Essay English 21 min read

Christian and Vote

John Mathew Thekkel, M.A., Ph.D. (Dr. Sunny Ezhumattoor)

A timely essay on Christian responsibility and civic participation.

Full text

Christian and Vote

A comprehensive Christian worldview provides the essential framework for discerning complete truth in all areas of life, including civic responsibility. As followers of Christ, we bear the obligation to support candidates and parties whose platforms most closely align with biblical principles. When faced with imperfect choices—as is inevitable in a fallen world—we must exercise wisdom in selecting the lesser of available evils.

Contemporary evangelical Christianity faces significant internal tension regarding political and social issues. Many prominent megachurch pastors have publicly embraced movements such as Black Lives Matter, Critical Race Theory, LGBTQ advocacy, and various Social Justice initiatives. A widespread misconception equates Socialism with Social Justice. However, a more accurate definition recognizes Socialism as essentially Communism implemented through legislative rather than revolutionary means—as one observer noted, “A socialist is a Communist without guns and bombs.”

The Indian Christian Voting Paradox

The political behavior of Indian Christians, both in their homeland and in diaspora, presents a particularly striking case study. Historically, Indian Christians have demonstrated strong alignment with left-leaning Socialist ideology. This pattern persists even after migration to the United States, where the overwhelming majority of Indian Christians consistently vote for the Democratic Party. Many of these believers serve as spiritual leaders and elders who exemplify authentic Christian living. They faithfully raise their children with solid biblical foundations and actively engage in gospel ministry while maintaining secular employment.

Yet a troubling disconnect exists between private faith and public political engagement. Many Christian parents remain unaware that their households are nurturing ideological commitments fundamentally at odds with biblical teaching. Personal observation within Indian assembly gatherings reveals numerous instances where children of devoted believers have become fervent advocates for movements like Black Lives Matter, despite the theological and practical concerns these movements raise.

The Voting Dilemma

This disconnect manifests most clearly at the ballot box. Believers who maintain orthodox theology and personal holiness nevertheless support political parties that have championed same-sex marriage, endorsed organizations such as Antifa and Black Lives Matter, promoted gender ideology claiming dozens of gender identities, and advanced the notion that biological sex is mutable and self-determined.

The abortion question alone demands serious consideration. According to reporting by Kyle Morris and Sam Dorman of Fox News, “More than 63 million abortions are estimated to have taken place in the U.S. since the Supreme Court’s 1973 Roe v. Wade ruling that granted federal protections to women seeking to terminate their pregnancies.”

A Question of Eternal Consequence

Many believers have expressed genuine confusion regarding why young Indian Christians, mirroring patterns among their non-Christian Indian peers, demonstrate such strong Democratic Party loyalty. The answer to this perplexing question emerges through careful examination of worldview formation and eternal consequences.

What follows is a narrative framework—a story that appears across cultures with various adaptations—which illuminates a profound spiritual truth. This story, shared regularly with students and colleagues, may contain the most crucial application for Christian civic engagement. The central thesis is sobering: Christians who embrace leftist ideology place their heavenly reward in jeopardy. At the Judgment Seat of Christ (the Bema), voting patterns that contradict biblical values may neutralize the eternal reward of an otherwise sacrificial Christian life.

The Warning of Scripture

The apostle John addresses this very concern in his second epistle: “Watch out, so that you do not lose the things we have worked for, but receive a full reward” (2 John 1:8). This warning carries profound implications. A believer may dedicate their entire earthly existence to serving Christ with genuine devotion, yet forfeit their full reward at the Bema seat by supporting political parties that actively promote policies Scripture identifies as wicked—including the advancement of Communist ideology and its various contemporary expressions.

The question before us, therefore, transcends mere political preference. It concerns the integrity of Christian witness and the reality of eternal accountability for the stewardship of our civic influence.

Chapter 1

The Historic Tension

The Enduring Debate

From time immemorial, Christians have confronted two diametrically opposing perspectives regarding their involvement in political affairs. This perplexing subject has generated continuous debate and will likely remain contested until the end of the age. For fundamentalist Christians, the question demands serious consideration: What should constitute our proper attitude toward, and level of participation in, political processes?

