Chapter 5 of 15
Speech by Walter Williams
The False Civil Rights Vision
First of all, I am going to talk about some of our thinking in matters of race, but keep in mind that economics is perfectly general. When we talk about issues having to do with race, we can also use the same theory to talk about issues having to do with sex as well. But I am going to focus with issues having to do with race. Even after passing the Civil Rights Sets in 1964, the racial problem still exists in America. There has been unprecedented progress in race in very, very important ways. I think that it is fair to say that black people as a group in our country have made the greatest progress over some of the highest hurdles in the shortest period of time than any other racial group in the history of man.
For example, if you were to add up all income earned by blacks each year and thought of black people as a nation, then black Americans would be the thirteenth or fourteenth richest nation on the face of the earth. Black Americans are chief executives of some of the world’s richest and largest cities. Black Americans have much to be proud of despite all the harshness of the slave system, black people in this country are the wealthiest, best educated, most influential people on earth. Blacks constitute a major segment of the armed forces. They sit on the supreme court of the valued legal system of the world. Every day activities of their celebrities are followed worldwide. Again, ask yourself the question: where else would I rather be?
What other country offers the most opportunities and tradition? There are no African nations, Caribbean islands, South American countries where black people have made a better life for themselves. Now, neither a slave nor a slave owner would have believed these facts possible in the space of a mere century of freedom. Now, these achievements speak very well of the moral character of a people. Despite the monumental gains, there is a large segment of the black population for which these gains remain elusive, roughly 34 to 35 percent. A large part of their problem has to do with how we look at matters of race. Now to remedy this false civil rights vision, we must examine a number of premises and assumptions that have taken on an axiomatic status, and hence removed from examination.
The most central rights of the civil rights vision are that-and you hear them in college in your preps and your classes-that statistical disparities in income, education, and other social economic variables are moral injustices caused by society. That’s the central premises of the civil rights vision if you listen to any civil rights leaders or if you listen to politicians, that’s the central premise of their vision. Now underline this premise are several assumptions whose status is felt beyond question in many circles. Let me just list first the assumptions and then we will examine then to see how realistic or how valid they may be. The first assumption that underlies the civil rights vision is that discrimination leads to adverse effect on the achievement of those determined against.
This assumption turns a justification for the argument that blacks cannot make broad advancements until discrimination is eliminated in the larger society. Why it is so important whether that statement is true or not, is it’s an allocation of resources question. That is, if the current amount of discrimination that exists is not an insurmountable barrier, then maybe it pays to put resources in some other are where there is greater payoff, rather than trying to eliminate every vestige of discrimination in our society. The second assumption is that statistical differences between races simply and measure discrimination. The third assumption, which is somewhat like the second assumption is that statistical differences between people would not arise and surely not persist in the absence of racial discrimination or sexual discrimination.
Now, the second or third assumption form the basis for considerable litigation calling for employment quotes and college admittance quotas and other kinds of preferences. That is, people are saying. “Well, there are these statistical differences, they would not exist in absence of discrimination; therefore, we have to have various programs.” Now, we can examine these assumptions, to see how valid or how general they are. First, let us consider Jews, Jews have faced centuries of discrimination which did not end when they are among the highest income earners in our country and have the highest educational achievement. Well, a lot of people would say, well, it is unfair to bring up the issue of Jews because Jews are not a readily unidentifiable ethnic group. That is, they can just kind of avoid discrimination by changing a name from Gold Berg to another Anglo name. Well, let’s consider the case of Japanese, Korean, Vietnamese, Indians, and Chinese in America, which no one had any problem identifying.
