Chapter 6 of 10

God Changes His Mind

18 min read · Pages 69–86 of the printed edition

But let's look at the Bible to get a clearer understanding.

The story we are going to look at today picks up with Moses on the mountain receiving the Ten Commandments. While on the mountain, the people below, with Aaron's help, built a golden calf and began to worship it. And the LORD said to Moses, “Go down, for your people, whom you brought up out of the land of Egypt, have corrupted themselves. They have turned aside quickly out of the way that I commanded them. They have made for themselves a golden calf and have worshiped it and sacrificed to it and said, ‘These are your gods, O Israel, who brought you up out of the land of Egypt!’” And the LORD said to Moses, “I have seen this people, and behold, it is a stiff-necked people. Now therefore let me alone, that my wrath may burn hot against them and I may consume them, in order that I may make a great nation of you.” But Moses implored the LORD his God and said, “O LORD, why does your wrath burn hot against your people, whom you have brought out of the land of Egypt with great power and with a mighty hand? Why should the Egyptians say, ‘With evil intent did he bring them out, to kill them in the mountains and to consume them from the face of the earth’? Turn from your burning anger and relent from this disaster against your people. Remember Abraham, Isaac, and Israel, your servants, to whom you swore by your own self, and said to them, ‘I will multiply your offspring as the stars of heaven, and all this land that I have promised I will give to your offspring, and they shall inherit it forever.’” And the LORD relented from the disaster that he had spoken of bringing on his people. Exodus 32:7-14 (ESV)

That last sentence is somewhat challenging if you come to the Bible with a fatalistic viewpoint. In response to Moses’ request, God relented from the thing that He said He was going to do. That doesn’t work well with the idea we have made of God who knows everything that will happen. This is God changing his actions based upon the actions of Moses.

Let’s read it in a few other translations:

So, the LORD changed His mind about the harm which He said He would do to His people. (NASB)

And the LORD repented of the evil which he thought to do unto his people. (KJV)

The word literally means repent. It means turning away from a course of action and doing another. The Bible says that God repented, that he changed His mind.

It wasn't like Moses presented a new idea to God that God had never thought of. We can't present God with a new idea; He has thought of all the ideas. He knew all the options and all the possibilities. It appears that God was waiting for a person to be faithful and willing to lead His people. Moses' courage and boldness showed God that Moses was that person, and God relented from the punishment that He said He would do. God changed His own mind. When Moses changed, God changed, and the people were unchained.

The story goes on:

Then Moses stood in the gate of the camp and said, “Who is on the LORD’s side? Come to me.” And all the sons of Levi gathered around him. (Exodus 32:26 ESV)

Like Moses had a choice on that mountain, he is giving the people a choice. People have choices. They always have choices. Moses had a choice. The tribes of Israel had a choice. You and me, we have a choice. The question is how do we respond when it is asked, "Who is on the Lord's side?" Because if you listen carefully, God is still asking that very question to all of us here today.

When in a battle between church tradition and Scripture, Scripture should always win. We can develop all sorts of beliefs about God when we abandon Scripture and start thinking in the ways of the world around us. Fatalism is a consequence of that approach. It dominated the church during the Enlightenment. If you want a rational, reasonable god, then you would create a god who does not change his actions based upon our actions. This god would no longer directly interact with humanity except through providence. The Christian world became less vibrant and less committed to living out the works of God because they created a reasonable god who they imagined preordained their salvation and their lives. For nearly the last four hundred years, reason was king in our society and the church discarded Scripture for their well-thought out yet unscriptural fatalism. We were ensnared by the prevailing thoughts of our time. We must always come down on the side of Scripture when there is a battle between church tradition and Scripture or between society and Scripture.

God Changes His mind again

Now, let's look go from the story of Moses, where God changed his mind based upon the actions of Moses to the story of Jonah. Jonah was told by God to go to Nineveh and preach that destruction was coming their way because of their evil ways. Jonah did not want to do it, but through a series of events, he found himself reluctantly prophesying to Nineveh and hoping for their destruction. The word reached the king of Nineveh, and he arose from his throne, removed his robe, covered himself with sackcloth, and sat in ashes.

