Chapter 5 of 7

Economic Paralysis in Kerala

11 min read · Pages 54–64 of the printed edition

It was announced that the iPhone 14 will be manufactured in Tamil Nādu starting in September 2022. The Wall Street Journal on March 4,2023, reports by Rajesh Roy, Yoko Kubota and Philip Wen

“Top Apple Supplier Foxconn plans Major India Growth. Apple inc.’s main manufacturer, Foxconn Technology Group, is considering a major expansion in India , including possibly assembling millions more iPhones and setting up new production sites as it seeks to further diversify beyond China. Foxconn is set to expand production of iPhones at its existing plant near Chennai, in the southern Indian state of Tamil Nadu, people familiar with the matter said. It aims to boost iPhone production to around 20 million unis annually by 2024, up from about 6 million, and roughly triple the number of workers to as many as 100,000, and the people, including a senior India government official.

Foxconn also plans to build a new production facility in the southern Karnataka state, where it would make products including iPhones, people familiar with the matter said.

In addition, Foxconn is considering building a new production site, in the southern city of Hyderabad as well as a silicon carbide fabrication plant and packing facility in India for its semiconductor business, some of the people said.”

Have you thought about why no companies start businesses in Kerala? Bangalore is the Silicon Valley of India. Thousands of foreign companies are operating in Karnataka, Tamil Nadu, and Andhra Pradesh. Some Malayalees who had great businesses in America and the Middle East started some businesses in Kerala in the past. They did so with a good heart, but not with a good head. They loved Kerala so much, and they made big investments in Kerala. However, as you know, every other day Kerala politicians or trade unions declare Hartal or Bandh. Also trade union workers demand exorbitant pay and boycott work. Usually, they will stop vehicles, including ambulances, and prevent them from reaching their destinations. Over the years many people have died due to lack of medical care. People who were bitten by snakes died on the way to the hospital since they could not reach the hospital due to violent strikes. Many pregnant women have died as well.

Many Keralites consider business as evil and businesspeople as looters. Consequently, no one dares to start a business in Kerala. You may not know it, but it is true that some Pravasi (Diaspora) Malayalees had to commit suicide due to the labor union persecution. It is interesting to observe that many Malayalees who burned down the buses and cars in Kerala happened to come to America. One of my cousins was a Naxalite (armed Communist fighter) in Kerala and had been in jail. He was a Christian by birth. He and many others like him have come to America, and live like kings, enjoying the fruit of Capitalism. However, they become very productive employees. If the work starts at 8:00 AM, they will arrive at 7.30 AM and work hard to impress their white bosses. No Hartal or picketing! The communist ideology and practices have corrupted many Keralites. However, when they migrated to America, they realized it would not work. Many Malayalees are in Anglo assemblies, and many are elders, too. I am an elder along with two other Malayalees in our assembly. Malayalees do not create any problems in Anglo Assemblies. If they displayed one tenth of the same discipline in Malayalam Assemblies there would not have been seven Malayalam assemblies in Houston. If you study the conditions of the assemblies outside Kerala, you will learn that there are less quarrels and splits. If there are Malayalee brethren, they tend to promote groupism which causes divisions. There will be less splits if the locals are left alone there.

Vizhinjam International Seaport

The Vizhinjam International Deepwater Multipurpose Seaport, also known as the Vizhinjam Port is an under-construction port on the Arabian Sea coast city of Trivandrum, India.

“Most people in Kerala conducted numerous protests to cancel this life changing project.

The idea for a port at Vizhinjam was first mooted by Travancore Diwan Ramaswamy Ayyar. However, the present under-construction port was originally conceived about 25 years ago.

What was the Adani group’s Vizhinjam port

project?

Then foundation stone of the Rs 7,525 crore port, being built under a Public Private Partnership (PPP) model with Adani Ports Private Limited at Vizhinjam on near Thiruvananthapuram, was laid by then Kerala Chief Minister Oommen Chandy in December 2015. It has since missed its completion deadline.

