Chapter 3 of 14

How capitalism enriches the working class.

12 min read · Pages 5–11 of the printed edition

One of the most pervasive and pernicious myths about capitalism is that capitalists have always exploited the working class. The anticapitalistic myth makers, the industrial revolution was a horror that subjected the American working class to nightmarish working conditions while a relative few capitalists became wealthy on the backs of the working poor, and that subjugation has only continued. But the historical record of capitalism in America and in every other country where it has been practiced reveals something quite different. Capitalism has continually improved the lot of the working class.

To be sure, the advent of capitalism and factory production created working conditions that seem unpleasant or even deplorable by today’s standards, but it is important to understand that they were significant improvement over the conditions the working class had previously endured. In the early days of capitalism, no, one forced laborers to leave the farms, poor houses or the streets. People voluntarily went in to the factories because they knew they improve their standards of living by doing so, it was the pre capitalist era that was utterly miserable for the average working person. Capitalism saved the working class from an impoverished existence that had remained stagnant for generations prior to the advent of capitalism. Factories saved millions of destitute.

The same can be said of the conditions in some of the world’s less-developed countries today. Those who deplore “child labor” and “sweatshop” fail to recognize or acknowledge that as deplorable as these conditions may seem by the standards of modern-day America, these people are much better off for having the opportunity to work a higher paying factory. In many parts of the world, the alternatives to sweatshop labor are malnutrition and starvation, child prostitution, and begging and stealing.

In the early days of industrialization in America, as capitalism grew and there was more capital investment, that is investment in machinery and equipment, workers became progressively more productive and therefore better paid. This is no surprise, capitalist society the only way the standard of living can increase is through increased productivity (output per worker), and the most important ingredient in increased productivity is capital investment. Skill, education, and on the job training (human capital investment, in the language of economics) do improve productivity, but only very slowly. In contrast, when a capitalist invests in newer or better machinery or equipment, this can increase the output per employee immediately. At once the very same employee, without a shed of additional training, education, or experience are producing more goods and services per hour worked and, most important from the capitalist’s perspective, are contributing more to profits. And when the laborer becomes more productive, his value to the employer increases – that is, the laborer’s wages go up. Skilled, reliable workers are always in demand, which means that employers must pay more to keep their more productive employees or else risk losing them to competing employers. In this sense labor is indeed a commodity in that its price -wages or compensation is determined in the market place by the forces of supply and demand.

And wages in manufacturing industries did in fact rise steadily in the 19th century.

From 1820-1860 wages grew at about a 1.6 annual rate, and during the period the purchasing power of an average worker’s paycheck increased between 60 and 90 percent, depending on what region of the country the worker resided in. Between 1860- and 1890, during what economists call the second industrial revolution, real wages- that is, wages adjusted for inflation increased by 50 percent in America. The average work week was shortened as well, meaning that the real earnings of the average American worker probably increased more like 60 percent during that time.

Capitalism improves the quality of life for the working class not just because it leads to improved wages but also because it produces new, better, and cheaper goods. In the second half of the nineteenth century, at the same time that American worker’s wages were shooting upward, more and more consumer products were being invented that made life more comfortable for the working, including kerosene lamps, which made it possible to light one’s house inexpensively. Although the products of capitalism almost invariably benefit the wealthy first, these goods became common place as capitalism enriches the working class and mass production allows for lower and lower costs of production. For example, when Henry Ford first started selling automobiles only the relatively wealthy could afford them, but soon enough working class families were buying his cars. The same was true even in the earliest days of American capitalism. In the late 18th century, textile mills in New England quickly adopted the policy of producing cheap cotton apparel for the masses.

