Chapter 9 of 16

The Teaching of the Church of Christ

10 min read · Pages 13–17 of the printed edition

The Church of Christ denomination believes and teaches that however good and godly a believer may be, if he has not been baptized subsequent to his profession of faith in Christ, he is still a lost sinner and under the condemnation of God. Their theory is based on Mark 16:16, Matthew 28 and Acts 2:38. In Mark 16:16, baptism simply indicates the normal outward evidence that a person has believed on Christ. He is baptized, not in order to be saved, but because he is already saved. Scripture teaches that we are saved by a person, and on the basis of a work accomplished by that person, and not by an ordinance. The word of God assures all believers that they are saved (Acts 16:31, John 10:27-31, Ephesians 4:30) Ephesians 1:3, that they have been blessed with “all the spiritual blessing in the heavenlies in Christ.” To assert that such are lost because they have not been immersed in water is to deny the plain truths of God’s word. Matthew 28:19-20, “Go therefore and make disciples of all the nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit.” This denomination teaches that this scripture should read, “Go ye into all the world and make disciples of all men by baptizing them,” etc. They teach that disciples are made by baptism. This error can be seen by referring to John 4:1 where we read, “Jesus made and baptized more disciples than John.” Consequently, the making and baptizing of disciples are two distinct and separate things. Baptism does not make disciples; it only marks them as being disciples.

In Matthew 28:19, the principal verb is “make disciples,” which is followed by a participle, “baptizing them.” Some would make this to mean, “Make disciples by baptizing them,” thus treating the principal verb and the participle by describing only one action. By this they seek to find scriptural support for baptizing persons without prior personal faith in and acceptance of Christ as Lord. They allege that by baptism such receive the status of being disciples. The falsity of such reasoning can be easily demonstrated by turning to similar construction of words in the New Testament. For example, Ephesians 6:17-18 reads, “And take the helmet of salvation, and the sword of the spirit, which is the word of God; praying always with all prayer and supplication in the spirit, being watchful to this end with all perseverance and supplication for all saints.”

“Take (the principal verb) the helmet of salvation, praying, and being watchful. It would confuse the whole passage to render it “Take by praying and being watchful.” Acts 18:23, “He departed (the principal verb) passing through the country” etc. It would make no sense to read, “They departed by passing through” Acts 14:21-22, “They returned (the principal verb) to Lystra confirming the souls of the disciples.” This cannot be made to mean, “They returned by confirming,” etc. Look at Acts 21:2-3, “They set sail (principal verb) and coming in sight of Cyprus.” No one would translate this, “They set sail by coming in sight of Cyprus.”

In like manner, it is only nonsense to translate Matthew 28:19, “making disciples by baptizing them.” The scripture previously quoted, “Jesus made and baptized more disciples,” which should settle this once and for all. Those who teach that disciples are made by baptizing are trying to make the scriptures affirm what they do not teach.

The New Testament describes how disciples are made. It is not by baptism, but through faith in the Lord Jesus (Acts 10:19-20). How did these people at Antioch become disciples (verse 21)? Read Acts 8:13, 36, 10:47, 13:38-39, 16:14-15, 30, and 18:8. It will be clear from these verses that these people were saved when they believed, and were baptized because they were saved, and not in order to be saved, or add to their salvation.

Acts 2:38 People who believe that baptism is essential for salvation quote this verse. They point out, by a chart, the three steps necessary to salvation:

  1. Repent
  2. Be baptized
  3. Receive the Holy Spirit.

They argue that there can be no salvation without baptism. This all sounds very convincing to the person who is not familiar with all the many other scriptures that bear on this matter of salvation.

In the first place, to whom was Peter’s message directed? Notice in Acts 2:14, “Men of Judea,” verses 22 and 29, “Men of Israel,” and in verse 36, “Therefore let all the house of Israel know.” Compare also Acts 3:12, 4:10, 5:30-31, 7:2, 51. It was a message addressed specifically to the Jews, and not a word is addressed to the Gentiles, as such. The Gentiles are not brought in until Acts 10, and then the message of salvation is quite different. The Jews are here charged with dreadful and national crimes of having rejected and crucified their Messiah. They are now urged to repent of this and, by their baptism, to publicly disassociate themselves from their complicity in the awful crime. By their baptism, they outwardly severed the link that bound them to the unbelieving nation, and thus came over on to Christian ground. This was also true of Saul of Tarsus, who was similarly urged to “arise and be baptized, and wash away thy sins, calling on the name of the Lord” (Acts 22:16). Saul had been a saved man for three days (Acts 9:9). Read Romans 10:9 also. By his baptism, Paul showed, in the sight of men, that he, who had previously been a hater of Christ and a persecutor of His people, now repudiated all he had once stood for, and confessed in this symbolic way, his belief in and allegiance to the Son of God. Thus, in a metaphorical way, he “washed away his sins.”

Since it is the blood of Christ alone that cleanses from all sin, how many sins are left for water to wash away? Baptism, for the remission of sins, is confined to two preachers only: John the Baptist and Peter. And in each case, the message is addressed to Israel only.

