Chapter 6 of 14
The Gift of Tongues
Throughout the history of the church, no spiritual gift has occasioned as much continual controversy as the gift of tongues. Many solutions have been offered to the problem of the nature of this gift, but every one has some difficulties.
The modern revival of speaking in tongues has focused attention upon the importance of the second chapter of Acts. No part of God's word has received more prominence in the present day excitement over the gifts of the Spirit; neither has any part been so commonly misunderstood. In fact, a correct understanding of this pivotal passage is basic to any serious study of biblical teaching on tongues. Error and inaccuracy here are bound to be reflected in faulty doctrine and unsound interpretations elsewhere in dealing with relevant scripture passages.
The paramount issue, therefore, to all who honor the Word and place it above alleged experience, is what the key significance of Acts 2 is.
What precisely does Pentecost mean? What bearing does it have on the modern charismatic revival movement? Does Pentecost teach a crisis experience of power subsequent to salvation? Do speaking in tongues have anything to do with enjoying such an experience?
Pentecost signifies the coming of the Holy Spirit from heaven to take up His residence upon the earth in the newly formed church. Jesus told of this occasion in John 14:16-18 and John 16:7, 8, 13. These prophecies of our Lord unquestionably had Pentecost in view and were fulfilled in the event of that great day. How unscriptural, therefore, in the light of this truth, to "tarry" or wait for the Holy Spirit to come when he has already arrived? How irrational for a regenerated believer to expect Him to come upon him or enter into him, when the spirit of God already permanently indwells his redeemed body (I Corinthians 6:19; Romans 8:9), and is promised never to leave him (John 14:16-18; Galatians 3:2, 14)?
Pentecost portrays a once and for all, unrepeated, and unrepeatable event. Pentecost is as unrepeatable as the creation of the world or of man; it is as once for all as was the incarnation, and the death and resurrection of Christ. The spirit of God could only come and take up His residence in the church once, which He did at Pentecost. The event occurred at a specific time (Acts 2:1). The verb translated "was fully come" literally means "was fulfilled." It is a word which is used to describe an event which takes place according to God's own timing; like the birth of Christ (Galatians 4:4) and the death of Christ (Luke 9:51). Pentecost was the divine plan of God and took place according to His own predetermined time.
The claims
All the various factional Pentecostal groups have essentially the same view toward "speaking in tongues." This is the one thing that gives unity and coherence to this movement. Their beliefs:
First, there is an experience called the "baptism with the Holy Spirit" which comes after conversion. This spirit baptism bestows power for life and service, and every believer should earnestly seek it. Second, the one initial outward sign, or evidence, that a person has received this spirit baptism, is speaking with other tongues. Third, the modern manifestation of tongues is identical with the biblical gift. And fourth, though the gift of tongues may be used to benefit the congregation, its primary purpose is to give the individual speaker some tangible evidence that he is spirit-filled, and to build him up in his Christian life. It is very common, for example, to hear tongue-speakers refer to tongues as a prayer language. In short, modern tongue-speakers claim that their tongues experience is a genuine work of God and is an exceedingly precious and valuable experience.
Tongues in the Gospel of Mark
Only three books of the Bible make any reference to tongue speaking: Mark 16:17-20; Acts 2:1-13; 10:44-48; 19:1-6, and I Corinthians 12-14. The only reference to speaking in tongues in the Four Gospels is found in Mark 16:17-20. Modern tongue-speakers make much of the importance of the teaching of this passage. The promise of Jesus that tongues will accompany those who believe is taken as exclusive proof that God intended for tongues to remain in the church. They believe that if there is an absence of tongues, it is an evidence of a lack of faith.
What are we to make of this reference to tongues in Mark? To begin with, there is a real question about the genuineness of Mark 16:9-20. Some of the ancient manuscripts of the New Testament do not include these verses as part of Mark's Gospel. However, let us assume that the passage is genuine. What then does it teach about tongues? First, tongues are spoken of here as a sign and not as a gift or experience. There is no hint of a mystical, ecstatic experience. Tongues are mentioned as one of five other signs, and no one would speak of "taking up serpents" or drinking poison as a gift or experience.
Second, tongues are mentioned as only one of five other signs. It is not sound biblical interpretation to focus on one of these signs to the exclusion of the others. According to this passage, tongues are no more important than any other signs.
Third, these signs are said to accompany the believers as a whole and not to every individual believer. It is important to note that there is a change from the singular in verse 16 to the plural in verse 17. The meaning is clear. Every single individual must believe if he is to be saved, but the signs are not necessarily given to every individual believer. This means that all the signs in verses 17 and 18 were never intended to come to pass in the experience of every believer. They were given to the church collectively.
This idea, is verified by the record in Acts. The presence of these signs was limited to a select few in the book of Acts. There was no record, for example, of anyone in the book of Acts performing a miracle, except the apostles (Acts 2:43, 4:33), and those upon whom the apostle laid their hands, such as Stephen (Acts 6:8) and Philip (Acts 8:5, 6). Besides, if the passage teaches that all these signs are to be present in the experience of every believer, then "the snake handling" cults are given biblical support to the same degree that speaking in tongues is supported.
The purpose of the signs was to confirm the message of the believers. They were not given as proof of a special kind of faith. Mark 16:19, 10 states that the disciples went forth and preached, and the Lord confirmed "the word with signs following." Modern tongue-speakers claim, on the basis of Mark 16:17, that the absence of tongues is a sign of deficient faith.
There is no hint in this passage that tongues are to be an evidence of the spirit-baptism or any other kind of superior or deeper spiritual experience. The Holy Spirit is not even mentioned in this context. Tongues are never mentioned in the Gospels in connection with the Holy Spirit's work. Matthew 3:11, Mark 1:8, Luke 3:16, and John 1:33 all refer to the "baptism with the spirit," but not one gives any hint that tongues would accompany this experience. In addition, Luke gives several examples of people being filled with the spirit without any mention of tongue speaking (1:15, 41, 67; 2:25; 4:1).
What then, may be concluded about tongues from this passage in Mark? The most that can be claimed is that tongues were to be one of several signs given to the church to confirm the word of God. This passage cannot be used to support the emphasis which Pentecostals and Neo- Pentecostals place on tongue speaking as the evidence of spirit-baptism. Neither can it be used to support tongues as a gift to be sought for personal edification.
Tongues in Acts
The second book in the New Testament which mentions tongue speaking is Acts (2:1-13; 10:44-48; 19:1-7).
Acts 2:1-13 the first and best-known occurrence of tongue speaking is found in the historical account of Pentecost. From it, modern Pentecostalism derives its name and its special doctrine of spirit-baptism as a post-conversion crisis experience, which is evidenced by speaking in tongues. The supernatural fire and the sound of a rushing, mighty wind (Acts 2:2, 3), are commonly neglected of in the present day excitement over tongues.
If Pentecost is repeatable, in regards to tongues, then why not in the accompanying features of a rushing, mighty wind and the tongues as of fire, dividing and sitting upon each of those claiming to have a repetition of Pentecostal blessing?
No where does this passage indicate that the disciples expected, sought, or prayed for the tongues experience. On the contrary, the whole account indicates that tongues were totally unexpected and unsought.
The most important single factor to keep in mind is the historical uniqueness of Pentecost. Luke states in Acts 2:1, when the day of Pentecost was fully come. The Holy Spirit came as a gift of God and not as a result of the efforts of man. It was the historic day on which the Spirit was given to all believers.
Pentecost should then be viewed in the same light as Calvary. As Christ died once (Hebrews 9:26), so the Spirit has been poured out upon all believers once. Both are unique and unrepeatable events. Both events were authenticated by three miracles each. At Calvary, there were the miracles of darkness (Matthew 27:45): the renting of the Veil (v. 51), and the earthquake (v.51). At Pentecost, there were the miracles of the sound of wind, tongues of fire, and speaking in other tongues. When by faith a person accepts what Christ did for him on the cross, he need not expect the repetition of the three miracles that took place at Calvary. Likewise, when by faith we share in the outpoured Spirit, we need not expect the repetition of the three miracles that accompanied Pentecost.
Baptism of the Holy Spirit
The baptism with the Holy Spirit has been differently understood by many believers. For one thing, the term "baptism of the Holy Spirit" is greatly abused, and it is not found in the word of God.
There are only seven passages in the New Testament which speak directly of the baptism with the Spirit. Five of these passages refer to the baptism with the Spirit as a future event; four were spoken by John the Baptist (Matthew 3:11; Mark 1:7, 8; Luke 3:16; John 1:33); and one was spoken by Jesus after His resurrection (Acts 1:4, 5). A sixth passage looks back to the events and experiences of the day of Pentecost (Acts 11:15-17) as fulfilling the promises spoken by John the Baptist and Jesus. Only one passage - I Corinthians 12:13 - speaks about the wider experience of all believers. In fact, the word "baptize," with reference to the Spirit, is never used in recounting the story of Pentecost, of Samaria, of Caesarea, of Ephesus, or of anywhere else. This is amazing.