Most fundamentalist Brethren speakers have vehemently opposed political participation, including the act of voting itself. Their position rests on several theological premises. First, they argue that our Lord occupies the throne of universal sovereignty, and nothing transpires without His express permission; therefore, our voting cannot effect any material difference in outcomes. Second, they contend that as citizens of Heaven, we bear no responsibility for the affairs of this wicked world—Christians cannot change the world through political means. Third, they emphasize our expectation of Jesus’ imminent return to take us home to be with Him, questioning why we should concern ourselves with temporal worldly affairs.

These arguments are not novel innovations. Brethren leaders inherited this theological framework, often unknowingly, from the early Brethren movement, particularly from John Nelson Darby. Remarkably, even many Brethren preachers who oppose Darby’s other teachings unconsciously promote these very ideologies. We must acknowledge that contemporary society differs diametrically from both nineteenth-century and early twenty-first-century culture.

The Doctrine of Imminence and Practical Responsibility

I maintain firm conviction in the doctrine of the Rapture. The Apostle Paul himself anticipated that Jesus might return during his lifetime. Similarly, John Nelson Darby and countless Christians worldwide who embrace premillennial, pre-tribulation Rapture theology believe in the imminent return of Jesus Christ. I share this conviction and believe that all prophetic requirements for Jesus’ return have been fulfilled.

However, consider this scenario: Suppose Jesus tarries another two hundred years. How will your children and grandchildren live upon the earth? Will you have instilled in them the spiritual values and biblical principles necessary to wage effective spiritual warfare? We cannot afford complacency.

We must not replicate the tragic example of German Christians before the rise of Adolf Hitler, who remained passive while evil consolidated power.

The Victorian Context and Darby’s Instructions

The Victorian era is commonly understood as a period of rigid social structure and strict behavioral codes. Victorian morality encompassed a comprehensive set of principles and moral standards, including the practice of sexual restraint, zero tolerance for criminal activity, and a stern public demeanor. Victorian England birthed many modern amenities we utilize today, including the telegraph and the telephone. Cities expanded into sprawling urban centers, and the burgeoning middle class championed social justice reforms—patterns that continue to influence contemporary society.

Alongside these technological and social advancements emerged a repressive moral framework known as Victorian morality. This system of personal ethics, grounded in the religious convictions of the period, was characterized by severe austerity and behavioral repression.

When Christians abstained from political participation during the nineteenth century, this withdrawal did not prove destructive to Christianity precisely because European society remained fundamentally conservative. John Nelson Darby’s instructions, formulated within that cultural context, were acceptable for that particular society. However, if Darby were alive today, he would not advocate such short-sighted instructions given our radically different cultural landscape.

Divine Stewardship and Cultural Responsibility

If Great Britain and America have transitioned into non-Christian nations, we cannot simply blame secular liberals. Throughout the six-thousand-year history of human civilization, God uniquely selected America and entrusted the governance of this nation to fundamentalist Christians in 1776. Consider a simple analogy: If you have children and they become unruly, the primary responsibility likely rests with you as a parent. Family influence constitutes the most powerful influence in the world.

The world’s current population stands at eight billion people. More than ninety percent of Hindus were born to Hindu parents. Similarly, 99.9 percent of Muslims were born to Muslim parents. Every religious denomination sustains itself primarily through its children. Most atheists’ children likewise become atheists. Some Christians have failed to raise their children with strict biblical discipline, resulting in their departure from Christianity. Christian parents must raise their children with a comprehensive biblical worldview.

The Transformation of American Worldview

American society has undergone profound transformation over recent decades. Many decades ago, when I arrived in America, I observed that a Christian theistic worldview dominated American society. Christian symbols occupied public spaces, and moral issues—including the portrayal of sexuality—were evaluated exclusively through a Christian worldview lens. The majority of those occupying positions of authority actively promoted Christian morality.

