Chapter 2 of 6

History of Hermeneutics

13 min read · Pages 5–17 of the printed edition

The Early Church

During the first two hundred years of the early church, two competing schools of interpretation arose. One was the Syrian School of Antioch that championed literal and historical interpretation; and the other was in North Africa at Alexandria, Egypt, which advocated an allegorical or spiritual hermeneutic. The Syrian School thought Origen in particular as the inventor of the allegorical method, and maintained the primacy of the literal and historical interpretation. Alexander of Alexandria and Origen (185-254 AD) developed the allegorical approach to biblical interpretation in the early third century.

Although the Syrian School had great influence, the first few centuries the Alexandrian School eventually won out, as Jerome and Augustine were advocates of the allegorical approach in the area of Biblical prophecy. Their influence paved the way for the dominance of allegorical interpretation during the middle ages. Most of the modern denominations still follow the allegorical method of interpretation. Allegorical interpretation involves looking for hidden spiritual meaning which transcends the literal sense of the text.

Historical Rise of the Consistent Literal Interpretation

It is interesting to note the legal background of the leading advocates of literal interpretation. This back ground is important in grasping that these interpretations simply took the hermeneutical approach necessary to interpret legal documents and applied them to scripture. Reformers Martin Luther and John Calvin, both students of the Law in their formative years, played integral roles in rescuing the church from the Alexandrian allegorical method. Luther denounced the allegorical approach to scripture in strong words. He said, “Allegories are empty speculations and as it were the scum of Holy Scripture.”, “Origen’s allegories are not worth so much dirt.”, “To allegorize is to juggle scripture.” Allegorizing may denigrate into a mere monkey game. Allegories are awkward, absurd, inventive, obsolete, loose rags. [Martin Luther: Quoted in Farrar, 328]. Luther also wrote that the scriptures “are to be retained in their simplest meaning ever possible, and to be understood in their grammatical and literal sense unless the context plainly forbids” (Luther’s Works, 6:509)

Calvin similarly rejected allegorical interpretations. He called them “frivolous games” and accused Origen and other allegorists of “torturing scripture, in every possible sense, from the true sense.” Calvin wrote in the preface of his commentary on Romans “it is the first business of an interpreter to let the author say what he does say, instead of attributing to him what we think he ought to say.”

Both reformers rejected the use of church tradition as a guide for spiritual truth and instead advocated returning to scripture alone or “sola scriptura” as the source of Christian belief and practice. However, despite their emphasis upon literally interpreting some aspects of scripture, Luther and Calvin did not go far enough in applying a literal hermeneutic to all areas of divine truth.

Because reformers were primarily concerned with soteriological issues, they failed to apply the same literal interpretation that they used to interpret soteriology to the areas of ecclesiology and eschatology.

Such a selective and inconsistent application of a literal hermeneutic was not rectified until John Nelson Darby took the literal hermeneutic applied by the reformers in the area of soteriology and applied it to all areas of theology, including eschatology and ecclesiology. By insisting on the application of a literal hermeneutic to all of scripture, dispensationalism, in essence, completed the hermeneutical revolution begun by the reformers.

Emphasizing the legal background of the early dispensationalists is important for two reasons. First, it shows that the early dispensationalists did what the reformers did in applying the same hermeneutics used to interpret legal documents to biblical truth. According to Charles Clough, the legal backgrounds of the early dispensationalists allowed them to see more clearly than earlier interpreters the nature of a contract or covenant as expressed in the scripture. John Nelson Darby, who rediscovered the New Testament principles, had a law degree and was called to the Irish Chancery Bar in 1822. However, after a spiritual struggle that led to his conversion he opted to give up the law in order to become a priest in the Church of England. Per Clough: “Both Nelson Darby and C.I. Scofield studied law in their early years, so they certainly recognized the hermeneutics of contract law. Thus, after uncovering the contractual structure in the Bible through which God governs His relationships with His creatures, these dispensational theologians insisted upon a strict literal and conservative interpretation of contractual (covenantal) terminology.”

A major ingredient of dispensationalism is a proper understanding of the unconditional nature of the Abrahamic covenant. If this covenant is unconditional and unfulfilled, then a future for national Israel remains and the church cannot be said to have replaced Israel. Someone trained in the realities of contract law and with an understanding of contract language and the force of a contract would be more sensitive to seeing similar concepts when they occur in scripture.

Another key dispensational thinker was Sir Robert Anderson. His work “The Coming Prince” is considered a classic in the area of biblical chronology because of its detailed explanation of the literal fulfillment of Daniel’s Prophecy of the seventy weeks. Anderson, like Darby, was also heavily influenced by the legal profession. After receiving a law degree from Trinity College, Dublin in 1863, he became a member of the Irish bar and worked by drawing up legal briefs on a traveling circuit. He served as a chief of the criminal investigative department of the Scotland Yard. After retiring with distinction, he used his investigative training and ability to think logically to study the scriptures.

