Chapter 2 of 10
What is Limited Freedom or Limited Will?
Common sense and logic
“The lips of the righteous feed many, but fools die for lack of understanding.” (Proverbs 10:21 NASB)
The Bible emphatically states in Deuteronomy 29:29, “The secret things belong to the LORD our God, but the things revealed belong to us and to our children forever, that we may follow all the words of this law” (NIV).There are numerous mysteries in the Bible; for instance, no one can logically explain the doctrine of “The Trinity”. However, the Bible is not beyond reason and logic. Calvinists think that if God gives any freedom to man, that would diminish the power and Sovereignty of God. I strongly believe that God is all powerful although God has given limited freedom to man. The following examples will prove my point. Compared to any other religious books, the Bible provides clarity and makes sense. Then one may ask why we have so many denominations that are correct in their own way of interpretation. Each group uses a particular methodology or formula, and they see their own particular doctrine from Genesis to Revelation.
There is such a group known as Oneness Pentecostals that believe in Modalism, a doctrine that does not believe in the trinity the website Got Questions explains it this way:
The "Jesus Only" movement, also known as Oneness Pentecostalism or oneness theology, teaches that there is only one God, but denies the tri-unity of God. In other words, oneness theology does not recognize the distinct persons of the Godhead: Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. It has various forms—some see Jesus Christ as the one God, who sometimes manifests Himself as the Father or the Holy Spirit. The core doctrine of Oneness Pentecostal / Jesus Only is that Jesus is the Father and Jesus is the Spirit. There is one God who reveals Himself in different "modes." (Got Questions Ministries. “What are the beliefs of Jesus only / oneness Pentecostals?” Last Updated July 26, 2019. https://www.gotquestions.org/oneness-Jesus-only.html)
If you read their books, they have proofs to justify their particular doctrine. If one follows their formula of interpretation it may sound real and true. The same exact way Calvinists use numerous verses from Old and New Testament to support their doctrine. It is amazing to learn that many Christians lost their faith in Christianity and have become atheists and agnostics because of the strong teachings of Arminianism and Calvinism. The Pentecostals are Arminians, and their doctrine promises health and wealth for those who become Christians. The prosperity preachers have made significant impact in the world. I know personally and from history the premature deaths of many charismatics who refused to take any medication.
They have verses to support their foolish doctrine all over the Bible. When people are not healed the victims get depressed and abandon the Christian faith.
Jehovah’s Witnesses
John 1:1 says, “In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God” (NIV). But the Jehovah’s Witnesses’ Bible translates this as, “In [the] beginning the Word was, and the Word was with God, and the Word was a god (emphasis added).” (New World Translation (1984 Edition) Watch Tower Bible and Tract Society of Pennsylvania
https://www.jw.org/en/publications/bible/bi12/bo oks/john/1/)
In John 1:1 the term for “God” is twice used. In the first instance, the word is accompanied by the article; in the second instance (with reference to Christ) there is no article. It is this absence of the article that leads the Watchtower advocates to the unorthodox rendition “a god.”
The Watchtower procedure has been utterly repudiated by the best of the world’s New Testament Greek scholars.
There are numerous instances in the original New Testament where the term Theos (God) is used either with or without the article “without any apparent difference in meaning” (Balz, 140).
But perhaps the best way to expose the Watchtower fallacy is to throw the spotlight on their egregiously inconsistent translation of Theos in those New Testament texts where Theos is unaccompanied by the article. (Jackson, Wayne. "What About That "a god" Translation in the Jehovah's Witness Bible?" ChristianCourier.com. Access date: August 17, 2019. https://www.christiancourier.com/articles/774- what-about-that-a-god-translation-in-thejehovahs-witness-bible)
The Jehovah’s Witnesses has played intellectual gymnastics in Greek Grammar to establish their doctrine.
The same way the Calvinists found different techniques and meanings to some words and asks you to believe it. Let us see John 3:16 King James Version (KJV), “For God so loved the world, that he gave his only begotten Son, that whosoever believeth in him should not perish, but have everlasting life.”
Here and many other places, Calvinist say that the word “World” means the elect.
