Chapter 6 of 6
Various Worldviews
Secularism
LEARNING OBJECTIVES
- To examine the dominant schools of thought in our culture.
- To get an overview of these philosophies.
OUTLINE
All believers are missionaries in their own countries.
A. Though we distinguish between laity and clergy, every Christian is a missionary.
B. Missionaries must know the language and the culture of the alien society, as well as Bible content.
C. America cannot be assumed to be a predominantly Christian culture.
- We live a secular environment, a post-Christian phenomenon.
- We do not live in a monolithic culture.
D. A Christian needs to be aware of the dominant systems operating in his culture.
E. There are six schools of thought operating in our society today:
- Humanism
- Existentialism
- Positivism
- Hedonism
- Pluralism
- Pragmatism
II. The one word that incorporates all the dominant
philosophies is secularism.
A. An “ism” is a school of thought, a philosophy, a worldview.
B. The word secular comes from the Latin saeculum, meaning world.
C. Secularism is the idea that all of life must be judged by today’s values.
III. The Bible concerns itself with long-range
considerations.
A. God Himself is timeless, eternal.
B. God looks at everything from an eternal perspective.
C. The Christian is called to live his life in light of eternity.
D. What you do has eternal significance.
E. The secularist’s motto is: RIGHT NOW ONLY COUNTS RIGHT NOW.
- Philosophers call this the “philosophy of the here and now.”
- This removes any eternal purpose from man or existence.
- We see this all around us, particularly in advertising.
- This is ultimately a philosophy of despair.
Existentialism
LEARNING OBJECTIVES
- To explore the history and meaning of existentialism.
- To point out the ways in which an existential culture conflicts with Christian principles.
OUTLINE
I.
No philosophical system has affected 20th century America as has existentialism.
A. Everyone encounters the influence of existentialism every day and in every area of life.
B. Existentialism has grown so rapidly because its proponents have been brilliant and gifted men, such as Sarte, Camus, Kiekegaard, and Nietzsche.
C. It deals not with abstract theories of knowledge but focuses on human existence.
II. Existentialism began in the 19th century with theistic
and atheistic varieties.
A. Its impact was felt in America after World War II.
- The destruction of the war moved many to despair about humanity.
- The artist colonies, like Greenwich Village, communicated some of the basic concepts in their art.
- The film industry and the theater furthered these motifs.
B. This is a movement away from rationality toward irrationality.
III. The main idea of existentialism is that “existence
precedes essence.”
A. The individual counts, not the group.
B. The only valid conclusions come from one’s individual experience.
C. Man lives in this dimension only.
D. There are several major themes in existentialism.
- There is nothingness. Nihilism proclaims that there is no meaning to human existence.
- There is despair and dread, which Hollywood films exploit.
- Another theme is “angst” or anxiety – the undefined, faceless feeling inside of oneself.
Martin Heidegger wrote Being and Time, which describes man as being thrown into the world.
- There is the theme of freedom and autonomy in which there are no norms because there are no absolutes.
Humanism
LEARNING OBJECTIVE
To examine the content, background, and influence of humanism.
OUTLINE
I. Humanism is an ancient philosophy and has undergone numerous changes.
A. It is not to be confused with humanitarianism.
B. Its beginnings lie in ancient Greece. Protagoras said, ”Homo mensura,” or “Man is the measure”
- Man becomes his own standard.
- Man is the ultimate being, ultimate authority, and ultimate reality:
Anthropocentric.
C. Where humanism is man-centered, Christianity is God-centered: Theocentric.
D. Forms of humanism have acknowledged God’s existence but limited His power.
E. Denying the supernatural, humanism is a conscious altrernative to Christianity.
- Erasmus was a 16th century Humanist.
- He is considered the Prince of Renaissance humanism.
F. To the Humanist, religion is just part of your human experience.
In the 16th century, Christianity prevailed over II.
humanism.
A. The Enlightenment, in the 18th century, saw the tide turn.
B. The 19th century saw humanism and theology combined into “liberalism.”
- If humanism denies the supernatural, and then is combined with Christianity, liberalism is the only logical conclusion.
- Emil Brunner, a neo-orthodox theologian, called liberalism “unbelief.”
- Liberalism caused a shift from personal redemption to “social gospel.”
III. There is militancy in some Humanists toward
Christianity.
A. Dewey believed that religion hinders the progress of man.
B. Humanism believes in changing the world through education.
IV. There is an obvious struggle between Christianity
and humanism.
