Chapter 2 of 15
Jesus among other gods: the uniqueness of Christianity Dinesh D’ Souza “What’ S so great about Christianity”
There are two types of people who allege that all religious are the same. The first group is made up of liberal believers. These well-meaning folks insist that all religions are equal pathways to heaven a position that only Hinduism endorses. But there is a wide spread sentiment in the west that religions are similar in that they are all human pathways to the divine.
The second group that considers all religious to be the same is Atheists. This group views all religions as equally false, and some unbelievers also hold them to be equally pernicious.
But contrary to what these people say, all religions are not the same. Most religions make exclusive and uncompromising claims about God and the human condition. As these claims are often incompatible, there is no way that all religions can be true. Certainly, it is possible for several to contain elements of the Truth. If one is comprehensively true, however, it follows that the rest must be false.
Even so, well-meaning people eager to avoid controversy commonly insist that all religions are different ways of comprehending the same truth. This is an erroneous view. As we have seen, there is a common morality that the great religions of the world share.
We can see that religions are not the same by looking at the way in which basic concepts are differently interpreted. Martyr is a term common to Christianity and Islam but largely alien to Judaism, Hinduism, and Buddhism. It comes from a Greek word meaning “witness”. In Christianity, the Martyr voluntarily gives up his life rather than his God. The Christian martyr was the man the Romans placed in the Lion’s den to be devoured for his refusal to renounce his faith. In Islam, a martyr takes up the cause of Jihad and loses his life killing for Allah. This is the sense in which Khomeini and Bin Laden have called on Muslims to be true Muslims “witnesses”. One term, but two different meanings.
In his comparative study of major religions, Huston Smith lists some crucial differences among them. Buddhism does not have a concept of the after-life or God. There is only one other religion that Christianity entirely embraces as divine revelation: Judaism. Christianity views itself as superseding Judaism, Islam views itself as superseding both Judaism and Christianity. Islam considers Moses and Jesus as Prophets, and Muslims, even endorse the concept of Christ’s virgin birth, but they do not regard Christ as the Messiah, and they do not believe he was crucified or resurrected in to heaven.
All religions are an attempt to solve the dilemma. Blaise Pascal (1623-1662) 17th century philosopher, Mathematician and Scientist, who invented calculator out lined in the Pen see’s. Pascal notes that for thousands of years man employed great intelligence and effort to solve certain basic problems. We want to have peace in the world. We want to live in Harmony with one another. We want to raise our children well. We want our lives to matter. Pascal says we have been at this for a very long time, so why haven’t we solved any of these problems? Why does the pursuit of happiness remain largely a pursuit? For leading Atheists like Richard Dawkins and Sam Harris, the simple answer is that man is ignorant, and science is the way to dispel that ignorance. A religious person knows that this is a half-truth. Science is only one way to achieve a certain kind of Knowledge. Science provides no answer to the questions above to reduce all knowledge to Scientific Knowledge is to condemn man to ignorance about the things that matter most in life. How, then can we understand the problem of good and evil that is such an obstacle to our happiness? Pascal noted that man is simultaneously heroic and wretched. He is capable of noble and wonderful thoughts and deeds, yet he also plots and performs horrible actions that are unworthy of even the lowest animals. Indeed, part of man’s greatness is that he can use his faculty of reason to recognize his baseness.
The situation can be described another way. Man has very high standards, but he is constantly falling short them. He knows what is good, but he will not do it. He is captive to selfish and evil desires, and he gives into those desires because his will is weak. All religious seem to agree in diagnosing the problem in this manner. And just about every religion agrees that the solution is to give man codes, commandments, and instructions for how to raise himself above his inclinations so that he can come within the reach of God. Religion in general in man’s strategic manual for how to reach God.
But Christianity is not a religion. Christianity holds that man, no matter how hard he tries, cannot reach God. Man cannot ascend to God’s level because God’s level is too high. Therefore, there is only one remedy: God must come down to man’s level. Scandalous though it may seem, God must quite literally, become man and assume the burden of man’s sins. Christians believe that this was the great sacrifice performed by Christ. If we accept Christ’s sacrifice on the basis of faith, we will inherit God’s gift of salvation. That’s it. That is the essence of Christianity. To some it may seem ridiculously simple. That is why Paul wrote that the message of the cross is foolishness to those who are perishing. 1 Cor: 1:18.