The people who teach that baptism is a prerequisite for salvation fail to take into consideration the transitional character of the first ten chapters of Acts. In Acts 2, the order is (1) repent, (2) be baptized, (3) the remission of sins, and (4) the gift of the Holy Spirit. In the tenth chapter, this order is completely changed.

In Acts, baptism was the condition on which the Spirit should be given. In Acts 10, the Spirit is given before baptism. In Acts 2, it is “repent and be baptized for the remission of sins.” In Acts 10, not a word is said about repentance and baptism being conditional for the remission of sins. From chapter 10 on, it is the normal procedure for both Jews and Gentiles alike. (Read Romans 10:12 also). Unless this transitional character of the first ten chapters of Acts is taken into consideration, confusion would follow. A gradual transition is seen between Acts 2 and 10. For instance, in Acts 2, the Jews received the Holy Spirit after water baptism. In the eighth chapter, the Samaritans received the Spirit through the laying on of the hands of the apostles. In chapter 10, the Holy Spirit is received without water baptism, or the laying on of hands. The only answer for this difference is to see dispensational aspects. Therefore, to apply Acts 2:28 as God’s present way of salvation for all is to ignore dispensational truths and ignore numerous scriptures that clearly teach that salvation is by grace alone, through faith in the person and work of the Son of God, entirely apart from any ordinance, whatever it may be.

Mormons teach and practice baptism for, or on behalf of, dead people. They base their theory on 1 Corinthians 15:29 which reads, “Otherwise, what will they do who are baptized for the dead, if the dead do not rise at all? Why then are they baptized for the dead?” Mormons base their doctrine of baptism by proxy on this verse. They teach that a living person, who is a Mormon, can be baptized in the place of another who has died without embracing Mormonism as his religious belief. Some Mormons have been baptized over a hundred times on behalf of their deceased relatives, sincerely supposing, in doing so, that the spirits of those who have died outside the pale of Mormonism would be benefited thereby and enabled to accept Mormonism in a future life, is they so desired.

The New Testament does not say anything about baptism by proxy. There are three explanations given by A.P. Gibbs.

(1) The subject of 1 Corinthians 15 is the physical resurrection of physically dead bodies. There were false teachers in Corinth who denied the resurrection of the dead, and Paul is here combating this false teaching. Verse 29 is an illustration that Paul uses to enforce his argument for the resurrection of the dead. He asks, “If there is no resurrection from the dead, then what is the use of being baptized?” Baptism is the symbol of the believer’s identification with Christ, not only in His death, but also in His resurrection. The emergence of the believer from the waters of baptism means something. What does it illustrate? It illustrates the resurrection of Christ. Therefore, if Christ is not raised, and there is no resurrection of the dead, then baptism becomes a meaningless rite, a dead and useless thing, and a hollow mockery. Those believers, who during their lifetime were baptized, and who have since died, were baptized in vain if there is no resurrection. If death ends all, then baptism is a cruel farce, for it has in view the resurrection.

(2) The argument from an illustration of a military figure. This is a very satisfactory interpretation of this verse. It will be noted that verses 20-28 are parenthetical. The argument from the end of v.19 is taken up again in verse 29. The words “dead ones” refers to Christians who have died. Now let us think of all Christians as forming the army of the Lord Jesus and doing battle against the common enemy. As time goes on, the ranks of this army become depleted by the hand of death, and thus, there are gaps left in the front ranks. The question is, who is to take the place of these dead ones, and thus fill up the gaps in the ranks? There is only one answer. Those believers who are being saved and baptized will fill those gaps in the ranks. Thus, by their baptism, which is the outward expression of their inward identification with Christ, these young believers would step into the places of those who had been removed from the ranks by physical death.

Hence, the question, what shall they do who are baptized for [Greek: “in the place of”] the dead ones, if the dead rise not at all? Why are they then baptized to take the place of the dead ones? If there was to be no resurrection of the dead ones whose places they had taken by virtue of their baptism, then their faith and their baptism had been all in vain, for they too would soon pass from this scene with no hope for the future. This seems to be the most reasonable interpretation of this disputed passage.

(3) The argument from the altered punctuation. There are no punctuation marks in the original, and a well-known and able teacher of the word, Mr. Harry Lacey, has suggested that a slight alteration of the punctuation of this verse would clarify it. He points out that 1 Corinthians 15:12-32 forms part of a reduction to absurdity argument, by which Paul seeks to combat the false teaching which denied the resurrection from the dead. After the parenthesis of vs.20-28, Paul renews the argument in verse 29, and he suggests that this verse should be punctuated as follows, “Else what shall they do who are baptized? It is for the dead, if the dead rise not at all. Why, then, are they baptized for them?” Then follows the logical conclusion if there is to be no resurrection, “If the dead are not raised, let us eat and drink, for tomorrow we die” (v.32). He then goes on to show that the denial of the resurrection blasphemes Christ, impugns apostles, and reduces baptism to a farce, since it is merely for the dead, if there is no resurrection. It leaves us with one course open, that of fatalistic “Epicureanism,” a philosophy current in that day, which affirmed that pleasure was man’s highest good.