Essay English 38 min read

An Overview of Charismatic Experiences

Dr. Sunny Ezhumattoor

Biblical analysis of charismatic movements and spiritual gifts in contemporary Christianity.

Full text

Charismatics build a wax castle based on experiences. At the height of the emotional fire, their castle of experiences melts down on Biblical grounds. Charismatic chaos is spreading all over the world like a wild-fire. It may be the prophetic fulfillment narrated in scripture.

II Peter chapter 2, verses 1-3, are noteworthy at this context: “1But there were also false prophets among the people, even as there will be false teachers among you, who will secretly bring in destructive heresies, even denying the Lord who bought them, and bring on themselves swift destruction. 2And many will follow their destructive ways, because of whom the way of truth will be blasphemed. 3By covetousness they will exploit you with deceptive words; for a

long time their judgment has not been idle, and their destruction does not slumber.”

Charismatics do not hesitate to promote wild ideas on television such as raising the dead, etc., without any independent verification. This charismatic disease is infecting other denominations, starting from Catholics to Plymouth Brethren groups. Many fail to follow the example of the Brethren in Berea. Acts 17:11 says, "They received the word with all readiness and searched the scriptures daily to find out whether these things were so." Charismatics don’t care who speaks in tongues, as long as they speak in tongues, they are happy. Many people who teach extreme false doctrines also speak in tongues. This reminds me of a speech by the late E.M.S. Naboothripad, Communist Chief Minister of Kerala in South India. He said, "To defeat the ruling Indian National Congress Party we will make an alliance even with the devil." Similarly, to authenticate their experiences, Charismatics usually quote the experiences and tongues by Catholics and other false sects.

Healings of all kinds are claimed, and most of them carry daily personal conversations with God. Now, some of them claim that their tooth fillings are transformed into gold fillings.

The mass suicides by many extreme groups are not coincidental. More than one thousand people committed suicide in Uganda at the end of March in 2000. Here is a quote from the Houston Chronicle, April 2, 2000, page 29A.

"Christian church membership is growing faster in Africa than in any other continent, and the fastest growth has been among charismatic ministries that provide ‘easy answers to difficult questions,’ said Grace Kaiso, executive secretary of the Uganda Joint Christian Council."

The Charismatic movement is a spiritual socialism. This utopian doctrine gives temporary comfort and solace for millions of poor people and outcasts in society. When an uneducated and poor person claims that he “saw Jesus, went to heaven, was escorted by Jesus, and given a tour,” he feels empowered and that he would be counted with the elite. When he speaks in tongues, he feels equality with the leaders of the Charismatic movement.

If you observe closely, you will realize one fact about Charismatics. Many of them are emotionally unstable and weak. Some leaders hold great influence on their flocks. People who are calm, quiet, and subdued may encounter great difficulties to fit into this group.

I remember one of my friends praying and putting his hand on a dead air conditioning compressor that had outlived its normal age. Their bizarre claims of starting a dead car, turning a one dollar bill into a one hundred dollar bill, and having people being slain in the spirit (knocked unconscious on the floor) are very common.

The Pentecostal movement has opened its door wide to every sect that embraces miracles and wonders. Their experience has no validity because we can hear the same type of experiences from Hindus and Muslims.

If you are a Christian who has not experienced some supernatural manifestations, they would label you as the one who cannot get this blessing and treat you like a second class Christian.

Do our Charismatic friends really have a closer relationship with God? Do they exhibit the fruit of the Spirit in their lives? No. If we observe impartially, they exhibit less Christian maturity than other groups. There is a cutthroat competition among Charismatic preachers and believers to outdo the other brother or sister. So many exaggerate, dramatize, or even fabricate some miracle or experience because of their need to keep up with their peers who appear to be more spiritual.

Charismatics build their doctrines on experience, rather than understanding that the authentic experience happens in response to truth. How can a Charismatic blame the Roman Catholic Church, which introduced most of the rituals and doctrines over the last 2000 years? They believe the Pope is infallible, and his word carries the weight of scripture. Roman Catholics have added to scripture such traditions as penance, purgatory, and prayers for the dead, and an entire sacramental system. None of those things has biblical support, but they all believe as if it is the revealed word of God through the Church. Similarly, visions, dreams, prophesy, words of knowledge, private conversations with God, and other experiences are given authenticity and validity among them. So they print an addendum to the scripture because the Bible is not complete if we accept their doctrines. Here is one section from Robert Liardon’s experience.

“Jesus and I visited a branch of the River of Life. This branch was knee deep and crystal clear. We took off our shoes and got in. And do you know the first thing Jesus did to me? He dunked me! I got back up and splashed Him, and we had a water fight. We splashed each other and laughed." 1

"Mysticism is a system of belief that attempts to perceive spiritual reality apart from objective, verifiable facts. It seeks truth through feelings, intuition, and other internal senses. Objective data is usually discounted, so mysticism derives its authority from within. Spontaneous feeling becomes more significant than objective fact. Intuition outweighs reason. An internal awareness supersedes external reality. Mysticism is at the heart of modern existentialism, humanism, and even many forms of paganism, most notably Hinduism, and its close ally, the New Age Movement.

Irrational mysticism is also at the heart of the Charismatic experience. It has subverted biblical authority within the movement, and replaced it with a new standard: personal experience." 2

Charismatic experience is an addiction similar to drugs and pornography. The person who consumes drugs has to take more potent drugs over the years. People who start with soft pornography become bored with it and start watching more hardcore pornography.

