Chapter 7 of 11
An Inglorious End
His Pro-Zionism and involvement in politics of Zionist cause finally reached the limit his superiors would tolerate. In November 1938 he took leave to travel to England. He met with Ben-Gurion and Weizmann to discuss ways of influencing British decision makers on favorable schemes of partition. Wingate was granted permission to say good bye. The Haganah leaders and men were sad to see their best friend leave. He met with his men and friends to say good bye and offer some advice and hope for the future. At one Kibbutz a farewell was held for him. Upon his entry he was met with great applause. He gave a speech saying war with Nazi Germany was imminent and that afterward there would be a war for Jewish independence that the Jews would win. He urged a more aggressive policy but cautioned against using violence directly against the British authority. At the end of another farewell party he raised his right hand pledging that someday he would return to an independent Jewish homeland, and he recited the Biblical verse from the Psalm 137:5-6 “If I forget you O Jerusalem, let my right arm forget its skill. If I do not remember you, let my tongue cleave to the roof of my mouth- If I do not exalt Jerusalem A bove my chief joy”.
Wingate had a great vision from above. He knew that Israel as an independent nation would be an oasis of democracy and freedom in the Middle East. History has proven beyond any doubt that civilized nation
A brief Biography of Charles Wingate
can only rely on Israel in the Middle East. Even in the third millennium Islamic nations follow the seventh century barbaric culture in their countries.The world is facing the retrogade throw backs from the middle ages.
Wingate testified before a commission examining partition and spoke favorably about the value of Jewish state and of his reasons for doing so, “Now a days people seem to imagine that impartiality means readiness to treat lies and truth the same readiness to hold white as bad as black and black as good as white…I believe that righteousness exalteth a nation and righteousness does not mean playing off one side against the other while you guard you own interest.” He also spoke to a cabinet minister and newspaper editors on how the Jews were the only reliable force in the region Britain could rely upon.
For these actions he was ordered back to Palestine. There his military superiors were angry at this breech of military protocol and political partisanship. When he returned he was removed from command of SNS and was transferred to staff intelligence duties in Jerusalem.
Wingate was accused of being Jewish and became the target of anti-Semitic innuendo. He found it necessary to make the following official declaration: “Whether I, nor my wife, nor any member of our families has a drop of Jewish blood in our veins. I am not ashamed to say that I am real and devoted admirer of the Jews – Had more officers shared my views the rebellion would have come to a speedy conclusion some years ago”.
Lessons Learned
Jewish state Israel was born to a tumultuous beginning. Daring Israel’s war of Independence (1948-49) the fledgling state struggled to survive its first year as Arab armies attempted to strangle the state in its infancy. During the war, the critical situation was not overcome until a more offensive strategy was undertaken, taking the war to the enemy. Imploring surprise, speed and mobility, moving away from defensive
A brief Biography of Charles Wingate
minds became the way to achieve survival. This was due to Wingate who imparted his bold ideas achievements upon the Haganah. The Israeli military leaders believe the impact of Orde Wingate has been the greatest significance on Israeli military theory and practice. As one of Israel’s Army chief of Staff put it “of science His basic contribution and it was a great one was to teach us that warfare is a science had an art at the same time. He was the perfect example of a military man, being himself the excellent combination of scientist and artist”.
Wingate installed a sense of purpose in a military operation any army in the world needs that sense of purpose. Israel commander wrote “Wingate’s second greatest contribution was to make us realize something which he had felt, but had never been consciously aware of before, that our faith in our cause and our morale resulting there from is an invicible weapon”.
Commander Sadeh said, “I have learned from Wingate, that a soldier has to think and not act like a sheep, we could hardly say that we learned from him a certain system, because he always found a new system that fitted in with the new situation. Wingate was meticulous and careful in planning before operations, yet at the same time there was a willingness to improvise and to recognize the necessity of doing so. He gave power to subordinates to use their initiative and so training them to be skilled small-unit leaders. Another important skill was in knowing when to operate a multiple or small unit and in recognizing the need when to concentrate one forces’’.