Chapter 1 of 7

The Importance of Learning History

12 min read · Pages 5–14 of the printed edition

A Spanish philosopher, George Santayana (1863-1952) once said, “Those who forget history are doomed to repeat it.” Many centuries ago the Roman writer Cicero stated, “Not to know what took place before you were born was to remain forever a child.” It is also said that consciousness of the past alone can make us understand the present.

The Brethren Movement was a divine movement that transformed the history of the Christian Church. It is called the Brethren Movement, but a more appropriate name would have been “The movement of the Holy Spirit of God in the last days”. The failure on the part of some great men, in all dispensations, is not a new thing. A movement that recovered the complete New Testament principles was not an exception.

One great servant of God wrote “Till Satan is bound and the Lord come to do it there will ever be conflicts.” Since the beginning of the world, whenever God had established anything good, man’s first act was to destroy it. First, there was man himself, who had fallen; then in the world after the flood, Noah became intoxicated. It goes on and on always.

There was a very definite action of the Holy Spirit in exercising many widely separated believers simultaneously, along similar lines, and bringing them into one fellowship. Between A.D. 1812 and 1820 letters passed between a group of Christians in New York City seeking after a simpler and more Scriptural fellowship. Similarly, there was another group of believers in Great Britain who were also dissatisfied with the existing conditions in the Protestant denominations.

The leaders of the Reformation overlooked many of the most important doctrines of the Word of God. The vital truth of salvation, through faith alone in the sacrifice of Christ, was startling for the superstitious Christians. In the excitement, the Reformers thought that no further truth was needed.

It would be difficult to find this theology with the early Christian Fathers, the Reformers, and the Puritans: the doctrine of the Church as the Elect Bride of Christ, which is separated from the world, and awaits His return from Heaven. To speak of the Church as the body of Christ, of which He is the glorified Head in heaven, and of her being indwelt and governed by the Holy Ghost, were new truths within the ears of Christendom. From the early centuries until the beginning of the nineteenth century, no theological writer seems to have brought these precious truths before the church. The simple gospel was so completely overlaid and mixed up with human feelings and works, that no one had the true assurance of salvation. Hence, we find some of the most holy and spiritual teachers, who had been in the church, praying on their death beds that they “might not take their sins and iniquities to the judgment seat.” The full efficiency of redemption, according to Hebrews chapter ten, was and is comparatively little known. There we read “because the worshippers once purged should have had no more consciousness of sins. The precious blood of Christ has cleared the conscience of the believer forever. There is no need of the Catholic mass to perpetuate Christ’s sacrifice or to use human feelings and good works to add to its value. When this truth is understood, the full forgiveness of sins and being accepted in the Beloved, become the happy condition of the Christian soul.

Prophetic Truth

During the first quarter of the nineteenth century, it pleased the Lord to revive in many minds a deep interest in the restoration of Israel to their own land, and the consequent glory of the Messiah’s reign. Bible studies led to the establishment of what were called “The Prophetic Meetings.” The study was held at Powerscourt Castle, in Wicklow, Ireland. Clergymen and many aristocrats also came to listen. “It was then the midnight cry was raised, “Behold the Bridegroom is coming, go out to meet Him.” Consequently, since that day the number of those who preach the second coming of the Lord has increased. The cry has been heard in every land throughout Christendom “And the spirit and the bride say, come.” (Revelation 22:17, 20)

The Effect of the Church

The first effect of discovering from the Word of God the calling, position, and hopes of the Church was that it was in deep contrast to what man calls the Church, and what the Church really is in the light of the New Testament Scriptures.

These great men began to see, in the clear light of God’s Word, that to remain where they were would be a practiced denial of what the Church is. Thus, God led them to separate themselves from the existing religious systems. It was a moral separation from the world and from the existing false denominations. Even the Roman Catholic confessions at an early period of the Church history, and the Reformers and Puritans later, had no wish to leave the communion of the established Church.

