals, “pneumatika,” that was, "the manifestation of the Holy Spirit through gifts imparted to the believer." "Now concerning spirituals, I do not want you to be ignorant, brothers" (I Corinthians 12:1; Greek). Strangely enough, the modern glossolalic movement fails at this starting point.

To illustrate the need of accurate knowledge and the peril of ignorance when dealing in a realm where satanic and demonic deception are so prevalent, the apostle cites the plight of the Corinthian believers in their idolatrous pagan condition before they were saved (I Corinthians 12:2).

The illustration gently but firmly implied that the demonic delusion and dynamic behind idolatry (I Corinthians 10:20) could still imperil the believer who moved into the spiritual realm in ignorance of the word of God, the Word itself being the only guarantee against demonic influence.

I Corinthians was penned not later than AD 57, at the end of Paul's three year ministry in Ephesus (Acts 20:31; I Corinthians 16:5-8). It is one of the earliest of the Pauline letters. When it was written, there was no New Testament in existence, except James and I and II Thessalonians. Even these had extremely limited circulation. So, for practical purposes of instruction and edification, the early church had only the Old Testament scriptures, plus what New Testament truth could be communicated directly by the Spirit through special temporary gifts like knowledge, tongues, interpretation of tongues, prophecy, and specially gifted men like apostles and prophets (I Corinthians 12:28; Ephesians 4:11). It is for this reason that tongues, along with certain other temporary gifts, are mentioned only in the earliest of lists of spiritual gifts (I Corinthians 12:8-11, 28). Compare the later lists: Romans 12:4-8; Ephesians 4:8-12). All believers have spiritual baptism (I Corinthians 12:13). The universality of this spiritual baptism is indicated also in Romans 6:3, Galatians 3:26, 27 and Colossians 2:12.

Speaking in tongues, as a sign in the book of Acts (2:4; 10:46; 19:6) or as a gift in I Corinthians 12:1-14:40, was never a sign of the baptism of the Spirit, as modern Pentecostals contend. The giving of the gift was the sovereign act of the Holy Spirit, not human choice (I Corinthians 12:11). There was no place for self-choosing or the notion of a special class of believers who had received a spiritual experience that put them in a different category from other believers. Tongues, either as a sign or as a gift, was never intended to be manifested by every Christian. It is a pure, unscriptural fabrication of modern glossolalic movements that tongues may and ought to be manifested by every believer who can rightly claim to have had a New Testament baptism in the Holy Spirit.

Permanence of Tongues

It is important to bear in mind that the passage dealing doctrinally with the gifts of the Spirit (I Corinthians 12:1-14:40) was called forth incidentally to deal with the abuse of some of the gifts, particularly speaking in tongues. The fact is that the only reference to tongues in the doctrinal epistles occurs in a passage that not only corrects the abuse, but definitely regulates the legitimate use of speaking in tongues in the early church, and very definitely and clearly declared the temporary nature of the phenomenon.

Gifts are good, but only effective and acceptable if ministered in love (I Corinthians 13). Tongues were to cease because, in contrast to ever-enduring love, they often fail (I Corinthians 13:8). In contrast to the fact, "love never fails," the apostle announced another fact: "Tongues shall cease, shall be caused to cease, shall stop altogether, come to an end."

Tongues had to cease because, like prophecy and knowledge, it was to be replaced by something better (I Corinthians 13:8). Tongues was not the only spiritual manifestation of the early church that had a limited use. Prophecy and knowledge were likewise to be superseded by something that would make them unnecessary; and so they too would be done away with, the same as with tongues. When it was seen exactly what was meant by the apostolic spiritual gifts of "prophecy" and "knowledge" (I Corinthians 12:8-11,28), it becomes obvious why these spiritual manifestations, like tongues, became antiquated and thus were to be superseded when the New Testament scriptures came into being and general use.

The gift of prophecy in the apostolic church was not forth-telling of the truth of the written Word, but declaring truth which had been specially and directly revealed by the Holy Spirit to the "prophet" in the absence of the New Testament revelation. It was, like the gift of knowledge, the sovereign enduement of special direct revelation of truths now contained in the canonical New Testament scriptures. Both "prophecy and knowledge" therefore were of necessity "tie-overs" to supply the church's practical needs until the New Testament scriptures became available. In exactly the same way, although not so directly and indispensably useful as prophecy and knowledge, was tongues, as long as the interpretation of the tongue's message was present (I Corinthians 14:1-22).

These truths are exactly what the apostle declares in I Corinthians 13:8. "Love never fails, but whether there are prophecies, they shall fail, shall be superseded, be rendered useless, 'unnecessary and meaningless,' because no longer practical or needful, shall be cancelled, done away with or put away; whether there be tongues, they shall cease, be caused to cease, stop altogether; whether there be knowledge, it shall vanish away, shall be superseded; the same word as used of prophecy."