Indeed, with capitalism, the emphasis shifted to producing goods as cheaply as possible for the masses- the working class, whereas artisans had previously produced their good and wares mostly for the aristocracy. Under capitalism every business wants to cater to masses, for that is where the money is. There is no better way to become wealthy than to produce and sell a valued product cheaply enough so that almost anyone can afford to buy it. Thus American capitalism from the very beginning produced a dual benefit for the working class. It provided new, better paying jobs and it supplied cheaper goods such as clothing, shoes and much else that the working class could hardly have afforded before the advent of mass factory production. Higher pay and cheaper goods translate in to a rising standard of living. To put in to perspective the almost miraculous benefits that capitalism has created for the American working class, consider this: the average middle-class family today lives better than millionaires did a 50 years ago, and better than kings and queens did 100 years ago.

A nineteenth -century Millionaire couldn’t grab a cold drink from the refrigerator. He couldn’t hop in to a smooth- riding car for 70 miles per an hour trip on an interstate highway to the mountains or to the seashore. He couldn’t call up news, movies, music, and sporting events or directions to travel to a stranger place by simply touching your smart phone or TV remote. He couldn’t transmit letters or documents to any corner of the globe within seconds. He couldn’t escape the summer heat in air conditioned comfort. He couldn’t check in to a hospital for a How did this happen? coronary bypass to cure a failing heart, get a shot of penicillin to ward off infection, or even take an aspirin to relieve a headache, or get a vaccination for polio, small pox and other killer diseases. None of these things were available a century ago at any price. Then, at first, every one of them was available only to the rich. But overtime each became available to virtually everyone. Refrigeration was invented at the turn of the 20th century and was only for the affluent, but after about 20 years’ refrigerators were common place in American homes.

Commercial air travel began in 1920s, again, only for the wealthy. Today, just about every one flies. When portable radios first appeared in American stores, the average American worker had to labor 13 hours to buy one; today he or she toils for only 30 minutes. In 1908 the typical American worker had to work two years to earn enough money to buy an average quality car. Today a Ford Tarsus costs in for an American worker about one year of labor, but the car is technological miracle compared with the cars of yester years, with standard air conditioning, heating, power loaded, all kinds of safety devices, cruise control, a sunroof, tinted glass, CD player and so on. In 1970 an IBM mainframe computer sold for around 4.7 million dollars; today, a personal computer that operates 13 times faster goes for about $500.00 or less.

Capitalism has also allowed the average worker to take more and more leisure time. The average work week has declined from 61 hours in 1870, to 48 hours in 1929 to about 34 hours today. How did this happen? Decade by decade, American workers have become more efficient, applying technology, better tools, and improved skills to produce more goods and services on the job. Being more productive, in other words, allows workers to produce more with the same work effort, or even to produce more while spending less time on the job. In 1870, in the early days of the “Second Industrial Revolution”, the average American began working full time for a living at age 13; today it’s at 20 years. The average American today works about half the number of hours as the 1870 worker did, spends much less time at home doing chores thanks to such capitalist inventions as microwave, refrigeration, frozen, cooked food, vacuum cleaners etc., enjoys many more hours of leisure activity each year.

The shorter work week was entirely a capitalist invention and not the result of government policy or labor union pressure. Competition in labor markets is also the reason why child labor has essentially been eliminated. Legislation banning child labor only codified what the free market had only created. Remember even today most socialist countries practice child labor. The work place has also become progressively safer over the past century, not because of the occupational safety and health administration (OSHA), which was created in the 1970s, but because of the economics of capitalism. A dangerous work place is costly to employees because, if they have a reputation of having a dangerous workplace, then in a competitive labor market they must pat a wage premium to entice workers to take the extra risk. An added incentive for safety is that a worker who is off the job because of an injury is not producing anything that the employer can sell, and it is costly to hire and train replacements.

Human beings will always make mistakes and cause accidents, and some employers are smarter than others in terms of going about the task of improving job safety. But overall, the profit incentive embedded in capitalism is the strongest driving force leading to a safer work environment.

What about inequality?

The critics of capitalism have always complained of “inequality”. Such complaints are usually nonsensical, since they do not acknowledge the plain fact that every human being is unique- has a unique level of motivation, experience, education, interests, desires. We all pursue different life courses and develop different skills and knowledge. This is the beauty of the division of labor. We can specialize in what we do best and or interests us the most, earn money doing it, and then trade the dollars we earn for products and services that others produce in very different ways and in very different settings. All of our wages are determined primarily by the supply of demand for the goods and services we participate in producing, which naturally leads to wage inequality. Older, more experienced in the same trade in a capitalist economy, but so what? It is nothing to fret about.