However what is more astonishing is that we are never told, commanded, or urged to seek the baptism of the Holy Spirit. The idea is alien to scripture. Some seek, pray, and wait for such an experience. They are persuaded that God has reserved for a chosen few that unusual baptism. They expectantly, prayerfully, and sometimes agonizingly wait before the Lord for this heavenly gift. Some even build whole systems of theology upon it, presenting it in their teaching as a second work of grace.
The Baptism by the Spirit in the Gospels and the Epistles
When we seek the scriptural truth concerning any such baptism of the Holy Spirit, we cannot find it in the gospels. There, such an experience is not referred to except in John's prophecy (Matthew 3:11). Neither is the doctrine discussed in the book of Acts. There again, the subject is not referred to except in the mention of John's prophecy (Acts 1:5; 11:16). It is in the epistles that the doctrine is unfolded. This is not an accident. It is according to the purpose of God.
As we turn to the epistles, a multitude of questions crowds our minds. What is the baptism of the Holy Spirit? When did it happen? When does it happen today? Who is the baptizer? Into what does the Holy Spirit baptize? What are the results?
Who is the baptizer and with what does He baptize? In Matthew 3:11, Acts 1:5, and 11:16, the prophecy of John the Baptist is presented. Jesus is unmistakably the baptizer and it could be that the Holy Spirit is the sphere into which He baptizes. But in the epistles, in I Corinthians 12:13, the Holy Spirit is the baptizer and the body of Christ is the sphere into which He baptizes. "For by one Spirit we were all baptized into one body" (I Corinthians 12:13). Are there, then, two different baptisms, one by the Lord Jesus and one by the Holy Spirit? We might think so, but for the fact that the same Greek phrase is used to describe both baptisms, “en pneumati.” Can we build two separate doctrines of the baptism of the Holy Spirit on the same Greek phrase and on the same Greek preposition?
Many people do so. These dualists interpret the Greek preposition "en" used in Acts 1:5 in a location sense, meaning a baptism into the sphere of the Holy Spirit. They interpret the same Greek preposition "en" used in I Corinthians 12:13 in an instrumental sense, meaning a baptism into the sphere of the body of Christ. The "en"
employed in I Corinthians 12:13 is clearly and only instrumental. The baptizer is the Holy Spirit; it is He who does the baptizing.
But what of the prophecy of John the Baptist in Matthew 3:11 where Jesus is clearly presented as the baptizer? In what sense is He the baptizer? In answering this question, we find the answer as to why Spirit baptism is not discussed in the gospels. The gospel presents pre-ascension events (John 7:39). Before there can be a spirit baptism, there must be an atonement made on earth for our sins and a justification declared in heaven for our souls. Before the Spirit can be poured out, Christ must be put to death, raised from the grave, and must ascend into heaven. Water baptism is that in picture; the Holy Spirit is that in fact and reality (Romans 6:3-5; Colossians 2:12). After the gospels comes the ascension, then the gift (John 16:7; Ephesians 4:8). The coming of the Holy Spirit at Pentecost is the ascension gift of our Lord to His church.
In this sense, is Christ the baptizer? He was the Giver of the original ascension gift. He sent the paraclete to take His place. But after the Spirit's advent, the Spirit, and not Christ, is spoken of as the baptizer. In all instances and in all experiences, Christ is the ultimate source or agent in the baptism by the Spirit, as Matthew 3:11 prophesies, Christ sent the Spirit.
The Time of the Baptism by the Spirit
We turn now to the question, when past or present does the baptism occur? John the Baptist, in Matthew 3:11 announced the reality as something beyond himself and his ministry. Jesus in the flesh (John 14:16, 26) spoke of it as a future event. In Acts 1:5, Jesus, raised from the dead, but not ascended, referred to the gift as immediately coming.
Acts 11:16 speaks of the baptism as having already taken place. The fulfillment of the promise clearly occurred at Pentecost and continued thereafter, joining both Jesus and Gentiles to the body of Christ. This baptism of the Holy Spirit is the new departure at Pentecost. The baptism of the Spirit places believers in the body of Christ, the church.
Ten days after Christ’s ascension, Pentecost dawned. The Holy Spirit came on 120 disciples. Although the other 3000 people who were also present did not seem to have experienced the same miraculous phenomena (the rushing mighty wind, the tongues of flame, or the speech in foreign languages), they also received the Holy Spirit (verses 33 and 39). The 120 were regenerated already and received the baptism of the Spirit only after waiting for 10 days. The 3000 on the other hand, were unbelievers, and received the forgiveness of their sins and the gift of the Spirit simultaneously, and it happened immediately when they repented and believed.
This distinction between the two companies, the 120 and the 3000, is of great importance, because the norm for today must surely be the second group, the 3000, and not the first. The fact that the experience of the 120 was in two distinct stages was due simply to historical circumstances. But those historical circumstances have long since ceased to exist. We live after the event of Pentecost, like the 3000. With us, therefore, as with them, the forgiveness of sins and the gift or baptism of the Spirit are received together.
From that day onward, the Holy Spirit has lived in the hearts of all true believers, beginning with the 120 disciples who received Him at Pentecost.
Exceptions explained
All believers have the Holy Spirit, who comes to dwell with them at the time of their regeneration or conversion.
The first passage is found in Acts 8:5, where Philip's trip to Samaria is recounted. Philip preached Christ and performed miracles. The Samaritans were emotionally stirred. Many of them professed faith and were baptized. The apostles in Jerusalem were so concerned about what was happening in Samaria that they sent two of their leaders, Peter and John, to investigate. They found a great stir and readiness to receive the Holy Spirit. "Then they had began laying their hands on them, and they were receiving the Holy Spirit" (Acts 8:17).
As we compare scripture with scripture, we immediately discover one extraordinary feature in this passage: when Philip preached in Samaria, it was the first time the gospel had been proclaimed outside Jerusalem, evidently because Samaritans and Jews had always been bitter enemies. This gives us the clue to the reason the Spirit was withheld until Peter and John came: it was so they might see for themselves that God received even hated Samaritans who believed in Christ. There could now be no question of it.
Notice too what happened when the Spirit of the Lord suddenly removed Philip, taking him down to Gaza, where the Ethiopian believed and received Christ and he was baptized with water. But at no time did Philip lay hands on him and pray for him to receive the Holy Spirit, nor was anything said about a second baptism. Thus, the situation in Samaria, as recounted in Acts 8, was unique and does not fit with other passages of scripture as we compare scripture with scripture.
Another passage that gives some people difficulty deals with the conversion of Saul on the road to Damascus as recorded in Acts 9. Some say that when he was later filled with the Spirit in the presence of Ananias (verse 17), he experienced a second baptism of the Spirit.
When Saul called Jesus "Lord," he used a term which means "my very own Lord," signifying his immediate conversion. Saul knew that a supernatural person was dealing with him. Some say the term simply means "sir," a title of respect rather than a confession of faith. But in Acts 9:6, Saul, asking, "Lord, what do you want me to do?" indicates an immediate obedience and conversion.
He did not speak in tongues here. Furthermore, Acts 9:17 says that Paul was to be filled with the Holy Spirit. The verse does not use the word baptism, and when he was filled, it does not say he spoke in other tongues.
Confusion about Baptism of the Holy Spirit
There is an improper understanding of the distinctiveness of the church in this age. This leads to confusion about the baptizing work of the Holy Spirit, which forms the church. If one believes that the church began with Abraham or with John the Baptist, then it would be difficult to understand the distinctiveness of the baptism of the Spirit in this age, and what that baptism accomplishes.
There is an overbalance on the doctrine of water baptism, which often obscures the doctrine of Spirit baptism. If the two truths are not distinguished, it is usually the truth of Spirit baptism that is lost, for it is regarded simply as another way of talking about water baptism.
The association of baptism with the gift of tongues multiplies confusion. Of course, if speaking with tongues is the evidence of the baptism of the Holy Spirit, then the baptism does not come at the time of salvation, nor is it experienced by all Christians. Some, to justify the association of baptism with tongues, attempt to make a distinction between the baptism by the spirit of I Corinthians 12:13, which places one into the body of Christ, and the baptism with the Spirit of Acts 1:5, which brings tongues. However, in both verses, the baptism is described as "en pneumati," and it would seem risky, at best, to build two separate doctrines on exactly the same phrase.
Baptism is frequently identified with filling of the Spirit. Sometimes, the terms "baptism" and "filling" are confused, while at other times, the same error is stated by asserting that the baptism does not come at the time of regeneration, but as subsequent work of grace. Confusion is compounded by the fact that great men, like Torrey and Moody were unclear on this issue.
- R.A. Torrey. The Baptism with the Holy Spirit. pp. 13- 14
- R.A. Torrey. Why God Used D.L. Moody. (NY Fleming H. Revell Co.) c. 1923, pp.
51-55
3. Ibid, p. 55
Torrey taught that a person could or could not be baptized with the Spirit at the moment of regeneration. The baptism, as a subsequent work of grace in Moody's life, is recounted in his biography.
The confusion prevailing in the treatment of this doctrine has its rise in many factors. The principal cause is the failure to apprehend the distinctive nature of the church. The baptizing work of the Spirit is the one work of the Spirit which is not found in any other dispensation. Many theologians regard the church as a universal group of saints of all ages, some extending even these boundaries to include nominal Christians. Theologically, we can see the proof based on I Corinthians 12:13, "For by one Spirit we are all baptized into one body, whether we be Jews or Gentiles, whether we be bond or free; and have been all made to drink into one Spirit."