Literalism resists going beyond what is written. Charles Ryrie notes that “literalism does not preclude or exclude correct understanding of types, illustrations.” The literalists do not deny the figurative language and symbols. If one follows non-literal methods, the authority transfers from the text to the interpreter. In other words, the basic authority of interpretation ceases to be the scripture’s, but rather the mind of the interpreter.

The literal interpretation properly constrains the dictates of the carnal imagination by allowing it to roam only so far.

Similarities to Legal Interpretation

Literal interpretation is the same hermeneutical philosophy that is used in everyday communication. Stopping at a stop sign, ordering from a menu, and paying taxes on time could not be accomplished if the literal, grammatical, historical method is dispensed.

The same rationale also exists in the domain of legal interpretation. When interpreting a contract, courts first of all observe the plain meaning of the contract language.

U.S. Constitution

Because jurists have traditionally not desired to amend the constitution from the bench, they have typically followed the plain language of the constitution’s drafters, thus allowing authority to abide in the constitutional text rather in their own ideological predilections. Traditional principles of constitutional interpretation recognize that the maxim of following the plain language of the text is indeed the best insulation against an overly ideological judiciary. If jurists apprehend these documents any other way, they would not be interpreting, rather they would be amending and rewriting them.

There are many similarities between the U.S. courts and Indian courts regarding the interpretation of the law. In India, like the U.S.A., it is the duty of the court to interpret the Act and give meaning to each word of the statute. The most common rule of interpretation is that every part of the statute must be understood in a harmonious manner by reading and construing every part of it together. The maxim “A verbis legis non est recedendum” means that you must not vary the words of the statute while interpreting it.

According to the Indian law, literal interpretation means giving words their ordinary and natural meaning and is known as literal interpretation or litera legis. It is the duty of the court not to modify the language of the Act and if such meaning is clear and unambiguous, effect should be given to the provisions of a statute whatever may be the consequence. The elementary rule of construction is that the language must be construed in its grammatical and literal sense and, hence, it is termed as litera legis or literal script. The Golden Rule is that the words of a statute must prima facie be given their ordinary meaning. This interpretation is supreme and is called the Golden Rule of Interpretation.

Dispensationalist Literal System

Dispensationalism is a system of biblical interpretation formalized in the nineteenth century by John Nelson Darby and later popularized by the publishing of the Study Bible of C.I. Scofield and the establishment of Dallas Theological Seminary by Lewis Sperry Chafer. Twentieth century writers such as John Walvoord, Dwight Pentecost, and Charles Ryrie brought the doctrines of dispensationalism into mainstream scholarship.

Three primary tenets of the system are:

  1. A clear distinction between Israel and the church.
  2. Literal Interpretation of scripture
  3. 3. The Glory of God as the primary goal of history.

Dispensationalism and Salvation

Some people wrongly say that dispensationalism teaches different methods of salvation in different dispensations. The words of H.A. Ironside, the Prince of Dispensationalism, are sufficient to state the mainline dispensational viewpoint.

“Let one point be absolutely clear: no one was ever saved in any dispensation on any other ground than the finished work of Christ. In all the ages before the cross, God justified men by faith; in all the years since, men have been justified in exactly the same way. Adam believed God and was clothed with coats of skin, a picture of one becoming the righteousness of God in Christ. Abraham believed God, and it was counted to him for righteousness. Nevertheless, afterwards he was circumcised; but that circumcision, the apostle tells us, was simply a seal of the righteousness he had by faith. And throughout all the Old Testament dispensations, however legalistic Jesus may have observed the ordinance of circumcision and thought of it as having in itself some saving virtue, it still remained in God’s sight, as in the beginning, only a seal, where there was genuine faith, of that righteousness which He imputed. (Wrongly Dividing the Word of Truth, pg 57-58).

The person who claims that dispensationalism teaches different methods of salvation in different dispensations completely misunderstands the point of dispensational doctrine. Dispensationalism is not about the method of God’s salvation, but the methods of God’s testing of man. In each dispensation, God gives a different set of instructions. The instructions are for pleasing and obeying God, not for obtaining salvation. In each dispensation, man proves that whatever the circumstances, he is unable to please or obey God. Dispensationalism emphasis is on God’s Glory rather than man’s salvation as being God’s ultimate purpose.

Covenant Theology

Covenant theology is a system of theology based on the two covenants of works and grace as governing categories for the understanding of the entire Bible.

In covenant theology, the covenant of works is said to be an agreement between God and Adam promising life to Adam for perfect obedience and including death as the penalty for failure. But Adam sinned and thus mankind failed to meet the requirements of the covenant of works. Therefore, a second covenant, the covenant of Grace, was brought into operation. Louis Berkhof defines it as “the gracious agreement between the offended God and the offending but elect sinner, in which God promises salvation through faith in Christ, and the sinner accepts this believingly, promising a life of faith and obedience.”

Some reformed theologians have introduced a third covenant, the covenant of redemption. It was made in eternity past and became the basis for the covenant of grace, just described, between God and the elect. The covenant of redemption is supposed to be “the agreement between the Father, giving the Son as Head and Redeemer of the elect, and the Son, voluntarily taking the place of those whom the Father had given Him.”