A. Humanism borrows from Christian ethics while denying accountability to its source – Christ.
B. The noble ideals of humanism have no rational foundation.
C. Christianity thrives on “principles”; the humanist on “preferences.”
D. The principal vehicle for the dissemination of humanist philosophy is the public school system.
Pragmatism
LEARNING OBJECTIVES
- To examine pragmatism as a philosophy affecting our culture.
- To compare pragmatism with the teachings of Chrisitanity.
OUTLINE
I. Pragmatism developed in the U.S. and reflects the
genius of the American culture.
A. Harvey Cox wrote The Secular City which evaluates pragmatism as being the dominant influence in producing the style of American life.
- The Pragmatist doesn’t think in terms of ultimate or religious questions.
- The spirit of pragmatism is the spirit of problem-solving.
B. The Pragmatist is either skeptical or agnostic about man’s ability to discover ultimate truth.
C. As a formal philosophy, pragmatism proceeds from a prior skepticism of metaphysics or theology.
D. Pragmatism looks at life from the perspective of naturalism.
II. There is a point of distinction between pragmatism
and Christianity.
A. Romans 1 paints a bleak picture of the man who will not have God in his thinking.
B. What you choose to believe or not to believe greatly affects your actions. People act in accordance with their value systems.
C. Pragmatism is a theory of truth; practicality is a test of truth.
- It has become highly subjective.
- Since there is no absolute truth, truth is experiential.
III. Historically, there have been several key criticisms of
pragmatism.
A. It is predominantly subjective.
B. It tends to focus on short-term consequences.
- Problem-solving often leads to more problems.
- The main conflict between what is right and what is expedient.
Positivism
LEARNING OBJECTIVE
To examine positivism as a philosophical system of life and worldview.
OUTLINE
Positivism emerged in Europe in the 19th century and I.
is usually associated with August Comte.
A. Comte was a scientist/philosopher with a vision for societal reformation.
B. He envisioned a society dominated by scientific knowledge.
II. Historically, we have tried to find a unifying factor for
the parts of life.
A. For the Christian, that unity is in God.
B. For Comte, there was natural law for the universe and for society.
C. As man progresses and matures, so does society. His stages were:
- The infantile stage, where people seek religious answers;
- The philosophical stage, based on more abstract reasoning;
- The scientific stage, where man reaches maturity.
D. For Comte, the only absolute was that everything was relative.
E. It has been called a religion without God.
III. Positivism led to logical positivism, which led to
analytical philosophy.
A. A small group of thinkers known as the Vienna Circle set out in the 1920s to eliminate the influence of metaphysics and religion on culture.
B. The contribution of logical positivism was the Verification Principle, which stated that truth had to be verified empirically (by the senses).
C. Since God could not be verified by the sensed, the word God was meaningless.
D. The cost of positivism was high, destroying unity and divorcing science from the whole realm of truth.
Pluralism and Relativism
LEARNING OBJECTIVE
To examine the last two ideologies that contribute to our cultural foundation.
OUTLINE
I. The basic tenet of pluralism is that there is no
ultimate unity to bring cohesiveness to our lives.
A. We have particulars, but no universals; the relative but not the absolute.
B. Plurality, as an “ism,” means that there is no unity to life.
C. Relativity is the key word of the 20th century.
- The idea is that there are different perspectives from which to consider everything.
- If everything is relative, then nothing is concrete or ultimately true.
D. Relativity leads necessarily to chaos, because there is no fixed reference point by which one measures or judges.
- Relativity is the very antithesis of Christianity.
- It leaves a church in total chaos.
- It leaves a culture with purposes, but no purpose; truths, but no truth.
II. Pluralism directly confronts Christianity.
A. People claim legal rights but don’t consider moral rights because morality has become relative.
B. Christianity requires that all views be treated with tolerance, but not necessarily with validity. Pluralism objects to that.
Hedonism
LEARNING OBJECTIVES
- To review the impact of hedonism on our lives.
- To examine hedonism as a world and life view.
OUTLINE
I. Hedonism defines the good or true in terms of
pleasure and pain.
A. The Hedonist seeks to increase pleasure and decrease pain.
B. This movement sprung from the ancient Greek school of the Cyrenaics.
C. It actually became a religion, where, through pleasure, man transcended to a higher experience of consciousness.
D. The Epicureans adopted a more moderate approach because of the “hedonistic paradox.”
E. Atarachia was the search for peace of mind. F. The Stoics settled for peace of mind through self-control.
II. Christianity says up front that there will be pain along
the way.
A. The Hedonist declares Christ a fool for accepting unnecessary pain.
B. Christianity sees pleasure differently than does the Hedonist.
III. The modern Hedonist lets his “feelings” dictate his
responses.