It is the baptizing work of the Spirit that places a believer into the body of Christ; is distinctive to this age, then so is the baptism. Biblically, the baptizing work is never mentioned as being experienced in the Old Testament or in the days of Christ's earthly ministry. This phenomena is also not mentioned in the millennium period. It is peculiarly the work of the Holy Spirit for the present age, beginning with Pentecost and ending with the resurrection of the righteous, when the living church is translated into Heaven.
In all, there are eleven specific references to spiritual baptism in the New Testament: Matthew 3:11; Mark 1:8; Luke 3:16; John 1:33; Acts 1:5, 11:16; Romans 6:1-4; I Corinthians 12:13; Galatians 3:27; Ephesians 4:5; Colossians 2:12. All references prior to Pentecost are prophetic. The major passage which may be taken as the basis of interpretation of the other passages is I Corinthians 12:13.
Baptism of the Holy Spirit Universal among Christians
Salvation and baptism are coextensive. Scripture makes it plain that every Christian is baptized by the Holy Spirit at the moment of salvation. Salvation and baptism are therefore coextensive, and it is impossible to be saved without this work of the Holy Spirit.
A serious departure from the truth is found in the attempt by some of the holiness movements to link the baptism of the Spirit with certain temporary spiritual gifts and their exercise. The special acts of revelation which occurred in the early church, and the phenomenon of speaking in tongues, are not to be confused with the "baptism of the Holy Spirit." While these special ministrations of the Spirit occurred only to the saved, they are not to be expected as the usual signs accompanying baptism of the Holy Spirit, in believers today.
Relations to Tongues
On the day of Pentecost, a number of ministries of the Holy Spirit began simultaneously. No doubt the new converts in the house of Cornelius, like the converts on the day of Pentecost, including the apostles, were regenerated, indwelt, sealed, and filled with the Spirit at the same moment they were baptized with the Spirit. The evidence that any part of the work of salvation had been accomplished in an individual can be taken as evidence that the other universal ministries of the Spirit were also present. Accordingly, any outward sign of salvation could be taken as evidence of the baptism of the Holy Spirit, even though there is no direct connection. It is clear that only Christians spoke in tongues, and the presence of this phenomenon was sufficient to justify Peter in concluding that the house of Cornelius was saved and therefore baptized by the Spirit. It is significant that speaking in tongues is found in Acts particularly where strong assurance of the reality of salvation and the truth of the gospel was needed. On the day of Pentecost, this phenomenon was present, and again in the case of Cornelius, where the gospel was extended freely to the Gentiles. There is actually no more connection between the baptism of the Spirit and speaking with tongues than there is between speaking in tongues and regeneration, or justification. All are within the sphere of ministry to the saved.
One Baptism
This thought is confirmed by Ephesians 4:5, "One Lord, one faith, one baptism." While this passage has been given various interpretations, it is clear that it refers to the things that are universal among Christians. This passage serves to confirm the teaching that the baptism of the Spirit is universal among Christians. All other references to baptism of the Holy Spirit are in harmony with this viewpoint.
No exhortation to be baptized by the Spirit
It is significant to seek the baptism of the Spirit. While there is every exhortation to seek a proper adjustment to the Holy Spirit, this was never called by the term baptism. Never in scripture is baptism by the Spirit recorded as occurring subsequent to salvation. It is rather an inseparable part of it, so essential that it is impossible to be saved in this age without it.
Baptism into the Body of Christ - Union of the Body
One of the important results of the baptism of the Holy Spirit is the union that is effected of believers into the body of Christ. According to I Corinthians 12:13, the baptism of the believer is "into one body." Using the figure of the human body as representing the church, individual believers are revealed to be joined to this living church by the baptism of the Holy Spirit. Baptism is, then, the work of the Holy Spirit, forming and adding to the living unity of the church.
The body of Christ - An important doctrine
Frequent reference is made in the scriptures to the church as the body of Christ. Its formation and increase is often mentioned (Acts 2:47; I Corinthians 6:15; 12:12-14; Ephesians 2:16; 4; 4, 5, 16; 5:30-32; Colossians 2:19). The sanctification of the body of Christ is revealed in Ephesians 5:25-27. Extended scriptures are also found on the doctrine of the gifts of Christ to this body (Romans 12:3-8; I Corinthians 12:27, 28; Ephesians 4:7-16). The doctrine of the church as the body of Christ is a major doctrine of the New Testament.
Place in the Body
The work of baptism assures the unity of the various members of the body. Without regard to race or culture, all true believers are united in a living union in the body of Christ. Frequent mention is made of this fact in scripture, and its basis is the baptism of the Spirit. The union effected, however, is not one in which individuals are lost in the mass. It is rather a sovereign assignment of God, in which every believer is essential to the harmony and perfection of the whole. The body is "fitly joined together" (Ephesians 4:16). An understanding of the basic doctrine of the baptism of the Holy Spirit is necessary then, to comprehend not only the origin of the church, but also its working and sovereign arrangement.
Baptism into Christ - A new position
Intimately connected with the fact that baptism by the Spirit brings the believer into the body of Christ is the inseparable truth that baptism also places the believer in Christ Himself. This truth was anticipated by Christ when He pronounced the words, "In that day, ye shall know that I am in my Father, and ye in me, and I in you" (John 14:20). The "ye in me" relationship was accomplished through the baptism of the Spirit. Before salvation, the individual was in Adam, partaking of Adam's nature, sin and destiny. In salvation, the believer is removed from his position in Adam, and he is placed in Christ.
Identification with Christ
Baptism into Christ is primarily identification. The believer is identified with Christ in His righteousness, His death, his resurrection, and His glorification.
Baptism at the moment of saving faith
From the two references to the baptism of the Holy Spirit in Acts, it may be safely concluded that this ministry was never found before Pentecost, and that it occurred simultaneously with the other ministries of the Spirit, which were given to all who believed the moment they placed their saving faith in Christ. The work of the Holy Spirit is the active joining of a soul to the body of Christ in a point of time. While it can be said that Christ died for all, even before they are saved, it cannot be said that individuals are baptized into the body of Christ until the moment they come to saving faith.
Baptism an act of the Holy Spirit
The Holy Spirit has been recognized as the agent of baptism by most students of the doctrine. However, we are baptized, not by the Spirit, but in the Spirit. Christ is regarded as the actor, He is the one baptizing, and the Holy Spirit is merely the sphere into which we come. It is clear, however, that the entire ministry of the Spirit is being accomplished for the believer at the will of Christ. The Spirit is His agent and doing His work.
Baptism of the Holy Spirit: A Brief History
One of the most spectacular movements ever to sweep through the Christian church was the charismatic movement. From the outbreak of speaking in tongues in the Azusa Street Mission in Los Angeles in the early part of the twentieth century to the growth of Pentecostal and Assemblies of God churches, to the spread into the Roman Catholic church and mainline Protestant churches in the 1960's, the charismatic revival has sparked zealous devotion among its adherents and fueled deep theological discussion.
The Doctrine
Neo-Pentecostalism refers to a significant modification in teaching with respect to classical Pentecostal theology. In the original Pentecostal denominations, the baptism of the Holy Spirit was linked to a concept of sanctification that was integral to the so-called Holiness movement.
The Holiness movement stressed the idea of sanctification as a second work of grace (following regeneration) that was instantaneous and produced either complete or partial moral perfection. Though the term "partial perfectionism" sounds strange to the ear, it involves some important distinctions. Indeed, partial perfectionism implies partial imperfectionism, which tends to cloud the whole idea of perfectionism. Strictly speaking, that which is perfect allows for no mars, blemishes, or other types of imperfections.
Some perfectionists argued that the second work of grace achieved total, pure, and complete sanctification, whereby the recipient was altogether free of sin. John Wesley, in his version of perfectionism, stopped short of this and restricted perfectionism to the reception of the spiritual power of a perfected love. The hymn "Oh Perfect Love," which ironically is used often in weddings, had its origin in an expression of this Wesleyan doctrine of sanctification.
Other Holiness advocates have modified the view of the "second blessing" to restrict it to achieving a victorious life over "willful sin." That is, once a person receives the baptism of the Holy Spirit into sanctification, he may still sin, but never willfully. Whatever sin remains in the sanctified person is accidental sin or sin committed in ignorance. The baptism of the Holy Spirit so sanctifies a person that he is then free of deliberate sin.
Although some churches still teach such perfectionistic doctrines today, the idea of perfectionism either in whole or in part, has not made many inroads into mainstream Christianity.
The evidence of continued sin in the lives of the greatest saints is so strong, and virtually inevitable that forms of perfectionism tend to be modified, limited, and restricted to some degree of partial perfectionism.
In Neo-Pentecostal theology, the link between moral perfectionism and the baptism of the Holy Spirit has all but been abandoned. We do not hear charismatic leaders such as Pat Robertson speaking of being totally sanctified, and Jimmy Swaggart and Jim Baker make no claims to being perfect.