Some charismatics get frustrated in this movement. Some spend the rest of their lives trying to find another experience. The Christian life becomes a pilgrimage from experience to experience, and if each one is not more spectacular than its predecessor, many people begin to wonder if something is wrong.

Paul’s Experience

It is useful to compare Paul’s experience with modern day Pentecostal experience. II Corinthians 12:1-4 reads, " 1It is doubtless not profitable for me to boast. I will come to visions and revelations of the Lord: 2I know a man in Christ who fourteen years ago – whether in the

body I do not know, or whether out of the body I do not know, God knows – such a one was caught up to the third heaven. 3And I know such a man – whether in the body or out of the body I do now know, God knows – 4how he was caught up into Paradise and heard inexpressible words,

which it is not lawful for a man to utter." He kept his experience secret for fourteen years, and now he remembers only vaguely that experience. Note that he is not boasting about his experience in this chapter, but explaining his weakness.

It is interesting to read the dictionary of Pentecostal and Charismatic movements.

Glossolalia (p.335) usually, but not exclusively, is the religious phenomenon of making sounds that constitute, or resemble a language not known to the speaker. It is often accompanied by an excited religious psychological state, and in the Pentecostal and Charismatic movements, it is widely and distinctively, but not universally viewed as the certifying consequence of the baptism in the Holy Spirit.3 Varied explanations (pp. 340 – 341).3 How does glossolalia occur?

What are its effects and significance? Responses to these and similar queries turn on the worldview of the inquirer and the methodology adopted.

Research conducted by social scientists (Malory and Lovekin, 1985) has been the kind of inquiry most productive of theories. The earliest psychological investigations viewed glossolalia as the byproduct of an unhealthy mind or a disordered personality. It has been attributed to hysteria or hypnosis, suggestion, or regression. Some researchers view it as an altered state of consciousness, while others view it as learned behavior or narcissistic self-preoccupation.

Buddhist doctrine explains “xenolalia” as a linguistic survivor from a prior existence. It has been described as the consequence of stimulation of Broca’s Area in the left cerebral hemisphere and as a form of right-brain speech. It can be styled as the suspension of the rational or as a mix of a cry (anticipating death) and a laugh (celebrating birth: Hutch, 1980) or as a kind of mysticism – although glossolalia played no major role in the classical Christian mystical tradition.

Evaluation - A few summarizing and interpretive conclusions can be offered

Glossolalia is a human phenomenon not limited to Christianity or even to religious behavior. Speaking in tongues "embraces every ecstatic oral-auditory phenomenon from speaking a language not generally known … speaking in forceful declamations, incantations, and other verbal effusions that are more likely to be psychological-spiritual projections of inner speech than some authentic language itself." 4

The impulse of glossolalia, not readily accessible to scientific determination, may rise from the speakers themselves, from a demonic spirit, or from the Holy Spirit. Even if glossolalia occurs in a balanced Pentecostal environment, any one of the three sources may apply. The discernment of the community is essential. On the other hand, glossolalia of simply human origin is probably more frequent than recognized. That explains, for example, the humanities scholar who "taught himself to speak in tongues and can do so at will."

History of Experiential Theology

The experience theology of the Charismatic movement is not the legacy of fundamental Christianity. It originated from existentialism. Humanism, positive philosophy, and the New Age movement claim that human beings have unlimited power. All answers come from one’s own self. The Bible says that we can do everything only through Christ. Experientialism downgrades the authenticity of the scripture because many so-called revelations are against Biblical principles.

Sin against the Holy Spirit

Pentecostals usually say that teaching against their version of tongues and baptism of the Holy Spirit, is a sin against the Holy Spirit. In Kerala, most Pentecostals say that K.V. Simon and Y. Ezekiel died because they spoke against the Holy Spirit. K.V. Simon was a tireless Christian worker, who labored for the Lord without proper food and rest. Comparing the mortality rate at that period and his hard work, his death at the age of 61 was not premature. Before his death, he was bedfast for a few months.

Similarly, a few months before the death of Y. Ezekiel, he visited the Brethren in the United States. While staying with this writer for 3 weeks, he had some medical problems and was taken to a doctor. The doctor suggested complete rest because of his poor health. However he went home to be with the Lord, in his own appointed time, at a ripened age. The immediate reason of his death was his preexisting heart condition. For a true Christian, death from this world would be a blessed event. We would be in the presence of Jesus.

However, if you look into the charismatic circles, we can see that many of their leaders were afflicted with terrible diseases, from cancer to skin diseases, and some of them died in terrible accidents. More Pentecostal leaders have succumbed to death at an earlier age than many of the Brethren leaders, so how can they claim that K.V. Simon died because of his teachings about the Holy Spirit? Once again, it indicates the lack of reasoning and the ignorance of some believers in that group. This type of interpretation is prevalent among Pentecostals all over the world (Matthew 12:22-32).

Some Kerala Pentecostals have no historical knowledge when they make their silly arguments against the Brethren and others who oppose their false doctrines. If you spend some time to research, the reader will get a different story.