Accordingly in the original Greek, I Corinthians 13:8 is a strong assertion of the truth of the temporary nature of three apostolic gifts, at least prophecy, tongues, and knowledge. To make prophecy and knowledge, in this case, general prophecy or knowledge, is ridiculous and utterly out of keeping with the context.

I Corinthians 13:9-10: "In past, piecemeal, partially bit by bit, we knew and in part (same word), we prophesy." The apostolic gift of knowledge by direct inspiration of the Holy Spirit was limited because it received truth only partially and piecemeal, within the various assemblies. The same was true of declaring the truth of the partial and piecemeal revelation.

"But when that which is perfect is come (Greek), the complete and final thing" - which means the New Testament scriptures; the neuter in the Greek denotes neither Christ nor His Second Advent, both of which thoughts are foreign to the context. Then, that which is in part (partial or piecemeal revelation through the gift of directly inspired prophecy and knowledge given), shall be done away with, shall be superseded, rendered unnecessary and meaningless, because no longer needed and so shall be cancelled and done away with. This is the same Greek word used of "prophecies" and "knowledge" in verse 8 and 11, "I put away childish things."

The apostle Paul employs two graphic illustrations to make his point. The first is that of a person growing up from childhood into adulthood. The second is that of looking into a mirror to see one's self.

Concerning the first illustration, the apostle stated in Greek, "When I was a child, I used to speak as a child, I used to think as a child, I used to reason as a child. But when I became an adult, I put away childish things" (verse 11). He is contrasting "that which is perfect."

Having to depend upon prophecy, tongues, and knowledge for instruction and edification until the completed New Testament became available was similar to childhood in the experience of the church. Speaking in tongues, for instance, had a purpose in the apostolic church, like the chatter of the child has a similar purpose in childhood, like the child's thinking and reasoning processes have a similar purpose in his growing up into manhood. The same was true of knowledge and prophecy.

But now that the church has grown up into adulthood, so to speak, with a complete revelation given it, it has put away childhood things, that is, has set aside, as superseded (same Greek word as in verse 8), as having no needful place in its adult life and belonging only to its childhood requirements.

Concerning the second illustration, the apostle says, "For now, just now, at this present moment (close upon it before or after), we see through a mirror, indistinctly, but then distinctly. Now (just now), I knew partially, but then I shall understand as I am understood" (Greek verse 12).

The apostle was comparing the state of the church before the New Testament scriptures were added to the Old Testament scriptures to a person looking into a mirror made of polished metal and which reflected only a blurred image. Piecemeal and partial revelation by prophecy, tongues, and knowledge to tide the church over, yielded only an imperfect understanding of divine truth, but then distinctly refers to the time when the New Testament revelation would become available and enable accurate and full comprehension of spiritual truth, as a person sees another "face to face" and so clearly recognizes him.

"Now I know partially," in fragmentary fashion, as a result of the limited revelation possible through the exercise of gifts of prophecy, knowledge and tongues. "But then I shall know" fully and completely, because a complete written revelation will be available to me for personal study, "even as I am known" by God who reveals my true condition through His word.

The conclusion is, "And now abides (remains permanently throughout the church age in contrast to prophecy, tongues and knowledge, which are to be superseded and cease) faith, hope, love, these three; but the greatest of these is love" (I Corinthians 13:13).

Most Bible commentaries construe "that which is perfect" of I Corinthians 13:10 as the coming of the Lord (rapture, I John 3:2) or the eternal state of the glorified believer. The apostle, however, had the completed, written revelation of truth then contained in the New Testament in mind, as suggested by the following considerations:

a) The Terminology: "That which is perfect" is neuter, the completed, final thing, not "He that is perfect" or "that which is perfect," but "that which is complete" as contrasted with "that which is incomplete."

b) The Contrast: "That which is incomplete," "that which is in part" (verse 10), specifically concerns piecemeal revelation by extraordinary, emergency means - "prophecies, tongues, and knowledge" (verse 8). "That which is complete" is the direct opposite and specifically concerns revelation by usual means - no longer requiring "prophecies, tongues and knowledge."

c) The Implication: The inescapable implication is that revelation by ordinary means, no longer requiring "prophecies, tongues and knowledge" would come through the inspired, written New Testament scriptures.

d) The Context: The connection concerns special, temporary, supernatural gifts (contrasted with love) needed for the exigencies of the time, not permanent spiritual manifestations needed throughout the age. "Prophecies" (verse 8) involved direct, on the spot revelations and declarations by the Spirit of the mysteries of grace for the early church now continued in the inspired, written Word (I Corinthians 14:26). The same was true of "knowledge." Prophecies and knowledge, both contemporary spiritual gifts, were meant to tide the church over an emergency (I Corinthians 12:7- 11), in no sense generalized prophecy or knowledge. The same was true of tongues.