In the simplicity, however, there is considerable depth and richness. We can appreciate all this better if we put it into slow motion, so to speak, and examine each of its central tenets more closely. The first premises are that the propensity to Sin is in man’s nature. In other words, selfishness, acquisitiveness, lust and greed are part of who we are as humans. Darwin would have agreed with this. Indeed, the Darwinian portrait of man is a remarkable corroboration of the Christian doctrine of original sin. Darwin’s unflattering view of man is much more realistic and accurate than Jean-Jacques Rousseau’s naïve view that man is by nature good and society is responsible for his problems (1712-1778 Genevan philosopher). Darwin understood that man is closer to the beasts than to the angels. In some ways man is worse than the animals because they simply do what comes naturally, while man sins willfully and deliberately. So, man must pay the wages of sin and wages of sin is death.
This is the second premise of Christianity. The Bible equates death in the biological realm with sin in the moral realm. Some people will find this unduly harsh. Let us see why it is duly harsh. Sin structures our personalities and defines our thoughts and behavior. Sin, is built in to our habits so that we sin routinely almost unthinkingly. Sin is not peripheral to humans, something we occasionally do, but is much more intrinsic to our identities. So, does sin deserve a heavenly reward? Should God, who is eternally just and holy, compromise that justice and holiness and offer us salvation despite our hatred for Him and our desecration of His laws? It seems only fair that we who sin both against God and man should pay for our sins. This means that sinners cannot enter the Kingdom of God.
How, then are we to have salvation? For most religions, man must take the active roll. Hinduism and Buddhism offer solutions that are remarkably similar. Though meditation we confront our selfish desires and recognize that the “self” is the core of the problem. So, we strive, in various ways, to eliminate this self and achieve its extinction. In effect, we seek to become nothing.
We can advance toward this goal not merely through meditation but also through disciplined self-renunciation: renunciation of possessions, renunciation of sensual pleasure, and so on. This is a supremely difficult project. Among Buddhists only some monks claim to even approach Nirvana. The awareness of the charm separating holiness from human weakness has produced in Hindu and Buddhist cultures their distinctive fatalism. Many Hindus believe fate will decree whether they reappear as a prince, flea or a tree frog in the next life.
Judaism and Islam offer a different formula, although they lead their adherents down the same path. Judaism and Islam are religions of law. Both have elaborate rituals and codes: Pray five times a day. Pilgrimage to Mecca. Sacrifice a lamb and goat. Wear a long beard. Keep Kosher. The great Jewish jurist Maimonides even argues that circumcision is essential for salvation. “Whoever neglects the covenant of our ancestor Abraham and retains the foreskin, will have no portion in the world to come”. The rigor of these rules has caused many Jews and Muslims to ignore many of them and simply follow a select few prescriptions they can live with. These are the “reformed” Jews and Muslims, who seem to have given up trying to live up to full rigor of their legal codes. They are basically living in hope that God is not a sticker for details. But God is not a lenient tradesman willing to accept 30 percent payment: His justice demands full reimbursement. Still, it is hard not to sympathize with the slackers. They are actually correct that it is too difficult to render adequate recompense to God. We even sympathize with Christopher Hitchens who complains that if God wanted man to live up to these high standards, “he should have taken more care to invent a different species”. Christianity agrees with Hitchens that the standards are difficult; they are impossible. Old Testament Jews thought that they could observe all the Laws. But they utterly failed. Not only is it impossible to stop sinning – even the most devout.
Christians cannot stop sinning- but it is also impossible to atone for one’s past sins. How would you go about atoning for them? Can you locate everyone you have wronged and make them whole? Yes, you can resolve to live a subsequent life of goodness, but this is no atonement’ you should be doing this anyway.
Christianity raise the bar even higher than other religions by insisting that in order to enter God’s Kingdom we must be perfect. Not good, but perfect. Being good is not good enough. As no one is perfect, Christians have the saying that “the ground is level at the foot of the cross”.