In Neo-Pentecostal theology, the emphasis on the baptism of the Holy Spirit falls upon the idea of being empowered or gifted for ministry. The word charismatic itself derives from the New Testament Greek word for "gift" or "spiritual grace." The English word "charismatic" has become so widely used that it has found its way into the lexicon of popular speech. An exciting performer or political leader may be called "charismatic" without any religious overtones connected to the word.
Since the Neo-Pentecostal movement has penetrated virtually all of the Christian denominations, its theology has been shaped by the theologies of the various churches. For example, Roman Catholic charismatics have a Roman Catholic flavor to their theology, just as Lutheran and Episcopalian charismatics have their distinctive flavors.
The basic trend in Neo-Pentecostal theology is to see the baptism of the Holy Spirit as a special work of the Holy Spirit by which a believer is endued with power for life and service. He is now gifted for ministry. They believe that speaking in tongues is the initial evidence of Holy Spirit baptism.
The Issue to Consider
Is the record of Acts proof that the sequence of the Holy Spirit's work among the first Christians was intended to be normative for the church throughout this age?
The practical issue that burns within the church is this: Are there two levels of Christians - one kind that has the baptism of the Holy Spirit and another that does not?
This question is further complicated by the record of church history. Though some have bent over backwards trying to prove that there has been a steady stream of speaking in tongues and other evidences of a subsequent Spirit baptism throughout church history, the overwhelming testimony of church history is to the discontinuity of speaking in tongues as an evidence of Spirit baptism.
Church history seems to indicate that the lives of the greatest saints - Athanasius, Augustine, Anselem, Thomas Aquinas, Martin Luther, John Calvin, Jonathan Edwards, Charles Spurgeon, George Muller, John Darby and others - failed to display any speaking in tongues indicative of having ever been baptized in or by the Holy Spirit. Some of them spoke favorably of the gift, but they never practiced speaking in tongues. Though speaking in tongues has occurred here and there in church history, it was often associated with heretical movements, such as Montanism in the second century and the Irvingite movement in the nineteenth century.
If speaking in tongues is the outward evidence of Holy Spirit baptism, and the baptism of the Holy Spirit is a crucial and normative subsequent work in the lives of believers, then why have the vast majority of believers in church history failed to attain this vital dimension of the Christian life? Was the original Pentecost actually a "failure" for the vast ages of Christian history until the present day? If the purpose of Pentecost was to pour out a continuous gift of tongues, then the historical discontinuity indicates that the objective was not attained.
Some have answered this question by posing an eschatological explanation. The first century phenomenon indicated the "Former Rains" of the Holy Spirit, while the present outpouring indicates revival of Pentecost and the "Latter Rain" of the Holy Spirit, and the approaching hour of Christ's return (the "rains" imagery comes from a prophecy in Joel 2:23).
This theory would explain the problem of historical discontinuity. However, it would also annul the theory that the intent of the record in Acts was to convey a normative Christian experience for all ages.
A weaker or lame explanation for historical discontinuity would be the claim that the believers of the past were simply not earnest enough in their pursuit of spirituality to acquire the fullness of the Holy Spirit. This is a possibility, but it hardly seems likely in the light of the deep spiritual ardor of some of the saints of the past. There were, and are, devout believers whose lives appear to be models of God-centeredness, yet most did not speak in tongues.
Nowhere does the scripture explicitly teach that speaking in tongues is a necessary sign of the baptism of the Holy Spirit or that there must be a time gap between conversion and Spirit baptism. These ideas are inferences drawn from the narrative. Such inferences are not valid.
These inferences jeopardize the full meaning of Pentecost in church history.
In light of the Old Testament principle of limited distribution of the Holy Spirit, the Day of Pentecost points to the outpouring of the Holy Spirit not on some of God's people, but on all of God's people (I Corinthians 12:13).
The difference between the mediator of the Old Covenant - Moses - and the mediator of the new covenant - Jesus - is that Jesus distributes His Holy Spirit upon all of His people. This is a key point that is obscured by the Neo- Pentecostal theology. They lower the importance of the book of Acts to the level of the Old Testament. Neo- Pentecostalism grants that the distribution of the Holy Spirit is available for all of God's people, but not necessarily gained by all of God's people. Here is where another interpretation of the book of Acts is relevant.
If we can identify the purposes as well as the intended audiences of Biblical authors, we can understand their teaching with greater accuracy.
For example, when scholars analyze the synoptic gospels - Matthew, Mark, and Luke - they are able to isolate material that is unique to each writer. Many scholars believe that Mark was written first and that Matthew and Luke had Mark's gospel in front of them when they wrote. There is much material in Mark that is duplicated in both Matthew and Luke.
At the same time, there is much material that is common to Matthew and Luke that is not found in Mark. It is apparent that Luke and Matthew used a source that was not available to or not used by Mark. What concerns us is the material found only in Luke. By isolating this material, we gain insight into Luke's special interests and concerns.
Matthew reveals a strong concern to speak to a Jewish audience.
An examination of Luke indicates that Luke was writing for a Gentile audience and that one of his chief concerns was to show the universality of the gospel.
We know from scripture that one of the most intense controversies that plagued the early church was the issue of the Gentile's status within the church. The church began primarily with Jewish believers and, as Acts relates, it spread to the Gentile world, in large part due to Paul's missionary journeys.
It is important to keep in mind that Luke was the author of the book of Acts. He was intimately aware of the crucial debate about the Gentile's role in the church. The book of Acts follows structurally the mandate of Christ's Great Commission (Acts 1:8).
The chronology of Acts follows this pattern of Christianity's spread – Jerusalem - Judea - Samaria - the Gentile world. The narrative begins with events in Jerusalem and then expands outward in the missionary enterprise.
The day of Pentecost was a Jewish event. It took place in Jerusalem. Pentecost itself was a Jewish feast. The participants were "Jews and devout men, from every nation under heaven" (Acts 2:5). The Jews had come up to Jerusalem for the Feast of Pentecost.
On this occurrence, it is important to notice that "they were filled with the Holy Ghost" (Acts 2:4). There was no evidence of some believer Jews failing to receive the Holy Spirit. There was no evidence that some earnestly sought the gift while others failed to achieve it. All the Jewish believers experienced the Pentecostal outpouring.
The same phenomenon is seen in the other outpourings recorded in Acts. There was no record in Acts of any believer in a group of believers failing to receive (or only partly receive) the promised Holy Spirit when He descended. The Spirit comes inclusively and unconditionally.
The Other Incidents
In the early church, the question of full inclusion in the body of Christ was not limited merely to the two broad generic groups of Jews and Gentiles. There were four distinct groups of people whose status in the church was at issue. These four groups included Jews, Samaritans, God-fearers, and Gentiles. The God-fearers were Gentile converts to Judaism who had embraced the tenets of Judaism but had stopped short of full conversion by opting to remain uncircumcised. It is clear, from Acts 10, that Cornelius was a God-fearer (Acts 10:1, 2). All four groups, and all in the groups, received the outpouring of the Holy Spirit.
The question remains: What is the significance of these events? Neo-Pentecostalism finds the significance in the time delay between conversion and receiving the Spirit and in the outward manifestations of tongues.
But that was not the significance of these events stressed by Luke. It is not the chief message the apostles themselves gained from these events. How did the apostles interpret those events? The key here is found in Acts 10:44- 48.
The text indicates that the Jewish believers were shocked to see Gentiles receive the Spirit. The clear meaning of this for Peter was that these converts were to receive full membership into the church. There was to be no second class believer in the church. There was nothing in the text that indicates a subsequent delay to receive the Holy Spirit to be normative. In Acts 19, Paul asked the Ephesians, "Did you receive the Holy Spirit when you believed?" (Acts 19:1-7). The Ephesians could have received the Holy Spirit at the time of their conversion, indicating that, at least at this point, Paul had no concept of a normative time delay. He allowed for the possibility of a time delay but not for the necessity of it.
Though speaking in tongues continued in the life of the church as witnessed by Paul's discussion of the matter in I Corinthians, it is clear that by the time I Corinthians was written, speaking in tongues was not regarded as an indispensable sign of charismatic endowment.
In I Corinthians, Paul labors the point that although tongues are a gift from God and therefore profitable, they are not to receive too exalted a status in the church. Read I Corinthians 14: 18,19.
The apostolic ratio here is 5:10,000. Paul raises a question elsewhere: "Do all speak with tongues?" (I Corinthians 12:30). There is no doubt about the answer here. Paul's question does not leave its answer open-ended. There can be only one answer to this type of structured question. The answer is no. Read I Corinthians 12:4-11.
The Holy Spirit sovereignly gifts His church. The church is a body of gifted members whose function lies within the framework of unity and diversity. No office or gift is to be elevated to the level of an exclusive sign of the Spirit's manifestation. A key verse is I Corinthians 12:13. "For by one Spirit we were all baptized into one body - whether Jews or Greeks, whether slaves or free - and have all been made to drink into one Spirit."