Observe the dramatic contrast today. Contemporary leaders evaluate morality using an entirely different measuring standard. In virtually every political debate broadcast through various media platforms, most politicians actively promote abortion rights, same-sex marriage, transgender ideology, Critical Race Theory, Black Lives Matter, and Socialist economic systems. Evolution and Climate Change are taught in classrooms as established scientific facts. These ideological commitments have gradually infiltrated the belief systems of a substantial percentage of self-identified Christians, who have essentially become something fundamentally different without even recognizing their transformation. We must now acknowledge that America has become a post-Christian society.

Applying Christian Worldview to Social and Political Issues

How should Christians apply a biblical worldview to social and political questions? A fundamental principle involves recognizing the equality of all human beings: “From one man He made all the nations, that they should inhabit the whole earth; and He marked out their appointed times in history and the boundaries of their lands” (Acts 17:26). Scripture explicitly teaches that Christians must not harbor feelings of superiority over others (Philippians 2:3). Believers are commanded not to make class distinctions between various people (James 2:1-4). Paul teaches the spiritual equality of all people in Christ (Galatians 3:28 and Colossians 3:11). Another essential component of biblical worldview concerns marriage. Marriage constitutes God’s design and provides intimate companionship for life (Genesis 2:18).

Significantly, the apostles never called for believers to engage in civil disobedience or to protest the Roman Empire’s unjust laws and brutal policies. Instead, the apostles commanded first-century Christians to proclaim the gospel and live lives that provided clear evidence of the gospel’s transforming power.

Democracy and Christianity: Compatible Frameworks

Democracy and Christianity represent compatible, not contradictory, concepts. Democracy functions most effectively within a Christian cultural framework. Many closet liberal evangelicals assert, “We should preach the gospel, and that is the only way Christians can hope to change people’s hearts and transform our society.” Yet if their preaching proves truly effective, why do many of their own children become liberal supporters? Evidently, no genuine internal or external transformation has occurred for them. They claim that the church is called exclusively to preach the gospel, not to address political matters. However, the gospel presented in the New Testament encompasses far more than simply trusting Jesus for forgiveness of sins, growing in holiness, and going to heaven. In its fuller sense, God’s good news addresses all dimensions of life.

The Great Commission itself affirms this comprehensive scope: “Therefore go and make disciples of all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit, and teaching them to obey everything I have commanded you. And surely, I am with you always, to the very end of the age” (Matthew 28:19-20).

Christian Responsibility to Vote for Good Government

Scripture explicitly addresses the believer’s responsibility toward government: “I urge, then, first of all, that petitions, prayers, intercession and thanksgiving be made for all people—for kings and all those in authority, that we may live peaceful and quiet lives in all godliness and holiness” (1 Timothy 2:1-2).

Consider the stark contrast between North Korea and South Korea. Christianity faces severe suppression and oppression in North Korea. Most people die without ever hearing the gospel. By contrast, the churches of South Korea, where the government has permitted religious freedom, are growing and thriving while sending missionaries throughout the world. Consider also the persecuted church in Cuba, which remains unable to send missionaries anywhere. Governments demonstrably affect the advancement of God’s kingdom work—precisely why Paul urged that prayers be made for kings (1 Timothy 2:2). Government can either permit churches to assemble freely and evangelize, or it can prevent these activities through force of law.

India provides an instructive contemporary example. After India obtained independence in 1948, the secular government granted complete freedom to preach the gospel. However, when Hindu nationalist parties assumed power approximately a decade ago, they implemented restrictions on gospel preaching. Today, Christians face daily persecution in India. Indian Christians demonstrate greater political wisdom than Christians in the West. They consistently vote for parties that protect minority populations. Since no Christian candidates contest Indian elections, believers vote based on party policies rather than the personal moral character of individual candidates. Indian Christians understand they are not electing a pastor. In the West, by contrast, many Christians refused to vote for Trump because of his divorces and past moral failures.

In 2012, seven million Christians abstained from voting because they refused to support a Mormon candidate. The consequence was that when Barack Obama became president, he initiated policies that dismantled foundational principles of American governance. I will provide additional insight into this development later in this work. Government possesses power either to promote and protect marriage, or to undermine and destroy it. Corrupt government can permit criminals to kill and plunder without consequence, as has occurred in certain liberal states in America.