e) The Alternatives: Both prophecies and knowledge, as incomplete, were to be superseded (verse 8) by "something complete." If that "something complete" is the coming of the Lord or the eternal state, then these supernatural gifts ought to still be in operation with direct inspiration in addition to the complete, perfect, all-sufficient revelation contained in the Bible. To argue that "prophecies" and "knowledge" are used, not of the supernatural act of the Holy Spirit, or of the temporary gifts, but as a result of such an act or gift eventuating in the written revelation, is gratuitous and removes the printed thrust of the apostle's argument. The terms were used exactly as they were in the lists in I Corinthians 12:8-11, 28 because the apostle was discussing this aspect of these gifts.

f) The Illustrations: The first, portraying of the infancy of the church in contrast to its maturity (verse 11) and the second, stressing seeing indistinctly through the metal mirror (of special prophecy, tongues and knowledge) in contrast to seeing distinctly ("face to face") in the completed written revelation, support the same conclusions. When the completed revelation had come, the apostle contrasts present learning bit by bit with full understanding, as he has all along been fully understood by God (verse12).

g) The Testimony of the rest of the scripture: If the apostle was referring to the Lord's coming as the point when prophecy shall be superseded, it would scarcely be an apt and pointed declaration. Christ's coming in glory with His glorified saints following the Rapture is predicted to be attended especially by a great resurgence of the prophetic gift and prophetic visions on the part of all unglorified humanity. "And it shall come to pass afterward, that I will pour out My spirit upon all flesh and your sons and your daughters shall prophesy, your old men shall dream dreams, your young men shall see visions" (Joel 2:28; Acts 2:17- 21).

h) The Meaning of I Corinthians 13:13: "So, 'now'; denoted not time, but 'as the situation was,' faith, hope, love, abide." Paul means they "remain permanently" for the age, not continue for eternity. He is dealing with the permanency of love (and faith and hope) for the church age over against the impermanency of certain of the miraculous gifts needed to authenticate Christianity and tide it over the period of partial revelation before the completed scriptures were received.

Those who teach tongues and prophecy in the New Testament church diametrically contradict the commandments given in Revelation 22:18. :For I testify to everyone who hears the words of the prophecy of this book; If anyone adds to these things, God will add to him the plagues that are written in this book."

Superiority of Prophecy to Tongues

Since the apostle Paul had declared the temporary character of tongues, prophecy, and knowledge in I Corinthians 13, it is of paramount importance to remember that he is treating both tongues and prophecy in chapter 14 as manifestations of the Spirit confined to the early church and to be superseded by the full New Testament revelation in I Corinthians 13:8-13.

In the first part of chapter 14, Paul discusses the superiority of prophecy over tongues in the apostolic assembly. The reasons he gives are set forth in verses 1-12.

First, Prophecy was superior to tongues because it was spiritually beneficial to others (I Corinthians 14:1-3). Prophecy in the early church was the only means of instructing believers in apostolic assemblies in the great doctrines newly recorded in permanent form in the New Testament, since the New Testament was not yet written and circulated. In a very definite sense, this gift was indispensable in the early church and being graced by love, had paramount importance.

Second, prophecy was selfless, outgoing, and was less liable to minister to spiritual ego and pride (I Corinthians 14:4). The sensational nature of speaking in tongues readily ministered to pride and empty conceit (I Corinthians 1:1-14:40). The same empty vanity, false spiritual pretension, and divisiveness is commonly manifested in the glossolalic movement today.

And third, prophecy was superior to tongues, except when the latter was made practically helpful to the church through the gift of interpretation (I Corinthians 14:5-9). When an interpreter was present and the message given in a language other than the vernacular, it was translated so that the church was instructed and edified, therefore, tongues rose to the status of being on a par with prophecy. Even then, the exercise of the gift was only a roundabout way of communicating the truths of grace to the church, which had not yet been given the New Testament scriptures. Prophecy performed the same function in a direct incisive manner.

The gift of interpretation (I Corinthians 12:10) enabled the early believer to translate tongues so that the latter had some practical value (verse 6). The believer who genuinely spoke in tongues by the Spirit would speak by "revelation," that is, direct, supernatural revelation of New Testament truth, not yet revealed to and written down by the Biblical writers. He also would speak by "knowledge," which was not knowledge from the Word by the Spirit's teaching ministry (John 16:12,13), but directly communicated knowledge to the gifted believer in the apostolic assembly, to make up for the absence of written revealed truth. He would also speak by "prophecy," that is, declare the revealed knowledge, all of which would be "instruction" for early Christians to tide them over the interim period until the New Testament would be written and become available. If the believer thus spoke in tongues, he could communicate this needed truth only through an interpreter.