A. We are a nation preoccupied with analyzing our moods.
B. We induce feelings artificially with drugs.
C. Hedonism makes value judgments, producing a system of ethics, which produces a behavioral pattern of morality.
Postmodernism
Postmodernism is a philosophy that says absolute truth does not exist.
Postmodernism supporters deny long-held beliefs and conventions and maintain that all viewpoints are equally valid.
In today's society, postmodernism has led to relativism, the idea that all truth is relative. That means what is right for one group is not necessarily right or true for everyone. The most obvious example is sexual morality. Christianity teaches that sex outside marriage is wrong. Postmodernism would claim that such a view might pertain to Christians but not to those who don't follow Jesus Christ; therefore, sexual morality has become much more permissive in our society in recent decades. Taken to extremes, postmodernism argues that what society says is illegal, such as drug use or stealing, is not necessarily wrong for the individual.
Postmodernism's rejection of absolute truth causes many people to reject the Bible. Christians believe God is the source of absolute truth. In fact, Jesus Christ proclaimed himself to be the Truth: "I am the way and the truth and the life. No one comes to the Father except through me." (John 14:6, NIV).
Not only do postmodernists deny Christ's claim to be the truth, but they also dismiss his statement that he is the only way to heaven. Today Christianity is ridiculed as arrogant or intolerant by those who say there are "many paths to heaven." This view that all religions are equally valid is called pluralism.
In postmodernism, all religion, including Christianity, is reduced to the level of opinion. Christianity asserts that it is unique and that it does matter what we believe. Sin exists, sin has consequences, and anyone ignoring those truths has to face those consequences, Christians say.
Glossary of Terms
The following glossary will enhance your ability to research difficult passage and unwrap the riddle.
Definition of Hermeneutics
Hermeneutics broadly, is the art and science of text interpretation. Traditional hermeneutics is the study of the interpretation of written texts, especially texts in the areas of literature, religion and law. A type of traditional hermeneutic is biblical hermeneutics which concerns the study of the interpretation of the Bible. In religious studies and social philosophy, hermeneutics is the study of the theory and practice of interpretation. Modern hermeneutics encompasses everything in the interpretative process including verbal and nonverbal forms of communication as well as prior aspects that affect communication, such as presuppositions, preunderstandings, the meaning and philosophy of language, and semiotics.[1]
The folk etymology places the origin (Greek: hermeneutike) with Hermes, the mythological Greek deity whose role is that of messenger of the Gods.[3] Besides being mediator between the gods themselves, and between the gods and humanity, he leads souls to the underworld upon death. He is also considered the inventor of language and speech, an interpreter, a liar, a thief and a trickster.[3] These multiple roles make Hermes an ideal representative figure for hermeneutics. As Socrates notes, words have the power to reveal or conceal, thus promoting the message in an ambiguous way.[3] The Greek view of language as consisting of signs that could lead to truth or falsehood is the very essence of Hermes, who is said to relish the uneasiness of the recipients.
Definition of DIALECTIC
: logic 1a(1) 2 a : discussion and reasoning by dialogue as a method
of intellectual investigation; specifically : the Socratic techniques of exposing false beliefs and eliciting truth b : the Platonic investigation of the eternal ideas 3 : the logic of fallacy 4 a : the Hegelian process of change in which a concept
or its realization passes over into and is preserved and fulfilled by its opposite; also : the critical investigation of this process b (1) usually plural but singular or plural in construction : development through the stages of thesis, antithesis, and synthesis in accordance with the laws of dialectical materialism (2) : the investigation of this process (3) : the theoretical application of this process especially in the social sciences 5 usually plural but singular or plural in construction
a : any systematic reasoning, exposition, or argument that juxtaposes opposed or contradictory ideas and usually seeks to resolve their conflict b : an intellectual exchange of ideas 6 : the dialectical tension or opposition between two
interacting forces or elements
Definition of DIALECTIC MATERIALISM
: the Marxist theory that maintains the material basis of a reality constantly changing in a dialectical process and the priority of matter over mind. The Communist manifesto in 1848 states “The history of all hitherto existing society is the history of class struggles”.
Hegel
Dialectical Materialism is essentially characterized by the thesis that history is the product of class struggles and follows the general Hegelian principle of philosophy of history, that is the development of the thesis in to its antithesis which is sublated by the synthesis.