The modern Pentecostal movement has two fathers, Charles Parham and William J. Seymour. Charles Parham had been afflicted with rheumatic fever and he eventually died with a bad heart at the age of 56. The other father is the one- eyed preacher William J. Seymour, who never received a miraculous healing for his blind eye and suddenly died of a massive heart attack at the age of 52. It is interesting to note that K.V. Simon and Y. Ezekiel had longer and healthier lives than the Pentecostal fathers.

Now let us examine the life expectancy of the founders of the Brethren movement in Great Britain in the nineteenth Century. The average life expectancy in Great Britain during the nineteenth century was between 38 and 48.

Most of the founders of the Brethren movement died as Septuagenarians, Octogenarians and Nonagenarians. Some of them even lived closer to 100 years old. One of the early brethren, who is known worldwide as “The Great man Of Prayer”, George Muller died at the age of 93. Dr. A. J. Cronin who received the light of New Testament Principles for the first time, died at the age of 81. John Nelson Darby who recovered the New Testament Doctrines that was lost for 1800 years, died at the age of 82. William Kelly died at the age of 85. Robert Chapman died at the age of 99.

The above facts show that God favored more special grace to the Brethren saints than the Pentecostal and Charismatic healers and miracle workers.

Charles and Frances Hunter, a charismatic husband and wife team, have written similar views. They say that criticizing the charismatic movement is an unpardonable sin. In Matthew 12:22-31, a demon-possessed man, born blind and dumb, was brought to Jesus, who healed the man. However, the Pharisees said, "This man casts out demons only by Beelzebub, the ruler of the demons." The Pharisees accused Jesus of casting out demons through the power of Satan, but Jesus received the power from the Holy Spirit. "Then Jesus, when He had been baptized, came up immediately from the water; and behold, the heavens were opened to Him, and He saw the Spirit of God descending like a dove and alighting upon Him" (Matthew 3:16). Jesus attributed His power to the Holy Spirit. "1The Spirit of the Lord God is upon Me, because the Lord has

anointed Me to preach good tidings to the poor; He has sent Me to heal the brokenhearted, to proclaim liberty to the captives, and the opening of the prison to those who are bound; 2to proclaim the acceptable year of the Lord, and the day of vengeance of our God; to comfort all who mourn" (Isaiah 61:1-2).

You can see the answer of Jesus in Matthew 12:25-26. "25But Jesus knew their thoughts, and said to them" ‘Every kingdom divided against itself is brought to desolation, and every city or house divided against itself will not stand. 26And if Satan casts out Satan, he is divided against

himself. How then will his kingdom stand?" If the Pharisees were right, the devil would be destroying his own kingdom, which would make no sense. Was Jesus talking about tongues here? The correct answer is that any sinner who comes to Christ in faith, repenting and confessing, will be saved.

According to John 16:7-11, the Father and the Holy Spirit point to Jesus Christ, convicting the world of sin, righteousness, and judgment. In Matthew, sin against the Holy Spirit was a historical event. It is applicable to everyone, since that time, who rejects the work of the Holy Spirit in presenting Christ’s divine credentials. It can never be used in reference to challenging charismatic experiences. Sin against the Holy Spirit is not accepting of Jesus Christ as one’s Savior and Lord.

History of Some Healers

Hobart Freeman believed God had healed him of polio. Still, he walked with corrective shoes. Freeman and the Faith Assembly congregation despised medical treatment, believing that modern medicine was an extension of ancient witchcraft and black magic. Many infants and mothers in his congregation perished. In December 1984, Freeman died of pneumonia and heart failure, complicated by an ulcerated leg.7

William Branham, the great divine healer, died in 1965 after suffering for six days from injuries sustained in an automobile accident. His followers believed that God would raise him up, but the resurrection never happened. A. A. Allen, famous faith healer, died of sclerosis of the liver in 1967, having secretly struggled with alcoholism for many of the years he was supposedly healing others. Kathryn Kuhlman died of heart failure in 1976. She had battled heart disease for nearly twenty years.8 And there are hundreds of names, but it is not necessary to mention all of

them. It is interesting though, that we have more proof for U.F.O. sightings than miracle healings.

There is not a single incident, or piece of evidence that proves a real miracle claimed by Pentecostal believers. Instead the charismatics claim subjective and unverifiable claims, such as backaches being healed. If God could really heal backaches for them, then He would also be able to do observable miracles, such as making a person's amputated leg grow back to normal, or restoring the eye sight of someone who is blind, or immediately making a bald person grow hair. Demonic forces are behind these bizarre subjective claims. Many healers have family members who are mentally retarded or have various other physical deformities. They conduct healing experiments on others and yet they themselves go to the doctor when they are sick. Fundamental Christians believe in miracles and healings, but not the same way charismatics do. God can still do any miracle as He pleases, but only in His sovereign will.

For argument’s sake, this writer can say that usually Brethren leaders have had more healthy and prolonged lives than the Charismatic leaders. None of the Brethren has said that many of the Pentecostal leaders had shorter lives with great illnesses due to their false teaching of the doctrine of the Holy Spirit. If you take a survey, you will be amazed to find that illness and premature death are more prevalent among Pentecostals.

In Houston, a few years ago, a divine healer and prosperity preacher, Pastor Gomez, came to preach. He was an arrogant man and spoke very contemptuously of the late K.V. Simon. However, good Pentecostal believers in Houston did not like his statement. He used to say that good Christians would be immune from accidents, cancer, and such terrible tragedies. This man perished in a tragic car accident.