My brother may be a better man than I am, and you may be a better man than he is, but ultimately none of this matter because none of us will make it under our own steam. The only solution is for us to “die to ourselves” and become totally different people, morally pure in the eyes of God. For unless the grain of wheat dies to itself, it shall not produce fruit, so Christianity agrees with Hinduism and Buddhism on the need to extinguish the old self. It disagrees by declaring in advance that this project is impossible. So how can a salvation be reconciled with divine holiness and Justice, the Christian answer is that God decided to pay the price himself for human sin. Not just this sin or that sin but all sin. God did this by becoming man and dying on the cross. The incredible moment was God’s decision to become man. No other religion can even conceive this. The Greek and Roman gods of antiquity often disguised themselves as mortals, but they would not actually become mortal. Mexican author Carlos Fuentes writes that when the Christian missionaries first presented their doctrines to the Aztecs, the Aztecs were totally uncomprehending. Fuentes writes, “In a universe accustomed to seeing men sacrificed to the gods, nothing amazed the Indians more than the sight of a God who had sacrificed himself to men”. Yet what other religions hold to be absurd, Christianity holds to be true.
Richard Dawkins writes that “atonement, the central doctrine of Christianity, is vicious sadomasochistic, and repellent”. This criticism makes sense only if you presume that the Christians made the whole thing up, which would be horrible of them to do to their God. Christians view the atonement of Christ as a beautiful sacrifice. God not only become man but took on all his sins and burdens in order to make him eligible for the heavenly kingdom. “Christ paid a debt he did not owe because we owe a debt we cannot pay”. Christ on his cross literally assumed all the darkness, loneliness, and sin of the world. Thus, through the extremity of Golgotha, Christ reconciles divine justice and divine mercy and provides man with a passport to heaven. The bridge man was unable to build to God, God has built for man.
“Christ offers us something for nothing”. C.S. Lewis writes, “He even offers everything for nothing”. In a sense, the whole Christian life consist in accepting that very remarkable offer”. So, what is the difficulty? The difficulty is in realizing that we are sinful and that there is nothing we can do to solve this problem. But the obstacle is human pride. The serpent’s temptation in the Garden of Eden was also lethally directed at human pride. Why should you serve? Why not choose your own future, which will be a better future than the one God has planned for you? Why obey god when you can be as a god, a law unto yourself?
The atheist basically wants to shut himself off from God, and this helps us see why heaven is not closed to atheist nor is hell the fiery pit into which atheists are flung for their misdeeds. Heaven is God’s domain, where He is eternally present. Hell is where God is eternally absent. God does not reject the atheist. The atheist rejects God. God does not dispatch the atheist to hell; the atheist wishes to close his eyes and heart to God and God reluctantly grants him his wish. In a sense, that gates of hell are locked from inside.
The Bible says that the Salvation is a gift of God. Many people – even many Christians understand this to mean that God is offering us Salvation as a Gift. But the Bible does not say that Salvation is the gift from God. Rather, it says that salvation is the gift of God. God himself is the gift.
For some, the Christian concept of a second sailing or a new life will continue to sound absurd and offensive. It is significant the Christ specifies the requirement of being born again to Nicodemus, who is neither a thief nor a prostitute but rather a learned and righteous man. Even righteousness is not enough. The only person who we know made it to paradise is the penitent thief hanging on the cross by Christ’s side. “Lord, help me”, he said, “For I am a sinner”. And Christ replied, “This day you will be with me in Paradise”. What an encouragement this is for us, because once we have confronted our pride, we realize that we don’t have to do anything to earn our heavenly reward. In fact, there is nothing that we can do to earn it.
What is denied to us by effort is supplied to us through grace. So when around us we see the decay of our life, when every earthly hope of redemption has failed us, when those whom we love cannot help us, when we have tried, everything and there is nothing else to try, when we have tossed our last log on the fire and all the embers have flickered out, it is at this point that God’s hand reaches out to us, steady and sure. All we have to do is take it. This is the uniqueness of the Christian message.
Property and Freedom: The inseparable connection
I feel very happy and privileged to be here and to speak to an eager audience.
A perusal of Russian history even before the communist takeover will reveal the hidden mysteries of Russian autocratic culture.
Why is it that Russia a European country by Geography, race, language, and religion virtually never managed to impose any limits on its Government? It always had autocratic role: the will of rulers rather than the rule of Law. Even today you see in Putin’s Russia a back sliding from Democracy into authoritarianism. We can attribute the phenomena done to the absence or rather a very late development of private property in Russia.
In Western Europe since Roman times, private property was considered sacrosanct. The principle enunciated by the Roman stoic philosopher Seneca that king’s role by the will of the people become fundamental to Western civilization, together with private property which was the main source of productive wealth.
On the other hand, the notion that property is to be viewed as an evil also goes back to the eighth century B.C in ancient Greece. The Greek writer Hesiod spoke about three ages of man: The Golden age, the Silver age and the Iron Age. According to Hesiod, the Golden age had no property lines dividing the land among neighbors it was all held in common.
