Chapter 14 of 15

Pilgrims Vs Puritans

6 min read · Pages 58–61 of the printed edition

Sometimes people think there was no difference between the pilgrims and the puritans. Both the pilgrims and puritans disagreed with many things about the Church of England in their day. But the pilgrims felt that reforming the Church was a hopeless endeavor. They were led to separate themselves from the official Church and to hold their worship services in a completely different manner. Hence, they were often labelled “separatists”. The puritans on the other hand, wanted to reform the Church of England from within. They argued from within for the purity of the Church. Hence, the name puritans.

The puritans were well-educated, wealthy, smart, professional men traveling with their families.

JOHN WINTHROP’S FAMOUS SPEECH

John Winthrop was the leader of another group of puritans who came to America in 1630. He gave a classic speech, known as “a model of Christian Charity”; while on board their ship, the Arbella. In the course of this lengthy exhortation, he called on the settlers to make Christian love the hallmark of their new colony. He recalled to their minds the main idea of covenant. “Thus, stands the cause between God and us. We are entered into covenant with him for this work”.

The Biblical idea of covenant was very significant. Winthrop was explaining that the puritans had made a covenant with God to obey him in the wilderness. The ultimate source of political power as the puritans saw it, was God himself.

The puritans did not view politics as a dirty business, as has sometimes been the case for modern Christians. For them, politics was a Biblical undertaking.

THE RESPONSIBILITY OF THE PEOPLE

The puritans continued to develop their views on government views which came directly out of a theocratic frame work. They were trying to create a new Israel, a new theocracy where God was the ruler through the ministrations of elected magistrates.

Since the puritans believed the Bible, they know well what Scripture teaches about the sinfulness of man. So, they created a system of government that did not permit too much power to flow into the hands of anyone person or group.

THE FIRST COMPLETE CONSTITUTION

Despite the fact that our modern constitution was drafted in Philadelphia, the motor vehicle license plates of Connecticut identify that state as “the constitution state”. The puritan founders of Connecticut really did write the first complete colonial constitution in America and yes, it too was a Spiritual/political covenant.

A haven for religious dissident’s Galatians-5:1 “It is for freedom that Christ has set us free. Stand firm, then, and do not let yourselves be burdened again by a yoke of slavery”.

America began as a haven for Christian refugees not only for the pilgrims and puritans who created colonies in New England; but also, for the Huguenots, Presbyterians, Roman Catholics, Quakers, Baptists, German dunkers and many others. Many religious refugees still come to our shores today. Our Christian nation welcomes refugees of every faith, precisely because of its Biblical heritage, which mandates that every person must come to God without coercion and through a personal act of faith.

This nation was founded as a sanctuary for religious dissidents.

ROGER WILLIAMS

Whenever the story of freedom is told, Roger Williams (1603-1683), the founder of Rhode Island, must be remembered. He was a pioneer for Christian liberty.

Roger Williams is sometimes represented in American history text book as a liberal who rejected puritan doctrine. But it was Roger William’s own dissident Biblical views that got him in to trouble with puritan authorities, making it necessary for him to flee from Massachusetts and found Rhode Island as a haven for religious freedom.

Williams questioned many of the puritan’s laws in Massachusetts, especially the right of magistrates to punish Sabbath breakers. He believed that requiring Church attendance, especially for those who were not sincerely religious, promoted hypocrisy.

Williams, who was the first to formulate the concept of separation of Church and state in America, said “the civil magistrate may not intermeddle even to stop a church from apostasy and heresy”. The separation was intended to benefit the Church. The doctrine of separation should not be confused in anyway with the modern secular misunderstanding of the separation of church and state. Roger Williams believed that the Church and the state were separate and distinct jurisdictions because the civil government may use the sword only to maintain peace not to impose doctrinal purity.

WILLIAM PENN -

Among the religious refugees who came to these shores in the 17th century were followers of George Fox, better known as Quakers. They were first labeled as such because they trembled at the word of God. The most important Quaker in America was William Penn, whose name has been forever enshrined in the annals of our history.

The state generally associated with him Pennsylvania, meaning “Penn’s woods or Penn’s forest was actually named for his father.

THE INFLUENCE OF JOHN CALVIN

John Calvin greatly influenced the founding of America. His theological influence on the founding of America was profound. It was Calvin’s stress on “covenant theology” that provided much of the frame work for the covenants, compacts, constitutions, and bodies of liberty which ultimately culminated in the U.S constitution.

American Calvinists

A key Calvinist doctrine that influenced early Americans was the Sovereignty of God over all spheres of life. Calvinists emphasized the belief that Jesus should not just be lord of their personal spiritual lives, but that he should also be Lord over every sphere of life- including politics and government. Their belief that the Lord superintends every area of life caused these American Calvinists to form Governments in the New World that respected religious liberty, while at the same time including Biblical principles in all aspects of personal, social, and political life.

Dr. Loraine Boettner, a Christian scholar who has sometimes been quoted by the U.S Supreme court, observed two-thirds of the population at the time of the Revolution had been trained in the school of Calvin.

Dr. Boettner wrote an over view of the Christian commitment of the colonists in the 1776 era. “Never in the World’s history had a nation been founded by such people as these. Furthermore, these people came to America not primarily for commercial gain or advantage, but because of deep religious convictions. It seems that the religions persecutions in various European countries had been providentially used to select out the

most progressive and enlightened people for the colonization of America”. Historian George Bancroft labeled the American war of Independence as a Presbyterian Phenomenon.

“The revolution of 1776, so far as it was affected by religion was a Presbyterian measure. It was the natural outgrowth of the principles which the Presbyterians of the old world planted in her sons, the English Puritans, the scotch covenanters, the French Huguenots, the Dutch Calvinists, and the Presbyterians of Ulster”.

Many in England placed the blame for the revolution directly upon the Presbyterian passion for liberty.

EDUCATION

Every founding father received a Christian education based on the Bible. America’s first college Harvard was America’s first college. The college was named for the reverend John Harvard. The school was founded in 1636, barely six years after the Puritans first began to colonize Massachusetts. The aim was to train ministers to preach Gospel. 200years it was a Christian institution last 100years it became an Anti-Christian University.