Japanese and Chinese Americans saw gross discrimination in the United States, which included alien land laws into west, if you did not know, where eleven states made laws denying Japanese and Chinese their right to own land, and then during world War II there was internment for the Japanese Americans, which saw their property virtually confiscated yet by every measure of socio-economic success, Japanese Americans are at the top or near it. For example, Japanese Americans have the highest family income in our country. 35% of Chinese Americans are professional workers, again, compared to 15% of the nation as a whole. Japanese and Chinese Americans have the highest marriage stability in our country. Lowest alcohol and also lowest crime rates. So, again, there’s this question about whether discrimination leads to adverse effects upon the achievement of those discriminated against. Well, some might also say, “Well look, the people you just gave examples of, they came here voluntarily. They don’t have the unique heritage of slavery as did the black Americans.” Well, we can examine that hypothesis by looking at the experience of West Indian Americans, who were also enslaved in the Caribbean. West Indian Americans have a median family income that’s slightly higher than Americans in general. They have a slightly higher professional status. That is, 15% of West Indian Americans are professional workers compared to 14% for the nation as a whole. Well, how do you this? Do you say that, “Well, a racist takes time to find out whether a black is a West Indian Black and then lets them off the hooks opposed to a regular black of USA?
Now, we need not continue our attention solely to the United States to examine this assumption. We can do international comparisons. Chinese in South Asia, in all of Southeast Asia are a minority. The so-called overseas Chinese and in south Asia, in all of Southeast Asia, they’re no more than 12% of the population.
Yet, in some countries like Malaysia or Burma, the Chinese own and produce forty to sixty percent of the G.N.P. or you can look at the Americans in the post-Ottoman Empire where the Turks, during the 1900s tried to exterminate them. Killed millions Well, the Armenians have the highest income in the post-Ottoman Empire. And very often – not always – you find that it is the case where the people who are discriminated against sometimes have higher incomes and socio-economic status than the people who are doing the discriminating. What about statistical differences. The argument goes that but for the fact of discrimination, we could be distributed equally or proportionally across income and occupations and education and the people assume that statistical proportionality is the norm, and that if you don’t see it, well, then something is wrong. Well let me give you a few stark contrasts in statistical disproportionality and see what you can make of it in terms of discrimination. First, black Americans are 78% of professional basketball players and the highest paid ones. Well, if you see that gross statistical disproportionality, what you make of it? Can you say that black basketball players are conducting some kind of conspiracy against white basketball players? And God help Asian basketball players.
How do you explain it? Can you say that, “Well, the owners of these multibillion-dollar corporations?” Like the Los Angeles Lakers, and the New York Knicks, can you say that, “The owners of those corporations, they’re just nice guys. They are not like IBM and Sears and other corporations; they are just nice guys and that explains why there’s so much participation by blacks.” I don’t think that cuts it all. I think that you are searching for an answer, it is just that people like Michael Jordan and Hakeem can just do a 360-slam dunk in your face and you can’t do anything about it. They are just a high productivity. Another disproportionality is very interesting, that is Jewish Americans are roughly three percent of the population, yet they walk away with 34% of the Nobel Prizes won by Americans. Now, what do you make of that? That’s a gross disproportionality. Are Jews hiding the books from the rest of us?
Now, what I am arguing is that proportionality is not the norm. No matter where you go on earth, people are not sorted proportionality. Even in areas where people have complete control over their activity, such as preferences for entertainment, child-rearing practices, people differ significantly. They differ in their preferences for scotch or cigarettes or whatever. As a matter of fact, advertisers spend millions of dollars a year discovering these differences because they want to target people.
They want to be able to target the advertising effectively. If people were distributed proportionately in terms of taste, well, then there would be no basis for targeting advertisement. Now, a lot of people say that racial discrimination explains the problems that blacks face of problems that women face-sexual discrimination-but racial discrimination all by itself can explain very much in this world using racial discrimination to explain things is very much like asking me, well, what was the cause of the Grand Hotel fire in Las Vegas a number of years ago and a number of people were killed. Suppose I was to say that it was caused by oxygen.
Well, some of you snicker, but had there not been oxygen around, there would have not been a fire. What is wrong with explaining it by saying that it was caused by Oxygen? Well, by saying that it was caused by oxygen does not explain why the Washington Hilton did not also burn down that same night because it too was surrounded by oxygen. In other words, what I am saying is that oxygen is so pervasive, it’s everywhere, that it alone cannot explain anything. It is the same thing with discrimination. Discrimination is so pervasive that it does not explain very much in this world, and discrimination of all kinds, it’s not only race discrimination, sex discrimination, which we all do. We would not want to outlaw race and sex discrimination, would we? No all, because there are some activities whereby, I systematically discriminate against men - and there are other activities where I systematically discriminate against women.