The port is to have 30 berths, and will be able to handle giant “mega” container ships. The Adani Group has said the ultramodern port, located close to major international shipping routes, will boost India’s economy. Its location is also of strategic importance, the project’s supporters have claimed. The port is expected to compete with Colombo, Singapore, and Dubai for a share of trans-shipment traffic.

While the fishermen’s protests are being supported by the Latin Catholic Church, a local people’s action committee is demanding speedy completion of the project. This committee has the backing of various Hindu community outfits like the upper caste Nair Service Society, besides the OBC Hindu organization, like the Sree Narayana Dharma Paripalana Yogam, as well as the Vaikunda Swami Dharma Pracharana, which has a considerable presence among the Nadar community in southern Kerala.

Opponents BJP and CPI(M) have made common cause over the port project, criticizing the protesters.

Senior CPI(M) leader and state education minister V Sivankutty has blamed the Latin Catholic Church, alleging there is a bid to create a riot. Pro- Left media in the state had also alleged involvement of foreign funding behind the fishermen’s agitation.

BJP state president K Surendran has said the forces that had organized the protest the Kudankulam nuclear power plant near Kanyakumari in Tamil Nadu, were behind the Vizhinjam protest. The Kudankulam protest was spearheaded by the Latin Catholic diocese of Tuticorin

By Matters India Reporter

Thiruvananthapuram, Nov 28, 2022: The police in Kerala have registered a case against a Catholic archbishop, his auxiliary and 48 others in connection with violence during a protest under construction international seaport in the southern Indian state.

The police and protesters clashed at the Vizhinjam police station close to the port protest site on the night of November 27th, which led to injuries to more than 50 people, including 36 police personnel.

The violent mob also ransacked the police station and destroyed equipment and police vehicles parked in the compound.

The protesters came to the police station demanding the release of five men detained by the police, the previous day for a violent clash in front of the port site. The protestors had blocked the entry of dumpster trucks with construction materials.

Some people claiming to be supporters of the port project, accompanied the trucks and threw stones at the protestors.

The clash continued allegedly in connivance with the police. Many had sustained wounds in the violence.

The police later charged Archbishop Thomas J Nettor of the Trivandrum Latin archdiocese, his auxiliary Bishop R Kristudas, priests, and other protesters for the violence.

Father Eugene Pereira, convener of the protest, blamed the Communist-led Kerala coalition government and the Adani Group that is constructing the multi-billion-dollar seaport project for the violence.

“Archbishop Netto, Bishop Kristudas and many priests and others named in the FIR (First Information Report) were not present at the protest site,” Father Pereira told media persons November 28th.

The priest denied any protesters who were indulged in the November 27, 2022, violence at the police station. “It is true our people were there in the police station, but somebody else in the crowd had attacked the station and put the blame on us.”

A priest who was wounded in the police action said the police personnel behaved so violently at the protestors. He was hit on the head with a baton.

This protest is not an isolated incident. It has nothing to do with preventing environmental disasters or helping poor fishermen. History would provide adequate reason for this degenerated DNA. In the sixties the Communist party prevented the introduction of tractors and other machinery for modern farming in Kuttanad. The self-proclaimed specialists concluded that modernization would create severe unemployment. In the seventies, they prevented computerization in universities and government offices.