The apostle enforced the need for interpretation of tongues in the early assemblies by the illustration of the distinction of sounds of musical instruments (verse 7). Unless musical instruments, such as the "flute" or "harp" produce "distinct" tones, how would listeners understand or differentiate between flute and harp?

The apostle also stressed the necessity of interpretation when tongues were manifested in the early church (verses 8 and 9).

Paul employed another illustration of the need of interpreting tongues. He referred to the many different "voices" or "languages" of the world, none of which was without meaning (verses 10, 11). In verse 12, the apostle summarized his whole argument on the superiority of prophecy over tongues.

Two criteria had guided the apostle in his discussion. Were tongues practical and useful? Were they constructive? In the early church, they could only be so because there existed, at that time, a need that they definitely met. But this need was only when there was an interpreter, and the early church was edified by the understanding of the spoken tongues.

Yet even under those circumstances, and at that time of need, prophecy and knowledge gave directly what tongues could give only indirectly when an interpreter was present. Today, there is no such need to be met, neither by tongues, nor prophecy. Accordingly, there is no place in the present church for either of these gifts - tongues, even with an interpreter present, or prophecy.

That was exactly why the apostle had given the directive in I Corinthians 13:8, "Love never fails. But whether there be prophecies, they shall be superseded (by the revealed New Testament scriptures), whether there be tongues, they shall cease (stop altogether because no longer needed, either with or without interpreter), whether there be knowledge, it shall be superseded (same word and for the same reason as prophecies)."

The Purpose of Tongues

To fail to see the temporary nature of tongues is to fail to evaluate the real purpose of the phenomenon. To maintain that tongues are a part of the church's heritage today is to attribute significance to a phenomenon that was not divinely intended to be manifested in post apostolic church history. The result of such a procedure is bound to result in both confusion of doctrine and erratic practice, which is so widely prevalent in the present day.

The purpose of tongues in the early church was outlined in I Corinthians 14:13-25. A survey of this passage will reveal the fact that, as a lesser or subsidiary gift, the purpose of tongues was very limited even in the apostolic assembly. Tongues in the early church had a very limited purpose in prayer (I Corinthians 14:13-17).

One who prayed either privately or publicly in a tongue was to "pray that he may interpret" (verse 13). The reason for this injunction was because praying in a tongue was not on a par with praying in one's own language that was understood. It involved limitation. "My spirit prays, but my understanding is unfruitful" (I Corinthians 14:14). "My mind (faculty of understanding or intellect) is unproductive" because it is inactive. The result is that neither self nor anyone else is enriched with divine truth or inspiration as a result of such praying. Although a believer might "speak to God" in a tongue (I Corinthians 14:2), even this was totally unnecessary because God was quite able to understand the believer in the believer's native language.

In the light of this very limited use of tongues in a prayer, the apostle states the answer in verse 15. In other words, "I will pray in my native language both to give and get the maximum blessing in prayer, rather than pray in tongues either privately or publicly and give or get limited blessing in prayer."

The apostle's conclusion on praying in tongues both publicly and privately is clearly that it was better to pray in one's native tongue than in some other language that was not understandable. The deduction is true despite the declaration in chapter 14 verse 2. "The mysteries" mentioned in this verse are New Testament revelations of truth now contained in the written scriptures, then not yet available. Tongues in the early church had a limited ministry of instruction (verses 18, 19).

Probably, it was in the sphere of preaching the gospel and instruction in New Testament mysteries as a pioneer missionary that the apostle said, "I thank my God, I speak with tongues more than you all" (verse 18). Since he did not exercise his gift in the public assembly (unless he interpreted what he said), it appears that he used it to preach and witness to people of various languages and dialects of the Greco-Roman world to whom he had a special ministry from God as the apostle to the Gentiles. By reading verse 19, we can understand that, indirectly, Paul suggests a very circumscribed use of tongues in the early church - the ministry of teaching or instructing.

In fact, to claim exercise of either the gift of prophecy or tongues in the church today is to suggest not only that the New Testament is not completed, but that revelations of truth in addition to the completed authoritative scriptures are necessary and desirable. Only cults hold such views.

It was to counteract the naive ignorance of those important implications to believers that Paul interjected a solemn warning, "Brethren, be not children in understanding (in your intellectual or mental comprehension of these things); however, in malice be ye children (be childishly naive), but in understanding (emphatic in the Greek) be men, be mature, grown up in intellectual comprehension, in contrast to children who are immature."