If this verse is interpreted as speaking of a second, subsequent and separate baptism in the Holy Spirit beyond baptism in Christ for only some Christians, then violence is done, not only to words of the text - "all...all" - but to the purpose of the text in its Corinthian context. In I Corinthians 12:13, Paul is not teaching a universal baptism won by only a few, he is teaching the gracious Christian baptism whereby the Spirit is given to all.
The weight of the Biblical interpretation of the meaning of Pentecost mitigates against the Neo-Pentecostal understanding of the baptism of the Holy Spirit. All, whom the Spirit baptizes, are filled and endowed with power for ministry.
This is the exciting news of Pentecost. In God's plan of redemption, the Holy Spirit has gifted every believer for ministry. The whole church has been empowered from on high. There are not two levels of believers - gifted and non-gifted, baptized in the Spirit and not baptized in the Spirit.
The Distinctive Tenet of the modern Charismatic
Revivalism
Appearing in various forms, this species of revivalism possesses one common basic element. It holds that the supernatural gifts and miracles of the New Testament days ought to be in the church today. Although it seeks to bring the complete list of apostolic gifts into operation in contemporary church life, it lays special emphasis upon glossolalia, or speaking in tongues.
Specifically, it is held that the spiritual experience accompanied by speaking in other languages granted by the early church on the day of Pentecost (Acts 2:1-4), is to be sought and enjoyed by believers today. It teaches that Pentecost is not only repeatable, but constitutes a blessing to be enjoyed subsequent to regeneration. The movement has frequently been called "Pentecostalism." This spiritual enduement, or gift, believed to be evidenced by glossolalia, is called by many names, such as the second blessing, the baptism of the Holy Spirit, the filling of the Spirit, receiving the Spirit and so forth. But by whatever name it is called, it is usually intended to describe not an operation of the Spirit connected inseparably with the believer's salvation, but an experience of the power of God coming upon the believer's life after his salvation and attested by the miraculous evidence or sign of speaking languages not previously studied or known.
In many communities over America and churches throughout the world, the spiritual vacuum left by a doctrinally defecting, Protestant, charismatic revivalism, is a fertile field in which to work, and has a phenomenal opportunity for growth. However, where churches resist apostasy and stand loyal to the word, retaining spiritual power and fervor, the new revivalism finds much less promise of spiritual ministry.
Although, the hallmark of the Pentecostal variety of Christianity, as stated by Pentecostal theology, is, "In addition and subsequent to conversion, a believer may experience an enduement of power, whose initial oncoming is signalized by a miraculous utterance in a language never learned by the speaker." The remainder of Pentecostal teaching is quite similar to the tenets of primitive Methodism and to the teachings of many of the smaller Holiness groups of evangelical Christianity.
In fact, Pentecostalism began as a revival movement that appealed to those who were already regenerated and hence members of various churches. The movement received many of its doctrinal traditions from these churches. Accordingly, most charismatic groups are Trinitarian. In the matter of the inspiration and full authority of scripture, the various charismatic sects do not differ essentially from the views of Bible-believing Christians in general. Regarding salvation through faith and insistence on an experience of regeneration, Pentecostals are in agreement with evangelical Christianity, following in general traditions of these communions. However, they do not practice infant baptism, but insist on a conversion experience prior to the believer's baptism by immersion.
The various charismatic bodies are predominately Arminian rather than Calvinistic. Calvinism teaches the sovereignty of God. The Arminians held the view that a truly born-again believer may fall away and be lost, a position stoutly denied by Calvinistic theology.
In the doctrine of sanctification, the charismatic revivalism was greatly affected by the Holiness movement, which became a vital factor in American Christianity after the Civil War. Though begun under Methodist leadership, this effort became largely interdenominational, championing godly living as a reaction against religious laxness that disturbed the American church in the last half of the nineteenth century.
Adherents of the Holiness movement found their bond of union in the Weslayan doctrine of complete sanctification, commonly called the "second blessing." The movement itself made important contributions that prepared the groundwork which modern Pentecostalism would ultimately spring. First, it introduced into American Christianity a new zeal for "spiritual experiences," subsequent to the experience of salvation or the new birth. Second, it popularized the scriptural phrase, "baptism of the holy spirit" as the name for the experience of sanctification or second blessing, thus generating a term and a concept that was to have central significance in the Pentecostal movement. Third, in this manner, the Holiness movement opened the way for the next step, that of connecting glossolalia, as in Acts 2, with this experience defined by these terms.
During the late 19th century, isolated manifestations of "tongues" took place in the Holiness movement, despite the absence of any doctrinal foundation or teaching on glossolalia. The explanation of this lies in the fact that the movement, in its worship, which was characterized by high enthusiasm and often ecstasy, stimulated unusual motor phenomena. Also in its theology, it unwittingly invited glossolalia and other charismatic manifestations.
Another prominent emphasis, which charismatic revivalism found prepared it for the Holiness movement out of which it largely sprung, was divine healing. Although faith healing has been present in every age of church history, several of the Holiness bodies distinctively emphasized this doctrine just prior to the rise of the Pentecostal movement.
The doctrine of faith healing became a distinctive doctrine of the charismatic emphasis through the ministry of Charles F. Parham, he was the first leader of the revival, and was active in it until his death in 1929. He could be called the father of the modern Pentecostal movement.
As Parham got his doctrine of sanctification from the historical teaching of Perfectionism current in Holiness circles, he made it one of the most distinctive of his messages, construing it to be a "second work of grace which completely destroyed inbred sin." So, this teaching in turn prepared him for his great emphasis on physical healing.
If Christ's atoning work provided for the removal of the old sinful nature instead of victory over it, then physical healing could also be conceived of as available in the atonement on the same basis of faith as the experience of salvation or that of sanctification. In such a case, every believer could claim healing if he exercised faith in Christ's atoning death.
A final distinctive emphasis of the charismatic revival is the imminent pre-millennial coming of the Lord and a vital interest in the prophetic scriptures. Rejecting post-millennial, or a-millennial views of the Lutheran reformed churches, the Pentecostals adopted the eschatological teaching of the Plymouth Brethren.
The Spirit's Baptizing Ministry
This operation of the Spirit was wholly unique to the new age and first occurred at Pentecost (Acts 1:5; 11:14- 16). That no regenerated believer in the Old Testament economy was ever so baptized, was evident from the fact that John the Baptist announced this spiritual operation as ensuing his day and ministry (Matthew 3:11; Mark 1:8; Luke 3:16,17). It was to be effected by the completed redemption work of Christ, who, as the provider of redemption and giver of the gift of the spirit, was declared by John to be the baptizer with the Holy Spirit (John 1:33).
After the Spirit's advent, the Spirit Himself is declared to be the agent of the baptism (I Corinthians 12:13).
The experience of power at Pentecost was not due to the baptism of the spirit, but the filling of the spirit (Acts 2:4). The baptism was not the filling, as is commonly, but erroneously, assumed. It was the basis of the infilling, but not the experience of infilling itself. It follows, therefore, that Pentecost does not teach a so-called "second blessing," erroneously called the "baptism of the spirit" and viewed as an experience of power subsequent to salvation. The Pentecost does teach many infillings, not only a second, but the third, fourth, and so on in the glories and victories of the spirit - filled life.
The Spirit's sealing and indwelling ministries
The Spirit was not said to have sealed Old Testament saints "unto the day of redemption," as in the case of the New Testament saints (Ephesians 1:13; 4:30; II Corinthians 1:22). Although the Spirit indwelt Joseph (Genesis 41:38,39) and Joshua (Numbers 27:18), the indwelling apparently was not universal, nor permanent among Old Testament believers (Psalm 51:11) as it is today (John 14:17; Romans 8:9; I Corinthians 6:19,20).
The Spirit's filling ministry
Pentecost was the occasion not only of the advent and the taking up of residence of the Spirit upon earth, but also of a marvelous infilling by the Spirit of the newly formed church (Acts 2:4). This was the harbinger of the wonderful spiritual privilege the new age was to afford. In Old Testament times, the Spirit sovereignly came upon a few. Warriors, kings, prophets, and mighty men were temporarily filled to perform some special task, such as Gideon (Judges 6:34), Amasai (I Chronicles 12:18), Samson (Judges 14:6), Saul (I Samuel 10:10) and David (I Samuel 16:13). Pentecost, however, marked a new era in which every believer, no matter how poor, how humble or obscure, might be constantly "filled with the Spirit." This was the reason for the stress upon the infilling (Acts 2:4).
That which warriors, kings, prophets and mighty men then enjoyed, only temporarily can now be enjoyed by every believer constantly (Acts 2:17,18).
Pentecost marks the first historical occurrence of the baptism of the spirit and the resultant formation of the church.
This vital truth inescapably appears from a simple comparison of Acts 1:5; 2:4; 11:14-16 with I Corinthians 12:13 and Ephesians 1:22, 23. It was just as impossible that there should be a church constituting the body of Christ before the spirit's baptizing work at Pentecost as that there should not have existed a church after that event. The reason is that the church is formed by the Spirit's baptism and therefore could not be formed before that baptism became operative at Pentecost. The second chapter of Acts gives the historical event; the Pauline epistles give the doctrinal explanation (I Corinthians 12:13; Ephesians 1:22,23; 4:4,5). To build a doctrine of the baptism of the spirit as a second experience subsequent to salvation from the book of Acts is to deny the doctrinal interpretation of these events as given by the Spirit in the epistles.