And he issued a proclamation and published through Nineveh, “By the decree of the king and his nobles: Let neither man nor beast, herd nor flock, taste anything. Let them not feed or drink water, but let man and beast be covered with sackcloth, and let them call out mightily to God. Let everyone turn from his evil way and from the violence that is in his hands. Who knows? God may turn and relent and turn from his fierce anger, so that we may not perish.” When God saw what they did, how they turned from their evil way, God relented of the disaster that he had said he would do to them, and he did not do it. But it displeased Jonah exceedingly, and he was angry. (Jonah 3:6-4:1 ESV).

This story carries a similar theme to Moses' story in Exodus. God tells the people of Nineveh that He is going to destroy them, but the king of Nineveh calls the nation to repent of their evil ways. God sees their repentance and changes His plans. People change, God changes his actions. Imagine if the Ninevites believed that they were predestined to be punished (because God actually said He was going to punish them) and that they could not change their fate from God's "plans."

God doesn’t change, but He changes His mind again

Now, if you really know your Bible, you may be thinking to yourself, “But how do these stories line up with the passage where the Bible says that God does not change?” Let’s look at that passage. The word of the Lord came to Samuel: “I regret that I have made Saul king, for he has turned back from following me and has not performed my commandments.”

Saul said that he did it to offer sacrifices to the Lord, but Samuel stated, “Has the Lord as great delight in burnt offerings and sacrifices, as in obeying the voice of the Lord? Behold, to obey is better than sacrifice, and to listen than the fat of rams. For rebellion is as the sin of divination, and presumption is as iniquity and idolatry. Because you have rejected the word of the Lord, he has also rejected you from being king…And also the Glory of Israel will not lie or have regret, for he is not a man, that he should have regret.” (Excerpts from 1 Samuel 15:10-35 ESV)

He who is the Glory of Israel does not lie or change his mind; for he is not a man, that he should change his mind. (1 Samuel 15:29 NIV)

This story takes place in the middle of the context of God removing Saul as king and appointing David. That's a change in case you missed that. Saul, who God anointed as king, was removed as king because of His disobedience. So God says that He does not change in the context of making a change in his actions. Now, we can either assume that God appointed the wrong person on purpose when He appointed Saul. This argument would hold that God wanted to teach the people a lesson in appointing a king over them who would fail to be faithful. Or we can conclude that God had hoped that Saul would be the king He destined Him to be. God had hopes, dreams, and plans for Saul, but Saul stumbled and failed to live in God's glory.

In light of all these passages, I conclude that Saul changed and became less fervent and faithful to God. As a result of these change, God brought about changes in HIS course of action. Saul lost his anointing, not because God wanted that to happen when he had appointed Saul as king, but because Saul changed.

God changed his course of action, but who God is never changing. That’s a distinction we have to make if we are going to allow these stories in the Bible to teach us the things about God that they are trying to teach. God is unchanging even when His course of action changes. His very nature stays the same. His goal for mankind stays the same. His love. His justice. His righteousness. Those are unwavering. This was emphasized in the story of Samuel because the people would begin to think that God is wishy-washy when He removed Saul, the king He appointed, for David. They would wonder, “Did God make a mistake?” But it’s not that God made a mistake. Unlike Moses and the people of Nineveh, Saul changed in the wrong direction. God’s actions will change based upon our faithfulness or lack of faithfulness. But God doesn’t change.

Improvements from believing

God changes His mind

So we have this false yet prevalent idea that God forces His will to happen and that everything that happens is exactly what God wants to happen. This is a very dangerous belief though. It keeps us enslaved. However, there are benefits to throwing off this idea.

  • Prayer Matters

Prayer not only changes us, but what we pray for influences the actions of God. Prayer matters. We see that clearly in the story of Moses. It's a meaningful conversation with the creator and controller of the universe, not some empty ritual that we must go through to become more of who He wants us to be.

  • You Can Change

You are not stuck into some fatalistic, predestined future. God does have a plan for you, but you have to change (and you can change!) to reach it.

  • The Evil Around Us Is Our Fault

If God is in complete control, then all the evil that happens around us is His fault. This would be the world He wanted. Shootings in schools and malls. Kids dying from dirty water. Tyrants killing innocents. But this is not God’s plan. If evil is the consequence of our fallen decisions that have created a fallen world that we live in, then when bad things happen it is our fault, not God's.

There is the story of a young man talking to Jesus. He asks, “So why do you allow things like famine, war, homelessness, crime, starvation, disease, suffering, despair, etc. to exist in our world?” And Jesus replies, “Interesting that you should bring that up as I was about to ask you the exact same question.”