Chapter 2

The Whole Gospel

The Scope of Gospel Transformation

The whole gospel encompasses nothing less than the transformation of society in every dimension of life. The argument that Christians should “preach the gospel and do evangelism, not politics” represents a fundamentally flawed and defective position. Authentic gospel ministry necessarily includes the transformation of society. The forgiveness of sins, while essential, does not constitute the totality of the gospel message. Jesus seeks transformed lives that produce, in turn, a transformed world. When the gospel genuinely changes people’s lives, it should inevitably result in transformed businesses, transformed institutions, and transformed communities.

Consider this challenge: Which portion of the Bible should your church refuse to preach? Have you determined that you will not preach from Romans 13:1-7, or that you will neglect 1 Peter 2:13-14? What about Genesis 9:5-6? Will you decline to preach about Daniel’s influence on the government of Babylon or Joseph’s influence on Egypt?

The Purpose of Christian Presence on Earth

God placed us on earth to fulfill a dual mandate: to engage in evangelism and to do good for others as the salt of the earth (Matthew 5:13). The “do evangelism, but not politics” perspective is fundamentally wrong because it misunderstands the very reason God has left Christians on earth. When people trust in Christ as their Savior and receive forgiveness of sins, does God immediately transport them to heaven? Why does He leave Christians here on earth?

Granted, we are commissioned to preach the gospel. But what are those people supposed to do after they trust Jesus as their Savior? Is their sole purpose on earth to preach the gospel, or does Jesus intend for us to fulfill additional responsibilities, such as loving our neighbors as ourselves (Matthew 22:39)? If we exist on earth to glorify God, we glorify Him by observing His commands. This means I should actively seek the good of my neighbors in all sectors of society. “You shall love your neighbor as yourself” means that I should advocate for good laws that protect marriage and family. It means I should pursue good laws that protect children from corrupting moral influences that promote sexual experimentation outside marriage. One fundamental reason Jesus left us here on earth is that we should glorify Him by doing good to others in all areas of life. Should churches teach their people how to perform good works in hospitals and schools, in business and in neighborhoods, but exclude government from this sphere of influence? Why should that particular area of life be exempted from the influence of believers’ good works that will bring glory to our Father who is in heaven?

God’s Dual Institution for Restraining Evil

The “do evangelism, not politics” view errs fundamentally in that it overlooks a crucial theological reality: God gave both the Church and civil government to restrain evil in this world. God employs civil government to restrain evil, and substantial evil exists that can only be restrained by the power of civil government. Most people on earth are unbelievers, and many people are extremely wicked and violent.

Consider a practical example: Why do we need laws against drunk driving? If the influence of the gospel alone were sufficient to change society, and if Christians were faithfully fulfilling their evangelistic responsibilities and modeling sober driving behavior, that would theoretically eliminate all drunk driving in the United States. However, until Christ returns, there will always be drunk drivers who remain unpersuaded by the Christian gospel, unconvinced by their conscience, and unmoved by common sense. Government has been instituted by God so that it would be “not a terror to good conduct” (Romans 13:1-3). God restrains drunk driving not merely through preaching the gospel, but also through the power of civil government (1 Peter 2:14).

Consider another historical example: When did people in the United States cease owning slaves? It was not when the gospel had been preached throughout the South in America, but rather after the American government rendered slavery illegal through the Emancipation Proclamation in 1863. This transformation occurred when many Christian abolitionists successfully influenced the government of the United States to change its laws.

Christianity’s Positive Influence on Government Throughout History

Historian Alvin Schmidt, in his book How Christianity Changed the World, documents how the spread of Christianity and Christian influence on government was primarily responsible for numerous revolutionary reforms:

  • Outlawing infanticide, child abandonment, and abortion in the Roman Empire (AD 374)
  • Outlawing the brutal gladiatorial battles to the death in which thousands of gladiators had perished (AD 404)
  • Outlawing the cruel punishment of branding the faces of criminals (AD 315)
  • Initiating prison reforms such as the segregation of male and female prisoners (AD 361)
  • Stopping the practice of human sacrifice among the Irish, the Prussians, and the Lithuanians, as well as among other nations (although illegal child sacrifices still occur in remote parts of India)
  • Outlawing pedophilia
  • Granting property rights and other protections to women
  • Banning polygamy
  • Prohibiting the burning alive of widows in India (AD 1829)
  • Outlawing the painful and crippling practice of binding young women’s feet in China (1912)
  • Persuading government officials to establish a system of public schools in Germany in the sixteenth century
  • Advancing the concept of compulsory education for all children in numerous European countries

In England, William Wilberforce, a devout Christian, led the successful campaign to abolish the slave trade and then slavery itself throughout the British Empire by 1840.