From the autobiography of the late K.E. Abraham, the founder of the Pentecostal movement in Kerala, this writer is going to give a list of the Pentecostal leaders who died with various illnesses.

The following list shows that Pentecostal believers were not exempt from natural illness or death. Although they boast about miracles, the facts show that believers from other denominations received more grace and blessings than the Pentecostal believers.

NameAgeIllness
K.C. Oommen53diabetes
Ayya Pilla65diabetes
K.C. Cherian53diabetes & septic
M.K. Cherian56septic & diabetes
V.K. Mathai53small pox
K.E. Thomas45influenza
Kochukunju Sanyasi66asthma
V.P.Thomas59diabetes
K.V. Kurien57diabetes

There are many other names that are not necessary to quote here.

Charismatic believers share sensational stories about miracles and special experiences in their lives. When I came to Houston from India, during the early seventies, a Pentecostal believer became my best friend and companion. This friend, A. K. Alexander, belongs to a cultist Pentecostal group known as Ceylon Pentecost Mission. Later this group changed the name to “The Pentecost”. Although Mr. Alexander had high blood pressure problems, he didn’t see a doctor. On several occasions, as a friend, I cautioned him and advised him that one day he would have to pay a high price for following his faulty theology. I also explained to him that the Bible is not against treatment for any kind of sickness, but his leniency toward the false doctrine could definitely bring great catastrophe in his life. In 1973 my tonsils were removed and I had pain and discomfort for two weeks. Mr. Alexander told me that the surgery was avoidable; instead he could have healed me by his prayer.

Later, my friend moved out of Texas and we lost contact, but toward the end of 2010, we re-established contact. Soon, to my amazement, I found out that he became blind and had a kidney transplant due to his untreated disease, and not only that, he had to visit special doctors and hospitals frequently.

This is not an isolated incident among the so called believers. Many misguided and naïve Pentecostals who rely upon prayer only, become prematurely ill and die. At present, many Pentecostals visit doctors and boast about their miracles. I remember a story of a magician who claimed that he could escape from a dog bite with his magical powers. On cross- examination, he stated that when the ferocious dog ran toward him to bite him, he chanted the magical words or “mantra” and climbed up the tree. Pentecostal miracles are like the magician’s tricks.

Keralites began to migrate to America during the early part of the seventies. The first wave of immigrants is in their sixties or seventies now. When I conducted a study of the Kerala community, one thing became very clear, Keralite Pentecostals have more deaths and health issues compared to any other religious sects. Many people in the Pentecostal community are blind; many have kidney and heart problems, and many women among them are barren. As normal Christians, we believe that no one is immune to death or diseases. After all, Pentecostals in America are not wealthier or healthier than others as they claim; their assertions of miracles are nothing but fabricated imaginations and hallucinations.

Fake Doctors

Most of the Pentecostal/Charimatics are extremely materialistic and vainglorious in their life.

This is a universal fact; however, Kerala Pentecostals go one more step higher than their peers around the world. If you visit a Malayalee Pentecostal church, you can see many of them with a double prefix - Reverend Doctor. These so called fake doctors make a mockery of the people claiming to have a real doctorate. Most of them are not proficient either in Malayalam or English. Many have only a high school diploma from India. However, the present fake doctors are better than their founding fathers. In Kerala some of their fathers studied up to middle school and received D.D. (Doctor of Divinity) from a Pentecostal Seminary. Present day Malayalee doctors are at least high school graduate) and D .D. This shows an improvement for the second generation doctors.

The above doctors used to enroll in a Pentecostal Seminary and conduct some correspondence theological courses for a fee. The seminary that is run by Pentecostal charlatans confers a Masters and doctorate degree to them. Many of the American T.V. preachers also have fake doctorate degrees.

If you compare the pioneers of the brethren movement and Pentecostal leaders of all time, a reader can see a great divide between these two groups. Almost all brethren pioneers were great world renowned scholars and linguists unlike the Pentecostal leaders. The brethren leaders never paraded their worldly knowledge and wealth, but showed immense Christ - like humility, as the John the Baptist stated, “You must increase and I must decrease.” This was their motto. Their only goal had been to show the glory of God.

Holiness

The main “Motto“ of the Pentecostal / Charismatic group is “Holiness”. They strongly believe that salvation can be lost. But their theology is vague and ambiguous. They don’t know when a person can lose his salvation. They don’t have a list of the sins that can cause one to lose his salvation. In Pentecostal Conferences we can hear an alter call from the preacher asking anyone who is backslidden to come forward and commit their life again. But we never hear the call for anyone who lost their salvation to come forward and accept Jesus Christ as their personal Savior again. They cannot explain this contradiction. They have an obligation to answer to the following questions. What have you done so far to preserve your salvation without losing it today? How do you plan to manage your life to protect your salvation gift? Please give a list of the sins that can cause you to lose your salvation. How do you know that at the present moment your salvation is not lost? Currently Pentecostalism is not a major denomination like Roman Catholicism in the world. We hear about widespread sexual misconduct among Catholic clergy. Roman Catholics number more than a billion in the world. Pentecostalism is a small percentage, but their sins encompass many areas such as sex, money and drinking. Catholic clergy limit their misconduct only in the sexual field... Pentecostals have a higher percentage of sins compared to any other denominations. If truly salvation can be lost, we know the majority of the Pentecostals would be in hell.