Or when I was choosing a wife to marry, I didn’t give ever a woman equal opportunity. I never checked with her for an approval also.
And most of us behave the same way. But there are all kinds of discrimination. Height discrimination, language discrimination. As a matter of fact, when you attend this lecture, you have to discriminate against all other possible use of your time. That is, you could have gone somewhere else. You had to discriminate. And one of the basic things of economic theory is that scarcity requires discrimination, it requires choice. A lot of the language that we use in reference to discrimination just doesn’t make much sense. Just the concept of equal opportunity, it doesn’t make much sense. For example, how many of you when you graduate from college, are going to give ever employer an equal opportunity to hire you, including the city sanitation the army or whatever, you are going to discriminate with respect to employers.
Let me talk about prejudice. Prejudice is a very good concept; it is a very good word. It is a very good term, but it is misused, and if we confine our attention to the Latin derivative of prejudice, normally prejudged, then it would make much more sense and we can understand the word better. An economist can best understand pre-judging as making decisions on the basis of incomplete information. Let me give you an example of how people make decisions on the basis of incomplete information; that is, use stereotypes I always use stereotypes, and I am not ashamed of it. You do too, but you might be ashamed of it. For example, when you go outside, as you are going out of the door, suppose you saw a full-grown Tiger sitting there, what would you do? Well, my prediction is easy; that is most of you would endeavor to leave the area in great dispatch.
That is uninteresting, but if you ask why, then that is very interesting. That is, your decision to run based on any detailed information about that tiger? Or is your decision based on Tiger folklore? How you have seen other Tigers behave, what your mother has told you about Tigers. Probably your decision is based on the latter. That is, you stereotyped that Tiger. Now, if you were not to stereotype the Tiger, you would seek additional information before you ran. That is, you would maybe pat him on the head or- stroke him to see whether he was mean, and then, only then you would run. But most people make a quick calculation when they see it. They say they calculate that the expected cost of additional unit of information about that tiger is greater than the expected benefit- and so therefore, they don’t search anymore. They stereotype. This is what people do with respect to many things. In other words, what I am saying is that physical characteristics are proxies cheap to observe characteristics or proxies or can be used for mere costly to observe characteristics.
Employers do this. For example, an employer who is recruiting, and he says, “Look, I want to go to high schools, and I want to hire some students who would get, let’s say, 10000- 1200 on SAT and it cost me $75.00 per person I interview. Well, he must be careful where he sends his recruiters. He will not necessarily send his recruiters to a ghetto school. Why?
Because he knows that the likelihood of success is very low. That doesn’t mean that he does not like blacks or Hispanics. It means that he is using racial characteristics as a proxy for some other characteristic that is costlier to observe. Now, while you and I might not like it, that’s human behavior. Let me just kind of say what I think are some of the problems having to do with race in our country. First one of the big problems that black Americans face has to do with education. Even education to the general population is not good. I mean, it is bad news. But for black Americans, it was a disaster. If I were the grand dragon of the Ku Klux Klan and I wanted to sabotage black academic excellence, I could not find a better way to do so than the current public-school system in most of our cities. They deliver fraudulent education. We cannot blame school alone. Throughout many communities, weak families, crimes, and un-interested kids that the school has not power over these things. But they do have the power to decide whether they will issue a diploma that is fraudulent. We can blame the educational for that. The school system will ask for more money to fix this problem. But we have been dumping more money in in to education for several years, and all the scores and indicators have been going down. The cities that spend the most money on education or the states that spend the most money on education, its students score the lowest. You don’t need a lot of money. They need to come to school. They need to leave their guns and knives at home when they come to school. They must come to school sober, and their parents have to make sure that they do their homework. Another major problem in our cities that is devastating to the black community is the high level of crime in the black community. A lot of people would say that poverty causes crime. I think they have it the other way around, the wrong way around. You could make an argument for crime causes poverty. The level of crime in our cities, particularly in black neighborhoods, is just like a law that says that there shall not be any economic development.