Plato, the first communist in Intellectual history, went even further, suggesting that private property causes quarrels and civil wars. He believed in sharing not only property but wives and children as well. His idea was that we would all become one and the same. We would have the same eyes and the same ears and the same sense of smell. We would lose or individuality entirely.
Plato was challenged by his disciples, Aristotle. Aristotle argued that it is not private property that causes conflicts and wars, but the desire for property. Thus, if you want to eliminate conflict, you have to eliminate the desire, which is quite impossible. Private property, Aristotle said, may have its virus and is far from perfect, but it leads to fewer quarrels and wars than would its abolition.
Christianity supported private property. Christ never demanded the abolition of private property and never made the accusation that it was a Sin. He approved private property and market mechanism. During the protestant reformation, Luther and particularly Calvin developed the notion that the possession of wealth is a sign of divine grace. Max Weber, the German sociologist, in his book “The protestant ethic and the spirit of capitalism, demonstrated how Calvinist theology promoted the development of private property and the accumulation of wealth.
The Basis of modern Socialism
A change began in 18th century France, the country which has often been the source of the most terrible ideas. A group of French philosophers launched an argument against private property using John Locke’s theory of knowledge. Locke, the father of classical liberalism, who argued that we have no innate ideas and learn entirely from experience, never anticipated the political implications that some would draw from his theory. These French thinkers argued that if everything we are is just a result of our experiences, then through proper legislation and education human beings can be changed. Since property is the root of all evil, through its abolition people can be totally socialized: then they will not desire to own anything, but will want to share everything. That became the basis of modern socialism and communism. Marx argued that our acquisitive feelings are entirely a result of the environment in which we live. He insisted that as long as we remained dependent on private property, we would never be truly free. Only when “society” owned everything would everyone receive according to his desired and needs.
According to Marx, under a communist system a person would be able to do anything he desired: he could be a literary critic today, a hunter tomorrow, and a fisherman another day, and so on. “True freedom” would follow. In the communist manifests, Marx summed up the definition of communism in one phrase: the abolition of private property.
Accordingly, the communist system in the Soviet Union became a gigantic educational structure to create new, totally socialized human beings. Of course, parents had to be completely changed first. If the parents did not crave private property, then the children would not either. The Soviet regime tried to practice this for 70 years, but sure enough it failed miserably.
The reality is that all living creatures, not only people, but also animals, are extremely acquisitive; they have to be in order to survive. All animals have the necessity of controlling their separate territories. When deer have their battles in the spring, they are in fact fighting for territory. A female will not mate with a male who does not have territory: he must be “rich”; otherwise she cannot raise her offspring.
Our species is not different. Research has shown that one of the first words children learn is “mine” and that approximately 75 percent of conflicts among children are over possessions. The most extreme example of an attempt to eradicate possessiveness was the “Kibbutz” in Israel. In those communes’ children had nothing of their own, not even socks or underwear; everything was shared. The results were terrible. When they grew up, those children could not establish normal human relations with other human beings because to them it was “selfish”. They could not fall in love because love involves possessiveness. They could not write poetry because it was not something that the group enjoyed. They made wonderful army officers because they were very brave and would sacrifice. But they did not make normal human beings.
Marx hailed a period of “Primitive communism”, or as he called it “The Golden age of Hesiod”, which he insisted, existed in the very early stage of human history when nobody owned anything. (Bible contradict it) (Read Job, and Abraham and Lot or Cain and his descendants). Only with the emergence of social classes, Marx said, did the powerful begin to appropriate property and enslave others.
But there is absolutely no evidence that there ever was an age of primitive communism. In fact, every society of the past whether as a tribe, community or family-imposed claims on property, which was at that time land or cattle.
Private property and European Liberty
Private property first began to emerge in ancient Israel. When the Israelis settled in Canaan, they apportioned the land among themselves by lot. (It is interesting that the word ‘lot’ in English has a double meaning: as a piece of land and also a raffle). In the Hebrew Bible you find many allusions to private property. For example, God curses anyone who moves boundary stones separating properties end.