This is a quote from George Smeaton, a 19th century theologian on the subject of the Holy Spirit: The Doctrine of the Holy Spirit. “As to Brethrenism, it will have a longer existence than the other Phenomenon (Irvingism). It has produced a literature on the Holy Spirit of a very mixed character. Mr. Darby, Mr. Kelly, and Mr. Harris have all written on the Holy Spirit. While many excellent things have been said by all these writers on the distinction which must always be carefully drawn between Christ's work for us and the Spirit's work in us, on the inhabitation of the Spirit in the hearts of Christians, and on the communion between Christ and His people by the Holy Spirit, the Paraclete, there are three points where their doctrinal views on the Spirit are mischievous in the last degree.”
- They have very much resuscitated the Cocceian notions as to the alleged low platform of the Old Testament Saints.
They divide the church which was one from the days of Abel into two.
- They make a presumptuous claim to be in their assemblies under the presidency of the Holy Spirit, as they phrase it; and accordingly, they venture to carry out the decrees and resolutions to come under this imagination with a confidence a little less than apostolic.
- They take exception to what most other churches, not swamped by ritualism, have always regarded as one of the most important and blessed duties - to pray for the Holy Ghost. The church of God of all ages, according to the most explicit scripture examples - the Greek Church, the Roman Church, all the Protestant churches - in the exercise of a deep Christian instinct, have invocated the Holy Ghost, and expected larger and larger supplies and communications; and they grieve for and confess their sin in not having more implored His help and presence. This sect, by an obvious misinterpretation of scripture, objects to the practice of praying for the Spirit, because forsooth He was given at Pentecost."
A quote from W.H. Griffith Thomas, one of the founders of the Dallas Theological Seminary: " Plymouth Brethrenism, to use the best known designation, represented a movement to unite all real Christians in view of divided Christendom in an endeavor to keep the unity of the Spirit. At the outset, the coming of the Lord as the present hope of the church and the presence of the Holy Ghost as the principle of the unity of God's people, were greatly insisted on. The church as a whole owes much to the testimony of the Brethren on the importance of the word of God, the judicial standing of the believer in Christ by the Spirit, and the coming of Christ as the blessed hope of the church. But, like many other movements, it developed extremes of teaching and discipline, and its undue and unbalanced individualism, with its fissiparous tendency, has led to deplorable severances and their consequent weaknesses. But in so far as the Brethren emphasized the Holy Spirit's presence in the church as characteristic of this dispensation; their witness to primitive truth was as welcome as it was necessary and one of their number has rightly said that 'their appreciation of the Holy Spirit's presence, power, and guidance is the grand and distinctive character of their theology.'" Until the origin of the Plymouth Brethren movement, the general belief was that the church was constituted of old and New Testament believers.
Pentecost was the birthday of the church. The believing disciples and converts under Peter's preaching were formed into one body. Since then, whenever and whereever a sinner trusts Christ as Savior, he or she becomes a partaker of that baptism and is joined by the Spirit to the one body, the church. After the resurrection, the intervening 50 days constituted a transition period before advent and giving of the Spirit, on which the risen glorified Savior sovereignly bestowed the Spirit on His chosen few disciples (John 20:22). The Spirit would tide them over the intervening span so they would be able to receive Christ's teaching during the forty days preceding His ascension (Acts 1:1-3; John 16:12,23).
It is in connection with the commencement of a new economy in God's dealing that the supernatural phenomena of fire, wind, and the languages of Pentecost are to be seen in their real significance. They were the outward visible signs that the new age was being inaugurated. Similarly, the legal or mosaic age had been introduced with fire, smoke, and earthquake as Mount Sinai was wrapped in flame (Exodus 19:18). In like manner, the future kingdom age will be opened with signs of fire, smoke, and celestial commotions accompanied by a marvelous outpouring of the Spirit as at Pentecost (Joel 2:28-32; Acts 2:16-21).
Unfortunately, modern charismatic movements frequently overlook the fact that Pentecost inaugurated a new age and that the inaugural events were once and for all unrepeatable. In the present day ado about tongues, much is made of the supernatural languages, but little is said of the wind and fire. Pentecost also involved only Jews. Non-Jews were not admitted to gospel privileges and membership into Christ's body, the church, until later.
Pentecost signals the opening of gospel opportunity to
the Jew in a racial sense
The keys of Peter were symbols of authority delegated to Peter which would open the door of salvation to admit Jewish believers then, and Samaritan and Gentile believers later. Giving these keys to Peter meant that to him would be given the power and authority to release the door of gospel opportunity initially at the commencement of this age. That is the reason Peter, only, was the God-chosen preacher to instruct his Jewish listeners as to how they were to receive God's grace and the free gift of the Holy Spirit (Acts 2:38,39). It is to be noted that Peter was not given the keys of the church, but of the "kingdom of heaven" as the sphere of Christian profession, as in Matthew 13. The Holy Spirit, who made His advent at Pentecost, alone, holds the keys to the church.
Pentecost bears a close similarity to Joel's prophecy of the latter day outpouring of the Spirit, inaugurating the coming kingdom age.
The specific reason why Peter introduced his Pentecostal sermon with a long quotation from Joel's prophecy (Joel 2:28-32), was to show his multilingual Jewish listeners, gathered from all parts of the Roman Empire to celebrate the feast of Pentecost, that the strange exhibition of languages, by the simple Galilean followers of Jesus, was not an instance of drunkenness or emotional excess. On the contrary, it was something paralleled by their own prophetic scriptures, closely akin to similar spiritual phenomena predicted to be visited upon their own race, previous to the establishment of kingdom blessing.
It seems quite obvious that Peter did not quote Joel's prophecy in the event of Pentecost, but purely as a prophetic illustration of those events. As a matter of fact, to avoid confusion, Peter's quotation evidently purposely goes beyond any possible fulfillment at Pentecost by including events in the still future day of the Lord, preceding kingdom establishment (Acts 2:19,20). To employ the term "partial fulfillment," involves illogical terminology that does not produce clarity and accuracy of concept. Peter's phraseology "this is that" means nothing more than "this is an illustration of that which was spoken by the prophet Joel (Acts 2:16). In the reference, there is not the slightest hint of a continual fulfillment during the church age, or a coming fulfillment toward the end of the church age. The reference is solely in an illustrative sense to Jewish listeners at Pentecost. Fulfillment of Joel's prophecy is still future and awaits Christ's second coming in glory and a copious spiritual outpouring ushering in kingdom blessing (Zechariah 12:10-13; Acts 1:6, 7).
The meaning of the Samaritan Revival: Acts 8:5-25
Some call it Samaritan Pentecost. They believe that "receiving the Holy Spirit is subsequent to salvation," and that "the gift of the Spirit is the same as the baptism of the Spirit." It teaches that the laying on of hands to "receive the Holy Spirit" is as applicable today as it was then.
In similar fashion, Pentecost had signaled the giving of the gift of the Spirit to the Jews. Yet the events in Samaria cannot be called a Samaritan Pentecost. These are the reasons why:
First, Pentecost is unrepeatable since it represents the advent and taking up of permanent abode of the Spirit in the church. The Spirit could not again arrive and take up residence. This was once and for all the new age. Second, the Spirit could neither be given, received, nor deposited again as was the gift initially so given received and deposited once and for all for the age of Pentecost. Pentecost, therefore, was the beginning of a new age. By contrast, the Samaritan revival was the entrance into the spiritual blessings of that age, not the inauguration of that age.
The Samaritan event represented growth, not birth. It was the extension of gospel privilege to another people, the Samaritans, not as at Pentecost, the introduction of gospel privilege to Jews alone.
The giving of the Spirit, the gift of God (Acts 8:20), to the Samaritans, was accordingly their admission to the blessings of the gift that had been poured out at Pentecost to the Jews. It was their receiving the Spirit (Acts 8:15, 17) in the sense of appropriating the contents of the gift on a horizontal plane, in distinction from the gift, having been received by the Jews at Pentecost on a vertical plane. The Jews at Pentecost received the gift of the Holy Spirit directly from the ascended Lord, in heaven. The Samaritans received the gift, not initially and directly from Him, but only subsequently and indirectly from Him. They received it in the sense of being introduced to the gift as already having been received and deposited for some time in the new people of God.
The terms "giving" or "receiving" the Spirit (Acts 8:15-17) always had a time context; they are time bound. They cannot be applied to the normal course of the new age once it had been established. Paul uses the term "receiving the Spirit" once as tantamount to receiving salvation by the Spirit (Galatians 3:2).
The Samaritan revival marks the coming of the Holy Spirit to the Samaritans to perform for them all His ministries in this age.
There was the ministry of regeneration. Although the Samaritans were doubtlessly regenerated under Philip's ministry (Acts 8:5-13), they were not saved with New Testament salvation before they received the Holy Spirit under Peter and John's ministry (Acts 8:14-20) anymore than Cornelius the Gentile had been saved before Peter preached to him (Acts 11:14). Their receiving the Holy spirit means that they were introduced to New Testament salvation which includes, besides regeneration, the baptizing, sealing, indwelling and filling ministries of the Spirit. Being a mixture of Jew and Gentile, the Samaritans therefore constituted a distinct ethnic group to whom the gospel privileges of the new age must be opened and made available (Acts 1:8).