This year we heard shocking news of an evangelist who claims to have direct communication with God. Let me quote the newspaper,

Charisma News .1/24/2012. Gina Meeks

“Richard Roberts, son of Oral Roberts and former president of Oral Roberts University, was released from Tulsa County Jail Tuesday morning after being arrested for driving under the influence.

According to the arrest and booking reports, an Oklahoma Highway Patrol trooper clocked Roberts' Mercedes at 93 mph in a 65 mph zone. Roberts was pulled over around midnight Tuesday morning.

A report from the jail indicates that the trooper administered a horizontal gaze sobriety test after he smelled a strong odor of alcohol, but Roberts was unable to follow the instructions. He was also unable to execute the walk-and-turn test.

The trooper arrested Roberts and took him to the Jenks Police Department, where he agreed to have a breathalyzer test. His blood alcohol level was tested at .11 percent. The legal limit in Oklahoma is .08 percent.

Roberts was transferred to the Tulsa County Jail and booked by 2:45 a.m. on DWI and speeding complaints. He was released from the jail just before 6 a.m. on $1,100 bond.

Roberts, 63, resigned as ORU’s president in 2007 amid allegations that he and his family misused university and ministry resources. He was given the honorary title of president emeritus in 2008. His father, Oral Roberts died in 2009 at the age of 94.

Richard Roberts is currently the chairman and CEO of Oral Roberts Evangelistic Association. He and his wife, Lindsay, host a nationally syndicated TV program, The Place for Miracles: Your Hour of Healing, a one-hour, interactive daily broadcast that reaches out to millions.”

It is not necessary to write about everyone in this group. We all know that germs grow in filth. Pentecostalism was established on a wrong foundation, which is the reason a majority of their leaders have become pawns in the hands of demons.

Which is the largest beggar nation in the World?

Beggars existed from time immemorial. Historically Asia and Africa had more beggars than other countries. In modern times another group of beggars came into existence incognito. When someone mentions about beggars you may immediately think of India. The current population of India is 1.2 billion, and many live in utter poverty. When you travel to India you can see scores of beggars surrounding you for money in the airports, around Tajmahal, and marketplaces etc. This is prevalent in African countries as well. But I have surprising news for you. African and Asian countries have fewer beggars than some of the more advanced countries. Charismatics and Pentecostals have made America the largest beggar nation in the world. Ninety-nine percent of the beggars in the U.S.A are Christian beggars in a particular group.

The only difference between third world beggars and U.S.A beggars are the methods and dress they wear for begging.

Modern American beggars wear three piece suits and use ultra modern technology such as radio, Television, Smart phones, YouTube and internet to collect money. This group has become a spiritual mafia. Through the mails and media, the public is constantly bombarded by pleas for money. This spiritual lottery promises immense wealth if you contribute to a particular ministry. Many people fall in their trap when they hear desperate and urgent pleas and subsequent blessings from God.

Courses are offered now to sharpen one’s skills at solicitation. Most television preachers undergo rigorous training, to learn the techniques to convince the public to donate money. These courses have been developed by highly qualified business men using proven techniques from behavioral science, psychology, sales training and fund raising.

Results

Although most of the television preachers became multi millionaires, this method has discredited gospel and has prevented millions of people from listening to the gospel. The unbelieving world scoffs and ridicules religion, and the name of true Christianity is maligned. It is just like another scam conning naïve and gullible people. The mail list of the donors are exchanged and sold to other evangelical groups. These modern day preachers trust the media more for money than the Lord Jesus Christ.

In contrast Brethren pioneers never solicited any funds from the general public, but looked to the Lord for their sustenance. Our Lord miraculously provided and they received sufficient funds for their ministries. They showed true faith in their life.

I Corinthians 14:1-3

"1Pursue love, and desire spiritual gifts, but especially that you may prophecy. 2For he who speaks in a tongue does not speak to men but to God, for no one understands him; however, in the spirit he speaks mysteries. 3But he who prophesies speaks edification and exhortation and

comfort to men."

One of my Pentecostal friends pointed out to me that some people may think that I have ignored or hid this section from my book that was written in Malayalam. Therefore, I wanted to explain these verses in my English book.

Spiritual gifts, including the gift of tongues, were given for mutual benefit, but was never intended for the benefit of God. Here, Paul’s comment is not suggesting that tongues should be used as a prayer language; he was using irony, pointing out the futility of speaking in tongues without an interpreter, because only God would know if anything was said. So, he had to speak silently without an interpreter. 1 Peter 4:10 reads, "As each one has received a gift, minister it to one another, as good stewards of the manifold grace of God." Paul further says in I Corinthians 14:4, "He who speaks in a tongue edifies himself, but he who prophecies edifies the church." The Corinthian’s were using tongues to build themselves up in a selfish sense. Those egocentric believers wanted to show off their gift and boast of spiritual superiority.

The word ‘understand’ in I Corinthians 14:2 is baffling to many believers. The original word in Greek for ‘understand’ is “akouoo.” The principal meaning of this word is "hear." This word is used 433 times in the New Testament. This word has been translated as "hear" 415 times. The correct translation here is "hear." Let us see J.N. Darby’s translation of I Corinthians 14:2: "For he that speaks with a tongue does not speak to men but to God: for no one hears; but in the spirit he speaks mysteries."

