Chapter 11 of 12
India's Political Economy
Socialism and Democracy
We quote frequently with pride that India is the largest democracy on earth. Superficially, this statement is legitimate and valid. But if someone took the time to study the laws and regulations of India and compare them with any western democracy, he would realize that India does not have a full-fledged democratic system. The country has managed to sustain a working electoral system since 1947.
Jawaharlal Nehru, the architect of modern India, did not believe in the economic power of the individual; he believed in the state. He was impressed with the Fabian Socialism of Great Britain and was magnetized by state control and the five-year plans of the communist Soviet Union. He gave India the most regulated, taxed, and tariffed economy in the world, in which the government owned basic industries. The Indian government allowed a few billionaires to exist in the private sector, which in collusion with the government stood in the way of reforms. India thus had two monopolies: government monopolies and private monopolies.
All these industries, built with antique technologies of the Soviet Union and its communist satellite nations, produced substandard products and also created one of the worst air pollution problems in the world. Manufacturers were licensed to produce goods in certain quan-tities at certain prices and were issued with raw materials. Free competition was seen as a vice. The word “profit” was considered a dirty and immoral word.
Since an industrial license was, in effect, a license to make money, corporations were not allowed to increase production to meet demand. Increased production meant increased profits, and wealth was a sin in India, although everybody desired it in a hypocritical way. The wealthy class preached for the socialist cause and preached against wealth. Imports were restricted and businesses were checked by state institutions.
Although Nehru and his daughter visited both western capitalist societies and Soviet bloc countries and saw the great gulf between these two systems, their preconceived prejudice, arrogance, and self-interest blinded them to the benefits of capitalism and a free society. To please the masses, Indira Gandhi started vigorous nationalization programs. Instead of teaching and leading, she followed the utopian ideals of socialism. But her son, Rajiv Gandhi, had more intellectual acumen and started a moderate liberalization program. Now India has hope. If India manages to implement Narendra Modi’s free-market policies, India will become the most advanced country in the world.
The Case for Free Markets
Socialism and state interventions are an anomaly of nature. Even Hindu, Muslim, and Christian religions only teach about the free market system for humanity. From practice in India and other socialist countries, we know that state intervention and control are a source of corruption and bribery. There are two powerful forces that operate in a free market: reputation and creditworthiness. In a free market, cheating, lying, and bribery are quickly exposed and published. Reputation is prized and protected.
A free market promotes good manners, the core of all morality. In a free market, you have to be nice to your customers. Under a socialist system, an employee’s job is secure, so that employee will tend to behave rudely to people, as we see in India. Only a free market can break the feudal system and religious strife in India. Indian leaders must act morally and support a just cause.
The limited liberalization has changed the face of India. These changes have a great impact, especially among the middle class. Attitudes have shifted because of liberalization. The desire for material objects is no longer considered a vice. Now you can see PCs, the internet, and cellular phones all over India due to this partial liberalization. Pursuit of individual goals is no longer seen as a bad thing.
A country which proclaimed socialism as its ultimate goal cannot be considered a democracy. True freedom is economic freedom. Political freedom unaccompanied by economic freedom is meaningless.
China started its liberalization in 1978 under supreme leader Deng Xiaoping. Chinese leaders were far-sighted and intelligent. So China today is one of the great powers on earth. The end of the Cold War and the collapse of communism removed a permanent threat to peace, liberated millions of people living under communist tyranny, and demonstrated the bankruptcy of planned socialist economies and the superiority of the free market.
Historical facts show that the societies and economies that flourish are those that allow the distinctive talents of individuals to blossom. Societies that dwarf, crush, or manipulate individuals cannot progress. The nation that places a high value on individual freedom experiences the greatest advance. A nation’s wealth is not based on its natural resources or population. A nation’s success is based on whether that country has the rule of law and a tax system that encourages individuals’ talents and abilities to flourish and enables people to profit from them.
Religious Freedom
Religious freedom is the cornerstone of a democracy. In Western democracies, anyone is free to propagate, preach, and convert. In India, when many states passed restrictions on conversion and a wave of anti-conversion propaganda came in full swing, India automatically ceased to be an ideal democracy.
The central tenet of Christianity is the proclamation of the love and sacrifice of Christ to humanity to provide salvation and eternal life. So it is imperative that a Christian must preach this good news. In addition, just as Christ loved and helped the poor, Christians also should be obliged to assist the poor and downtrodden. Therefore, Christians are establishing schools, colleges, hospitals, and orphanages. While they do these great services, Christians fulfill their divine duty of proclaiming the gospel.
Christianity came to India in A.D. 52. After 2,000 years, including British rule for more than 150 years, Christians are less than 3% in India. Indian Christians are unique and more patriotic than anybody else. They observe most of the Indian culture and way of life.
Although Hinduism has many outdated practices, it is one of the most accommodating religions in the world. The pride of Hinduism is not in conquest, but in acceptance of all other religions. That is actually its strength.