The Brethren

In the winter of 1827-28 four Christian men agreed to come together on the Lord’s Day for the breaking of bread as the early Christians did, counting on the Lord’s Spirit to be with them. These were J.N. Darby, Dr. Cronin, Mr. Bellett and Mr. Hutchinson. Their first meeting was held in the house of Mr. Hutchinson #9, Fitz William Square, Dublin. They had for a considerable time- along with others who attended their reading meetings- been studying the Scriptures and comparing what they found in the Word of God with the existing state of things around them. However, they could not find any expression of the nature and character of the Church of God. This brought them into the place of separation from all these ecclesiastical systems and led them to come together in the name of the Lord Jesus and under the presidency of the Holy Spirit. (Matthew 18:20, Ephesians 4:3, 4)

Thus, the spirit of God was working in many minds and in a special way at that time. In this state of mind, they agreed to study the Word together, and look to the Lord for light and direction as to their future path.

The Beginning

This was how the first individual received the light: A young man, Dr. A. J. Cronin, came from southern Ireland to Dublin to enroll in the university circa 1825. He applied for communion as a visitor, and was readily received at the table of the Independents. However, when they learned that he had become a resident, this liberty was refused. This event made a deep impression on Cronin’s mind and was used of God to turn his attention to the truth of the one body. He thought that if all true believers are members of the body of Christ, what can that strange expression mean “special memberships with the Independents”? He paused, and after much exercise of conscience and prayer, he refused to submit to their Church order. He remained outside the congregation for several months, feeling deeply his loneliness and separation from many that he loved in the Lord. To avoid the appearance of evil, he used to spend the mornings of the Lord’s Day in secret. These seasons he found to be of great blessing spiritually.

Dr. Cronin was publicly excommunicated by name in a chapel, of which the Reverend William Cooper was the minister. The Church had gone far beyond its jurisdiction. She only has authority from her Head in Heaven to cut off those who have proved themselves to be wicked persons. (1 Corinthians 5) Thus the church in so acting, received the deeper wound herself. One of the deacons, Edward Wilson, secretary of the Bible Society, protested against this step, which led to his departure from the congregational body.

These two brothers, Cronin and Wilson, after studying the word for some time, began to come together on the Lord’s Day morning for the breaking of bread and prayer. They first met for their purpose in the house of Mr. Wilson, Sackville Street. They were joined a short time later by two others, Miss Drurys, who left Mr. Cooper’s chapel and also Mr. Tims, bookseller, Grafton Street. Mr. Wilson was leaving soon for England, so the little meeting was transferred to Mr.

Cronin’s house in Lower Pembroke Street, where several were added to their number. This little meeting never formally broke up, but they united at once with those who were breaking bread in Fitzwilliam Square, as the accommodation was greater, and the principles the same.

The Brethren’s First Pamphlet

In the year 1828, J. N. Darby published his first pamphlet entitled “, The Nature and Unity of the Church of Christ”. This tract is not a creed or catechism, but it contained almost all the elements of those distinctive truths which have been held by Brethren from that day even until now. This paper was the first public testimony of a movement which was rapidly producing blessed results in liberating souls. This can be read in the Collected Writings, Volume 1, and Second Article.

The Effect of this Pamphlet

The effects of these statements, so plain, solemn, and Scriptural, were immediate and great. They found an echo in many Christian’s hearts; many, both great and average men read this pamphlet and left their existing denominations.

Many thought that the movement would soon come to nothing, as they had no definite organization, clerical order, confession of faith, visible bond of union, or ordained minister. However, the Lord Himself was with them; true to His promise “Where two or three are gathered together in my name there am I in the midst of them.” The gospel was preached with clearness, fullness, and power. Books and tracts were written and widely circulated. The grand doctrines of the Church, the operation of the Holy Spirit, and the blessed hope of the Lord’s imminent return, were brought out with great freshness and power, to the uplifting of many hearts and the eternal blessing of hundreds of precious souls.

Those who came to the meeting out of curiosity were struck by the fact that hundreds of people were assembled together without a minister. Yet there was no confusion, but “all things were done decently and in order.”