Now, if fatalism was the view that Scripture taught, then God is big enough to live with the responsibility of all the wrongs committed in the world. But fatalism is not the view of Scripture, so there is no reason that we have to go around and defend it. God actually wants us to join in with Him in bringing about His kingdom plan here on earth as it is in heaven.

  • Your Actions Matter

Your actions matter. God is waiting for faithful people to bring about His will. There is a great disdain for good works in fatalism, but Paul wrote in Ephesians that we are saved by grace through faith for works. We are saved for works. We need to never get that confused with being saved by works, but, in this context, we are talking about how we can be total disciples and who God wants us to be. We can choose to do more for the Lord than we are already doing. And when we are in that position of being right with the Lord, we will want to do His works. What do you think of when you hear the name "Nobel?" More than likely, you think of the Nobel Peace Prize. We probably wouldn't even know the name Nobel if Alfred Nobel did not read his own obituary while he still had time to change his life. He was a real-life Tony Stark, who saw what He was doing and decided to change course.

The Story of Alfred Nobel

If you're like me, some days, we ponder what people will think of us after we will die. What will they remember? What will they say? Who will they think we were? This question was answered for Alfred Nobel.

When Alfred's brother died, the newspaper mistakenly thought Alfred had died and ran the obituary they had prepared ahead of time to be used at his passing. Nobel had a unique experience of opening up the morning paper and reading what people actually thought of him. He was not happy with the impression.

What will people say about you at your funeral? Will it be about the eternal things of God or the passing, yet alluring, things of this world?

Nobel's obituary showed that he would be remembered for inventing dynamite and being a weapons dealer. And that is not how he wanted to be remembered. So he set up a trust to promote world peace. Every year, we have the cause of peace promoted around the world through the Nobel Peace Prize because Alfred Nobel changed his actions after seeing what he would be remembered for when he would die.

Most of us will not be fortunate enough to read our obituary and have time to change our lives. We won’t have Jonah coming as a prophet of God to our town telling us that God’s judgement is coming. Death can come in the blinking of an eye. But we don't need that wake-up call. We just need to respond in faithfulness to God and do whatever He wants us to do. Now. It is never too late to obey Jesus'. We are never too broken to be mended. We are never too fallen to be healed. He calls us to love God and love our neighbor. He is in the restoration business. He wants to mend the broken relationships in our lives, but it starts with mending the broken relationship we have with Him. He wants us to forgive those who have wronged us, but it starts with accepting the forgiveness he freely gives to us. He wants us to love others, and it comes through his love overflowing in us. God doesn’t need perfect people; He just want faithful and willing people.

The Unchangeable Nature of God

By Peter Amsterdam

Audio length: 10:47

Download Audio (9.8MB)

The immutability of God—or His unchangeableness or constancy—is part of His divine nature. It means that God doesn’t change in His being, His perfections, His purposes, and promises. He doesn’t change in His nature or character.

The universe and all that is in it changes. There is transition, movement from one state to the next. People, for example, age; and as they do, they change. They grow or diminish in size, as well as intellectually and emotionally. Someone can also change morally, going from being a bad person to being a good one, or vice versa. Someone can study and practice a skill, and in the course of doing so, learn and eventually become proficient in what they have studied. These are all examples of change, which is part of life within creation.

However, God transcends creation. He doesn’t change. If He did, He would become either better or worse. He’d either grow in His intelligence and knowledge or diminish in it. He’d become more loving or less loving, more holy or less holy. But as God, He is infinite in all of these things. He therefore doesn’t improve or deteriorate in them. If He did, He wouldn’t be God.

All of creation is “becoming”—it’s becoming something different than what it presently is. God, in contrast to this, is “being.” He is. Always. He doesn’t change.

God’s character, His attributes or perfections, don’t change. He is always good, loving, just, righteous, holy, all-knowing, all-powerful, etc. There is never any varying in these things. He is constant.

If God’s character varied, then we couldn’t be certain that the God we know to be good and loving would remain that way. If God was subject to change, then at some point He could start thinking that sin isn’t so bad after all; He could eventually degenerate to the point where He would begin to do evil things Himself, and even eventually become an all-powerful evil being. But His character and attributes do not and cannot change. They are constant; there is no variation.