Europe from the earliest times of the barbarian occupation practiced private property. And adopted Seneca’s idea: king’s rule and subjects own. This notion became especially deeply rooted in England which as an island was easier to protect from foreign invasions. Countries like France, Germany, and Italy were constantly attacked and thus were willing to give their government certain powers over their property and taxation in order to defend themselves. The English were not willing to grant such authority because they felt safe in most of medieval Europe. The kings ran the government by their own income. They leased out their large estates, collected rent and were supposed to use this reverence to run their court, navies, armies, and so on. But by 1300 the English kings didn’t have enough money to do that. Since they respected their subject property right, they had to convene the House of Commons and ask “please give me subsidies through taxes.” The House of Commons agreed, but only with the recognition of some right in return. Eventually power transformed from kings to the parliament. By the early 1800’s when England was fighting battles against Napoleonic France, King George the third was declared legally insane, but it actually didn’t affect the country. In reality a prime minister not the king was running England.
This formed the basis of European liberty: possess on of property that required government to come to its subject, ask them for appropriations and grant them power in return. Eventually property right led to the development of parliamentary institutions and of many other liberties.
No Freedom without property
In Russia the situation was completely different. As Trotsky once so bluntly pointed out, “it used to be said that he who doesn’t work doesn’t eat. In communist societies, he who does not obey does not eat”. In order to survive, everyone had to become an embryo of the state. That has been the case throughout Russian history.
For a variety of historical reasons Russian czars appropriated the totality of the land. They granted the land to servitors, mostly military men, under one condition: absolute obedience and loyalty. They were allowed to live on the land and use it, and they were given serfs to work for them, but only as long as they served the crown properly. Otherwise the land would be given to somebody else. As a result, every subject, from the lowest to the highest, had to loyally serve the czar for life, as a serf, military man, official in the bureaucrat, or clergyman. The spirit of individualism was completely absent and had no soil from which to emerge.
It is not surprising that for most of its history Russia had no parliament and no need for them: the czars did not have to seek permission to raise taxes. They could do it on a whim as they wanted. Finally, in 1905, as the result of a revolution, the government granted its people a parliament and accepted political parties as part of a new parliamentary system. But the nation that the parliament could have any actual power was really not acceptable. The czar was
persuaded that the function of the parties was to collaborate with the government, not to oppose it. Modern Russian government: said the same statement. The idea is a loyal opposition is totally alien to Russia and the very concept of freedom and human rights has never taken root. Russia simply cannot get over its authoritarian impulses and is moving back towards authoritarianism.
Most Russians attach almost no value to freedom. To them it is either security or freedom, but never both. When asked “what do you value more highly, security or freedom? Approximately 85 percent answer “definitely security”. When asked “what value do you attach to private property? Only about 20 percent say that property is an inalienable human right. The overwhelming majority views democracy as a joke, a façade behind which the rich and powerful rule with no attention to people.
The result is that only 10 percent of the population is interested in or pays attention to politics. The other 90 percent are totally depoliticized and don’t care one way or the other. This makes it entirely possible for someone like Putin to appoint governs, forbid certain electoral producers in the provinces, and take over the media- the Russian people don’t mind it. In fact, 76 percent of Russians want the re-introduction of censorship on media. Why? Because they are confused by the flow of contradictory news and would prefer to be told what to believe.
Private property is always closely connected with Law, which explains Russia’s failure to develop a functional judiciary system. In case of any disagreement or contract violation, business results to arbitration or the mafia, since the courts will not enforce private contracts. The judiciary system largely remains what Russians call “telephone justice”, where the prosecutor telephones the judge and tells him what sentence to impose. For example, Mr. Khodorkovsky, the richest man in Russia, was arrested and jailed, allegedly for not paying his taxes. But his major crime is really the fact that he had the temerity to finance political parties which were neither friendly to Putin, nor under his control.
The absence of any tradition of and respect for private property negatively affects the Russian investment climate. Why would you invest money in Russian knowing that if the government is displeased, it will take your property, arrest you, and the prosecutor will tell the judge what kind of sentence to enforce.
This is a tragedy for Russia, but it also emphasizes to what extent private property is vital for liberty and economics progress. We must bear that in mind in our society. Although nobody in this country, challenges private property directly, it is done in a very oblique fashion through the welfare state. When government in India owns corporations, had means of production that constitute a challenge to private property and ownership. The welfare state is an enemy of private property. The excessive taxation used to support the welfare state is extremely dangerous.
Today in the United States, the federal, state and local governments together control 35% of the GDP. This means that the government is controlling a great deal of cash, which allows it to influence public publicly, tell universities whom to hire and whom not to hire, and do all sorts of things. Redistribution of wealth is immoral and sinful.