At Pentecost, Peter first used "the keys of the kingdom of Heaven" (Matthew 16:19) to open the gospel of grace and the privilege of salvation of the new age to the Jews. Now he employs the identical prerogative a second time to open the same glorious gospel to the Samaritans. This is the reason Peter is sent with John as a witness (Acts 8:14). This is in part at least the significance of the laying on of hands for receiving the Spirit.
Peter was employing a ceremony commonly used in the mosaic economy to express identification (Leviticus 1:4; 3:8; 4:4; Hebrews 6:2). In the case of the Samaritans, the act of laying on of hands indicated apostolic mediation and communication of spiritual blessing through divinely given prerogative.
The privilege was used for the last time to unloose the gospel to the Gentiles (Acts 10:1-48). It is to be noted that this privilege carried with it none of the papal claims made by the Roman Catholic Church. It was confined to the initial opening of the message.
Does not the delay in the giving of the Spirit to the Samaritans prove that it is subsequent to salvation (Acts 8:14-17)?
That there was a delay in the giving of the Spirit to the Samaritans who had believed, is beyond question. Was there a reason for this delay, or does it signify that the indwelling of the Spirit comes subsequent to salvation? Some say that this was a filling of the Spirit, but it clearly was not, and such an answer really avoids the problem.
Others say that this was different because the Samaritans were the first non-Jewish group to be taken into the church. This is half-true, but the Samaritans were also partly Jewish. However, when the Spirit was given to the Gentiles, it happened at the moment of believing (Acts 10:44), making it the norm for non-Jewish believers.
The best explanation of this delay in Samaria seems to be in the schismatic (differing) nature of the Samaritan religion. Because the Samaritans had their own worship in Jerusalem, it was necessary to prove to them that their new faith was not to be set up as a rival to the new faith that had taken root in Jerusalem. And the best way for God to show the Samaritan believers that they belonged to the same faith and grace as Jerusalem believers and contrariwise, the best way to show Jerusalem believers that the Samaritans were genuinely saved, was to delay the giving of the Spirit until Peter and John came from Jerusalem to Samaria. There could be no doubt then, that this was one and the same faith and that they all belonged together in the body of Christ. This delay in the giving of the Spirit saved the early church from having two mother churches - one in Jerusalem and one in Samaria - early in her history. It preserved the unity of the church in this early stage.
The case of Simon the sorcerer furnishes a solemn warning against spiritual deception and imposture.
Many of God's dear people in our day of doctrinal confusion fail to see the danger of venturing into the spiritual realm without sound doctrine to guide them and keen discernment based upon God's word to ferret out deception. As a result, many are being snared in error and exploited by religious imposters. Simon, who was under the spell of demon power and deluded the people of Samaria, promoted himself as "some great one" (Acts 8:9). The people were deluded into thinking he was "the great power of God" (Acts 8:10), when all the while he was performing wonders by demon powers (Acts 8:11).
In our day, the same danger prevails, especially in circles where people, hungry for the power of God, fall prey to ignorance and error in the matter of the doctrine of the Holy Spirit. Little do some Christians realize that in confusing such terms as "receiving the Holy Spirit," "the baptism of the Holy Spirit," and seeking an experience of tongues or healing where doctrinal error abounds, they are unwittingly exposing themselves to demonic delusion. Worse still, they forget that in seeking experiences not sanctioned by the Word of God and sound Bible teaching, they expose themselves to demon control and all types of excess.
The meaning of Cornelius' conversion
The events connected with salvation of the first representative Gentiles in the home of Cornelius (Acts 10), were associated with speaking in tongues. This much abused chapter, so pivotal in apostolic gospel outreach, is frequently used today to teach that tongues are a manifestation of an experience of power subsequent to salvation. This so-called second experience is further inaccurately called "the baptism of the Spirit."
The Spirit was given to Jews at Pentecost to work in them the glorious salvation purchased by Christ on the cross. Now He is given in a similar introductory manner to the first representative Gentiles. With this, the gospel was released to the "uttermost part of the earth" (Acts 1:8). This episode cannot be called a "Gentile Pentecost."
There was the ministry of regeneration. Was Cornelius "saved" before Peter prescribed to him and his household (10:2)? He was regenerated, as were all Old Testament saints. Their condition was similar to the Samaritans under Philip's preaching (Acts 8:5-13), before they had received the Holy Spirit under Peter and John's ministry.
The New Testament salvation introduced to the Gentiles included besides regeneration, the baptizing, sealing, indwelling, and filling ministries of the Spirit. Old Testament salvation included regeneration, but not the Spirit's baptizing ministry of placing the believer in Christ.
The Spirit's ministry of filling also comes into clear focus at Caesarea. "While Peter yet spoke these words, the Holy Spirit fell on all them who heard the word" (Acts 10:44). The term "fell on" suggests a powerful infilling of the Spirit (Acts 1:4). It must be carefully borne in mind that in the great historical instances of the initial giving of the Spirit to the Jews, Samaritans, and Gentiles, there is always the infilling.
The baptism and infilling occur simultaneously in the unique key passages in Acts because a new age was being inaugurated. Now that the introductory phase had reached its terminal point with the admission of the Gentiles and the normal order of the age obtained, the infilling may or may not occur with the regenerating, baptizing, indwelling, and sealing. The infilling occurs at the time one is "saved" only when the conditions for it are known and complied with at the time of salvation.
Cornelius' conversion furnishes the third and last occasion for Peter's use of the keys.
Cornelius' conversion and tongues
There are three references to speaking in tongues in the book of Acts. The first, Acts 2:4, is associated with the opening of the gospel of grace to Jews and the inauguration of a new age in God's economy. The second, Acts 10:46, occurs in connection with the introduction of Christ's great salvation to Gentiles and the establishment of the normal course of the new age. The third, Acts 19:6, furnishes an example of individual, Jewish believers, who in the period when the new age was inaugurated and in the process of being established in its normal course, had never been instructed in the gospel of grace or the operation of the Spirit in the new age. Hence, they knew only Old Testament salvation, not the common salvation purchased by Christ and inwrought in the behavior by the outpoured Spirit.
To understand the meaning of tongues in this pivotal passage in the Acts, it is absolutely imperative to see this spiritual manifestation in its proper context. Modern charismatic interpretations fail here. They draw unwarranted conclusions concerning the meaning of tongues in these key passages because they fail to see the meaning of these events in their true perspective and particularly in their time setting.
Just as the fire, wind, and tongues at Pentecost were once and for all inaugurated features giving miraculous auditory and visual demonstration that a new economy in God's dealing with redeemed man had began, so the tongues at Caesarea (Acts 10:46) was a witness that the new age had been introduced and its normal order established with admission of Gentiles to gospel privilege. To ignore the events at Caesarea with those at Jerusalem is to forfeit any accurate interpretation of the phenomenon of tongues in each case. This was intended in its time context merely to be an inaugural and introductory feature. It is like making the marriage ceremony, the wedding reception, and the honeymoon repeatable and continuous features of a normally established married life.
Tongues at Caesarea had no direct connection with the baptism of the Spirit. As at Pentecost, the baptism of the Spirit was not an experience of power subsequent to salvation, but an intrinsic component of that wonderful salvation Jesus provided by His redemptive work on Calvary. It follows, then, that speaking in tongues never was an evidence of the baptism of the Spirit. The only connection between tongues at Pentecost or at Caesarea with the baptism of the Spirit is that those "saved" spoke in this manner. But the baptism was an inseparable element of their salvation, not an experience subsequent to it. This is the pivotal truth that is so widely misunderstood in present day charismatic revivalism.
As Pentecost was introductory in the sense of inaugurating a new age, so Acts 10 is terminal in the sense of marking the consummation of the introductory period and the establishment of the normal course of the new age.
To treat Cornelius and his household as "saved" before Peter came to bring them New Testament salvation (Acts 11:14) is to fail to see what New Testament salvation is or to differentiate it from Old Testament salvation. To treat him and all his household as examples of believers in the sense of believers today and what happened to them under Peter's ministry as a blessing in addition to salvation is like taking any event of history and interpreting it apart from the historical context in which it occurred. Such a practice is like taking a man's experiences of childhood, and losing all sense of time, applying them to the adult person or worse still, like forgetting who a person is or what he represents, and using him as an unfit example. All present believers are baptized, indwelt, and permanently sealed and have the privilege of being continuously filled with the Spirit (I Corinthians 12:13; Romans 6:3, 4; Galatians 3:27; Colossians 2:9-12; Ephesians 5:18).
Baptism of the Spirit and filling are different
There was certainly the filling ministry of the Spirit at Caesarea (Acts 10:44). As at Pentecost and Samaria, the filling of the Spirit and the baptism of the Spirit occurred at the same time. But this fact by no means denotes that these ministries of the Spirit are identical, or that they always occur together. In fact, they occurred together of necessity in the great historical instances of the initial giving of the Spirit to Jews, to Samaritans, and finally to Gentiles, because all the elements of Christ's great salvation released were to be manifest. A high tide of spiritual experience also accompanied the opening of gospel opportunity to the various racial groups concerned.