Reading Meetings

John Nelson Darby, the apostle of the recovered truth, went to Limerick, Ireland. He held reading meetings and many clergy and other people came to attend. From the Brethren’s earliest history, it is evident that reading meetings have been a mode of teaching, which has been universally practiced. Many reading groups were formed in various homes. In this way the Word of God was closely read by small companies of twenty or more, with anyone being free to ask a question. Difficulties were removed, and the true meaning of Scripture was more clearly seen. No other kind of meeting, it will be seen, so stimulates the Christian to study his Bible constantly. This may account for the Proverbial saying that “whatever may be the faults of the Brethren, they are at home with their Bibles.”

The true secret of their knowledge of the Bible was their knowledge of Christ. The Holy Spirit, who leads into all truth, connects everything with the person and work of Christ. It is merely human, they say, to handle any particular truth as a subject. In such cases the mind takes the lead in learning the truth of God, so consequently everything is darkened and unsettled. It is not by any means of human learning, or by the power of the human intellect that the glory of Christ is seen, but by the teaching of the Holy Spirit. One ray of that sacred light will do more to enlighten the soul as to the person, work and glory of Christ, than the workings of the human mind for a thousand years. Herein lies the mighty difference between a reading meeting conducted under the direction of an appointed leader, however sincere, or spiritual and one under the acknowledged guidance of the Holy Spirit.

The individual state of mind is very different in the one meeting from the other. In the former it partakes more of an intellectual turn-disposed to discuss, to infer, to draw conclusions, and build upon them. In the latter, when the soul is subject to the guidance of the Holy Spirit, the conscience is exercised before God, and their affections are engaged with the blessed Lord Jesus.

What was the secret of producing more than 100 great expositions by this small movement? Even common men and women had more scriptural knowledge than today’s great expositors. They knew the Word, not because they are better than other Christians, but because the Holy Ghost was owned as the leader and teacher in their assemblies. There may be failure on the part of some men, nevertheless, it is the Holy Spirit’s presence which constitutes their assemblies and characterizes them as Christians.

The Brethren believed that the Holy Spirit was to work in and guide this assembly. They would not think it right to be present at any meeting of the assembly where a person occupied the chair as a leader. In regular reading meetings there was no need of a president.

The Various Means of Spreading the Truth

Besides the prayerful study of the Word of God, these believers were most zealous in preaching the Gospel to sinners because of their knowledge of the finished work of Christ and the riches of His divine grace. The gospel was preached with power and many came to know Christ. So zealous were they in spreading the glad tidings, that in some places almost every brother became a preacher. Teaching or giving lectures on Scripture to other Christians was also greatly practiced by the better instructed. The important distinction between preaching the Gospel to the unconverted and teaching Christians was altogether new. The gift and work of the evangelist are perfectly distinct from those of the teacher.

Another means adopted for spreading the truth was writing and circulating books and tracts. In a short span of time, people had in their hands, and at a small cost, the means of becoming acquainted with the Word of God. Many tracts were written and appeared from time to time on such subjects as: the grand doctrines of the Church, the heavenly calling and operations of the Spirit’s ministry, worship, prophecy, the efficiency of redemption, the heavenly relations of the Christian, the coming of the Lord, the rapture of the saints, the first and second resurrection, the millennium, the eternal state, the New Heaven and New Earth, etc.

In this way, the truth was rapidly and widely circulated. These believers possessed a great advantage over the popular religious bodies by what is called lay ministry. Ordination was absolutely essential to the exercise of ministry in these bodies, where the work was limited to the authorized few. The Brethren have maintained that this system of ministry is opposed to the truth of God.

For example, an educated man though destitute of spiritual gifts, and perhaps even of spiritual life, yet if he was duly ordained, might exercise every branch of ministry in the denomination to which he belonged. On the other hand, if a Christian possesses the most decided gifts for preaching and teaching he could not exercise either within the jurisdiction of the Church, unless sanctioned by human authority.

Happily, for them, for the Church of God, and for the souls of men, they found the true source of ministry in all its branches, in Christ Himself, the glorified Head in Heaven. (Ephesians 4:7-12). Here we have the true basis and the only source of all ministerial gifts-the redemption accomplished by Christ on the cross, and his ascension to God’s right hand in heaven. Christ as the head of the Church is the giver of these gifts; nothing is said of human authority or of human ordination. The professing Church has suffered immensely from her traditional ideas of ministry, regarding it as an honorable profession among men, and giving a certain status in society.