The five points of Calvinism are presented in a logical way. Calvinism is an all or nothing system. Even if you embrace four point of Calvinism, they will contemptuously label you as an Arminian.
The Theory of population
I am providing some historical facts to prove that man can form his own destiny if he follows the Biblical principles within the limited power imparted from God and uses his commonsense.
Thomas Robert Malthus, (born February 13/14, 1766, England—died December 29, 1834 English economist and demographer who is best known for his theory that population growth will always tend to outrun the food supply, UK and that betterment of humankind is impossible without stern limits on reproduction. This thinking is commonly referred to as Malthusianism. (MacRae) (MacRae, Donald Gunn. “Thomas Malthus – English Economist and Demographer.” Encyclopædia Britannica, Inc., 05 April 2019, Britannica.com. https://www.britannica.com/biography/Thomas- Malthus. Access Date: August 17, 2019.)
Now atheists have even discredited this theory. If we correctly understand the sovereignty of God such theories will not have any value. God has provided every human enough resource to sustain and lead a comfortable life. His love and mercy toward the people, and His care for the animal kingdom is reiterated by our Lord Jesus Christ. Then, why is there poverty in the world? It is created by man who makes wrong choices in his life.
Most of the problems in the world are self-inflicted problems. All come from sinful selfish practices, whether in personal relationships between husband and wife, or between nations, not because God programed or decreed it before the creation of the world.
Most people do not have analytical thinking, because those who have some ability to think, find out that the Charismatics are not wealthier, or healthier than anyone else. So, they get depressed and lose faith in God in the same way when Calvinists teach that Jesus died on the cross only for a chosen few, and decreed majority of the people to go to hell. This doctrine diminishes the attributes of God and limits His power.
Decree of God before the foundation of the world
Truly the theology of eternal decree by Calvinists limit the omnipotence, omniscience and foreknowledge of God. Calvinism teaches that God can only know what He himself has decreed. If God did not foreordain all things including every aspects of humans, animal kingdom and nature, He could not know the future. According to them God knows everything in the past, present and future because He decreed everything in the eternity past. Also, God ordained sin, and man is to blame. Rationalists and atheists are glad to hear such ludicrous teaching. In addition, many Christians have become atheists because of this paradoxical teaching of Calvinism. I hear every week one particular statement by good Christians as a word of consolation to others who face difficulties.
Here is that statement “God is in control; and He is on the throne”. Was God not in control when Hitler murdered six million Jews in Germany or when Satan rebelled and a group of angels also defected, Eve ate the forbidden fruit? Does God’s being in control mean that all mass shooting, hurricane and wrong turn we take in the Highway?
Examine critically, the logic of eternal decree of God. The point is whether God has determined each person’s destiny before creation. Let us look at the nations in the world.
There are many countries that want to follow a dictatorship or enact socialism. What is their outcome? They all remain in misery while conversely all free market countries are affluent. No one questions the sovereignty of God. If you observe history and the Bible, we can understand that God gave limited autonomy, while providing instructions (Bible) on how to determine one’s own destiny. Does God intervene in the affairs of the world? According to Calvinism, God made all the decrees before the creation, and people and nations are on autopilot. Consistent with their view, prayer never changes anything. Then why do we pray?
They would answer that we need to pray because God command us to pray. It is like a drama, or a “Leela” (divine play) of Hindu gods. The Jehovah’s Witnesses give different meanings to many verses and established their denomination. Similarly, Calvinists provide different meanings to many verses and say that God had a Secret will. Calvinists claim that whatever happens, it happens for the glory of God. That means the Holocaust in Europe was also for the glory of God. What about the Islamic holocaust killing around 600 million people since the inception of Islam, and mass rape by ISIS terrorists? Do all of these things bring glory to God?
In Hinduism, there are three main gods: Brahma, Vishnu, and Siva. You would be amazed to know that according to the Hindu religious texts, the Hindu gods engaged in incest, fornication, envy, and many other embarrassing stories such as the worship of the phallus or Linga puja. They claim that it is all divine plays (Leela) of gods and is for the glory of god. Krishna, one of the incarnations of Vishnu, was unable to stop the great epic battle of ‘Kurukshetra”, as described in the Mahabharata. Millions of people perished in that carnage. He said it was ordained before and god could not alter their fate.