God doesn’t change in His purpose, His will, and His plan. Once He has decided that He will bring something about, He does it. His plan of salvation is something that He determined before the foundations of the world, and He carried out His plan as promised. Prophecies, predictions, and judgments throughout the Old Testament were fulfilled. His purposes of saving people through Jesus, of Jesus’ return, of eternal life for believers, of judgment, of heaven, don’t change; they remain firm.

God doesn’t change in regard to His Word and His promises. If He stopped honoring His promises, if He acted contrary to His Word, then He couldn’t be trusted. The promise of salvation, of eternal life, and His willingness to answer prayer, would all be in question. If God could change, then these bedrock foundations of our faith could change. But His promises and Word remain forever. “Your Word, O Lord, is eternal; it stands firm in the heavens.”

Does God change His mind?

When God’s unchangeableness is presented, the question often arises about the times God seems to have changed His mind, such as when God told Jonah to go to Nineveh to announce that in forty days the city would be destroyed. Another example was when He gave the ailing king Hezekiah fifteen more years of life, after having told him he was going to die.

When considering these examples where it looks as if God changed His mind, we must remember that God is a personal being who interacts with humanity. Within this interaction, God responds to man’s choices and decisions. When someone is doing evil, God is displeased with that person’s actions, but if the person repents and changes, then God’s relationship with that person changes. His overall love for the person never changes, but there is a response from God depending on the choices made by the person or people. In the case of Nineveh, because they were wicked, God’s response was that He rightly was going to destroy them. He told Jonah to tell them so.

When Jonah did, the people repented, and God’s response to their repentance was mercy.

With Hezekiah, God declared he was going to die, yet when Hezekiah prayed and wept, God responded to his prayer and healed him.

In these cases, God was responding in mercy and love to changes made and prayers prayed by the people involved. In neither example did God change His character or nature, nor His overall purpose and plan. God didn’t change, but the people changed, and God responded in accordance with His divine nature.

Author and theologian Wayne Grudem explains it this way:

These instances should all be understood as true expressions of God’s present attitude or intention with respect to the situation as it exists at that moment. If the situation changes, then of course God’s attitude or expression of intention will also change. This is just saying that God responds differently to different situations. The example of Jonah preaching to Nineveh is helpful here. God sees the wickedness of Nineveh and sends Jonah to proclaim, “Yet forty days, and Nineveh shall be overthrown!” The possibility that God would withhold judgment if the people repented is not explicitly mentioned in Jonah’s proclamation as recorded in Scripture, but it is of course implicit in that warning: the purpose for proclaiming a warning is to bring about repentance. Once the people repented, the situation was different, and God responded differently to that changed situation.6

Another factor to keep in mind regarding the scenarios above is that the Bible uses anthropomorphic descriptions of God, such as the mention of God having “relented” in the story of Jonah. These are best understood as descriptive language within human comprehension.

On this matter of anthropomorphic language, William Lane Craig says:

It’s vital that we understand the literary genre, or type, of most of these biblical stories. The Bible is in the form of narratives—they’re stories about God told from the human point of view. So a good storyteller will tell his story with all of the vivacity and color that he wants, to enhance his narratives. And so you’ll find stories in the Bible about God told from a human perspective, where God not only lacks knowledge of the future, but even lacks knowledge of what is going on presently.

God comes down to Abraham and says, “I’ve heard the outcry in Sodom and Gomorrah. I’m going to go see if what I’ve heard is really happening there.”7 Well, that would deny not only God’s foreknowledge but His knowledge of the present. And there are other passages where God is spoken of in other anthropomorphic terms as having nostrils and eyes, arms and other sorts of bodily parts, wings, and if you take all these literally, God would be a fire-breathing monster. These are anthropomorphisms. They are literary devices that are part of the storyteller’s art and shouldn’t be read like a philosophy of religion or systematic theology textbook.

In each of these situations, God didn’t change in His nature, character, purpose, or promises. In fact, He was constant in all of these by being just, loving, righteous, and personal, and acting within His overall purpose.

God’s immutability—His constancy and unchangeableness—is central to our faith in Him. If He was inconsistent, if His nature or character was regularly changing, if He improved or deteriorated, then we couldn’t trust Him. We couldn’t trust His Word or His promises.

But God doesn’t change in His Being, nature, character, purposes, promises or plan. He can be counted on, for He is faithful and true. He is the rock that we can build on, the one we can trust in this ever-changing world, because He is the unchangeable God.

Originally published May 2012. Adapted and republished April 2017.

Read by Gabriel Garcia Valdivieso.