Tongues in the early church had a distinct use as a sign to the Jews (I Corinthians 14:20-25). Tongues were a sign that the Jews (and not Gentiles) needed to be divinely assured of; namely, that the legal or mosaic age had passed away forever. It was really very hard for Jews to believe this stupendous and earth-shaking change that they required clear proof that such a new economy had begun. Tongues as a sign was never given to the Gentiles. They did not need such a sign as the Jews did, since they had no dispensational hurdle from mosaic legalism to grace in Christ to clear. Read verse 23.

Verse 23

Wildfire and fanaticism, often characteristic of glossolalic movements, are not the result of the Holy Spirit's working but of alien spirits. It must be remembered that these spirits which are not of God (I John 4:2) energize the false prophets of this world (I John 4:1). Unless God's true prophets are wary, they may, to a greater or lesser degree, come under the control of these evil intrusive spirits or demons (I Timothy 4:1-6). This is especially true in glossolalic circles where the word of God is so widely misunderstood and the truth is not available to the untaught or ill-taught so that they do not rely upon it as the only sure guarantee and protection against satanic deception and demonic despoilment.

Devotees of charismatic manifestations may be utterly sincere and dedicated servants of God, but sincerity and dedication do not shield them from satanic attack, if the truth of God is garbled, and the armor of sound teaching is not put on to quench all the fiery darts of the devil (Ephesians 6:10-20; I Timothy 4:1). Many believers also fail to see the significance of what is meant by "doctrines of demons." Many confine the term to blatant infidelity that denies the deity of our Lord or His efficacious atonement, or unbelief that rejects the full inspiration of the scriptures as in liberalism or neo-orthodoxy. These and kindred denials of the word of God are assuredly "doctrines of demons."

But many of the Lord's people do not see that numerous doctrinal errors associated with glossolalia are just as much "doctrines of demons" as the teaching of liberals and neo-orthodox theologians. Satan takes advantage of God's professing people whether their error is deliberate or naive, or whether it is the result of ignorance or incompetent teaching. It follows, then, that teaching and practices not sanctioned by the word of God open the door to satanic intrusion and demonic confusion. For example, "tarrying for the Holy Spirit" is a popular error associated with the modern charismatic revival. It is based on doctrinal ignorance of the fact that the Holy Spirit came at Pentecost and has been resident in the church - the body of Christ and within each individual believer - ever since. Moreover, in encouraging believers to seek something not sanctioned by the word of God and in often condoning passive throwing of themselves open to spiritual forces, such unsound teaching and practices lead to demon intrusion, gross confusion, or what is still worse, actual demon influence, if not in some extreme cases, demon possession.

The present day church needs to be warned against the powerful role of Satan and demons in cultism and the hold evil spirits may get over even God's genuine saints when they fall prey to false doctrine and follow teachings and practices contrary to the sound interpretation of God's word (I Timothy 4:1-5; I John 4:1-6; Revelations 16:13-16).

To take another example, the apostle in discussing the subject of speaking in tongues doctrinally (I Corinthians 12:1-14:20), most clearly teaches that the phenomenon would cease or stop altogether when "the completed and final thing" - the New Testament revelation - would be consummated (I Corinthians 13:8-13). To gloss over this and espouse the manifestation of tongues in the church today, claiming that I Corinthians 14 regulates such manifestations, is to fly in the face of God's revealed truth and to court many perils and irregularities. In fact, in ignoring, explaining away, or rejecting the witness of the Word on this important point, modern charismatic movements expose their adherents to every type of demonic delusion and disorder.

In the apostolic assembly, women were to remain silent in church services and not engage in tongues or prophecy (I Corinthians 14:34-36).

In Greek cities of the first century, female publicity suggested loose morals. The irregularity and confusion in the exercise of spiritual gifts in the Corinthian Church was due to a lack of modesty and restraint on the part of the women members. Today, in glossolalic circles, women have taken an unscriptural position of leadership in violation of clear Biblical teaching. The result has been extremely harmful. Numerous, well known examples in the twentieth century revival of tongues could be cited, the most notorious perhaps being the case of Aimee Semple McPherson of Los Angeles, California, whose sensational career ended in tragedy. In churches that practice tongues, women evangelists and pastors are common. Much disorder has resulted.

Reflecting upon the fact that the Corinthian church on these matters had acted at variance with the practice of other churches and in a manner that assumed independence of his apostolic authority, the apostle asks, "Or did the word of God come forth (originate) from you or did it come to you alone?" (verse 36).

The apostle, therefore, inquires of the Corinthians with something of sarcastic indignation whether they were the source from whence God's word came or whether they consider themselves its sole recipient, that they should set themselves above the other assemblies and above God.