Poor people in America
American inner cities like Baltimore have a high population of low-income black families living in poverty. Most of them are dissatisfied and blame slavery for their plight. Most of them blame the “white man” for their calamity. Here is an article by Walter Williams, a black American and one of the eminent economists in the world.
By Walter E. Williams | May 19, 2015
Hustlers and people with little understanding want us to believe that today's black problems are the continuing result of a legacy of slavery, poverty and racial discrimination. The fact is that most of the social pathology seen in poor black neighborhoods is entirely new in black history. Let's look at some of it.
Today the overwhelming majority of black children are raised in single female-headed families. As early as the 1880s, three-quarters of black families were two-parent. In 1925 New York City, 85 percent of black families were two-parent. One study of 19th-century slave families found that in up to three-fourths of the families, all the children had the same mother and father.
Today's black illegitimacy rate of nearly 75 percent; this is also entirely new. In 1940, black illegitimacy stood at 14 percent. It had risen to 25 percent by 1965, when Daniel Patrick Moynihan wrote "The Negro Family: The Case for National Action" and was widely condemned as a racist. By 1980, the black illegitimacy rate had more than doubled, to 56 percent, and it has been growing since. Both during slavery and as late as 1920, a teenage girl raising a child without a man present was rare among blacks.
Much of today's pathology seen among many blacks is an outgrowth of the welfare state that has made self-destructive behavior less costly for the individual. Having children without the benefit of marriage is less burdensome if the mother receives housing subsidies, welfare payments and food stamps. Plus, the social stigma associated with unwed motherhood has vanished. Female-headed households, whether black or white, are a ticket for dependency and all of its associated problems. Ignored in all discussions is the fact that the poverty rate among black married couples has been in single digits since 1994.
Black youth unemployment in some cities is over 50 percent. But high black youth unemployment is also new. In 1948, the unemployment rate for black teens was slightly less than that of their white counterparts — 9.4 percent compared with 10.2.
During that same period, black youths were either just as active in the labor force or more so than white youths. Since the 1960s, both the labor force participation rate and the employment rate of black youths have fallen to what they are today.
Why? Are employers more racially discriminatory today than yesteryear? Were black youths of yesteryear more skilled than those of today?
The minimum wage law and other labor regulations have cut off the bottom rungs of the economic ladder. Put yourself in the place of an employer, and ask: If I must pay $15.00 an hour — plus mandated fringes, such as Social Security and workers' compensation — would it pay me to hire a worker who is so unfortunate as to possess skills that enable him to produce only $5 worth of value per hour? Most employers view that as a losing economic proposition. Thus, the minimum wage law discriminates against the employment of low-skilled workers, who are most often youths — particularly black youths.
The little bit of money a teenager can earn through after-school, weekend and summer employment is not nearly so important as the other things he gains from early work experiences. He acquires skills and develops good work habits, such as being prompt, following orders and respecting supervisors. In addition, there are the self-respect and pride that a youngster gains from being financially semi-independent. All of these gains from early work experiences are important for any teen but are even more important for black teens. If black teens (inner-city) are going to learn anything that will make them a more valuable employee in the future, they aren't going to learn it from their rotten schools, their dysfunctional families or their crime-ridden neighborhoods. They must learn it on the job.
The bulk of today's problems for many blacks are a result of politicians and civil rights organizations using government in the name of helping blacks, when in fact, they are serving the purposes of powerful interest groups. (Williams, Walter E., The True Black Tragedy, http://walterewilliams.com/the-true-black-tragedy/)
The following examples prove that we create our own destiny.
After the fall of South Vietnam in the seventies, millions of refugees came to America. They did not speak English, many had no education and had nothing. However, their culture fostered some values and lifestyle that can succeed in a free market country like America. They started small businesses with their family members, working and living together, saving their profits instead of spending it on alcohol or prostitutes. Amazingly within two decades, a large population of Vietnamese people became affluent and some even became multi-millionaires. Can black Americans or poor countries around the world say that God decreed them to be poor, and they are suffering due to the eternal decree of God?
