Chapter 1 of 10
Introduction
I am grateful to the Lord for giving me an insight to solve the puzzle that bifurcated the Christian Church for five centuries. My solution is sufficient to satisfy both Calvinists and Arminians.
This work is to rescue true believers from the shackles of five-point Calvinism and about the power and plan of God for the world. My goal is not to debate the five points of Calvinism, but to point out some serious errors and misconceptions believed by Calvinists. While following a few pro Calvinist websites through Facebook, one truth became evident to me: the ardent followers of Calvinism are following a cult. There is one prominent Kerala Christian who claims that Jesus Christ is a five-point Calvinist which prompted me to write this booklet.
In America, a Calvinist website conducts a daily discussion about the greatness of this teaching. Recently in February 2019 on this website, I saw a question by a participant and he was asking who the best teachers of Calvinism were, and the answer given was Jesus and Paul. I believe that all true Christian believers should be a strict Biblicist, and should not accept any worldly labels such as “Calvinist”, “Arminian”, or any other sectarian identification. This is like putting different labels on empty bottles. There are plenty of good books for a comprehensive study on the entire theology of Calvinism. My thesis is based on facts from Christianity, Hinduism, Islam, Economics, Sociology, History, and psychology.
I have great admiration for many reformed leaders such as R.C. Sproul, C.H. Spurgeon, and John MacArthur. For 35 years, while commuting to work, I used to listen to the radio messages of R.C. Sproul and I still tune in frequently to hear him even after retiring. Although these reformed leaders have made great contribution to Christianity, their teachings have misled thousands of believers all over the world.
There are many groups and subgroups of Calvinism. The Calvinists bifurcates Christianity into two classes: Calvinism or Arminian. They give an impression of superiority using scholarly words and phrases, and they look down on the other Christian groups. This is similar to the old Communist nations and how they used special words to demonize the free market system and Western countries like America, calling them names like “Blood thirsty Imperialists”, “Parasites”, “Colonialists”, “Reactionaries”, etc. Interestingly, these evil communist countries called themselves “The Union of Soviet Socialist Republics”, “People’s Republic of China” or “the Democratic People’s Republic of Korea” (North Korea). These names have no real truths, because they were used for propaganda.
I don’t want to be in either group and want to follow the Biblical truths. History proves that if you follow certain leaders or groups it doesn’t bring any glory to God. I may agree with some doctrines of Calvinism, however that doesn’t make me a Calvinist. Just like I agree with the teachings of the Trinity by the Catholics, it doesn’t make me a Catholic. All the Brethren pioneers also believed in Election and Predestination. Most of them came from a Puritan background, and they had a leaning towards Calvinism. Later, Brethren teachings evolved and shifted away from Calvinism. Early brethren like John N. Darby, William Kelly, F.W. Grant, and C.H. Mackintosh were neither Calvinists or Arminian. If you would like to research, you can go to stempublishing.com to verify their real stands. For example, read: “One-sided Theology” (about Calvinism and Arminianism) by C. H. Mackintosh. Darby’s writings are so huge, it may be difficult for a regular reader to research all his writings. It may not be available in many parts of the world. I am providing some fast research tips for the reader to figure out what Darby actually taught concerning Calvinism.
This website (www.presenttruthpublishers.com) has a monthly publication called “Thy Precepts”. The following magazines on Calvinism are worth reading.
May/ June 2007 Vol.22, #3
Jan/Feb 2007 Vol.22 #1
July/Aug 2006 Vol.21, #4
Nov/Dec 2003 Vol.18 #6
May/ June 2005 Vol,20 #3
There are many more.
Calvinists think that they are the custodians of biblical doctrines. Most of these teachers like C. H. Spurgeon, R.C. Sproul, J. I. Packer, Louis Berkoff, James Montgomery Boice, John Gerstner, and so many others ridicule dispensationalism and the Brethren Movement. They call dispensationalism a cult and “heretics”. Many of them are Presbyterians, Lutherans, and from other Churches who practice false doctrines similar to that of Martin Luther and John Calvin.
In the early part of the nineties, I taught in my local assembly from the book “The Sovereignty of God” by A.W. Pink. While I have been teaching from this book, I felt restlessness in my inner soul. The teachings of Pink and others conclude that God is the author of sin and God doesn’t approve of sin, however, man is to blame for the sin God caused them to commit. This incongruous and paradoxical teaching questions the character and justice of God. A serious Bible student can be confused and may even lose faith in God. Calvinists, who are anti-Israel, teach replacement theology, that all the blessings given to Israel in the Old Testament have been transferred to the Church, and that Israel has no place in this age. At the same time, all the curses given to the disobedient nation of Israel in the Old Testament would still be applicable to the present-day Israel. From this inconsistent teaching alone, we can understand that all Calvinists and Reformed people are misled and biased thinkers. When I saw the fervency of Calvinists being like that of a cult, I began to pray and ponder, and I escaped from this blasphemous teaching.
The role of the Holy Spirit is minimized under Calvinism. If you follow the methodology of Calvinism, you would have to ignore many sections from the scripture such as Ephesian chapter 6 which deals with spiritual warfare. Calvinists believe that we receive faith from God, at the same time Eph. 6:16 says to take the shield of faith. John Calvin also attributed to God giving false light to those whom God has predestined to damnation in order to deceive them. This makes Jehovah in parity with Allah, the god of Islam who bragged by calling himself “Khayrul Makereen”, which literally means “the Greatest of all Deceivers” (Quran 3:54). In Hinduism, the gods Brahma and Siva gave boon to Asuras (Demons) to deceive themselves. Calvin’s understanding about faith contradicts 1 John1:9. “If we confess our sins, he is faithful and just and will forgive us our sins and purify us from all unrighteousness”. St. Augustine is the father of Catholicism and Calvinism. The thinking process of Muslims and Calvinists are indistinguishable in that Calvin trusted the inner witness of the spirit.
