Chapter 11 of 16
Argument for Household Baptism
It is argued that since the New Testament describes the baptism of five different households, that each, or at least some of these households, must have included little children, and that these children were baptized on the strength of their parents’ faith.
- The house of Cornelius, Acts 10:24-48. Peter, as a result of a direct revelation
from the Lord Himself, goes to the home of a Roman centurion who has gathered his friends and relatives together to hear the message that Peter is to bring. Cornelius said to Peter, “We are all here present before God, to hear all things that are commanded thee of God.” Thus, all present were capable of intelligently hearing the message that Peter was to bring. This naturally eliminates all ideas of babies being present, for they are incapable of intelligently hearing and believing. Peter presented Christ, and the spirit of God fell on all of them, which heard the word. The effect of this visitation was that they all spoke in tongues, they all magnified God, and they received the Holy Spirit, and were baptized as believers. To suppose that there were little babies in this company and that these little ones were recipients of the Holy Spirit, spoke in tongues, magnified God and were baptized is somewhat of a strain on one’s imagination and credulity.
- The house of Lydia, Acts 16:14-15,40. Here was a businesswoman, a seller of
purple from Thyatira, a city 200 miles from Philippi. She was accompanied by her household servants who carried her goods. Through the ministry of Paul, the Lord opened her heart and she attended to the message of the gospel and was saved. Then, when both she and her household had been baptized, she invited Paul and Silas to stay in her home, and the invitation was accepted.
Later on, after the arrest, imprisonment, and miraculous release of Paul and Silas, we are told, “They went out of the prison and entered into the house of Lydia, and when they had seen the brethren, they comforted them and departed.” From those three verses, the household Baptists would have us believe that (1) Lydia was a married woman, (2) that she had little children, (3) that these children were with her at the time, (4) that these little children, on the strength of her faith, were baptized, and (5) that all her household servants, on the strength of her faith, were also baptized. This is the suppositious “evidence” for household baptism in the case of Lydia, on whose strength they are prepared to baptize babies, the unsaved servants of a Christian master, and the unconverted children of a Christian father or mother.
Now let us look at the facts as they are recorded in the word. In the first place, no mention is made as to whether Lydia was married or not, as to whether she had children, that these children were with her on this business trip, that these were little children, not old enough to object being baptized, and finally, that her household servants, without any profession of faith in Christ on their part, were compelled to be baptized. The facts, which are here recorded, surely point entirely in the opposite direction. What married businesswoman, with little children, would undertake a 200 mile journey with these little children? There is no mention whatsoever of children in this story. What is mentioned, however, is that her household consisted of “brethren” who could be “comforted” by the word ministered by Paul and Silas.
- The house of the jailer of Philippi, Acts 16:22-40. Here also, we see the
description of the event. Paul and Silas spoke the word of God to the jailer and to all the others in his house. Immediately after the jailer and all his family were baptized, the whole family rejoiced. Again, we are told that there must have been little children in this home, and, on this gratuitous assumption, we are assured that all these little children were baptized on the strength of the faith of the father, the head of the house, who had been saved! However, as we look carefully at the wording of this account, we discover there is no mention whatsoever of little children. On the contrary, we are told that Paul and Silas spoke the word of God to all that were in his house. The word “all” is mentioned three times in verses 32-34. They all believed, and they all rejoiced. Can you imagine a little baby listening intently and intelligently to the word of God, then believing and being baptized and rejoicing in the assurance of salvation?
- The house of Crispus, Acts 18:8, 1 Corinthians 1:14. “And Crispus, the chief
ruler of the synagogue, believed on the Lord with all his house.” Here again, we hear the same argument.
- The household of Stephanus, 1 Corinthians 1:16, 16.
The argument from the above five households mentioned afford no evidence whatsoever for the baptism of any, save those who have heard the word and believed in Christ. To assume that infants were in each of these households, and that they were baptized because of the faith of the head of that household is pure speculation and entirely unsupported by any evidence of its actuality.