I published my first book in 1994 titled “Capitalism - A Panacea for Socio- Economic Woes." I argued in the book that the large population in India is a boon, although all Indian Economists taught erroneously that overpopulation is the main cause for our maladies. Also, India is very rich in natural resources. We all had to leave Kerala because of Socialism. All Socialist countries are poor. Singapore has no resources, so how did they become affluent? Nehru and Congress followed Socialism. Then in 1991, P V Narasimha Rao liberalized Indian economy which allowed foreign companies to establish in India. Although the liberalization was only 25 percent India made rapid progress. If they had liberalized completely, India could have surpassed America. Why is China the second largest economy? Communism is only for administration. They liberalized economy in 1979 because the Chinese were more farsighted than the Indians. I will be writing an essay on Sir C. P. Ramaswamy Iyer later in this work. His vision was to keep Kerala as a separate country with Capitalism. Today, most Malayalees abroad would still be living in Kerala. Look how Socialism is ingrained in Indian DNA. The best example is the Vizhinjam port protest. The history is repeated. In the sixties, Marxist were against introducing tractors and other machinery in Kuttanad. In the seventies, Communists were against computerization in colleges and government offices. After destroying our generation when Communist leaders came to America, they understood their foolishness and started private enterprises. When Jyoti Basu visited America, he also had a change of heart. However, he was too old and died. Today, Bengalese are predominantly manual laborers in Kerala. Kerala could have faced the same situation. Kerala avoided it because their people migrated all over the world, and are sending billions of dollars. I usually do not respond to our people. Most Indians brag about the top level of Indians in American corporations. There are two dozen chairmen of Indian origin and about 40 percent of Indian employees in major companies.

I agreed with those people. All Indians feel the same way. My message for them is that they should have felt a righteous indignation instead of a false pride. The leaders of these American companies if they were in India, would have become mediocre employees eating peanuts, Vada, and coffee. Their brain did not expand as soon as they landed in an American airport. American capitalism made it possible for Indians to thrive in America, this was my point in the book. Indians are smarter than all other people, however, Socialism robbed their opportunity to thrive.

A Latin bishop is leading the violent protest in Vizhinjam. If that port is finished, it would change the whole state of Kerala. The government has met most of their demands. Then again, they would bring additional demands which means they wanted to stop the construction.

The underlying reason is jealousy and evil in the minds of the Kerala people. The name “Adani” created a violent allergic reaction among the evil Leftists. Adani and Ambani did not loot anyone. They are shrewd businesspeople. Just imagine, if all the private companies were eliminated, our standard of living would revert back one century. Does anyone remember how our telephone system worked before privatization? If I had to make a call from Tiruvalla to Kottayam, I had to call the exchange and book a call. It was called Trunk booking. After a few hours I might get a connection. People don’t appreciate the comfort and convenience that Capitalism created. Today, we can make video calls free of charge. Private competition has made it possible. When my mother passed away in 2001. I did not call her frequently because of the exorbitant telephone bill for international calls. Capitalism creates wealth.

When the British introduced an Indian railway system, there were widespread protest all over India. They thought it was a conspiracy of White Colonial masters to drag India to England. The above story may be hard to believe in the twenty-first century.

Automobile

As with any transformative new technology, automobiles encountered considerable resistance when they arrived on the American scene in larger numbers between 1900 and 1910. There’s no doubt that they became popular—one of the features of American life at that time was the birth of dozens of automobile enthusiasts’ “clubs,” a network that quickly coalesced into the American Automobile Association, which was founded in 1902.

European Americans generally relied on oxen and wagons for extended overland travel. Oxen were sturdy and steady. They could pull wagons for longer distances and with less maintenance than that required by horses. Oxen could also be consumed if an injury necessitated euthanasia. Sea travel was arduous, and people usually attempted long voyages only when it was unavoidable. A journey across the Atlantic could take up to eight weeks depending on sailing conditions. Ocean travelers also exposed themselves to many dangers and discomforts, including piracy, drowning, and disease.

Millions of people lost jobs when the automobile was introduced. However, the living standards and comfort and affluence only increased by introducing cars. People in America and Europe also resisted modern inventions such as the automobile, printing press, telephone, cell phone and many other inventions. Now Kerala people are protesting the modern rail system where people can reach their destination faster than today. Travel time can be cut down in half. They also protested the Nedumbassery International Airport in the nineties. In addition, with every project the protesters have the same reasons. Environmental damage and loss of job etc. Today. on December 6, 2022, I read in the media that the 140 days of cantankerous protests by fishermen against the Vizhinjam sea port has been settled. The Adani business group who is building their port stated that they lost 220 crores rupees due to the strike. Now you know why nobody wants to touch business in Kerala. Whatever the companies do to satisfy trade union demands, the next day they come up with another cock and bull story and make further outlandish demands.