Today in the normal order of the age, the infilling may or may not occur when the person is saved. In other words, it may happen at the same time with the regenerating, baptizing, indwelling, and sealing ministries of the Spirit.
The gift of tongues at Caesarea was a sign to the Jews
This outward tangible evidence of languages was essential as far as Peter and the six Jewish believers who accompanied him from Joppa to Caesarea were concerned (Acts 11:12). Something startling and unheard of, especially from the Jewish viewpoint, was about to take place. The Spirit was to be given to every tongue, tribe, and kindred. The gospel of grace was to go to the "uttermost part of the earth" (Acts 1:8). The unclean Gentiles, so long cut off from religious opportunity, considered as "dogs" (Matthew 15:24-27), and symbolized by the various unclean animals of Peter's preparatory vision (Acts 10:9-16), were to be given the "like gift" as God gave to the Jews at Pentecost (Acts 11:17) and become recipients of full gospel privilege.
This stupendous development needed some concrete evidence that it was God's undertaking, not only as far as Peter and the six Jewish witnesses who went with him from Joppa to Caesarea were concerned, but even more so on the part of the Jewish authorities in the church at Jerusalem, to whom Peter was to be called in question and to whom he was required to give a report of his amazing activities among the Gentiles (Acts 11:1-18).
This need at Caesarea was supplied by the phenomenon of tongues (Acts 10:46). This supernatural sign was evidence to the Jews that the gift of the Spirit "poured out" upon the Gentiles was identical in every way to the gift liberally bestowed upon them at Pentecost (Acts 2:4-13; 10:45,46).
Peter and his Jewish colleagues were immediately impressed and thoroughly persuaded that God had really granted the Gentiles the same glorious salvation as an identical gift, equal in every sense (Acts 11:17) as had been vouchsafed to them at Pentecost. The decisive tangible evidence and proof of this was "they heard them speaking in tongues."
It is thus obvious that the manifestation of tongues at Pentecost (Acts 2:4) and Caesarea (Acts 10:46) was not a sign to the apostolic gift itself (I Corinthians 12:1-14:40). In both cases, the sign was to the Jews. At Pentecost, the sign to the Jews was of the outpouring gift of the Spirit upon them and the inauguration of a new age. At Caesarea, the sign to the Jews was that the outpoured gift of the Spirit upon the Gentiles was an identical gift equal in every sense to the gift lavishly bestowed upon them at Pentecost. In both cases, the sign was also meant to demonstrate that the Spirit was lavishly bestowed to work out in believers Christ's glorious salvation purchased at Calvary; and to enable them to herald the glorious message of this salvation to the ends of the earth (Acts 1:8).
It is also to be carefully noted that at both Pentecost and Caesarea, the sign of tongues was neither related to the baptism of the Spirit, nor to the filling of the Spirit, but to the giving of the gift of the Spirit. However, this extremely important distinciton is to be made. At Pentecost, the sign of tongues, like the wind and the fire, was evidence of the initial age-opening giving of the gift of the Spirit, in the vertical sense of being dispensed from heaven and deposited permanently as the free gift on earth. At Caesarea, the sign of tongues was evidence that the introductory phase of the age opened at Pentecost was now completed and that the normal course of the age was established as the gift deposited permanently on earth in the church (since Pentecost), given in a horizontal sense to others besides Jews and Samaritans, that is, to the Gentiles, who comprise the rest of the human race.
The meaning of the conversion of the Ephesian
disciples
This is the account of the conversion to Christianity of the dozen or so disciples of John the Baptist and students of Apollos whom Paul found at Ephesus (Acts 19:1-7). This incident demands careful scrutiny on the surface, and especially in the misleading rendering of the original Greek in the Authorized Version. The passage might seem to teach that receiving the Holy Spirit is an experience subsequent to salvation.
To present a sound interpretation of the events at Ephesus, the episode must be correlated with the other key passages on the Holy Spirit in Acts that enter into a correct interpretation of Acts 19:1-7. These passages are Pentecost (Acts 2), the Samaritan revival (Acts 8:14-25) and Cornelius' conversion (Acts 10).
The dozen men seen in (Acts 19:7) represented individuals within the Jewish racial category. They accordingly belonged to an ethnic group, to which the gospel of grace ministered by the outpoured Spirit, had been opened at Pentecost some twenty years or so previously. They, for reasons clearly suggested in the context which bears on their case (Acts 18:24-19:2), did not have the gospel of grace presented to them during the introductory period. As a result, they were not New Testament believers (Christians), but only disciples of John the Baptist. They were well taught in the Old Testament by Apollos (Acts 18:24-26), but ignorant of the meaning of Pentecost and of full and free salvation by grace then available to Jews or Jewish proselytes.
Like their teacher Apollos, they knew only the baptism of John and nothing of the baptism of the Spirit (Acts 18:25; 19:3). Like John, and their teacher Apollos, they consequently were acquainted only with baptism in water "unto the remission of sins" (Matthew 3:11; Mark 1:8; Luke 3:16, 17), a baptism purely preparatory and introductory to the baptism of the Spirit, the latter provided by Christ through His death (John 1:19-34) and ministered by the Spirit poured out by the risen and ascended Savior at Pentecost (Acts 1:5; 11:16).
These dozen disciples were believers, but for all practical purposes were still living in the superseded Old Testament age. They were similar to Jesus' disciples before Pentecost and not radically different from Old Testament saints in general. Although they were living in a new age, now established in its normal course with the gospel of grace released to Jews, Samaritans, and Gentiles, they, as Jews or Jewish proselytes, still were living - insofar as their knowledge and spiritual experience were concerned - in the pre-Pentecostal period. Although they were doubtlessly regenerated as Old Testament saints were, they were neither baptized, indwelt, sealed, nor filled with the Spirit. In other words, they were not saved with New Testament salvation provided by Christ's death and resurrection.
These disciples were representatives, doubtless of many other Jews or Jewish proselytes, in the transitioned period between the mosaic age and the new age of grace, who had believed in Christ, the coming One or the One who had come and made atonement (Acts 18:25), but who had no clear presentation of salvation. These disciples were still performing and trusting the mosaic ceremonies for salvation in addition to faith in Christ (Acts 15:1, 5).
The conversion of the Ephesian disciples illustrates the importance of correct doctrine to act upon for faith. The primary deficiency of the Ephesians was a lack, not of faith, but of correct doctrinal teaching for faith to rest upon. The object of faith is just as vital as faith itself. Modern charismatic revivalism does not lack faith, but rather accurate doctrinal truth to take hold of faith.
The object of the Ephesian disciples' faith was faulty. John the Baptist's message of baptism in water for repentance was now antiquated and superseded by the baptism of the Spirit, placing the believer in Christ, and giving him his glorious position before God, the basis of all his possessions and blessings in Christ. Faith in the gospel of grace alone could bring the free gift of the Spirit and the blessings of the Spirit's inwrought salvation based upon a completed redemption. The moment these disciples believed the gospel, the Spirit of God, who had come at Pentecost, worked the glorious salvation of Christ in their hearts and they became Christian believers (Acts 19:4,5).
They were then baptized in water with Christian baptism in the name of Jesus Christ, signifying their identity with Him who had purchased their salvation (Acts 19:5).
The Ephesian disciples and tongues
The twelve Jews, or conceivably Jewish proselytes, had no knowledge whatsoever of Pentecost or its meaning; that the Spirit had been given to them as a race and a new age had commenced. This is evident from their reply to the apostle Paul when he asked them if they had received the holy Spirit (Acts 19:2). "But we did not so much as hear that the Holy Spirit is" (Greek).
The same idiom is employed in John's gospel to explain Jesus' prophecy of the Spirit to be outpoured at Pentecost (John 7:37-39). To explain the idiom, the following equation can be set up: a) before Pentecost, "the Holy Spirit was not yet" (John 7:39); b) at Pentecost "the Holy Spirit came and took up residence"; c) after Pentecost, "the Holy Spirit is" (Acts 19:2). They actually became Christians. In all this, there is not the slightest ground for the error of a "second blessing." Paul's question to them was, "Did you receive the Holy Spirit when you believed?" (Acts 19:2). This accurate rendering does away with any false idea that the Spirit was received at sometime subsequent to the exercise of saving faith in the gospel of grace.
Summary of the sign of tongues in Acts
1 The gift of tongues in the book of Acts was a sign in every instance (2:4; 10:46; 19:6). In no case were they the apostolic gift itself (I Corinthians 12:1-14:40).
2 The gift of tongues in the book of Acts was a sign or evidence to the Jews only, never to the Gentiles.
3 The gift of tongues in the book of Acts was a sign or evidence to the Jews collectively in a racial and religious sense.
4 The gift of tongues in the book of Acts was a sign or evidence to individuals only in a qualified sense.
Tongues was not the sign of the baptism of the Spirit, nor of the filling of the Spirit, but only of the receiving of the gift of the Spirit. Even then, the individual was not in view, except as a member of a racial or religious group.