I Corinthians 14:2 must be connected with verse 28 to comprehend the correct meaning. "But if there is no interpreter, let him keep silent in the church, and let him speak to himself and to God."

After the first century, until 1900, only a few occurrences of speaking in tongues took place; Montanists in the second century, militant protestants in France in the late seventeenth century called ‘cevennes,’ Shakers in the mid 1700’s in the United States, and Edward Irving, in Scotland in the nineteenth century. All those groups had been discredited and connected with heretical and strange teaching. If tongues are so indispensable, the Lord would have poured the gift out on all ages and to all believers.

Joel 2:28

"And it shall come to pass afterward that I will pour out My Spirit on all flesh; your sons and you daughters shall prophecy, your old men shall dream dreams, your young men shall see visions."

Some Charismatics agree that tongues ceased after the apostolic era, but contemporary manifestations of the gifts are a final outpouring of the Spirit and His gifts for the last days. Joel 2:19-32 is a prophecy of the coming millennial kingdom and cannot refer to anything earlier.

Many use Peter's quoting of Joel 2:28 in the message he preached on the day of Pentecost as recorded in Acts 2:17. Their premise is that Peter is saying that their would be a great outpouring of the Spirit of God in this dispensation and God would speak to men in dreams and visions. Let us then examine these passages and seek the truth on the matter letting the Bible interpret the Bible.

Joel 2:28-31

And it shall come to pass afterward, that I will pour out my spirit upon all flesh; and your sons and your daughters shall prophesy, your old men shall dream dreams, your young men shall see visions: And also upon the servants and upon the handmaids in those days will I pour out my spirit. And I will shew wonders in the heavens and in the earth, blood, and fire, and pillars of smoke. The sun shall be turned into darkness, and the moon into blood, before the great and the terrible day of the LORD come. And it shall come to pass, that whosoever shall call on the name of the LORD shall be delivered: for in mount Zion and in Jerusalem."

Acts 2:16-21

But this is that which was spoken by the prophet Joel; And it shall come to pass in the last days, saith God, I will pour out of my Spirit upon all flesh: and your sons and your daughters shall prophesy, and your young men shall see visions, and your old men shall dream dreams: And on my servants and on my handmaidens I will pour out in those days of my Spirit; and they shall prophesy: And I will shew wonders in heaven above, and signs in the earth beneath; blood, and fire, and vapour of smoke: The sun shall be turned into darkness, and the moon into blood, before that great and notable day of the Lord come: shall be deliverance, as the LORD hath said, and in the remnant whom the LORD shall call. And it shall come to pass, that whosoever shall call on the name of the Lord shall be saved."

First let us examine Joel 2:28.

The first thing we must determine is when is God telling Joel that there will be a pouring out of His Spirit?

The first sentence states that, "And it shall come to pass afterward, that I will pour out my spirit upon all flesh."

This means the pouring out of the spirit will come "after" something. An examination of Joel 2, clearly shows that the events preceding the "pouring out of the spirit," happens after the Great Tribulation, and after the destruction of the northern army, (Joel 2:20) which is Russia. The major theme of the Book of Joel, is of the coming of "the great and terrible day of the Lord to" (Joel 2:31). The Bible tells us that the coming Day of the Lord, includes the seven year Tribulation, Christ's Second Coming at the end of the Tribulation and Christ the ruling in the following Millennium.

The chronology of the events seen in Ezekiel 38, and Daniel 11:36-45 indicate that Russia will be destroyed during the last half of the Tribulation. The destruction of the nations in the campaign of Armageddon is followed by the Second Coming and the Millennial reign of Christ. Thus the pouring of the Spirit of God occurs after the destruction of the northern army and in the time of blessing promised of God.

Two other important facts should be noted. First, the prophecy is addressed to Israel. This is not a prophecy addressed to the churches. The churches are not in view here. Second, the prophecy stated that the spirit will be poured out on all flesh. The spirit of God cannot be poured out on the lost, yet this verse states that it will be poured out on "all" flesh. At the beginning of the Millennium, everyone will be believers. No lost persons will enter the Millennium, and thus the spirit of God could be poured out on "all" flesh because all will be saved.

Also, the prophecy states other events are in view in verses 30-32. These are clearly Tribulation events. (See Matt. 24) The churches are not in view in this prophecy which is addressing events that will happen after the present Church Age. These events refer to Israel and are not related or addressed to the church or this present dispensation.

After this dispensation ends with the Rapture of the Church, Christ's bride, then God's prophetic clock again begins to run as the events of the Great Tribulation unfold ending with the Second Coming of Christ and the setting up of the Millennial Kingdom.

The second question is this: In Acts 2:16-21, is Peter by quoting Joel 2:28, applying this prophecy to this present age in which God is working through the institution of the local church? It is clear that he events recorded in Acts 2, that happened on the day of Pentecost are not the same as are recorded in Joel 2. The context of Joel 2, is the end of the Great Tribulation, and the destruction of the northern army accompanied by great signs and wonders. The only event that is similar is the pouring out of the spirit.