Nevertheless, the anti-capitalist mentality is stuck on a mindless egalitarianism that insists that “equality” must be pursued even though no two people were ever equal in terms of talents, productivity, interests, and so forth. Making everyone equal under the law is an entirely different matter. The quixotic pursuit of economic equality is essentially a revolt against God and human nature. Statistics on “income inequality” can be very misleading, providing a totally inaccurate picture of American capitalism. For example, critics of capitalism are fond of pointing to US census Bureau data that seem to indicate that “the rich are getting richer and the poor are getting poorer”. From 1967 to 1997, for example, census data shows that the share of total national income going to the top 20 percent of income earners in America increased from 43.2 percent to 49.4 percent, whereas the share going tom the bottom 20 percent fell from 4.4 percent to 3.6 percent in that period. But such statistics are deceiving because they are a snapshot at a single point in time and say nothing about how actual individuals progress overtime. That is, they tell us nothing about the degree of economic opportunity and advancement in the U.S. economy. The critics suggests that there is little or no room for the “poor” to advance, that class of people is essentially stuck in the bottom 20 percent. But this is unequally false. In reality, the bottom 20 percent like all other quintiles is constantly made up of different people. A family in the lowest income quintile today, as recorded by the census data gatherers, will typically move up in to a higher income category over the next five or ten years and be replaced in the lower category by a different family, perhaps immigrants to America who like so many immigrants throughout history, come with very little money in their pockets.

For example, see the status of the refugees who came to America decades ago. They came here without money, but they had great dreams and ambition, and they with hard work moved up the economic ladder, as has been the American story for generations. Cox and Alm (A research company) has demonstrated the upward mobility of the American labor force and the uselessness of static income distribution statistics as clearly as anyone has. Only five percent of families in the bottom fifth of the income distribution in 1975 were still there in 1991. More than three fourths of them had made their way up to the two highest income quintiles. The poorest families made the largest gains. Those who started in the bottom 20 percent in 1975 had an inflation adjusted gain in annual income of $27,745 by 1991; those who started in the top 20 percent in 1975 also improved, but only by $ 4354. The rich are getting richer, the researchers concluded, but the poor are getting richer even faster. Less than one percent of the sample population remained in the bottom 20 percent during the entire time period under study.

Among the second poorest quintile in 1975, more than 70 percent had moved to a higher quintile by 1991, and one fourth reached the top 20 percent bracket. With education and training the rise up the income brackets can be very swift. More than half of the families who were in the bottom 20 percent in 1975 made it to a higher bracket within four years.

America has always enabled this kind of upward mobility, as the stories of wave after wave of immigrants attest. Indeed, America still draws immigrants from all over the globe who want to enjoy the benefits of American capitalism and freedom; many come to America to escape socialist hellholes (supposedly the workers’ paradise), whether they be in Cuba, Africa, China, Mexico or elsewhere. The anticapitalistic rail against income inequality, and there will always be income inequality in a vibrant, capitalist economy. But the same is true of a socialist economy, where wages are often determined by political rather than economic considerations. Indeed, any type of economy will produce income inequality. More important, when listening to the critics of capitalism, one must put American income inequality into proper perspective. America isn’t an egalitarian society. It wasn’t designed to be socialism, a failed and receding system, sought to impose an artificial equality. Capitalism, a successful and expanding system, doesn’t fight a fundamental fact of human nature- we vary greatly in capabilities, motivation, interests and preferences. Some of us are driven to get ahead. Some of us are just plain lazy.

Some of us are willing to work hard so we can afford a lifestyle rich in material goods. Some of us work just hard enough to provide a roof overhead, food, clothing, and a few amenities. It shouldn’t come as a surprise that our incomes vary greatly.