The same spirit of arrogant pride against sound Bible teaching is widely manifested in charismatic movements today. Being unscriptural, the movement tends to engender the same spirit of insubordination to the Word.

Many promoters of the revival of glossolalia today act as if the word of God originated with them or that they are its sole recipients. It is common for these assemblies to set themselves above other sound churches and above apostolic regulation. They tend to pride themselves in thinking they have so much more truth and power than churches that do not practice tongues. Conceit is one of the common sad results of glossolalic error. It is often coupled with a spirit of defiance of plain scriptural regulations of doctrine and conduct.

Paul strikes upon a note so frequently abused in charismatic movements when he says, "If anyone considers or thinks himself spiritual" that is, "filled with and controlled by the Spirit." Adherents of glossolalia consider speaking in languages as a sign of deeper spiritual experience. But nothing could be further from the truth. Indian fakirs, Muslim dervishes and spiritistic mediums speak in tongues by spirits not of God (I John 4:1-4). Even speaking in tongues by the spirit of God was not a sign of spirituality as the carnality of the Corinthian believers attests (I Corinthians 3:1-4). The apostle lays down a test of true spirituality. Let the spiritual believer acknowledge and admit that the injunctions he is laying down are the "commandment" of the Lord. Let there be no arrogant self sufficiency or proud reliance upon some experience. Let the inspired word of God have the place of supreme authority and command absolute submission and loyalty.

Here is where glossolalic movements go seriously astray. Alleged experiences are placed above the word of God. The Word is construed to fit the experience, rather than the experience tested in the light of the Word. If the modern charismatic revival would let the word of God speak first, scripturally unsanctioned experiences would not be sought after in the first place. In the second place, such experiences would be evaluated drastically by the Word.

The modern charismatic revival needs sound doctrine based on the common laws of hermeneutics and Bible exegesis.

Up to the recent revivals of glossolalia among the more educated groups in the main-line denominations, charismatic manifestations have been confined mostly to the uneducated and uncultured strata of society. Charismatic preachers have been, except in rare cases, untrained in sound exegesis and in the Biblical languages. They have lacked the tools of learning that the Holy Spirit could use to make them competent teachers to lead their people out of sincere but palpable misconceptions of truth.

Such ideas as "tarrying for the Holy Spirit," "second-blessing sanctification," "the baptism of the Spirit" as an experience subsequent to salvation, "receiving one's Pentecost," and similar unsound tenets are espoused because the uneducated leadership is unequipped in the light of the fine distinctions of the original languages and in the context of sound exegetical principles.

Those that have practiced tongues in the modern era, like Joseph Smith, have at least been consistent in also resurrecting "prophecy" and insisting upon new prophetic revelations in addition to scripture (like the book of Mormon). Those like the Irvingites (and the Mormons also), have with equal logic, resurrected the office of the apostle.

A Brief History of Tongues

Glossolalia has not enjoyed wide publicity until recent times. Speaking in tongues had no significant place in the post-apostolic church, AD 100-400. The early fathers referred infrequently to the gift of tongues.

The earliest clear evidence for glossolalia after the New Testament era concerns Montanus, a converted priest of a Phrygian mystery cult, and two of his followers. According to the description of Apollinaris, Bishop of Hierapolis (AD 170), Montanus "became beside himself, and being suddenly in a sort of frenzy and ecstasy, he began to babble and utter strange things, prophesying in a manner contrary to the constant custom of the church."

The silence of all church fathers concerning tongues cannot lightly be dismissed. These early leaders represent a wide geographical area. They wrote doctrinally and purposefully, and often with a corrective emphasis. Had the phenomenon been normal manifestation continued from New Testament times, they would certainly have mentioned it.

Justin Martyr (100-167 AD), who traveled widely as a Christian teacher, makes no mention of tongues, although he does claim that "the prophetical gifts" were found among Christians, by which he must have meant the ability to declare the revealed content of scripture with power.

Irenaeus (130-195 AD), Bishop of Lyons in Gaul and one of the most distinguished teachers of the Ante- Nicene Church, asserted that he had "heard of many in the church who allegedly 'through the Spirit, speak all kinds of languages.'" He is doubtlessly referring to the heretical Montanists, a sect characterized by a distorted doctrine of the Holy Spirit and an unhealthy stress on visions and emotional prophetism. This ill-balanced movement, strong in Asia Minor, also had a strong influence at Lyons, where Irenaeus labored.

Eusebius gives a clear statement of the excesses of Montanus, who he says was "carried away in spirit, and was excited into a certain kind of frenzy and irregular ecstasy, raving and speaking, and uttering strange things and proclaiming what was contrary to the institutions that had prevailed in the church."