Covenant theology came to America with the Puritans. Covenant theology as taught today is a development from both the theology of the reformers (who did not teach a covenant scheme at all) and the teachings of Cocceius and the Westminster Confession.

Augustine (354-430)

The early days of Augustine’s Christian faith were premillennial. However, through time, he abandoned the idea of a literal return of Christ to establish a physical kingdom on earth. He used the allegorical method of interpretation to explain away the literal return of Christ and, thus, amillenialism was born. In his book, The City of God, Augustine taught that the universal church is the Messianic Kingdom and that the millennium began with Christ’s first coming. When the church lost hope of the imminent return of Christ, it plunged headlong into the dark ages. The seeds of false interpretation bore fruit giving rise to Roman Catholicism and a works-based religion.

Amillennial Teaching

When the reformers broke away from the Roman Catholic Church, they carried a lot of baggage with them. Amillennialism was one such fetter that kept the church in bondage to the law. You might be wondering, “how does a doctrine about the ‘end times’ affect the teaching of law and grace?” Augustine and his contemporaries faced a dilemma. It had been years since the Lord Jesus had said, “behold I come quickly.” By doing away with the literal return of Christ for His church, Augustine felt that he was helping out God. After all, if there was no literal return of Christ and no literal millennium, then Christ could be reigning over His spiritual kingdom up in Heaven. The literal promises given to Israel in the Old Testament could be spiritually applied to the church. However, applying those promises to the church came at a tremendously high cost. Attached to the promises given to Israel was also the Old Testament Law. If the church is “spiritual Israel” then she must also keep the law – if not for salvation, then at least for Christian living. The Lutheran, Reformed, and Anglican reformers rejected premillenniealism as being merely “Jewish opinions.”

Miles Stanford observes like this: “The Lutheran Church is an example of…little birth truth and no growth truth, resulting in legalism, lack of eternal security, and even a charismatic element as well as liberalism. In general, the reformation-oriented Reformed churches, with birth truth but little or no growth truth, also reflect this imbalance in their unscriptural application of ‘the law as the rule of life’ for the believer.”

The reformation brought back the truth of salvation by grace, but reverted to the law for living the Christian life. This law-grace paradox continued to plague the church until John Nelson Darby and his followers came on the scene in the early 1800’s. Darby adopted the literal, historical – grammatical method of Bible interpretation. As Darby studied God’s word in this light, the distinction between Israel and the church seemed to leap off the pages of scripture before his eyes. He and his followers took the truths of dispensationalism and put them into a more systematized form. God used this to restore to the church not only the imminent, premillennial return of Christ, but also the teachings of grace, not law for living the Christian life. During the time period between Luther and Darby, covenant theology came in to being. Unfortunately, it reflected the “law based” doctrine of amillennialism.

Covenant theology was introduced to America through the puritans, but dispensational theology came to America through John Nelson Darby.

Reformed / Covenant Dispensationalism Theology

Modified Calvinist Five Point Calvinist

Literal Interpretation , Plain /

normal ; allowing for Literal as well as allegorical figurative and allegorical if interpretation

applicable

May mean either literal or Israel always means Israel

spiritual

God has two peoples with

God has always had one two separate destinies: Israel

people group, the church - Earthly, The Church -

gradually developed. Heavenly

The Church began in the Old The Church was born at Testament (Acts 7:38) and

Pentecost reached fulfillment in the

New Testament The Church is the culmination The Church is a parenthesis in

of God's saving purpose for God's program for the ages

the ages

The main heir to Abraham's The main heir to Abraham's covenant was Isaac and literal covenant was Christ and

Israel spiritual Israel The Holy Spirit indwells only believers in the dispensation

The Holy Spirit has indwelled of Grace not the Old

believers in all ages Testament and not after the

rapture

Jesus made only an offer of Jesus made an offer of the

the spiritual kingdom, which literal Kingdom to Israel; since

was rejected by literal Israel Israel rejected it, it is

but has gradually been postponed.

accepted by spiritual Israel Old Testament believers were Believers in all ages are "in not part of the Body or Bride Christ" and part of the Body

of Christ and Bride of Christ

The Law has three uses: To The Law has never been restrain sin in society, to lead abrogated, but the Christian to Christ, and to instruct is dead to the Law (Rom 7:4). Christians in godliness. The Christians are under a new moral laws (Ten command-

law; the Law of Christ. ments or the Decalogue) are

still applicable. O.T. Laws are no longer in

O.T. Laws are still in effect effect unless repeated in the

unless abrogated in the N.T. N.T.

The Millennium is the The church is the Kingdom of

Kingdom of God God

David will also sit on the

Christ alone sits on the throne during the Millennium

throne. in Jerusalem.

1000 year millennium 7 year tribulation Acts 2 to Rapture: 2000 years and counting Concious Civil Government

Adam to Noah: 1600 years. Noah to Moses: 876 years. Moses to Christ (Law): 1500 years. Adam (Jews and Gentiles)

Noah

Moses Law

Grace (Law of Christ)

Church Acts 2 to Rapture Kingdom of God

Tribulation Millennium Eternal State