Similarly, Muslims believe they don’t need any proof because the Quran asserts that Muhammad is the prophet of Allah. The Muslim believer is exhorted not to question (the Quran) and they are to kill anyone who does. Calvin also prescribed the same result for those who disagreed with him.
Heresies have always existed, and they have been an attack against Christian doctrinal teachings from the beginning of first century. In the long run, Calvinism proves to be a fatal blow to worldwide evangelism. Calvinists and reformed Christians indisputably believe God doesn’t love the entire world, but that He loves only a select few, and they are predestined for heaven. The rest who are not chosen, have no opportunity of getting into heaven.
Calvinism is a form of Theistic Fatalism, which is defined as “the doctrine whereby all events are predetermined by fate and are therefore unalterable.” Calvinism teaches that God predetermined the fate of all men by an immutable decree, such that from eternity past, every man’s lot in life has been fixed and determined by the arbitrary power of God. Let me quote Harry Ironside, the prince of expositors:
Turn to your Bible and read for yourself in the only two chapters in which this word predestinates or predestinated is found. The first is in Romans 8:29-30, the other is in Ephesians1:5 and 11. You will note that there is no reference in these four verses to either heaven or hell but to Christlikeness eventually. Nowhere are we told in the scripture that God predestinated one man to be saved and another to be lost. Men are to be saved or lost eternally because of their attitude towards the Lord Jesus Christ. Predestination means that someday all the redeemed shall become just like the Lord Jesus. (Full Assurance, pp. 93-94)
The arguments used by Islamic scholars in their commentaries to rationalize their doctrine of predestination is identical to the ones used by the Calvinist scholars. If you remove some of the words such as “Allah”, the statements become indistinguishable from Calvinist commentaries. Dr. Samuel M. Zwemer an American missionary to the Muslims wrote that “Islam indeed in many respects is the Calvinism of the Orient”. (Zwemer,) Calvinism subtly crept into Kerala Brethren assemblies and hoodwinked unsuspecting believers very easily.
John Horsch in the “History of Christianity” says “According to Augustine’s teaching, the history of mankind would, from a religious and spiritual point of view, be little more than a puppet show” R. C. Sproul writes, “God wills all things that come to pass…God desired for man to fall in to sin.. God created sin” (R. C. Sproul, Almighty Over All – Baker Books 1999 page 54) The following quotation by a staunch Calvinist Edwin H. Palmer in “Five points of Calvinism “proves the exact similarity of Hindu fatalistic view and doctrinal view of Calvinism.
Foreordination means God’s sovereign plan, whereby He decides all that is to happen in the entire universe. Nothing in this world happens by chance. God is in back of everything. He decides and causes all things to happen that do happen…He has fore-ordained everything “after the counsel of his will” (Ephesians 1:11): the moving of a finger, the beating of a heart, the laughter of a girl, the mistake of a typist- even sin”
The above view is a good fodder for atheist and some Christians because they can blame God for everything. Augustine taught that even unelected infants also are doomed.
Today, the American Reformed Churches and their leaders are trying to recover their lost doctrine of Calvinism and endeavoring to convert all Evangelicals to their philosophy. They have deviously infiltrated among the Southern Baptists and Brethren Assemblies in America. R.C. Sproul, the modern apostle of reformed doctrine, lamented about the lack of Calvinism among evangelicals because most of them are dispensationalists.
It was John Nelson Darby, during his visit to the United States in 1862, who converted the Baptists to be dispensationalists. Now, the American reformed movement is coming back with a vengeance.
John Calvin, in a comparable fashion to Catholics, murdered the people who disagreed with his doctrine. This proves that Calvin’s life was not controlled by the Holy Spirit and he had no access to God’s mind.
Burning Heretics
Calvin had sent a copy of his book Institute of the Christian Religion to Michael Servetus a Spanish thinker, who was also a gifted scientist and geographer. Servetus was the first person to accurately describe the human circulatory system. He read Calvin's work and made many refutations Three important ideas he criticized were Calvin’s teachings on infant baptism, predestination, and Calvin's explanation of the Trinity. (Servetus had many erroneous teachings regarding Trinity). He then sent Calvin's book back to him with his negative comments.
Infuriated, Calvin remarked that if Servetus ever came to Geneva, he would never leave the city alive. However, the Catholic Inquisition caught up with Servetus before Calvin did. He got arrested in France (where he had fled) and sentenced him to be burned at the stake as a heretic. Servetus escaped from prison and was headed to Italy, when on his way, he unwisely passed through Geneva. He thought it would be interesting to hear Calvin preach.
But Calvin recognized Servetus in the crowd and ordered his arrest. The authorities threw him into a horrible dungeon where there was no heat or light, and little food.
At his trial, Servetus was denied the right to have a lawyer or attorney. The authorities charged him with forty articles of heresy, and the judge did not allow Servetus to explain or defend any of the things he had written. After hearing the evidence, the Geneva authorities condemned Servetus to be burned to death at the stake for his heretical teachings, even though he wasn't a citizen of Geneva, but was just passing through. The executioners chained Servetus to a stake and piled a bundle of wood, about half of which were green, around him. Because of the green wood, Servetus died a slow and agonizing death while the crowd watched in amusement. Do you see any difference between Calvin and with modern day Islamic extremist like Bin Laden?