That people who are the most about living in civilized communities should not enter the area. It is devastating. It is devastating to business. The tiny percentage of the black community that makes life a living nightmare for the overwhelming law-abiding majority, it turns out that these guys are equal opportunity crooks. That is, they will rip off a black-owned store just as well as they rip off a white-owned store. The crime impales very, very high cost on a community. It you go to some stores in the communities, you will see the rolled down gates in front of the windows Steal gates to install those things, they cost about 15000.00 to 20000.00 this is a cost that does not have to be incurred in a lower-crime community. The high crime causes very high insurance rates.
Bankers are not fools, they are very reluctant to lend money in these areas for businesses. And then the high crime imposes other costs that are not always seen, things like poor people have to get on buses and trolley cars to do their shopping at suburban malls or pay the high price of the “Ma and Pa” stores in their neighbor hoods. The crime imposes a very, very high cost on the law-abiding people, and if you look at it, the people who need law and order the most in our country are poor people. Poor people’s security depends on a lawful and orderly environment more than anybody else. Why? Because middle class and well-to-do people, if things get lawless, they can hire guards, they can have alarm systems for the homes, and if it gets too shaky, they can move. But poor people don’t have this option, they are stuck.
They are completely dependent on a lawful environment. Another big problem that poor people face and that has to do with much of the regulation of the economy. The minimum wage law cuts off the bottom rugs of the economic ladder. It makes it too costly for firms to hire low-skilled people, and it destroys jobs. Children want to make money by cleaning, shovel snow etc. Those opportunities are not open today. Let’s say like the American Railway union, they are not interested in seeing a kid shovel off a platform for twenty bucks when their member could get $200 for the same job. The retail clerk’s union is not interested in seeing a kid come in and sweep out a supermarket for $20.00. They will go out on strike. Then the minimum wage has destroyed many jobs. Long time ago if you went a neighborhood theater and there were two or three ushers to show you to your seat. Today you don’t see any. Now, why don’t you see ushers? Is it because Americans of today like to stumble down the aisles in the dark to find their seat? No, it is because the minimum wage law has destroyed that kind of job. Or you would go in a gasoline station years ago, and your car would be almost assaulted by young people. That is, one person to come to wash your window, one to check the hood one to check the air and tires and one to fill the tank of gas. Why do you think we have self-service stations today? Is it because Americans of the 1990s and 2000s like to smell gasoline fumes and get gasoline on their shoes while they fill up their tanks?
No, the minimum wage has destroyed that kind of job. Then there are other impediments to getting out of a poor environment occupational licensing law. Some of the most egregious forms of it is in the taxi cab business. We need to get rid of a number of these licensing laws. Do something to introduce competition in to education, and then we have to reduce welfare. That is, we have to reduce those things that give people incentives not to work. The war on poverty has been a tragic thing in the United States. Since 1965, we have spent 5 trillion on poverty program. Two and a half tri Million dollars in 1985 could have bought all of the financial assets of the future 500, companies, plus all the US farmland. In other words, just imagine we have given the poor people all the US farmland and all the fortune 500 companies.
The major beneficiaries from poverty programs have been poverty pimps. That is, those are those people who make their living on the existence of poverty. That is, the college professions who get 5000,000.00 grants to do studies on poverty and have meetings in Miami at a nice hotel in the winter to talk about the poor at a conference. The welfare system has made a large percentage of Americans, including black Americans, immune to the standard care for poverty, and the standard care for poverty has been a robust, growing economy during the eighties, but many, many people did not benefit. At one time during the 1980s, you could not walk two blocks in a commercial district without seeing “Help Wanted” sign, even $6.00 an hour at Wendy’s. But these jobs are turned down. Why? Because of the welfare system. The poverty among black Americans is roughly 30 percent. If the family structure had remained the same as it was in the fifties, black families would not be in the predicament today. That is, it has been a decline - you pick up the huge poverty rate among single female – headed households. If they don’t do something with that, then we are never going to solve the problem. It is almost a written guarantee that you are going to be poor if you have a baby when you are 14, and you drop out of High School, and you depend on welfare, it is almost a guarantee that not only are you going to be poor the rest of your life, but your kids are going to be poor as well. So, in conclusion, we need to approach our problems with greater insight and better attention, and we need to challenge some of the conventional wisdom of issues having to do with race. Thank you very much.