God is always in charge and He intervenes according to His will and pleasure. God did not create artificial intelligence and robots. Make an introspection in our own life and lives of the people who we encounter every day. Many people made good choices in their lives and became successful. On the other hand, some people made bad choices and started drinking and smoking. Do you think God decreed his life as an alcoholic before the creation of the world? God has given humanity limited freedom to choose his own destiny. Try to walk outside in a subfreezing temperature without proper clothes. That person will die of frost bite and would freeze to death. God has given us commonsense and the Bible. It is for us to utilize it wisely.
Indians in America
The following facts would prove that God has given limited freedom to humans so they can create their own destiny. The Indian population of India suffered and still suffering due to socialist policies. They made excuses why India could not progress. Even the so-called great economists believe that India had too many negative factors that prevents her growth. The Indian elites and rulers found solace in the fact that it was their fate to be poor forever. The Socialists asserted that India has a high population, limited natural resources, and various languages, all such things being the reasons for their plight. In addition, they blamed American CIA for all their misfortunes. In 1991, the Indian government began limited liberalization policies and India started to grow rapidly.
China started the liberalization in 1978 under the visionary leadership of Deng Xiaoping. Communism was for administration only. The Chinese invited American companies and corporations to transfer all manufacturing to China for cheap labor. The Chinese demanded the transfer of technological secrets of American companies. In addition, China stole intellectual secrets too. Both Republican and Democratic leaders allowed China to loot America and the trade imbalance reached up to 800 billion dollars per year. Thus, China became the second largest economy, and it may surpass America very soon.
When compared to China, India was more developed, however they started liberalization only in 1991, and the liberalization was very minimal and implemented very slowly. Since India has around 300 million English-speaking people, American corporations transferred their call centers and manufacturing plants to India. Millions of young Indians became millionaires within a decade. In the communication and technology area, India is not behind anyone today. The immigrants from India made great achievements in the United States.
Indians are at the top of three dozen corporations in America including Microsoft and Google. If these people were still India, they could be doing some mediocre jobs, leading above average lifestyle. There are millions of smart people in India, but because of socialism, they could not excel, so instead they live in mediocrity. The Indian people didn’t get smart as soon as they landed in USA. Capitalism in America enabled them to exercise their innate abilities. The free market system in America will provide equal opportunity not equal outcome. In 1978, a socialist Industry Minister in India, George Fernandez, kicked out several American companies including IBM, one of the most innovative technological companies in the world at that time. Thus, he destroyed the future of millions of Indians. One man can build or destroy a country. Conversely, look at Chandra Babu Naidu, the chief minister of Andhra Pradesh from 1994-2004, and from 2014 -2019. He made Andhra Pradesh into an Asian tiger over the 20 years while he was in office. He slashed food subsidies, introduced free market reforms, and unleashed the individual ingenuity of his people. Time magazine wrote, “He has turned an impoverished, rural backwater place into India’s new information-technology”. Some prominent men are from south India especially from Andhra Pradesh. Malayalees (From Kerala State) used to be around every nook and corner of the world. There is even a joke that a Malayalee had a coffee shop on the moon. Now the Telegu people of Andhra Pradesh have replaced Malayalees from Kerala just because Chandra Babu Naidu changed the destiny of the Telugu people single handedly. There is another phenomenon in America. For many decades, Indian children have been the Champions of spelling bee. Indians are most finalists and they have to defeat other Indian students. The majority of Indian kids in spelling bee are south Indian origin.
How did they come to the top? The Indian parents focused on the success of their children, and their family culture contributed to their overall success.
Why did I write these facts or what is the relevance here with Calvinism? My point is that God did not make a secret decree for the South Indian kids to excel in American schools. God did not have a secret will, for black American families to have 70 percent illegitimate birth rate. Black Americans had the same opportunity in America to succeed. Unlike the thinking of the Democratic party, I believe that black Americans and others have equal intelligence and ability. They are not inferior, and they do not need any special protection. Thomas Sowell, a prominent black American economist, made the following statement, “Have we reached the ultimate stage of absurdity where some people are held responsible for things that happened before, they were born, while other people are not held responsible for what they themselves are doing today?”.