The question, on the day of Pentecost, was what was happening to the men who had received the outpouring of the Holy Spirit? They were perceived to have been drunk. (Acts 2:15) Peter answered and said what you see happening to these men is like what Joel said would happen in the Millennium. Peter was referring to Joel's prophecy as an illustration from Scripture of what the crowds were seeing. Peter was not saying that Joel's prophecy was being fulfilled. He was saying that the pouring out of the spirit of God at Pentecost was what would happen in the day Joel's prophecy would be fulfilled.

The pouring out, or indwelling of the Holy Spirit of God, was not given to all in the Old Testament dispensation. The Holy Spirit was only given to individuals for specific service. Today, in the Church Age all believers are indwelled by the Spirit of God, and this indwelling started on the day of Pentecost. When this future out pouring of the Spirit of God would come in the Millennium it would be on "all" flesh. Clearly he was saying that in the same way, all believers in this dispensation would have the indwelling of the Holy Spirit of God.

Peter, in Acts 2:38, urged those that were present to "repent" and be receive Jesus Christ, and be baptized and the would receive the gift of the indwelling of the Holy Spirit. There is no emphasis on speaking in tongues, prophesying, seeing visions or dreaming dreams by Peter.

There are several New Testament references to visions or dreams, but all are in the Gospel or the transitional period between the Old Testament dispensation and the full implementation of the dispensation of the present age when God is working with the Gentiles through the institution of the local church. Historically one can see the transition through the New Testament in which the sign gifts and miracles gradually ceased as God by inspiration was giving the New Testament to the early churches.

The early church was totally Jewish and remained so until gradually Gentiles were saved and added to the early churches. There was a transitional period of about forty years in time while the early church was slowly becoming a Gentile church. The Gospel was first preached by Peter on the Day of Pentecost and was delivered to the Jews only. All those who were saved on that day were Jews. God was offering to Israel their resurrected Messiah who had suffered, died and been resurrected and paid the sin debt of the world. (see Isa. 53). However, the Jews rejected the Lord Jesus as their Messiah. Paul said in the beginning of his ministry that the Gospel was to go to the Jew first. He said, "For I am not ashamed of the gospel of Christ: for it is the power of God unto salvation to every one that believeth; to the Jew first, and also to the Greek" (Rom. 1:16, also see 2:9-10). Paul later changed the direction of his ministry because the Jews bitterly opposed and rejected the Gospel. Acts 18:6, says, "And when they (the Jews) opposed themselves, and blasphemed, he shook his raiment, and said unto them, Your blood be upon your own heads; I am clean: from henceforth I will go unto the Gentiles."

In 70 AD, the Roman general Titus totally destroyed Jerusalem and the Temple, and Judaism ceased to exist on earth as practiced in the Old Testament. The Jews lost their nation, their home land and the place of worship and sacrifice the Temple. Without the Temple the Old Testament commandment could no longer be practiced, thus Old Testament Judaism ceased. It has not been practiced since and is not being practiced today.

There is no mention of visions or dreams being used by God in any of the Epistles to the churches. The Epistles were written to instruct the early churches in all matters of doctrine and practice. 2 Tim. 3:16, states that in the early church pastors and members where instructed to seek their teaching and guidance from the Scriptures. If dreams and visions were operable then they would have been included. Some Charismatics spiritualize the "former rain and the latter rain" of Joel 2:23. They argue that the former rain refers to Pentecost, when the Spirit came, and the latter rain to His outpouring in the twentieth century.

Throughout the Old Testament, the former rain refers to the autumn rains and the latter rain to the spring rains. Joel was actually saying that in the millennial kingdom, both rains will come as before. That means God will make crops grow abundantly in the kingdom. "24The threshing floors shall be full of wheat, and the vats shall overflow with new wine and oil. 25So I

will restore to you the years that the swarming locust has eaten, the crawling locust, the consuming locust, and the chewing locust, my great army which I send among you. 26You shall

eat in plenty and be satisfied, and praise the name of the Lord your God, who has dealt wondrously with you; and My people shall never be put to shame" (Joel 2:24-26). The former and latter rains have nothing to do with Pentecost.

The recurrence of miracles and signs in the Church age is not mentioned in the New Testament. Nonetheless, near the end of the age, there will be false prophets who perform miracles, prophecy, and cast out demons in Jesus’ name. "22Many will say to Me in that day,

‘Lord, Lord, have we not prophesied in Your name, cast out demons in Your name, and done many wonders in Your name?’ 23And then I will declare to them, ‘I never knew you; depart from

Me, you who practice lawlessness!’"(Matthew 7:22-23). "Then many false prophets will rise up and deceive many" (Matthew 24:11).

May the Holy Spirit help us to understand the scripture correctly.

Biblical Revival

Biblical revival involves a religious awakening and a zeal for the things of God. Just as the church of Ephesus did not love Christ as they once did (Revelation 2:4-5), or as the church at Sardis needed to wake up (Revelation 3:1-3), or as the Laodicean church had become lukewarm (Revelation 3:15-16), so Christians can lose their spiritual enjoyment, desire for prayer and scripture, and compassion for the lost. Fervency marks a dedicated life. "As many as I love, I rebuke and chasten. Therefore be zealous and repent" (Revelation 3:19). "Not lagging in diligence, fervent in spirit, serving the Lord" (Romans 12:11). "This man had been instructed in the way of the Lord; and being fervent in spirit, he spoke and taught accurately the things of the Lord, though he knew only the baptism of John" (Acts 18:11). According to II Chronicles 7:14, humility, prayer, and repentance are God’s conditions for restoration. However, the Charismatic movement promises a shortcut to spiritual maturity. One of the greatest attractions of this movement has been that it offers believers power, understanding, or whatever they desire, immediately through an experience, without time, pain, and struggles, which are a natural part of our growth process.