In the United States, many Southern Christians supported slavery; however, they were vastly outnumbered by the multitude of Christians who served as ardent abolitionists, speaking, writing, and agitating constantly for the abolition of slavery in the United States.

Christian ideas and prominent Christian leaders exercised strong influence in the formulation of the Magna Carta in England (1215), the Declaration of Independence (1776), and the Constitution (1787) in the United States. These three documents rank among the most significant governmental documents in the history of the earth, and all three bear the unmistakable marks of substantial Christian influence in their foundational ideas regarding how governments should function. These foundations for British and American government did not emerge as a result of the “do evangelism, not politics” view. All Western governments’ legal documents possess a distinctly Christian character. God cares deeply about how people treat one another here on earth, and good laws possess eternal value in the sight of God.

The Historical Vindication of Christian Political Engagement

If the Christian Church had adopted the “do evangelism and not politics” view throughout history, it would never have brought about these immeasurably valuable changes among the nations of the world. But these changes did occur, because Christians recognized that by influencing laws and governments for good, they would be obeying the command of their Lord: “Let your light shine before others, so that they may see your good works and give glory to your Father who is in heaven” (Matthew 5:16). They influenced governments for good because they understood that “we are His workmanship, created in Christ Jesus for good works, which God prepared beforehand, that we should walk in them” (Ephesians 2:10).

The Mandate for Continued Engagement

What we do know with certainty is that while we have the opportunity, God commands us not to surrender, but to continue preaching “the whole counsel of God” (Acts 20:27), doing good works (Ephesians 2:10), and loving our neighbors as ourselves (Matthew 22:39). This means we should persist in attempting to influence governments for good as long as we possess the ability to do so. “Blessed is that slave whom his master finds so doing when he comes” (Luke 12:43).

If all the Christians who influenced governments for good in previous centuries had simply surrendered and declared, “Persecution is coming and governments will become more evil, so there is nothing we can do,” then none of those beneficial changes in laws would have materialized. Human sacrifices, the burning of widows alive, slavery, and racial discrimination would still be protected by law. That mentality would have constituted a defeatist, fatalistic attitude, and it would have led Christians to disobey many of God’s commands for how we are to conduct our lives during this present age. Instead of capitulating to such a hopeless attitude, courageous Christians in previous generations sought to do good for others and for governments, and God often blessed their efforts.

Addressing the Straw Man Argument

The following quotation is from the book Politics According to the Bible by Wayne Grudem, page 53:

“Some writers accuse Christians who emphasize political involvement of holding to this ‘do politics,’ not evangelism ‘view. They say some conservative Christians seem to think that voting Republican will save the nation or that we should trust government to save us rather than trusting God, or they make some similar allegation.

But these seem to me to be attacks against a straw man, a hypothetical opponent that does not really exist. So far as I know, this view has not been advocated by leaders at Focus on the Family, the Christian Coalition, the Family Research Council, the 700 Club, Concerned Women for America, the Alliance Defense Fund, the American Center for Law and Justice, or previous organizational advocates seeking to change government instead of doing evangelism. In fact, many of the evangelical leaders who are involved in seeking to influence government have been active evangelists, such as the late D. James Kennedy, who preached regularly on biblical perspectives and political issues and whose Evangelism Explosion book and program provided much encouragement to personal evangelism among many thousands of evangelicals. Not once have I heard any Christian in any of these groups say, ‘Good government will save us’ or ‘if we just win this election we do not have to pray or do evangelism or seek changes in people’s hearts.’ Not once have I heard anyone say, ‘We should trust government and not God.”’