Their unsoundness, like modern charismatic movements, moreover centered in the doctrine of the spirit, the spiritual gifts, and an unhealthy prophetism.

Tertullian (155-202 AD), of North Africa, like Irenaeus, came under Montanist influence, and describes some of the excesses of the emotional and unsound movement. He mentions tongues, but merely as an apostolic manifestation, not as a phenomenon of his time.

Origen (185-254 AD), in all his voluminous writings, gives no hint that tongues were a normal manifestation in his day or that the signs and manifestations of the early church had continued in his time. Likewise, Chrysostom (347-407 AD), the great exegete and preacher, in dealing with the spiritual gifts of I Corinthians (chapters 12-14), confesses that the whole passage is "very obscure," but adds, "the obscurity is produced by our ignorance of the facts referred to and by their cessation, being such as then used to occur, but now no longer take place." This is a clear statement that tongues and other miraculous manifestations had stopped altogether by the end of the fourth century even in erratic fringe groups. Augustine also dismissed the practice as a thing of the past. "These were sign adapted to the time," he observed in his exposition of I John 3:24.

The long drought

From the early fifth century through the entire medieval era, evidences for tongue speaking are scanty at best. The claim about Francis Xavier (1506-1552) speaking in Indian languages has no historical truth. Throughout his letters, Xavier stressed the difficulties he had communicating with different tribes. He tried numerous approaches - translating some of the main church formulas into the language after he had learned enough of the language to do this, getting help from others to patch together some doctrinal statements to be memorized. He used various techniques using interpreters, mixing various dialects, or even using signs. Xavier's "gift of tongues" was apparently not mentioned until his canonization under Urban VIII (1623-1644), almost a century after his death.

After this, the legend grew. By 1872, the Jesuit Father Coleridge could sum up Xavier's Japanese ministry by saying, "He spoke freely, flowing, and elegantly as if he had lived in Japan all his life. The complete inaccuracy of this statement has been demonstrated more recently by a Jesuit scholar, Father George Schurhammer, who attributed the legend to the imagination of two unreliable witnesses in the beatification process. As we look back over the first sixteen centuries of Christian history, then, we have to reaffirm our conclusion that they were lean years for tongue speaking.

The reformation period gives no evidence of the continuance of speaking in tongues in the church. In the seventeenth to the nineteenth centuries, there were two noteworthy outbursts of tongues speaking, one in France, and the other in England. Besides these, the phenomenon also seems to have accompanied the revival movements of the same area. At Cevennes, France, the so-called "little prophets" arose in the last few years of the eighteenth century. Youngsters three years old and upward are claimed to have preached in flawless French, accompanied by high emotional faintings and swoonings which were prominent.

The second major outburst of tongues occurred in England during the nineteenth century. Edward Irving (1792-1834) was the leading light. He was an able preacher of the Church of Scotland who preached to large audiences in London from 1822 until he was deposed from the Church of Scotland in 1833 because of unsound views on Christ's humanity and his belief in the continuance of the gifts of prophecy, healing, tongues, and the order of apostles. Early Methodism also had some experience with extraordinary spiritual phenomena, especially in Northern England and Wales.

The positive attitude of Wesley toward spiritual gifts paved the way for modern Pentecostalism, for the modern day movement had its roots in the revivals of the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries in America. The great awakening and subsequent revivals produced some unusual byproducts, of which tongue speaking was undoubtedly one. Spirited preaching, singing, physical movement, and the demand for a tangible display of the receiving of the Spirit worked together to create astounding physical demonstrations. Barking, violent jerking, shrieking and shouting, wild dancing, fainting and the like were common and still continue.

Important in considering the manifestation of tongues on the eve of the modern charismatic revival, two groups must be credited for early occurrences, namely, the Mormons of Joseph Smith and the Shakers. Joseph Smith espoused tongues, prophecies, visions, and revelations. The book of Mormon was the result. To him, tongues signaled the reception of the Holy Spirit, which furnished the entree for his visions. The character of these revelations and the demonic nature of Mormonism sufficiently demonstrate the dangers of this procedure.

Similar manifestations occurred among the Shakers, notably in the case of the founder of this sect, "Mother" Ann Lee, who made the claim that she could speak in seventy-two languages. Tongues were rampant among this group, with hilarious dancing and high-pitch emotionalism displayed.

The latter rain

In the twentieth century, the Pentecostal showers of an earlier day have given way to a steady rain, first in the founding of the Pentecostal churches, and more recently in its development in other denominations, especially the Roman Catholic Church.

Reasons for Pentecostal movement

In essence, the Pentecostal movement developed as a partial reaction to the increase of secularism and the subsequent waning of revivalism following the Civil War. Its immediate ancestor was the holiness or perfectionist movement within Methodism, occasioned by a controversy over John Wesley's doctrine of sanctification.