Marks of True Spirituality

The fundamental trait of a believer is the awareness of their own sin and shortcomings. In scripture, those who most despised their sinfulness were often those who were the most spiritual. Paul said he was the chief of sinners. "This is a faithful saying and worthy of all acceptance, that Christ Jesus came into the world to save sinners, of whom I am chief" (I Timothy 1:15). "When Simon Peter saw it, he fell down at Jesus’ knees, saying, ‘Depart from me, for I am a sinful man, O Lord!" (Luke 5:8). "Then I said: ‘Woe is me, for I am undone! Because I am a man of unclean lips, and I dwell in the midst of people of unclean lips; for my eyes have seen the King, the Lord of hosts" (Isaiah 6:5).

The ultimate goal of a Christian is to be like Christ. "Imitate me, just as I also imitate Christ" (I Corinthians 11:1). "I have been crucified with Christ; it is no longer I who live, but Christ lives in me; and the life which I now live in the flesh I live by faith in the Son of God, who loved me and gave Himself for me" (Galatians 2:20). "Till we all come to the unity of the faith and the knowledge of the Son of God, to a perfect man, to the measure of the stature of the fullness of Christ" (Ephesians 4:13). "12Not that I have already attained, or am already perfected;

but I press on, that I may lay hold of that for which Christ Jesus has also laid hold of me. 13Brethren, I do not count myself to have apprehended; but one thing I do, forgetting those things which are behind and reaching forward to those things which are ahead, 14I press toward the goal

for the prize of the upward call of God in Christ Jesus" (Philippians 3:12-14). One cannot become like Jesus from a one-time experience or any other modern techniques. It is a growth similar to our physical growth.

Many Charismatics believe that once you receive the baptism of the Holy Spirit with tongues, you attain your supreme goal. When the glow of one’s experience fades, he seek numerous experiences one after another.

Spiritual Gifts Do Not Bring Spirituality

"So that you come short in no gift, eagerly waiting for the revelation of our Lord Jesus Christ" (I Corinthians 1:7). The Corinthians had all spiritual gifts, but they had most of the problems. Enthusiasm, euphoria, fervor, excitement, and emotion are all characteristics that Charismatics equate with spiritual intensity, yet they have no power to restrain lust, pride, selfishness, and all other vices. Their experiences cannot solve the problems of the natural man. When they fail, as it is common, they seldom take responsibility, and blame Satan rather than reexamine their faulty premise. Their moral life is not higher than that of other Christians, and they do not know the fact that the Christian life is not an easy escape and a shortcut, but that it is a journey through a thorny path.

Experience of Paul

False apostles in Corinth tried to discredit Paul and made false allegations and questioned his apostleship. The false teachers boasted themselves and claimed extraordinary powers.

It is interesting to read II Corinthians chapters eleven and twelve. Paul never mentioned the miracles he conducted. Paul could not remember his heavenly experience clearly that took place 14 years ago. Yet in these chapters, he is describing his weaknesses and shortcomings. If Paul appeared to us today, he would be scorned by some Charismatics who also ridicule Job in the Old Testament.

Christian Life

Scripture is full of commands about how to live the Christian life. In chapters 4 and 5 of Ephesians, we have ample instructions. After Paul gave his contrasting command, "Be filled with the Spirit," he spent the next several paragraphs of his letter explaining what being filled with the Spirit was all about. There is no mention of getting high with wild, ecstatic, religious experiences. Instead, being filled involves submitting to one another, loving one another, obeying one another, and seeking the best for one another. We are to be continuously filled with the Spirit.

A good example of revival is given in the book of Nehemiah in chapters 8 and 9. After the Jews returned from the Babylonian captivity (B.C. 586-539), Nehemiah rebuilt the walls and started celebrating. Here are some characteristics of that worship celebration:

1 Extensive Bible reading (8:1-3), Ezra, the scribe, read the Law of Moses before the assembly from daybreak till noon; this went on day after day (8:18)

2 Attentive listening (8:3); the people listened to Ezra’s reading

3 Worship (8:5-6); Ezra praised God as the people "lifted their hands and bowed down, worshipping the Lord"

4 Sound teaching (8:7-8,12); the Levites instructed the people in the word of God, making it clear and giving the meaning so that the people could understand what was being read.

5 Permitting emotional response, with guidance (8:9-12,17); the people wept, apparently convicted of their sins, but since this was a time of celebration, Nehemiah thought it inappropriate, thus, he encouraged them to rejoice instead, "for the joy of the Lord is your strength"

6 Alm giving (8:12); Nehemiah directed the people to share their blessings of food and drink with those who were less fortunate

7 Proclaiming the word of God (8:13-16)

8 Repentance (9:1-3)

We can see the same guidelines in the New Testament, as I have previously mentioned. "And do not be conformed to this world, but be transformed by the renewing of your mind, that you may prove what is that good and acceptable and perfect will of God" (Romans 12:2).

Charismatics reach the so-called holiness through shortcuts, without any conscious effort. Experience is the key word for them.

Converted from the 18-page printed edition. The original PDF remains available above.