Chapter 3

Biblical Foundations

Scriptural Examples of Believers Influencing Secular Governments

The Bible provides numerous compelling examples of believers in God who exercised substantial influence over secular governments. Those who have carefully studied the Prophet Daniel and Joseph would find sufficient evidence for godly men influencing secular governmental structures. A New Testament example of influence on government appears in the life of John the Baptist. During his lifetime, the ruler of Galilee (from 4 BC to AD 39) was Herod Antipas, a tetrarch who had been appointed by the Roman emperor and remained subject to the authority of the Roman Empire. Herod was not descended from the people of Israel but was rather an Idumean (from Edom, a neighboring nation). Matthew’s and Luke’s Gospels document that John the Baptist rebuked Herod for a specific sin in his life (Matthew 14:3-4; Luke 3:18-20).

If we as Christians endeavor to bring significant Christian influence to bear upon civil governments and government leaders, we possess many positive examples in the narrative history of the Bible, including Joseph, Moses, Daniel, Nehemiah, Mordecai, and Esther.

Beyond these narrative examples, the mere existence of specific Bible passages that teach about government constitutes a compelling argument for significant Christian influence in governmental affairs. Why do we think God placed Romans 13:1-7 and 1 Peter 2:13-14, along with other related passages, in the Bible?

Democracy and Christian Influence

In a democratic system, a significant portion of the ruling power of government is entrusted to the citizens generally, exercised through the ballot box. To possess the ability to vote is to hold a share of ruling power. Therefore, all citizens who have reached voting age bear a responsibility before God to understand what God expects of civil government and what kind of moral and legal standards He desires government to follow. But how can citizens acquire knowledge of the kind of government God seeks? They can learn this only if churches teach about government and politics from the Bible.

Christianity’s Historic Influence on Government

The Christian Church throughout history has been largely responsible for persuading governments to place far greater value on individual human rights, individual freedom, freedom of religion, equality before the law, and separation of church and state. Significant Christian influence can be traced in the Magna Carta, the United States Declaration of Independence, and the United States Constitution. Moreover, Christian influence led to the abolition of such evils as abortion, infanticide, gladiatorial contests, human sacrifice, polygamy, the burning alive of widows, and slavery, as well as the granting of property rights, voting rights, and other protections to women.

The Theological Foundation of Human Equality

The biblical teaching that all human beings are created in the image of God and therefore possess equal status before God exerted significant influence on the thinking of the Founding Fathers of the United States and their bold declaration that “all men are created equal.” This stood in clear contrast to the prior assumption in many European nations that there existed a special category of human beings known as “royalty” who possessed hereditary rights to rule over ordinary people. In many nations, this conviction of the equality of all people led to the limitation of the monarchy’s role to predominantly ceremonial and symbolic functions, and to a role of leadership by example for promoting a nation’s exemplary behavioral standards and the finest elements of its cultural heritage.

Should Christians Only Vote for Christian Candidates?

Many Christians contend that we should remain above politics. However, God’s Word explicitly calls Christians to be “the salt and light” in their culture. The question then arises: How can Christians be politically active while remaining Christlike? In this era of cancel culture, Woke ideology, and Transgender Culture, many Christians are afraid to articulate their convictions. However, Plato stated a profound truth: “One of the penalties for refusing to participate in politics is that you end up being governed by your inferiors.” The Bible makes it clear that, despite the stigma associated with politics, God calls and uses political leaders. If I possess the only light in a dark room, its darkness becomes my fault. Caring for our culture and engaging in its political process constitutes good citizenship for God’s people.

Divine Sovereignty and Human Responsibility

Yes, God occupies the throne and exercises ultimate control, but that does not mean we should do nothing to further His will. Evidence exists in Scripture that God has been displeased with our choices of leadership at times (Hosea 8:4). Much of the suffering on earth occurs because of godless Socialist leaders and dictators. Scripture provides Christians with instructions to obey legitimate authority unless it contradicts the Lord’s commands (Acts 5:27-29; Romans 13:1-7). Candidates that violate the biblical commands for life, liberty, family, marriage, and faith should never be supported (Proverbs 14:34).

Converted from the 13-page printed edition. The original PDF remains available above.