Definition of SYNTHESIS
1 a : the composition or combination of parts or
elements so as to form a whole b : the production of a substance by the union of chemical elements, groups, or simpler compounds or by the degradation of a complex compound c : the combining of often diverse conceptions into a coherent whole; also : the complex so formed 2 a : deductive reasoning
b : the dialectic combination of thesis and antithesis into a higher stage of truth 3 : the frequent and systematic use of inflected forms as
a characteristic device of a language
Definition of HYPOTHESIS
The Adjective hypothetical meaning “having the nature of a hypothesis, or being assumed to exist” is an immediate consequence of a hypothesis. Hypothesis is a proposed explanation for an observable phenomenon. For a hypothesis to be out forward as a scientific method requires that one can test it. Scientists generally base scientific hypothesis on previous observations that cannot be satisfactorily explained with the available scientific theories. Even though the words hypothesis and theory are often used synonymously in common and in formal usage, a scientific hypothesis is not the same as a scientific theory – although the difference is sometimes more on degree than of purpose.
Definition of THESIS
An unproved statement put forward as a premise in an argument. A proposition that is maintained in an argument, a dissertation advancing an original point of view as a result of research, especially as a requirement for an academic degree. A hypothetical proposition, especially one put forth without proof. It is the first stage of the Hegelian dialectic process. It is a dissertation resulting rom original research, a doctrine maintained or promoted in an argument.
Definition of ANTITHESIS
A contrast, or opposition of thoughts, usually in two phrases, clauses, or sentences i.e. “you are going, I am staying”. The second expression is in contrast, opposition, or the exact opposite.
Definition of SYLLOGISM
One of the most common and useful forms of deductive reasoning is the syllogism. A syllogism is a specific form of argument that has three easy steps: a major premise, a minor premise and a logical conclusion. For example, the premise "Every X has the characteristic Y" could be followed by the premise "This thing is X," which would yield the conclusion "This thing has the characteristic Y." The first wasp example could be broken up into the major premise "Every wasp has a stinger," the minor premise "This insect is a wasp" and the conclusion "This insect has a stinger." Creating a syllogism is considered a good way for deductive reasoning to be tested to ensure that it is valid.
Definition of OBJECTIVE
- Of or having to do with a material object.
- Having actual existence or reality.
3.
a. Uninfluenced by emotions or personal
prejudices: an objective critic. See synonyms at fair1.
b. Based on observable phenomena; presented
factually: an objective appraisal.
- Medicine. Indicating a symptom or condition perceived as a sign of disease by someone other than the person affected.
- Grammar. a. Of, relating to, or being the case of a noun or pronoun that serves as the object of a verb. b. Of or relating to a noun or pronoun used in this case.
- Something that actually exists.
- Something worked toward or striven for; a goal. See synonyms at intention.
- Grammar. a. The objective case. b. A noun or pronoun in the objective case.
- The lens or lens system in a microscope or other optical instrument that first receives light rays from the object and forms the image. Also called object glass, objective lens, Also called object lens.
Definition of SUBJECTIVE
1.
a. Proceeding from or taking place in a person's
mind rather than the external world: a subjective decision.
b. Particular to a given person; personal:
subjective experience.
- Moodily introspective.
- Existing only in the mind; illusory.
- Psychology. Existing only within the experiencer's mind.
- Medicine. Of, relating to, or designating a symptom or condition perceived by the patient and not by the examiner.
- Expressing or bringing into prominence the individuality of the artist or author.
- Grammar. Relating to or being the nominative case.
- Relating to the real nature of something; essential.
Bibliography
The above notes were compiled from the following resources
- MacArthur, Jr., John. Charismatic Chaos. pp.35-36
- Hermeneutics and Historical Precedent-Perspectives on the New Pentecostalism. Grand Rapids: Baker. 1976. pp. 119- 122
- (2). p.103
-GotQuestions.org
-Changingminds.org
-Theopedia.com
-Triviumpursuit.com
-Wisegeek.com
-Mountainretreatorg.net
-Merriam-webster.com
-Thefreedictionary.com
-Answers.com
-Bible.org
-Consistent Literal Interpretation by George Zeller www.faithbibleonline.net/miscdoctrine/displov.htm
-Dispensational Hermeneutics by Andy Woods -General Principles of Interpretation by New Delhi -The Supreme Court of India -Historical Implications of Allegorical Interpretation by Thomas Ice - Covent Theology Verses Dispensationalism by Bob Nyberg - Wikipedia Dispensationalism and Gospel by Shawn Abigail - Dispensational Literal System of Bible Interpretation by www.TheRemnant-journalhome.com -Dispensationalism by Charles Ryrie -Inductive Bible Study by Tony Warren -Inductive and Deductive Bible Studies by Harvey Bluedorn -Christian Worldviews by R.C. Sproul