Wesley had much to say about sanctification; in fact, it was one of the keystones in his theology. He taught the "progressive sanctification" of believers, that is, their gradual growth toward perfection. However, he conceded also to some of his followers that the Christian can attain perfection in love, even while he lives, citing I John 4:17. At the same time, he insisted, contrary to those who rejected out of hand the doctrine of "entire sanctification," that, "we should expect to be saved from all sin before the article of death." This uncertainty in Wesley's thought opened the way for later debate. Some Methodists stressed the doctrine of "entire sanctification," that is, the immediate and complete perfection of love in the believer, and organized revivals designed to lead to it. By 1867, this movement had gained such a large following as to alarm Methodist leaders.

Between 1880 and 1900, Methodists split into holiness and anti-holiness factions. The holiness groups gradually separated from the Methodist Church.

The Pentecostal churches

In the wake of this turmoil, the Pentecostal movement also began. It was related to, but not the same as, the holiness movement. Both, of course, were concerned about sanctification. Holiness groups stressed complete perfection or entire sanctification. The Pentecostals stressed charismatic gifts.

Several Pentecostal revivals accompanied the United States just after the turn of the twentieth century. In the minds of the early adherents, the incidence of these in their day fulfilled the prophecy of Joel 2:23 concerning the "latter rain."

The "latter rain" fell first in Topeka, Kansas, 1901. The movement took shape around the founder and leader of Bethel Bible College, Charles F Parham. On New Year's Day, 1901, the "baptism of the Spirit" fell first upon Miss Agnes N. Ozman, a student in the college, who claimed to speak several languages. Parham's baptism came on January 3rd, along with that of other students. Filled with new zeal, Bethel students set out to evangelize Kansas and to share their newly found power. By 1903, the movement reached into Missouri and Texas. Parham himself opened a Bible school in Houston, Texas in 1905.

In 1906, the "latter rain" hit Los Angeles. The movement began to take on international proportions.

From Los Angeles, the Pentecostal movement spread to Chicago, New York, and elsewhere in the USA and Canada. Before the end of 1906, there were Pentecostals also in Kerala, India, Norway and Sweden.

Constituency Pentecostalism has drawn its greatest following from the masses, the lower economic and social strata with limited education. Recently, the situation has changed considerably. One can cite among its strongest proponents some from higher economic, social, and cultural levels. They have a grip on the leadership of the masses. The present Pentecostal movement among non-Pentecostals covers a wide economic, social, and cultural range.

Factionalism is a common trait of Pentecostal movements. Many modern cults have its roots in Pentecostal movements.

Fertile ground for the growth

It is an observable fact that where sound and able Bible teaching and preaching are conducted, the phenomenon of tongues does not occur. It is only in circles where scripture is not competently expounded by teachers qualified on both spiritual and academic levels that the phenomenon is evidenced. This fact is not only true today, but has been true during the centuries of church history since the close of the apostolic age when the miraculous gifts, having discharged their temporary functions, died out.

In tongue movements, alleged experience and emotional excitement have attempted to be a substitute for accurate teaching and clear exposition of the scripture. The result has been that the word of God has been interpreted on the basis of human experience instead of experience being interpreted on the basis of the word of God. Experience must be relentlessly conformed to "what does God say?"

rather than "what does my experience lead me to believe?"

Tongues today run the risk of inviting demonic deception and despoiling. In "tarrying" for the Holy Spirit; when He came over two thousand years ago, seeking to receive Him who already dwells within them if they are true believers; sincere, but ill-taught saints forget that they can come under "spirits" who are "not from God" (I John 4:1- 3). There are evil spirits or demons that have an important role in perverting the truth of God and producing "doctrines of demons," that is, "teaching inspired and originated by evil spirits." Compare I Timothy 4:1 to I Kings 22:13-28 and Revelation 16:13-16). Tongues can and are counterfeited by demon spirits. It is evidenced by the fact that spiritistic mediums, at Muslim and Hindu festivals show many that speak in tongues and perform miracles. Ancient Greek and Roman pagan prophetesses spoke in tongues.

If glossolalia today are not explainable by demon power, it may be due to psychological suggestion or psychosomatic manifestations produced under high emotional excitability. Much of what parades as an ecstatic utterance, supposedly evidencing a deeper spiritual experience, is mere gibberish produced by auto suggestion under great emotional stress and a strong desire for a tongues experience. This experience is often desperately sought with a predominant motive of attaining spiritual status within the group. No wonder the revival of tongues in the twentieth century has not been a "latter rain," but a doctrinal fog, productive of much confusion, division, carnality, and immaturity within the church.

Section Two